Only two flavors remain in our Ultimate Flavor Tournament — Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake and Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. Who will win? Your votes in the poll on the right will decide! As always in the final round, Ernie will refrain from choosing a winner (he doesn’t want his “expert opinion” swaying the voting process), but he will offer an analysis of both final round flavors.
CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP
“Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is the Chicago Cubs of the Ultimate Flavor Tournament. A great, lovable flavor, but it always seems to come up short in winning the title. With Vanilla Bean (the New York Yankees of the tournament) and Light Recipe Moose Tracks on the bench, this could be the year CPBC finally steps up to the plate and hits one out of the park to win the whole thing. By the way, can you tell it’s spring? I think I’ve used more than enough baseball references in this analysis to last the entire season.”
TASTYKAKE CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
“If its competitor is the Chicago Cubs of ice cream flavors, then Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake is the Kansas City Royals (right down to the royal blue color). It’s a small, pint-sized flavor, and certainly the underdog of the tournament. No one would have predicted it would be here on week five, just one win away from a championship title. Does this little flavor have the heart and drive to win it all? Your votes will decide!”
Tags: ice cream, tournament, turkey hill
Loading ...
If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
well, well, well, look at this, it has come down to chocolate peanut butter cup vs chocolate peanut butter cake. how can we choose? it will be a tie or it will be all one sided. I know which side I want to win.
i don’t even have to second guess on this….we’ve only bought chocolate peanut butter cup.
This is a very tough decision!! Hmmm… what to do, what to do!!
I have to vote for the chocolate peanut butter cup because it looks like a larger container.
You can do it Chocolate Peanut Butter you can win this one…Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake can come in 2nd for me too. Love them both…
I am surrprised at the final two. Moose Track lovers where are you? Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates will always be the #1 to me. Like the gold medal winner in the ice cream olympics.
Choc PB Cup has this one in the bag, I am sure of it!!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is the flavor that turned me on to Turkey Hill in the first place. I haven’t looked back and have converted many loyal ice creams fans as a result. CPBC is THE BEST!!
I literally can’t choose. I’ll have to review the descriptions of each or better yet purchase one of each and give it a taste test (hey is this your ultimate goal! You’re sneaky).
That’s OK , But give me good old raspberry
Mmmm, good old strawberries & cream for me
My vote it cast (no going back). I think I made the right choice as a light ice cream purchaser.
I love your ice cream!
I voted for my favorite peanut butter cup, but banana split will always be my other favorite.
Love ‘em both, but favor the tried & true Chocolate PB Cup. I have a son with a nut allergy & it’s my only contact with my former peanut butter love.
Imagine a duet version of these two flavors!
i think they are all winners. congrats to which ever flavor wins.
I really like peanut butter cup, but would prefer vanilla ice cream
I like both, but I’m going with the veteran on this one. Gotta love that peanut butter.
I chose, I voted and now I’m eating (one scoop of both please!) LOL
Chocolate cupcake sounds wonderful. Will have to buy some.
I grew up with Tastykake cupcakes. I like peanut butter. But I think nostalgia wins out. I vote for the chocolate cupcake.
Also, I don’t have the link available on the right side of my screen to vote. Is there another way to vote?
glad it came down to a chocolate flavor this year…but it’s a hard choice…I was still hoping that Box of chocolates would have been in the finals…maybe next year…
even though i still haven’t tasted chocolate pb cup, i’ll have to go with tastykake ch cupcake.
I can only dream of a duet with both flavors, or add PB swirl to Tastycake. No matter what, DO put Tastycake in a large container so my local store will carry it and I can finally taste it.
i definitely vote for the Tastykake!! what a great combo–ice cream and chocolate cupcakes…
I know I’m in a distinct minority, but I just don’t like peanut butter.
Glad I voted for the underdog. I am not a chocolate fan so I wouldn’t really enjoy either of these. But since I live in Philly, and grew up with Tastykakes, that’s where my vote went. Good luck, Tastykake, hope you come out the winner…
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup all the way. It’s about time it got the respect it deserves!
