October 17th, 2007 | Category: General
ICE CREAM AFTER TONSIL REMOVAL – FACT OR FICTION?
Posted by: Turkey Hill Team
Quick, you’ve just had your tonsils removed, what’s the best food to eat to sooth that sore throat?
Most people would say ice cream. After all, soft foods are the prescription during the tonsillectomy recovery process and what better soft food is there than ice cream? Ice cream is also a “comfort food” and when you’re in the hospital (or recovering at home), comfort is of the utmost importance. It’s the perfect plan, right?
Now for the bad news: The whole “ice cream after tonsil removal” thing isn’t exactly the best medicine. In fact, most doctors advice against it. We know, the news was hard for us to hear too.
To double check this myth, we talked to Dr. Robert Belser, an otolaryngologist (that’s an ear, nose and throat doctor) from Lancaster Otolaryngology.
Dr. Belser admitted to being a Turkey Hill ice cream fan, but recommended that patients avoid ice cream and other milk products for about two weeks after having their tonsils removed. The reason, according to Dr. Belser, is that milk products generate phlegm, which causes patients to cough or clear their throat and potentially aggravate the healing tissue and increase the chances of bleeding.
Instead of ice cream, the doctor advises patients to eat sherbet or freeze pops. Both options offer the same throat-soothing qualities of ice cream (although our sherbet, like most sherbets, does contain some milk). Thankfully, Turkey Hill makes sherbet. And don’t worry, two weeks without ice cream may seem like an eternity, but you can make up for lost time later!


Follow us on twitter!


If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
42 Comments
Herr, i had my tonsils removed yesterday. and they arevery very sore, i am use to bad thoart infections which feel basically the same and so i learnt quickly to cope with the pain and eat. I can drink tea water and oasis and i have ate today; Toast (in hospital) skittles, fridge raiders and ice cream. I no say do not eat icecream, it has coated my tonsils and makes me feel like am drowning in my own spit. and i keep coathin it really hurts. owww
September 8th, 2009 at 7:35 pmI had my tonsils taken out 3 days ago and ive had some bad days with not feeling good but this is the worste ive ever felt, im 21 and i cant sleep, i only drink water and take my liquid tylenol which works for about an hour and i have to wait 4 more to take it again, i have tried to eat ice cream and it tastes horrible so i decided to stop eating it.. if id known how painful this is i would of never had it done.
August 23rd, 2009 at 7:55 pmi had my sugery on friday the 17th of 2009, and the experience was not bad at all. when i got to the house two days later my teeth and face started hurting to the point i had to use ambesol for the pain and take more pain medecine,for i call my doctor she said that was normal give it a few more days.
July 24th, 2009 at 9:31 amif you have to get it done do it you can handle it, but if you ever have to get a hemmoriod remove pray because it hurts like hell.
To:Jeff
Yeah i got mine out 3 days ago and they told me that if you cough or clear your throat by accident(or not) to check your tounge for blood. though it’s diffrent for adults and teens getting this done i’m glad i got it done b4 high school!
June 19th, 2009 at 6:00 amHi All
March 30th, 2009 at 3:38 pmI am 39 and had my tonsils removed, deviated septum repaired and the soft palate uvula shortened (UPPP) last week Thursday. I had problems swallowing water or anything else right after the surgery and then was given some anti-inflammatory meds into the IV and that helped a lot the first night. Now I am on my 4th day after surgery and have been able to eat: Mashed potatoes, scrambled eggs, white bread with butter (crust cut off), pea soup (strained like baby food) and gallons of water. I have had a bit of ice cream here at home. In the hospital there was a freezer full of ice/Popsicle and it did help a lot, albeit the mucous buildup was noticeable. Same with pudding based on milk. I am getting bored now at home. I have been written off work for 2 weeks but could go back the next few days the way I feel now. The pain isn’t half as bad as I thought it would be, but I am not out of the woods yet. Ice packs on my throat every few hours or so help. The pain relievers I was given was Ibuprofen 600mg so no heavy meds either. The one’s I was given to take home with me are still unopened on my table. Way too many side effects so I dare not take them. I will just use 2-3 200mg Ibuprofen every 6 hours with a lot of liquids and the ice packs. Hope everyone is feeling better. Oh by the way a question: I heard a lot about possible bleeding after the operation. I can tell in my nose if I am bleeding but my throat, I have no clue. How would you know? Signs? Thanks
hey my name is Melissa and no im not trying to be perfect on here hell im to messed up on painkillers omg number one the name of it is roxicet and it is fabulous liquid form of course but you feel no pain. i am 10 days into this after having tonsild removed and thanks doc for fibbing about the pain my ears have so much pressure and the swelling only makes it worse but ill live. i have developed a thrush form of infection from all the antibiotics and sterilization to say the least so i still cant go to semi solid form foods still ice cream popcicles and pudding im so tired of it all i want food!!!! i do not advise this surgery to people who have a hard time healing but it is good for kids under 14 but the ice cream helps and milk heat it up it doesnt leave the filmy stuff in your throat. but to all who yet to have it done good luck.
