Looking for a flavor or a store that sells Turkey Hill Ice Cream? Check out our Flavor Finder and our Store Finder. Can’t find a store near you? Now you can order Turkey Hill Ice Cream online!

March 14th, 2008 | Category: General

KEEP THE VOTES COMING!

Posted by: Turkey Hill Team

Wow, the Ultimate Flavor Tournament is DEFINITELY under way! So many of you have already weighed in with your opinions about who should win in the first round of the tournament and there’s still time to vote if you haven’t already. The Sweet 16 polls will close on Monday morning and the winners will move on to the “Delicious Eight.” Delicious Eight  voting will be open for one week, so visit the Ice Cream Journal again on Monday to vote for who makes it into the “Frosty Four.”

For all of our new readers who have joined us over the last few days, WELCOME! We’re glad to have you and hope that you become regular Ice Cream Journal readers. Just a reminder, you can sign up to have new Journal blog entries (we write two or three new entries each week) e-mailed to you by entering your e-mail address in the “Subscribe” field on the right.

Link to Entry
Previous Article: THE ULTIMATE FLAVOR TOURNAMENT HAS BEGUN!

Next Article: ROUND TWO: THE DELICIOUS EIGHT HAS BEEN DECIDED!

68 Comments

Carol Byrnes wrote:

I love the mango/vanilla ice crean— it is smooth and refreshing


Carol Byrnes wrote:

I love the mangao/canilla ice crean— it is smooth and refreshing


Niecarrah wrote:

Rapsberry Duetto is quintessentially the
most perfect blend, of the two most superb flavors married together!


mary frey wrote:

I HATE SAY , THAT THEY ARE WINNERS. JUST BECAUSE TURKEY HILL MAKES THE BEST;


Sharon wrote:

Love the Duetto’s all flavors and they make great summer drinks. Let’s keep
voting for Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup,
it’s so creamy and when the flavors mic
together, it’s chocopblicious!


Tom O wrote:

So the ONLY BRAND to buy Turkey Hill, leds us all (ice cream addicts) to choose and pick all of its wonderful flavors of their ice cream and frozen yogurts, and narrow the flavors down to a few choice winners. Guys this is not fair… Black Cherry is GREAT, but Black Raspberry still ROCKS!


christie wrote:

Turkey Hill rocks. There are always a few cartons in my freezer. We all love our ice cream.


Christine wrote:

If only my basketball bracket would do as well as my ice cream picks! Good thing ice cream is a super comfort food!


Darcy F. wrote:

Huskie fans are Mad about Skinny Minty in March….Go UCONN & go Skinny Minty!!


Amy K Gross wrote:

What’s going on with the choc. pretzel? I think that’s a big upset. It looks like Mint Choc. Chip is the leader. I bought it Friday(at midnight)for my 6 kids and it was gone by Sat. afternoon. I think it’s the leader at my house as well. Amy


Toni wrote:

Dutch Chocolate - divine!


R. Frazer wrote:

Congrats to Heels fans. Let’s celebrate the ACC Championship with a big bowl of Turkey Hill Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup.


Peggy Gavin wrote:

I like Iris Hookes sugestion of peanut butter & chocolate in vanilla ice cream sounds yummy.


Sue P wrote:

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough-my family’s favorite!


Peggy wrote:

Turkey Hill ice cream rocks!!….especially the peanut butter ripple and moose tracks!


Holly wrote:

Dutch Chocolate reigns supreme over all other brands of ice cream. It is a flavor that you can never get tired of if you like chocolate. It is a classic.


Holly wrote:

Dutch Chocolate is a classic. It reigns supreme over all over brands and is the best classic Turkey Hill flavor.


EMacK wrote:

That Duetto is the BOMB!! All the flavors are winners. No second places here. Keep up the good work :)


Anne King wrote:

I agree with “Barbara”-love your Southern Lemon Pie! No one makes a good lemon real ice cream!


sherri digiovanni wrote:

Raspberry definetely has my vote, but all of the others that have tried are good also, still working on trying them all!!


Elaine wrote:

There is no better than Turkey Hill Philadelphia Style Vanilla Bean! Eat it as is or add your favorite toppings … it’s a win/win situation :o)


janine wrote:

I love to mix a couple of ice creams when I have mine. I usually mix a light with a regular or two lights. Moose tracks is one og my favorites.


Barbara wrote:

Great flavors to choose from but you are missing my favorite - Southern Lemon Pie. Do you know that you have the one and only really GOOD lemon ice cream out there?? (Your lemon duetto is good, too.) This is a rare flavor and Turkey Hill makes it the very best!!


peg wrote:

KEEP THE DIFFERENT FLAVORS COMING. i like trying them all.


peg wrote:

Keep the different lavors coming. I just love to try them.


Stefanie Schmidt wrote:

There is no denying that turkey hill is the best tasting ice cream and this is the tastiest competition ever. It looks like there are some clear winners in some categories, but it is still neck and neck for the best fruit and yogurt competitors. But no matter what happens, everyone wins with turkey hill!


Stefanie Schmidt wrote:

This has got to be the tastiest grudge match in history. The votes are close, but it looks like the creamy Eagles Touchdown sundae, mint chocolate chip and chocolate peanut butter or no match for their competitors. Its neck and neck and anybodys game in the race for the best yogurt and fruit. Keep voting and keep eating Turkey Hill…yum!


Carolyn wrote:

I work with over 60 children in an after school program - all I have to say is we are having ice cream and all of them ask what are we celebrating? I tell them “ice cream”! Turkey Hill has so many great flavors and we have tried quite a few and will continue to do for the rest of the school year! To celebrate ice cream!!!!!


R. Frazer wrote:

Chocolate peanut butter cup is the BEST!