Wow, chocolate and peanut butter
together. I start to drool just
thinking about it.
Hard choice to make.
I think Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is the BEST!!!!
Chocolate Peanut Butter is my favorite. But where’s Butterscotch? TH has to make it, I know it would be delicious!
TASTYKAKE CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE and BUTLER ALL THE WAY TO WIN.
mmmmm…chocolate!
I have a confession to make. I love Chocolate, peanutbutter & nuts, but for some strange reason, I hate any flavor chocolate ice cream. Go figure! So I don’t care which flavor wins! I’m sticking with good ole fashion vanilla & the new coconut cream pie, delicious!
Hi everyone, I can’t make up my mind. they are both very good. So I have to say both. I can eat both together also. I try them both together and they both taste good together.
tastycake chocolate cupcake
Which one’s Republican?
You just can’t go wrong with Chocolate and Peanut Butter Cup. Go Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Go!!!!!!!
How can anyone go wrong choosing anything containing chocolate and peanut butter?
Turkey Hill no matter what !!!! but vanilla or coconut first please–
Chocolate cupcakes and cream…a natural combination to win!
Not a big one on Peanut Butter, So that one is out for me , Thanks
I don’t love peanut butter!!!! Could we try some hazelnut instead. That goes great with chocolate, too.
love chocolate peanut butter cup and tastykake chocolate cupcake so either way its a winner for me. Thanks TH
Chocolate peanut butter cup all the way!
No question – chocolate peanut buttercup all the way and then some!!!!!!!
I don’t like peanut butter so Tastykake ftw!
To the Victor..goes the spoils! Some spoils huh?
Super hard choice but I’ve got to go with the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. It is delicious,
Chocolate peanut butter cup for me! Rah1 Rah! Rah1
Peanut butter cup
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup all the way!!!
Tastycake and TurkeyHill go together great
Chocolate penut butter cup !!! Yum!!The best wait until I tell my mom it has made it this far (and I think It will win) she will be so happy.
just as good as easter candy to me, would love to have ssome in the freezer right now
I voted and now I am waiting to here the announcement of the winner.
Chocolate and peanut butter …. NO CONTEST!
I love the chocolate peanut butter
chocolate anytime
Peanut Butter Cup and Moose Tracks are two of my favorites from Turkey Hill but there are many others I enjoy too!
I LOVE Chocolate Peanut Butter cup! It blends my two most favorite things in life!
there is nothing in the world like a TASTYKAKE CUPCAKE AND TO INCORPORATE THAT WITH ICE CREAN JUST MAKES MY MOUTH WATER. we don’t get tastykake here in Corry,Pa but I am from NJ and we had them all the time, I so miss them and this would be like a dream come true.
Chocolate and chocolate cupcakes are good but the contrasting flavors of chocolate and peanut butter are beyond delicious. Turkey Hill’s is best as it is peanut butter swirls instead of cups…just the right balance.
I would like to see the taste cake ice cream, that really sounds good.
I got to go with the tastykake. I’m from Philly, what can I say!!!
TastyCake chocolate cupcakes have been one of my favorites for as long as I can remember…to team it up with another of my favorites(TH chocolate ice cream), just puts me in chocolate heaven!
turkey hill ice cream is the best and the very best ice cream is the chocolate peanut butter cup hands down. i would be in my glory to have a never ending supply of the fantastic ice cream. way to go turkey hill your #1.
We purchase at least 1 container of Chocolate peanut butter cup every time we buy Turkey Hill ice cream!
Not an easy choice but Chocolate Peanut Butter gets my vote.
I vote for the newcomer! Although they both are good (of course anything with chocolate is good
)
Awwwww………………..I was really rooting for York peppermint patty.
They are both great flavors!
Way to go Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup , now may you win the contest!!!!
We always buy chocolate Peanut Butter Cup so we both can enjoy it. See we also have to buy the vanilla kind so our doxies can have ice cream with us. I tried the Fudge coconut ice cream, that is so good.
We are pulling for Peanut butter chocolate cup ice cream to win!!
I think Chocolate Peanut butter Cup is the winner!