February 21st, 2009 at 1:32 amFirst of all, good God people! Can anyone here type a complete sentence?! Is everyone illiterate? And what’s with the spelling? Are you just mashing the buttons on your keyboard? Are you even trying to spell words correctly? Jesus Christ people, take some grammar lessons.
Ok…now that I’ve vented about that, I wanted to say that I just got my tonsils out 7 days ago. It actually hurts more now than it did for the first few days after the surgery. And as far as the ice cream goes, it is pretty much the ONLY thing that doesn’t make my throat hurt.
January 21st, 2009 at 11:20 pmI am 31 and I did mine 2 days ago, I read so much about it I was scared to death,well I made it,I need the swelling to go down I want steak and shrimp.when I take the med there is no pain except if I swallow. and for some reason pain comes every 4hrs and meds say take every 6hrs.Also feels like there is nasty coating on my tounge which a scrapper is not helping.But I think I could do this 10 times again,haha don’t mean to show off.Get well all of you.
December 12th, 2008 at 6:40 pmHi, i’m 17 years old.i had my Tonsil and Adenoid Removed 5 days ago.. and let me tell you it’s one of the worst feelings ever! ive had peircings..body modifications to my ears but.. holy shit this is terrible.I have had neausea.. tireness..sore.. i cant even stand up straight. Im on day 5 and it’s a slight better..was better the 1st and second day. I feel the swelling from the adenoid removal.. i cant eat and i feel so weak.. i just want this to be over with it’s so much pain.. i couldnt even shower..im prety much a living zombie. hope u guys have bttr experiences… i jus stick to ice water and pudding..everything else makes me neaseous..
November 21st, 2008 at 7:17 pmI got rid of my tonsils 3 days ago, It pains and is continues… I just can’t eat anything, I am drinking lot of water to keep myself away from getting dehydrated… I am not sure how long I still have to stay this way, If you are looking for tonsillectomy, better not…
October 25th, 2008 at 5:33 amMy surgery was last Friday, the first day I just drank cold water, the next two days my entire was in pain as if I had completed a full work out. I did have light fever as well, but I was able to eat light soups on the third day, but i still have pain and I also notice when i after a while into eating my ears or the back jaws are hurting so pretty much i stop eating. for the medication I was prescribe tylenol with codine but it help for about a hour or so. I also notice sherbet ice cream was good. and again maining cold water. its already been 5 or 6 days my throat still feels sore but i notice i feel like i have two large blisters in the back of my tonge.
October 22nd, 2008 at 11:50 pmI cant tslk to much or else it starts to hurt.
I had my toncills out on the 12th of semptember. I am 24 years old and i have to say that it was the worst pain ever. I thought delivering two babies was bad. I found that the cold foods were horrible on my throut. I agree with the doctors, i found by personal experience that ice cream was the worst thing to eat becuse of the phlem.. It is now day 13 and the back of my throut still is uncomfortable. It feels like it has bad bruising.. it hurts to yawn.. anyways my advice is to do what you can handle but i used ice packs on my throut and i thought that was a big help and warm soup.. Good luck to all….
September 25th, 2008 at 12:53 amI had my tonsils removed last week, this is day 7, and I’m 22 years old. So far it’s been horrible, and today was the worst of all! Apparently I had very large blood vessels running through my tonsils so cautery was not an option so the stitches are rubbing and scratching my already painful throat… The ear aches are making me crazy as well. So far the best thing I’ve found is a warm/HOT steamy shower to moisten my throat and hot chicken broth… frozen products are not helping one bit! Thin mashed potatoes are awesome too. This was not the diet I had in mind, already lost eleven pounds!
September 23rd, 2008 at 6:27 pmHey its friday today and i am supposed to get my tonsils removed tuesday and im reading all these stories and i am freaking out!!! i hear 2 sides of the story mac and cheese or no mac and cheese. that is the question. im assuming not since everyone is saying no dairy products but idk. and also, i dont wanna throw up. does everyone?
September 19th, 2008 at 9:38 amHello!
August 14th, 2008 at 9:46 pmI’m 38 and I got my tonsils out on Aug. 8th. I thought I was not going to be able to talk right away,but I was wrong. I was suppose to take 10 days off but only took two days and went back to work. I’m a chef. I have stayed away from all milk products. I ate cold items the first 3 days and warm foods after that.
