If everyone loves s’mores, then everyone should really love ice cream s’mores, right? That’s the thinking behind this recipe, sent to us by Sheldon M. of Freeport, NY.
We drew a picture to help illustrate how this treat stacks up. The fun thing about it is you can use just about any flavor of ice cream you’d like. You also don’t have to roll the finished s’more in chopped almonds. You can roll it in any topping, including mini chocolate chips, sprinkles, coconut. Which one would you choose?
ICE CREAM S’MORES
INGREDIENTS
18 whole graham crackers
1 jar (7 ounces) marshmallow fluff
1 jar (18 ounces) thick chocolate fudge topping
1/2 gallon Turkey Hill Rocky Road ice cream, slightly softened
1/2 cup chopped almonds
DIRECTIONS:
Break graham crackers in half to form 36 squares. Spread marshmallow fluff on 18 squares and chocolate fudge topping on the other 18 squares. Place cracker squares on cookie sheet, marshmallow and chocolate sides up, and freeze for half an hour until sauces are hardened. After half an hour, place one scoop of ice cream on top of marshmallow-coated cracker. Top ice cream scoop with chocolate-coated cracker, chocolate side down, to form sandwich. Press down lightly until ice cream overflows sandwich. Place in freezer, about one hour, until hard. Using sharp knife, trim ice cream to edge of graham crackers. Roll in almonds.
Loading ...
If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
I may be the only person in the world…..but I don’t like smores! I think it’s because of the gramham crackers, but this is one recipe I won’t be trying.
Would it be possible to get some Turkey Hill coupons. Turkey Hill is the only ice cream that we buy so some coupons would really help out.
Thank you
Ann Marie Curran
8 Cross Roads
Waymart,Pa 18472
DESSERT TONIGHT! THANKS!!
Actually I don’t care for graham crackers, BUT it sounds so tasty I would try it!
sounds really good and I love Smores
I like my Rocky Road plain. Yummy!
OH!!! YUMMY!!! Why didn’t I think of that???
Oooooo……that’s sounds delicious!!!!!
My idea of a truly great dessert is Turkey Hill Ice Cream, hot fudge topping, whipped cream, cherry on top and just “dig in”! Sometimes, the simplist tried and true dishes bring the most oohs and ahhs and also evoke the most “remembering” of good times shared and who we shared them with! To each his own!
Sounds delish. I’ll take one!!!
Sounds ok, but I would use plain chocolate TH instead of Rocky Road. Of course you could just make a S’mores sundae by crushing the crackers and topping a bowl of chocolate TH with fudge topping, marshmallow topping and the crushed crackers. That sounds more like my speed, but cool idea.
Sounds good! I may give it a try!
before I read any of the recipe, I thought it would include a chocolate marshmallow ice cream but it suggests using rocky road, either way, I would eat it because I always want S’more
Thanks Sheldon M. of Freeport, N.Y. this is a very yummy recipe. I can almost taste my version now.
Love those grahams dipped in milk , so this should be better yet, :–)
MMmmm Good
Yummy!
I am going to try this Smores with the church youth group, they love smores when they make them in the summer. Should be a big hit, I hope. I hate smores myself but I’m a minority I’m sure.
I really like S’mores and Rocky Road ice cream,and all of the other ingredients, so I will definitely try this! Al Yankovic did a parody of Joan Jett’s song “I Love Rock and Roll”, but his was “I Love Rocky Road”. I would listen to it and also watch the video of Al Yankovic singing his song while eating this great treat!!
if you were creative, you could make s’more ice cream
We love smores especially around the camp fire with the marshmallows roasting the chocolate melting but we will bring a cooler because adding the ice cream to this treat sounds great!
This reminds me of an ice cream sandwich but fancier because of the ingredients. But once you start enjoying it I would be quick so the ice cream wouldn’t melt and drip down your hands. But I certainly would be willing to try it because I love all the ingredients.
The recipe sounds delicious. Thanks Sheldon!
Maybe on a cookie but no thanks to grahm crackers with my ice cream.
This sounds delicious! We always made S’mores with our Girl Scout troop when we went camping! This would be a great alternative to the “real thing”! The girls always wanted ice cream!!!! Thanks for the recipe!!!
i never had one might try it
Maybe I like things too easy, but all those ingredients could be incorporated into a new flavor by Turkey Hill and would save a lot of time and checking to see if everything was on hand for this treat.
I’ll try that with my granddaughters. They love to play with their food… make it and eat it.
Great Recipe Sheldon! I will try it as soon as I get the proper ingredients!
Yum!
Gimme s’more ! This is the yummiest ever.
I’m not a lover of traditional s’mores but this sounds delicious. Can’t wait to make them.
I’m not fond of s’mores because they’re too sweet but Turkey Hill is always “just right.”
i’m not a huge fan of smores either–but my daughter will love it, so i’ll pass it on to her!
I think a chocolate peanut flavor of Ice cream would be great..
There havebeen some good alterations to this recipe, which by itself sounds fabulous. For anyone with a nut allergy, obviously use your favourite flavor. Otherwise, this is a great twist to the ice cream sandwich
SOUNDS GOOD BUT I PREFER MY ICE CREAM PLAIN, ESPECIALLY WHEN IT’S TURKEY HILL.
Our camping club is named campin S’Mores wit a s/more as our logo. Use a hershey bar section instead of the syrup. deliciious.
I’ll take my ice cream as is with maybe some whipped cream:)
I would substitute plain vanilla in this. Sounds great …and easy!
looks easy but graham crackers are gross
Sounds yummy!
I love Smores and these look so good. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe, I will definitely be making them. YUM!
My kids would love these. I have a feeling some adults might like them as well.
That looks awesome!!!!
I think this recipe is really cool and different. Being that s’mores are one of my favorite dessert foods I am looking forward to trying this and incorporating the ice cream. I will have to share it with all of my friends