Neither is a favorite of mine, but chocolate peanut butter would have to be the winner.
Chocolate and PB has always been one of my favorite combos, and Turkey Hill does it right! It has my vote!!
” . . . swirled with ROASTED peanut butter.” Says it all! Go Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup! Yum!!
I think this poll is fixed. Original vanilla is the true winner. maybe I’m a little biased. Duh!
My votes for Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup cause they just go together so well!!
I vote for the chocolate peanut butter cup!
Choclate Peanut Butter Cup is finally getting its due! What could be better than a huge ripple of peanut butter surrounded by creamy chocolate ice cream???
I would love to have the Chocolate Peanutbutter Cup> The two flavors together, OH YUM!!!!!
Since my fav is out of the race, I’ll have to have Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup….there are no bad flavors, some are just better than others.
I hate peanut butter so you know what my choice is all your ice cream is good so it is a hard decision but peanut butter is out in my book.
chocolate peanut butter cup for me,tried it & liked it
My mom and I love ice cream and our true favorite is Phillies flavor you guys make. and though I had peanut butter in my food, the peanut butter cups are great in ice cream. my pick here is chocolate peanut butter cup
I’m glad to see a flavor that I would eat if I wasn’t Lactose Intolerant is in the lead. Keep on trucking, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup! I want you to win, so I can win! Yea!!!!!
With my allergy to nuts and anything made from them, there is only one choice for me…..Tastycake Chocolate Cupcake. Still….I am not surprised that Chocolate is in both the finalists as I think Turkey Hill makes the best chocolate ice cream just as it is.
Chocolate Tasty Cake YUM!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup,has my vote!
It’s no rocky road, but i will go ahead and accept the pending victory of PB cup.
Love Ernie’s analysis so fitting to the season but I think that PB will hit the grand slam and take the title home! yeah!
We always pick TastyKake products here.
What a tough decision! But in the end I had to vote for Peanut Butter Cup. At least Tasteykake Chocolate Cupcake made it into the final rounds!
My favorite is the light strawberry cheesecake. My second fav is the peanutbutter chocolate one that is being voted on….so that def. has my vote!
My vote goes to chocolate peanut butter cup! I love it!
there’s still time, tastykake. you can rally in the 9th
Besides chocolate what else could be better than peanut butter? Since I was about 4 and ate a half a jar of peanut butter and got sick it has been my favorite treat.
Tough decision. I love anything chocolate but Peanut Butter makes it the irresistable one!
You’ll find TH chocolate peanut butter cup in my freezer.
i voted for chocolate cupcake
Both are good, but Choc. Peanut Butter is better!
I’ve been looking for the TastyCake chocolate cupcake ice cream ever since they discontinued it in the big tub version. Unfortunately I cannot find this smaller version anywhere. Oh TastyCake chocolate cupcake, how I miss you so. Here’s my vote to you, hoping one day you’ll get back the place you deserve in our grocery freezers.
I love both flavors they are both winners in my opinion. Linda
This is my boys favorite flavor (hubby & son). They are not satisfied for me to buy just a single container but I have to get at least 2 cartons per shopping trip. I’e tried to get them to try something else just for varity but no deal – I still have to buy CPBC for their nightly ice cream fix.
Hands down – this is the winner.
DH
Vote Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake Now!!!
You can have your kake and eat it with ice cream too.
let’s see – peanut butter or cupcakes- cupcakes are it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
While tastykate holds a special place in my heart – there is no contest here Choc Peanutbutter has my vote – HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!
I am such a vanilla person….ice cream can stand alone…peanut butter combos are so overdone, so I will stick with tastykake…..
As much as I love Tastykake, I gotta go with chocolate peanut butter cup on this one.
Mmmm, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is amazingly delicious!
Since we don’t get tastykake in Michigan, it had to be Peanut butter Cup
Being originally from Philadelphia and now living in New England it brought make sweet memories of my youth. My vote is Tastykake
I like both flavors, but i will go with
chocolate peanut butter cup.
I tend to prefer the basic types of Ice Cream. Give me a great vanilla any time.
