The latest Turkey Hill Limited Edition flavor – Coconut Cream Pie – has been popping up in grocery stores here in Lancaster County which means it should be arriving in a freezer aisle near you soon. The flavor is a combination of creamy coconut ice cream swirled with coconut cream pie pieces. It’s the perfect excuse to squeeze in at least one more picnic in August before the summer ends!
Tags: ice cream, turkey hill
These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.
The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.

If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
Looking good. I’ve been wanting to try that flavor for a while now. Hopefully it’ll trickle down south in the next month or two.
I am very much looking forward to trying this ice cream. Coconut cream pie is a big favorite in our house. Thank you for creating this flavor…Yum!
Oh my…..this is sinfully delightful!YUMMMMMMMYYYYYYY!
This sounds great! I’m looking forward to trying this new flavor.
OOOh I can’t wait til I can try it ..YuMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!
i definitly will buy it soon as i see it in the store.sounds good to me.
Wow this flavor sounds amazing and is definitely going to be my new favorite flavor. Thanks Turkey Hill!
I will be watching for this to arrive at my grocery store. We all love Coconut Cream Pie so to have this flavor of Turkey Hill ice cream will be such a wonderful treat!
Coconut cream pie – another favorite dessert. Can’t wait to try it. Now, if you can come up with something that’s like Banana Pudding…….That’s what I’m talking about!!
Now that looks gooooood!!
Yum!!! You’re so clever!!!
wow! can’t wait to go find this one!
I love coconut cream pie so this ice cream will be one I will try!! This week I bought TH Peaches and Cream.
I will be watching for Coconut Cream Pie. Sounds interesting. Perfect for our next block party and Luau.
This sounds so delicious and coconut cream pie is a favorite of mine. How about making this flavor in a yogurt or slow churned version for those who are watching their diet?
Who needs the perfect excuse to squeeze in at least one more picnic? We prefer Baqckyard BBQ’s since it is easier to go to the freezer than carry all that food. Life is enough of a reason to invite freiends and family over to enjoy the outdoors and food. An ice cream dish of an interesting flavor is always a plus and the Coconut Cream Pie fits the bill. I hope our local stores get it before the outdoor season ends.
I love these Limited Edition Flavors. The Gertrude Hawk Box Of Chocolates was a 5 star, gold medal, academey award winning flavor. Definitely my favorite. I would love to see it available again (hint,hint,hint). I am sure this Coconut Cream Pie will be good, but nothing comes remotely close to the Gertrude Hawk Box Of Chocolates.
Robin, I have to agree that the Box of Chocolates is the best limited edition flavor I’ve ever had. As a matter of fact it runs neck and neck with Party Cake as my all-time favorite flavor. I think you guys should make it a permanent flavor.
This sounds awesome! I tried the duetto rootbeer and vanilla this week – and I’m hard pressed to say which flavor is my absolute favorite!
Had the coconut and chocolate duetto, could have used some coconut pieces in it. Will try this coconut cream pie, sounds delicious
This sounds delicious. Can you send me a sample please?
Sounds delicioso and a coupon for a container of it would be great!
MOO ON OVER,GALS ; I GOT MY SPOON!
This sounds great! I am the only one in this family who likes coconut. Bring it on! All for me!
I’m still waiting for Peaches and Cream to get to my area. Hey TH did you guys make German Chocolate Cake this year? It was the June flavor of the month. Maybe it didn’t make it to my area. We seem to get the limited editions about 2 months later.
WOW!!!, life doesn’t get better than this, my favorite flavor of pie and now I can have it in Turkey Hill Ice Cream……thank you, I just hope this flavor is in my area……(Western PA)
I am going to check at the Giant Eagle today and let you know.
The new coconut cream I’m anxious to try
I wish the next flavor would be Key Lime
Pie!
Sounds delicious, can’t wait to try it.. keep producing more different flavors.
I’m going to my local TH Store after dinner tonight to check for the Coconut Cream Pie Ice Cream, just love Coconut. If they don’t have it yet I will get another wonderful TH flavor, there is no doubt about that. Linda
That really sounds good to me—will try it for sure.
No kidding, I was just saying yesterday how I could eat some coconut cream pie and now I see this!! You bet I’ll be looking for some!!!
Yes, thank you, I have been waiting for coconut cream pie, too. Graham slam has not showed up around this area, I guess I have to ask about it at the grocery store and see if they will get it.
Can’t wait for this to show up on the freezer section in our local Wegmans
My husband’s favorite.
Good Evening to all Turkey Hill Fans,
I hope to find this one in the store. I have not found the Jr.Mint one yet. I love Jr. Mint Ice Candy. I know I will like the ice cream. As allways, Turkey Hill Ice Cream…..You have come up with a another great ice cream. Coconut cream pie ice cream lover this is your dream come true. Turkey Hill Coconut cream pie ice cream.
Our Turkey Hill store and Giant didn’t have the Coconut Cream Pie, but I was told when I called another TH Store that they have Duetto Choc. Coconut, must go tomorrow and get that one, sound Delicious. Now I would like Peanut Butter Ice Cream. I have the Peanut Butter Swirl, but would really love plain Peanut Butter. Linda
mmm sounds delicious! Can’t wait until my supermarket gets it!!!
Looks like we have to make another trip to the US for your new ice cream Boy do we like coconut
Rose.
I would like to try a lemon cream with coconut in my ice cream box. Someone mentioned key lime and that also brings my taste buds wanting these new flavors.
Haven’t even found the Jr Mint yet!
dont like coconut but ill try it
I wish i could try it but i am allergic to cconut. but like all the others
It has been years since I had the real coconut cream pie. But in the meantime I certainly wouldn’t mind trying the Turkey Hill version. I marvel at the unique flavors that Turkey Hill makes.
I agree with Sarah. I need to watch my cholesterol so I try to buy only the low-fat and no-fat versions of ice cream. I love coconut cream pie and would love to try this.
Coconut Cream Pie has been my favotie pie forever. I can’t wait to get my hands on that ice cream
Wow this sounds delicious!!! Hurry TH stock my store freezers!!!!
Coconut Cream pie is my favorite! I can’t wait until it arrives in Rochester, NY!!!!
Can’t wait to try it.Sounds delish!!!
One of my favorite pies!!! Can’t wait to try the Turkey Hill ice cream. Is there, by chance, a Turkey Hill Boston cream pie!?
At holidays, my Mom made everyone their favorite pie, & yep, mine was coconut custard. Can’t wait. You just keep stirring up such fine childhood memories with all your summer flavors.
Thanks Turkey Hill!!!