Better late than never, but we just learned that this past Saturday was National Peanut Butter Lovers Day. Who doesn’t love peanut butter? On a sandwich, on chocolate or just a big spoonful on the go. Of course, it also goes well with ice cream. Even though the holiday has already come and gone, below is a listing of Turkey Hill flavors that use peanuts or peanut butter you can sample to help you celebrate in style.
Buffalo Bills Stampede Sundae (premium recipe)
Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks (light recipe)
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup (premium recipe)
Eagles Touchdown Sundae (premium recipe)
Graham Canyon (frozen yogurt)
Jets Sundae Blitz (premium recipe)
Moose Tracks (light recipe)
Nutty Caramel Carabou (frozen yogurt)
Peanut Brittle (no sugar added)
Peanut Butter Mania (light recipe)
Peanut Butter Ripple (premium recipe)
Tin Roof Sundae (premium recipe)
Moose Tracks (Creamy Commotions)
Tastykake Peanut Butter Kandy Kake (Creamy Commotions)
Loading ...
If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
Bring on the peanut butter! I like to put a spoonful on my chocolate ice cream now and then. Now I really want some. I hope I have peanut butter at home!
WE LOVE GO NUTS OVER PEANUTS SO MUCH WE .PUT PEANUTS ON TOP OF TURKEY HILL ICE CREAM AND IN HOME-MADE COOKIES, IT IS LIKE THE TURKEY HILL ,ICE CREAM. HOW ABOUT MAKING SOME UTTERLY MOO NUTTY COW ICE CREAM
I love the Bills Ice Cream! Can’t wait to watch the Bills win the Super Bowl while eating a bowl of Billa Ice Cream
This just might be my favorite day. I love peanut butter, especially when it is in a sundae with some Turkey Hill.
I love peanut butter, the crunchier the better, add dark chocolate and I’m in heaven. A great ice cream treat to put together.
I should add that we love Moose Tracks at our house.
Although I eat peanut butter on hot toast regularly, I don’t long for it in ice cream (go figure). From your list of products, I would go with Turkey Hill Tin Roof Sundae.
Yes Yes peanut butter is one of my favorite foods and will eat some again today to celebrate!!!!! Love to take Peanut Butter and melt it a little bit but leave some solid to it and put it over any flavor icecream. Little off the subject but how about taking a spoon of peanut butter and adding chocolate chips to the spoon. Also try a peanut butter , mayo and banana sandwich.Don’t say Yuk to the sandwich until you try it and get the taste as kids love it too.
Any flavor ice cream with peanut butter is a favorite of mine but Moose Tracks and Buffalo Bills Stampede Sundae are right at the top of my list. Hope Bruce Smith is right about the Bills being in the Super Bowl….that would be awesome!
I fell in love with peanut butter topping on chocolate ice cream years ago!! It’s different than the ‘pre-made’ peanut butter cup, cause the topping is soft and smooth and creamy! Much better, I think! It was hard to find until Reese’s came out with it pretty recently. We got it in the large cans for the IC parlor we had.
love peanut butter in our hot fudge sause for a topping for turkey hill world famous sundies
Whether you love peanut butter or not, I would recommend trying the Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks. I have found that the T.H. coupons are an encouragement to try new flavors, especialyy when it is on sale, and you also have a coupon. This is not a flavor I would usually pick to try, glad I did, it is fabulous!
I love to take diluted, melted peanut buttet and pour it over my ice cream…it’s even good for diabetics cause it’s protein!!
MMMMM all great ice cream flavors! Keep the peanut butter coming.
peanut butter is one of our favorite toppings and of course the eagles icecream, light moose tracks and kandykake, and the choclate pb cup.
oh dear, I missed another great celebration, but don’t worry, I have some Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup to drown my sorrows in and enjoy
I Love peanut butter what a great day to celebrate eating ice cream with peanut butter!!!
When you can’t find any Turkey Hill containing peanuts why not have peanut butter cookies with your ice cream. Some of the best are those sold by the Girl Scouts at this time of year.
I love all of the peanut butter flavors you guys use!
Try a peanut butter float. Oh my gosh it is heaven
We have food allergy issues, so I’m afraid we can’t try a lot of those. But we think your vanilla bean is the best ever!!!
One bowl and it’s all over for me! Eating Turkey Hill turns into two, sometimes THREE bowls in one sitting – somebody HELP ME!!!!!!!
Turkey Hill ice cream is the best! Any thing with peanuts or peanut butter will work for me. My all time favorite is chocolate peanut butter cup.
I absolutely enjoy peanut butter icecream or especially swirled in!!!
I was lucky enough to find the Eagles icecream in NY and every time I see it in the freezer, sale or not I purchase the icecream.
I keep icecream on hand so that when I cannot fall asleep I have a scoop or two before bed and it helps me to fall asleep within the 1/2 hour. Perhaps it’s the milk that does the trick, but it’s the flavor that sends me to sleep with a smile!
Yeah, you know Mint Chocolate Chip will/should win, hands down. There isn’t a substitute out there (believe me I’ve tried). I used to live in Florida and I would even find it there sometimes which was a great cool treat.
My family loves Moose Tracks Ice Cream most of all the flavors. I can buy others but then I have to buy two and one of them has to be Moose Tracks.
mint chocolate chip is definately my favorite type of ice cream. I especially love Turkey Hill’s mint chocolate chip because the chocolate is not hard and chunky but light, flakes
Moose Tracks is my second favorite – Its just such a great mixture of chocolate, peanut butter, and carmel.
- yum -
I am in love with just about every Turkey Hill ice cream flavor=but most of all the Chocolate Peanut Butter. Keep the flavors coming!
Peanut butter anything is my husband’s favorite. If he can’t find a Turkey Hill ice cream with peanut butter in it he buys vanilla, and dips the peanut butter by spoonfuls from the jar onto his ice cream in the bowl.
I know that a Tin Roof Sundae gives me everything I could want in an Ice Cream. Nuts, Chocolate and Marshmallow all combned into a smooth delicious sumptious taste. Nothing beats that. Not in a million years.
Dan
Picking a favorite Turkey Hill ice cream with peanuts or peanut butter is like picking a favorite book for a bookworm – almost impossible! However, to my taste buds, it is hard to beat Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!
whatever happened to coconut creme pie?
Please do not forget to include that – feels so good in your mouth you hate to swallow it- most fabulous- creamiest flavor of all time Chocolate Marshmellow. No one makes this flavor like Turkey Hill, it is the best comfort flavor around, even if you do not need comforting.
Moose Tracks (Creamy Commotions)!! Wins this competition,HANDS DOWN!
One of your most awesome flavors, Graham Canyon, should be on the list of ice creams containing peanut butter. It is not on the list, I believe, because it is not currently available for purchase, although it should be. When will you be bringing it back? ~Sherry
I was so disappointed to hear that Graham Canyon frozen yogurt was discontinued!! It was so difficult to find this flavor in my area. I hope that it is added again (even temporarily!!) to your frozen yogurt line.
The most wonderful thing about Turkey Hill products is that you can get whatever you want 12 months of the year. Every flavor of ice cream is available for you to try whether it is an old standby or something new. I enjoy selecting something new depending on my mood. I can select a pint or I can select the larger size. I enjoy having so many selections.