Both sound good, but wish they were either sugar free or reduced sugar for those of us who are limited in what we may enjoy.
Although Tasytkakes and Peanut Butter Cups are both made here in PA, nothing can compare to peanut butter. I have to vote for Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup.
When the winner is finally determined, there should be a run off against last year’s winner, since it was not put into this year’s tournament. Next year this year’s and last year’s winners should be held out until the winner is determined and then have a three way run off.
i’m 72 years old and still love ice cream just as i did when i was a kid.
Come on everyone, vote for for CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP……by far the best ice cream ever created!!!
Definitely chocolate peanut butter cup!
I just got back from a long extended vacation — I was so excited to see the flavor I had hoped would get in the finals to be there – CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP! I had posted this on the first day – so hurry up everyone and vote for the best flavor ever. But come to think of it, everything Turkey Hill makes is the best!
I have loved chocolate peanut butter cup since I was 8 and learned the technique to digging the awesome peanut buttery core out of the half gallon. My mom still yells at me for doing it to this day…so my vote must be for chocolate peanut butter cup.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Rocks!!!!
My vote is for the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup for sure! Love it!
4 Words … Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup — Need I say more?
PEANUT BUTTER CUP PLEASE……
peanut butter seals the deal! i love all things PB
The only thing better than the chocolate ice cream is the peanut butter swirl. This is the best combination of penut butter and chocolate since the R**s*’s Penut butter cup.
Anything with chocolate is great but I enjoy digging out that big chunk of peanut butter and letting it melt in my mouth!
I go to Fl in the winter. One of the first things I do when I reach Pa in the spring is buy TURKEY HILL CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP ice cream. I have tried every brand of chocolate peanut butter ice cream I could find and none of them are as good as Turkey Hills. There is no comparison!!!!!!!
I definitely vote for the chocolate peanut butter cup!!! This has always been my all time favorite. It has to win!!!!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup wins my vote. I’m getting hungry just thinking about it!
Chocolate Peanut Butter has it all -flavor, texture and coo0l, melt in your mouth creaminess (quality ingredients, too!).
One vote for the underdog!
Tastycake Chocolate Cupcake
I can close my eyes and imagine that I’m at the top of Mt. Everest savoring the ultimate in creamy chocolate euphoria.
It is no contest. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is the ice creamiest dessert imaginable.
Chocolate and peanut butter – the ultimate combination! Who could resist?
Peanut butter cup – definitely.
ALl my favs left in earlier rounds… oh well, i will vote my kid’s favorite here… CHocolate PB Cup. I say marshmallow and more marshmallow… choc marsh the best! I would like to see you add the marshmallow in other flavors… your marshmallow cannot be beat. I like to scoop it out of the half gallon and eat just that. You still get great choc ice cream that is left!
Chocolate PB Cup is the choice of the ice cream lovers in my family. No ifs, ands, or buts!
No competition in my family CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP all the way!
Tastycake chocolate cupcake – take me back to my youth growing up in Penna. when both baker and “ice cream man” came down the street in a truck, selling those tasty Tastycakes and choclate ice cream respectively
I am definitely more fond of the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. I hope it wins. I buy it regularly. My one son loves it!
Chocolate Cupcake for me, please.
Chocolate peanut butter cup all the way.
:-0
Chocolate peanut butter cup is my FAVORITE!
I love chocolate,I love cupcakes, and I love ice cream. So the combination stimulates my taste buds for a delightfully satisfying snack or dessert.
As long as it’s not chocolate covered turkey, I’ll be happy, although I prefer chocolate peanut butter cup.
Tastykake all the way!!!!!!! two local treats combined in one container cannot compete with any other flavor!
Chocolate & Peanut Butter! What better combination!!
Hmm..I’ll have to go with chocolate peanut butter cup. Honestly I’m a bit surprised other flavors didn’t make the cut. One of my personal favorites is Strawberry Cream. Also, I absolutely love Party Cake, even though I have read elsewhere that it is not in high demand.
What beats chocolate and peanut butter! It gets my vote hands down.Although I would eat the chocolate cupcake too!!