I had my tonsils removed earlier this morning, and it has been pretty bad but not as terrible as some people have made it sound. I’m 21, and they say that the older you are the harder it is to recover, but I think the older you are the more pain you can deal with so it balances out. As far as eating goes, all I have drank is iced water that is just fine, popsicles are ok but the sugar kinda clogs my throat. Pudding was pretty bad because of the dairy. However, theres a product out call fruit chillers that are basically frozen fruit puree’s, the mango is delicious and they make my throat feel great!
August 14th, 2008 at 7:39 pmI had my tonsils and adnoids removed two weeks ago and I still am unable to eat the foods i wish i could. Ice cream was probably the worst food i could possibly have put in mouth. I didn’t like how it felt on my throat after the surgery. I prefered warmer liquids like chicken broth. That’s about all I ate until i could handle those Ramon Noodles. Room temp sweet tea is really good too. That’s all I drank. But for the cold stuff, I just stayed away from it!
August 7th, 2008 at 1:06 pmhey, im 11 and ive just got my toncils out about 9 days ago and ice cream makes your throat really cloggie and it is really not good. I personaly think that milkshakes are better but remember to keep your throat moist or it will bleed like mine did, i was in hospital for 4 more days and 3 more nights on a drip and trust me its not good when you have a needle in your arm 20 4 7. So i seguest that you should have ice blocks and milkshake and try not to dehighdrate
thanks for reading my comment
ps: im only 11
Rhiannon
August 7th, 2008 at 2:46 amI got my tonsils taken out a week ago.. 2days my 7th day.. & it still hurts… the first to days I was fine.. It did hurt.. But it wasn’t THAT pain ful. I got my tonsils removed & my anoids? Lol idk what there called.. But I got those strunk …
crushed ice is amazing 2… gatorade & water… it does hurt 2 swallow liquid still but it keeps u feeling better hydrated & such… I’ve been eatting rice pudding.. By Kozy snackes.. Its good & its easy 2 swallow trust me.. You’ll wanna eat something besides popsiscles & water after 3days. TRY it!!
Mashe potatoes r really good cuz I know all of you guys are starving.. Ice cream is cool… but its get warm by the time you swallow it.. So popscicles r awesome
The first couple of days were fine….I was talking on the phone & everything… it didn’t really hurt to talk @ all
…..but ya…
I ate some easy mac the other day to see if it was okay to eat before I went to bed… it felt fine.. But when I wokeupp OH MY. Dnt eat easy mac. Lol that’s all I have 2 say…that was say 5
Day 6 was rough I couldn’t tlk much… cuz of the easy mac lol
Day 7…
My ears kinda hurt 2day.. Like a ear infection.. But the doc says that’s totally normal..
Well see what happens ill keep this updated.
July 17th, 2008 at 7:18 pmI got my tonsils removed yesterday morning and let me tell you….I am a pretty strong guy and it hurts like hell, so since we did not have ice cream at that time my mom decided to cut and mix little pieces of cantaloupe and crushed ice together and it seemed to do the trick. Also gatorade is a great product to drink since it has salt and sugar in it.
June 18th, 2008 at 6:21 amgood luck to all
EG
I am 13yrs.old.I got my tonsils and adnoids out thursday the 5th. Its been 5 very painful days.Haven’t got a lot of sleep because of the severe pain in my ears and throat. Milk Shakes at 3:00am are my usual. Pop sicles are better though. I probably eat 8 a day. Gatorade has been my all time favorite though. Drinking atleast a gallon a day. Sweet tea with honey is extraordinary though! I have been able to eat a few soft foods. Soup,Mashed poatatos,and mac&cheese are brillant.
*NO KETCHUP
OR ORANGE JUICE!
*sky.
Hopefully this helps!
June 10th, 2008 at 8:27 pmI had my tonsils removed here recently, and I’m on my 7th day after healing and I still can’t manage to eat anything even semi-solid. I’ve found that the cold foods hurt worse and that actually warm foods are more soothing to my throat. But for some reason everything tastes really bad and all sweet things taste the worst of all. So ice cream has really been off limits for me all around, which really bites, cause I was looking forward to eating all the ice cream I wanted after my tonsilectomy.
May 13th, 2008 at 4:39 pmhey i just got my tonsils removed and omg iam in so much pain i can hardly drink water evern i tried ice cream and popsickels and that made them even sorer,the only thing that seemed to help were spice foods or a slirpy.really helped:-)
April 21st, 2008 at 2:33 pmI just got my tonsils removed two days ago, and let me tell you worse pain I have ever felt. I tried to eat ice cream and for some reason it just didnt taste good. Now popsicles on the other hand are the winners. Orange cream and fudge pops. I have been drinking tons of water and ice cubes. Unfortunately can’t eat much more than that. Food sounds so good but I attempted mashed potatoes and while they tasted good, it hurt eating them and I bled a but after
January 3rd, 2008 at 1:38 amI also understand that milk/dairy products are a perfect breeding ground for bacteria, too. Better safe, than sorry. Besides, patience is a virtue!