Deb wrote:

OH my goodness! We just got Turkey Hill Ice Cream in our area of Indiana and Man. You guys rock. Way better than the other premium ice creams on the market. Great job. I love raspberry dueto


Alvin wrote:

Butter Pekan is my favourite and will
always be. Butter P is the favourite of
allmy friends and neighbours


Pat wrote:

Just had some Fudge Ripple, another one of my favorites. With all these favorites it is so hard to choose. I will just have to keep taste testing. :)


GES wrote:

Anyone remember the “Death by Chocolate” flavor? I was awsome and even came in regular AND light—so u could eat more! What ever happened to it? Can’t find anymore!


Pat wrote:

Just had some Fudge Ripple, Another favorite of mine. I have so many favorites it is hard to choose.


Mike Y wrote:

Go peanut Butter and Rasberry. Glad I finally got a chance to vote


Pat wrote:

Chocolate and Peatnut Butter - nothing better!


Cheryl Rhine wrote:

Ahhh! Chocolate and Peanut butter, Turkey Hill Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, It doesn’t get any better than that!!!!


Joan MM wrote:

There is something about Turkey Hill Ice Cream that just isn’t in the other big name brands, must be the old fashioned care you take in making it.


Marge wrote:

We love Dutch Chocolate and Black Rasberry and we eat ONLY Turkey Hill ice cream!!


Rachel Justin Karen wrote:

I just went food shopping and of course picked up my weekly supply of Turkey Hill. I eat it every night.


Rachel Justin Karen wrote:

I decided to check in even on the weekend. I can’t wait to see which flavor is the ultimate winner.


Maureen Bordzuk wrote:

I have to say that my favorite is Chocolate Marshmallow but the Cherry Duetto is a close second. Turkey Hill has THE best ice cream around. Keep up the good work.


Jean Marando wrote:

Chocolate peanut butter cup is our choice for the Turkey Hill Awards.


Ron wrote:

Turkey Hill Raisin Rum Ice Cream is great, but it would be awesome with double the raisins !


Glenda Yablonsky wrote:

ANything with Chocolate is a hit in my family. Moose Tracks is a favorite or Choc and PB. How about makingChoc and PB with a lot of everything else like an everything bagel?
Turkey Hill Ice cream rules*****


Richard B. wrote:

Anything with chocolate and peanuts has to be the best, either together or separate.


KEN N. wrote:

Raspberry Duetto and Peanut Butter anything are the “BOMB” as my five (5)
grandchildren would say!


Linda V wrote:

I agree with Melanie, Turkey Hill Dutch Chocolate is the best chocolate I’ve eaten.


Iris Hooke wrote:

I would like to see both chocolate and peanut butter rippled through vanilla ice cream as a choice of new products.


Cate wrote:

I keep telling my friends that Turkey Hill ice cream is the best. This week, a few of us were at a conference at Willow Valley in Lancaster. My friends and I had the soft serve ice cream. Everyone was raving about it! Guess what, it is Turkey Hill Soft Serve. Go Turkey Hill, you win on all fronts! Thank you.


Melanie Lee wrote:

I have to say that Turkry Hill Dutch Chocolate is the best I have ever had. I am a die hard chocolate lover so I think I know superior taste when confronted with it!


Melanie Lee wrote:

Turkey Hill has the best ice cream. They have a great selection of flavors, and their Dutch Chocolate is the best I have ever tasted.


Jennifer Barr wrote:

whatever happened to the flavor …i think it was called deep dish apple pie ? I havn’t seen it in a LONG time. That was my absolute favorite :)


Jacqueline wrote:

Okay, I voted in the poll. It seems like my tastes are with the majority.
Good to know!

We’re eating chocolate chip cookie dough at the moment. And it’s going fast!


Donna wrote:

Turkey Hill has so many flavors available it is hard to choose a favorite — let alone which ones to take home.


dan murray wrote:

OH BOY, DECISIONS DECISIONS,
when theyare all so good how do you pick a FAVORITE?
usually i choose by “WHIM” at the counter.BUT i most allways go for the BLACK CHERRY so that must be at the top of my list. HOORAY


rhy wrote:

raspberry duetto rules!!!


Margaret Skinner wrote:

Love so many flavors its hard to choose!


eric wrote:

Peanut butter ripple is awesome. Maybe you could add some chocolate covered pretzels to it and make a new flavor.


Cynthia wrote:

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough!!!! Does this count as “health food” for my kids??? They DEVOUR gallons of this stuff! This is a fabulous idea! KUDOS.


Christina M. wrote:

I third fourth or fifth vote for the Cherry vs. Lemon Duetto, I really would have thought that would have been right up there with Choc. Vs. Vanilla. Keep these tournaments coming, this is extremely fun!!


Jenny wrote:

My boyfriend will be very disappointed if peanut butter ripple doesn’t grab the title! It has to be in our freezer at ALL TIMES!!


Heidi wrote:

Turkey Hill is the best ice cream on the face of the planet! My dream job is being a Turkey Hill taste tester. Moose Tracks rules!!!


GES wrote:

Cherry Duetto rocks!!! Would like to see a vote on Cherry vs Lemon Duetto!


GES wrote:

Duetto Cherry Rocks, yet not on list!
Would be interested in a vote re. Lemon vs Cherry Duetto!


Leslie Carcaise wrote:

Raspberry anything rocks!


Barbara wrote:

These flavors are all valid entries, but in regard to the duetto flavors which are great my favorite is the original cherry. Oh, sweet!!! My daughters love it, too. We ate it when it was still “gelato” and I can hardly ever find a carton of it.


Butter Brickle Fan wrote:

Go Chocolate chip peanut butter cup! That’s the best flavor ever. It will probably win it all.


These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.