Chocolate peanut butter cup vs any other dessert treat and hands down the CPBC wins in my book. I love all Turkey Hill flavors and this one is a winning combination of two great favorites!
it hard to decide between the two. I would enjoy either flavor but peanut butter goes so good with anything
I love Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!!!
A dish of tastykake chocolate cupcake is like falling in love for the first time.
Stan mirel
Hi. I just love Turkey Hill Ice Cream. My favorite is Coffee but my next favorite would be Chocolate Peanut Butter. I voted for that one and hope that it wins.
Are you kidding me? Tastykake has GOT to win this one – it’s a no brainer! Growing up in the Northeast, I grew up snacking on Tastykakes. Mixing it into ice cream is GENIUS!
Chocolate peanut butter cup is absolutely my favorite flavor.I but it every month it’s on sale.
I always make certain we have Turkey Hill Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake ice cream in the house because my wife goes nuts every time I take it out of the freezer. (If only it had been around in my Single Days, they would have been much fewer!)
She says she loves me, but I think its really the ice cream.
hansenpj05(aat)aol.com
chocolate peanut butter
Tastykake Chocolate Cupcake makes the buzzer beating basket! The Pennsylvania home state team wins it all!
Both sound yummy but there are plenty of peanut butter ice creams out there, I say go with the tastycake!!
Chocolate Peanut Butter — although I would be happy with Any Turkey Hill Ice Cream.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is to DIE FOR!! It is a treat inside your mouth!
Ahhh! Tastykake Chocolate all the WAY!!
I love the Chocolate peanut butter flavor, but the tastycake one sounds pretty good, too!
Didn’t Josephine say “Let them eat cake”?? ….Lucky us,we can have our cake and ice cream too. Tasycake it is!
have our cake and eat it tooo!
yes i’m hoping and a praying it’ll be tastycake all the way, i’m 83 and tastycakes are my favorite,but either way Turkey Hill has the best ice cream this side of the rockies.
Chocolate and Peanut butter need I say any more!
Whenever chocolate and peanut butter are together it’s always a sure winner!
Chocolate Peanut butter all the way!! That’s my vote
Chocolate peanut butter cup is awesome. Coming from the Philadelphia area where Tasteycake hails from, made this choice a bit more interesting. HOWEVER, Peanut butter wins, how bout adding peanut butter tandy cakes? Oh yeah, U already have in the past. Good Job. Best Ice Cream EVER. Turkey Hill ROCKS>>>>>>
Both flavors sound great as the winner of this contest! I am partial to the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup though so I hope that one wins. My son is cheering for the Tastykake Stuffed Chocolate Cup Cake flavor to win! Time will tell whose flavor is the winner!
Definately chocolate peanut butter cup…i love my Tastykakes but Turkey Hill makes the best peanut butter/chocolate combo ice cream! I want some now! LOL
Tastycake Chocolate Cupcake should be the winner in my book.
Hard choice! Go Tastycake!
Go…Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!
Chocolate peanut butter cup should win because it’s better and it comes in a larger container.
Chocolate peanut butter should win because it’s better and comes in a larger container.
The real winner is everyone who gets to eat either flavor!
Chocolate peanut butter for me! I love the candy version and believe the ice cream version would be a delight. Haven’t seen either flavor at my local supermarkets, but hope to see them in the future.
No Contest-chocolate peanut butter cup is the winner in my book
Chocolate peanut butter go so well together. It will and still is my f a v o r i t e!!!
Chocolate Peanut Butter….all the way!
Chocolate Peanut Butter for us folks in Annapolis, MD!! And of course only Turkey Hill ice cream as well!!
I’m going to have to go with the Tastykake one. I’m a sucker of cake and ice cream.
Count me on team Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!
want to see cho peanut cup win
I don’t know which one should be the winner because the stores where I live don’t carry the Tastykake flavor
But my guess is that Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is hard to beat!
chocolate and peanut butter
Definitely Tasty Cake!! Turkey Hill shall remain original and one-of-a-kind!! Although chocolate with peanut butter is a fabulous flavor, it’s already available by other companies! Stay true to your own, Turkey Hill!.. that’s what makes you #1!!
