On January 30, because of the ongoing peanut investigation by the FDA, we announced a voluntary recall on six Turkey Hill Ice Cream Flavors and, on Friday, we announced the recall of our Dynamic Duos Movie Night flavors.
Ever since the day we announced the recall, the Turkey Hill team has been hard at work identifying a new peanut supplier. We’re happy to announce that we’ve found a new supplier and that three of the recalled flavors are currently being produced with new ingredients (but with the same Lancaster County taste). Those flavors, which include Tin Roof Sundae (1.5 quart), Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks (1.5 quart) and Nutty Caramel Caribou Frozen Yogurt (1.5 quart), will be hitting shelves in the next couple of weeks!
It’s probably been a long month for those of you who are fans of those flavors (including many of us here at Turkey Hill), which is why were so happy to announce this news. As for Movie Night and the other recalled flavors, production of those will begin in the near future. When those flavors are ready to hit stores, we’ll let you know.
In the meantime, enjoy the return of these nutty flavors. As always, if you have any questions, feel free to email us using the “Contact Us” page of the Turkey Hill website.
Tags: ice cream, peanuts, recall, turkey hill

If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
Yes, Rocky Road will soon be back — how cool is that?
Actually in my haste I wrote Rocky Road, when I meant Tin Roof Sundae–I guess that’s because I am always eating some kind of ice cream
Great job, Turkey Hill!!!
Tin Roof Sundae is my favorite, can’t wait for it to be in the stores.
Hi Turkey Hills Fans,
I know Iwas missing some flavor when I went tot he store to buy some turkey Hill ice cream. I end up getting the three flavor chocolate,strawberry and vanilla. I was looking for the Nuttey carmael one. or the tine roof. Yu have so many to choose from..I don’t think I ever get try of eating turkey Hill ice cream.
Glad to hear.
yea from our th lovers
It has been a long month, but well worth the wait, since some of my favorite flavors will be back.Turkey Hill rocks. Linda
Glad to hear things will be returning to normal and I can get my favorite flavors in time for SPRING!!!
Great! I missed Nutty Moose Tracks!
I am very happy to see that all these flavors, especially Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks will be available soon. Thank you, Turkey Hill for getting a new supplier so soon and keeping us informed on the changes.
Thank goodness Turkey Hill is such a responsible company. Not only for taking the flavors off the market but quickly bringing them back to the delight of the consumers. Hopefully the concern over peanuts will pass and we can go back to really enjoying our favorite Turkey Hill ice cream.
All good things are worth waiting for…YIPEE!
I never doubted that Turkey Hill would do the responsible thing to benefit its customers and its company. Thank you Turkey Hill…I will keep on buying your products because I know that they are delicious, good, and the company is responsible.
Thanks for keeping us up to date. Wish more companies were like you.
So glad to hear the good news. They are all some of my favorite flavors and I missed them. Going to load up. I knew Turkey Hill would come through.
I am so excited these flavors are returning and thank you so much Turkey Hill for looking out for the safety of your consumers. I wish we could get free samples of the new flavors before they hit the shelves, they sound amazing.
I love Turkey Hill – Especially the Nutty Combos!
As long as its Turkey Hill I don’t care what the flavor is as long as you fill my bowl LOL. I just love any flavor, can’t choose which I love the most.I have lots of different TH flavors in my freezer at this moment. Tonight will have Party Cake Hmmmm. Linda
Yum, yum, yum.
Turkey Hill Ice Cream – GOBBLE IT DOWN !
why dont you make fried icecream more often. PLEASE…………………….
Love Turkey Hill Ice Cream – have a hard time finding it in CT!
god bless you, in honestly truth about the recall of turkey hill ice cream;;;
wow, wonderful new.on the way about turkey hill
Dynamic Duos Caramel Cone Chaos — yum
love the taste of rocky road can’t for it’s return.
Thank you Thank you Thank you!!!
I would really like that blueberry cheesecake ice cream.
Thanks for getting Phylly’s Grand Slam in our super market, Martins.