November 5th, 2007 at 9:42 pmi disagree with it because my ent requested it
November 4th, 2007 at 12:33 amMy 3 kids just had their tonsils out! I was out of my mind when I scheduled the 3 at the same time.
I am exhausted running from bed to bed. Hopefully this will end soon!!
The only rest that I get is when I bring them thier Duetto!!
They say the the Lemon Duetto is the best thing that they can eat!
I am being very lax with them. I usually give them a single scoop, but they say they need more. I’ve been to my local Shop-Rite and bought the last 4 Lemon Duetto. I may have to race out to Pathmark.
Thanks for the wonderful product!!!
Barbara
November 2nd, 2007 at 12:36 pmouch is having your teeth pulled to get dentures, but the ice cream helps keep the swelling down
October 19th, 2007 at 12:03 amI must dispute your scientific findings.
My father, brother and nephew were all otolaryngologists (Ear, Nose & Throat MDs.) When I was a child, my father performed more than a dozen tonsillectomies daily in his office that was in our house. Now, ice cream ingestion was a necessity to proper healing and rapid pain relief in those days. Why the controversy? Because we didn’t have TURKEY HILL ice cream in those days with it’s thick, creamy, extraordinarily satisfying taste. Instead, ice cream was watery and thin. The chill was what relieved the raw surgical throat and sputum production was not a concern as Turkey Hill was not available.
THIS, actually, is the explanation for my never having had my tonsils removed. No Turkey Hill ice cream??? No surgery!
I hope this clears the air – and the palate.
October 18th, 2007 at 11:29 pmI still have my tonsils~The article was a tad scarry for me since I did at one time have a bleeding vocal cord …I did still eat my ice cream …I remember alot of vanilla !!!!
October 18th, 2007 at 2:23 pmBest remedy for tonsils, if you can eat ice cream,(the pain ouch!) go the Duetto way. This way you get a little bit of ice cream and that delicious ice in all those great flavors. But in reality anyone who can eat anything after that…your good!!
October 18th, 2007 at 11:13 amKATH – Good advice. And remember, crumbling your cookies over ice cream doesn’t count!
JACQUELINE – You had your tonsils taken out twice? Ouch and ouch.
STEFANIE – Almost. It doesn’t work on athlete’s foot, but it sure is fun to sit there with your feet in two tubs of Vanilla Bean.
October 18th, 2007 at 8:14 amI still think Turkey Hill is the cure for everything!
October 18th, 2007 at 2:00 amThis could be trouble. If my husband ever has to have his removed he would expect TH as I and my grown children had. He would feel cheated but hopefully he will never need them removed since he has had them for 67 years. If my grandchildren ever need the operation I think they could handle the sherbet.
October 18th, 2007 at 12:20 amI was told, also, that ice cream is not the treat of choice after having tonsils removed. Ok, so you have to go a week or two with no TH ice cream,,,, just think how much more you’ll appreciate it when you CAN have it again!
October 17th, 2007 at 9:38 pmThank goodness I had my tonsils removed years ago when they recommended ice cream to sooth the throat. What would I do without Turkey Hill for two weeks!
October 17th, 2007 at 8:48 pmThank you for the research on that topic. I will remember that. My daughter had her wisdom teeth removed this summer and they did suggest milkshakes…made with Turkey Hill Ice Cream, of course!
October 17th, 2007 at 8:25 pmNever had my tonsils out. I finally got hold of some Baked Apple Dumpling this weekend-I bought 4 containers of it! I cleaned out the supply of it at the Ukrop’s in Roanoke, VA. It’s awesome.
October 17th, 2007 at 8:22 pmI had my tonsils removed–twice.
I do remember the ice cream, but the pain was too great for me to eat it.
October 17th, 2007 at 8:11 pmIt seemed totally unfair!
I knew ice cream wasn’t the way to go when two of my children had their tonsils removed. As a matter of fact, their otolaryngologist……what a mouthful………..suggested putting crackers, chips or cookies beside their bed because it would help keep the phlegm from the throat area and they would heal faster……..It worked! His reference point was when he and his twin had their tonsils out…He ate chips and crackers and his brother ate ice cream. He was up and about much sooner than his brother was!
October 17th, 2007 at 7:58 pmWow, I’m glad I never had to get my tonsils out either, I use any excuse for some TH indulgence!!! It makes you happy which in turn makes you feel better!! And you can quote me! There’s never been a time that I ate TH that I didn’t feel happier afterward, I swear it’s number 1 under the ingredients listing!
October 17th, 2007 at 4:36 pmYou know… doctors can be wrong…
I’m just glad I have not had my tonsils removed. I’d have to get my ice cream intravenously or something…
(Or that sherbet idea sounds like a good option too…)
October 17th, 2007 at 11:00 amThese comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.
The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.