My favorite is Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Cup
I wish I could find the Tastycake flavor, it sounds great. I would prefer that over Chocolate Peaunut Butter cup.
I have been trying to find the tastycake flavor but haven’t been able to!!!!
Hands down, the best ice cream ever, is Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. The best peanut butter and creamiest chocolate. Nothing else comes close!!
Tastykake gets my vote. Cupcake/ice cream combination? It’s like 2 desserts in one!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup gets my vote.
i never was a peanut butter fan, howver, after readingthe reviews, I will definiatly try it. But my vote still goes to Tastycake…….
I love Tastykakes, but I love peanut butter better . . . if only they used the peanut butter tastykakes, then it would be the best of both worlds. Chocolate Peanut Butter All The Way!
choc p/b cup all the way. No losers, just one winner…me!
chocolate peanut butter cup, i know you’re ahead….but good luck to you, tastykake chocolate cupcake, you little pint of deliciousness, light as you are with your yummy mounds of chocolate cupcake pieces and chocolate gooey swirls in your creamy th ice cream, you don’t need anything else to be a satisfying, heavenly treat when i get a crazed urge that time of evening for th ice cream!!!!
Chocolate peanut butter cup is the only reason why I agree to visit my inlaws, and the thing I miss most since I moved. Hands down the best icecream. I have asked several times for the local Bi-lo to stock this flavor, but so far no luck
There isn’t much of anything better in life than Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream!
Tastykake chocolate cupcake rocks, nuf said
I have never tried Tastykake and probably never will. I am not fond of bits of cake in my ice cream. Besidea, there are just too many other flavors I have put to the test and just love. Chocolate peanut butter is one of them.
Unless you’re allergic to peanut butter, you’ve GOT to love Turkey Hill Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup ice cream!
Tastykake chocolate cupcake makes my husband very happy!! He tells everyone about it. Plus the light ice cream factor makes it “healthy” choice. Right?
Choc PB is the only container of ice cream that won’t last 48 hrs in our house. The bowls are fuller and even though savored, just go faster. We survive this by only buying it when its on sale. The sweet dutch chocolate with the salty thick peanut butter, there’s none other on the market that comes close.
I feel in my big Turkey Hill Ice Cream Loving – Eating heart, that the winner will be the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!
May may the best (of the best) winner win!
CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP ALL THE WAY!!
Chocolate PeanutButter Cup is the ultimate flavor for you Chocolate and PeanutButter Lovers!!My Children and Grandchildren Just love this Ice Cream from Turkey Hill and we love the fact that you can buy this ice cream in Blair County, PA!!!! GO CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CUP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
I opened the trashmasher tonight to find an empty Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup container — couldn’t decide whether to yell at my husband or cry. No contest — cry! My vote is for Choc PNut Butter!!!!!!
How can anyone prefer anything peanut over Tastykake chocolate cupcakes!!!!!
The chocolate cupcake is AWESOME but I think more people have tried the PBC so that’s the one getting the votes!
Who can resist chocolate cake with ice cream? Both together in an ice cream is the ultimate.
deffinatly should be chocolate peanut butter cup as I can’t eat the other one Due to its non GF status
I love chocolate and more chocolate.
The best flavor of course is chocolate cupcake!
The chocolate cupcake is the true winner and so delicious!
Even though I love both, I gotta go with Chocolate Peanut Butter. Can’t resist peanut butter and chocolate! Also, makes great milkshakes!
Turkey Hill STUFF’D Tastykake chocolate cupcake ice cream says “happy birthday to me” with every spoonful.
Now I’m sure that I have been buying the right ice cream for a very long time. Chocolate peanut butter cup is THE BEST. I just love it and am so glad it won the contest!!!!!!!!!!
I am a big lover of chocolate & peanut butter, but i am a bigger fan of Tastycakes, grew up on them & still love them…go Tastycakes!
Hmm I wish that flavor was around here. I don’t think I’ve seen it at any local stores.
…
This is truly wonderful news. Thank you for discussing it with us!…