What’s better than a peanut butter and jelly sandwich? How about a peanut butter and jelly ice cream sandwich pop? These pops are simple to make. We’re also pretty sure they’re delicious!
INGREDIENTS
- Ice cream of your choice (Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple works best!)
- 1 pound graham crackers
- 16 ounces strawberry jam
- 1 cup unsalted peanuts, chopped
DIRECTIONS
Spread softened ice cream onto baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Ice cream should be about one inch thick. Freeze for at least three hours. Cut ice cream into squares, about 2 1/3 inches each (squares should be the same size as the graham cracker you’re using, which are broken in half).
Break graham crackers in half to make 2 1/2-inch squares. Spread one side of each with a layer of jam and freeze until firm (about 45 minutes). Add ice cream squares with jam facing the ice cream. Insert a wooden popsicle stick into each sandwich. Dip each side of ice cream sandwich in chopped peanuts and pat with your hand to help them stick to the ice cream.
Freeze until ready to enjoy!
Loading ...
If you’ve got a technical question about the ice cream making process or some other inquiry about the nuances of America’s favorite treat, chances are Ernie has the answer. He might not be able to answer all questions, but he’ll try his best and some may be featured on the Ice Cream Journal.
Sounds Yummy — I will try it after the weather warms up a bit!
A big recipe for a big appetite. Great and clever twist on a classic. Bon Appetit!
Good for any season: shake like jelly and goes down easy..
My hubby will Love it! I would make it with strawberry and the nuts. Either way a great treat, any day of the week!
…i want one!! how clever – will definitely be trying this.
thank YOU “turkey hill”.
I was never a fan of PB&J sandwiches but think this sounds yummy, especially with TH.
I will try this. It looks good.
I’m afraid to try it because I don’t think I’ll be able to stop eating them.
Looks fabulous. Can’t wait to try it. Tonight!
Peanut butter is good for you, graham crackers are a type of whole grain, they have strawberries in them and the milk is nutritious. A new health food has been created!
I can’t wait to get home to try this. I knew there was a reason I bought the peanut butter ice cream. Love this stuff
Something new to try! Thank you, Turkey Hill!
NOT A PEANUT BUTTER FAN BUT I HAVE TO SAY THAT THIS LOOKS VERY TEMPTING.
I do like peanut butter in my ice cream on occassion but would not care for the jelly factor.
How do you EAT this thing??? I think it’s gonna get messy…
looks like a good tasting treat!
why don’t you mash up all that stuff and put it into some peanut butter ripple ice cream and call it “PB&J reloaded”???? That would make a great flavor of the month!
Love this idea and agree with Ann King… what a great suggestion for an new TH flavor….
wow, some people are so creative
I was really expecting pbnj ice cream
but this is a pbnj ice cream sandwich
I would if it would work on toast rye bread too
LOVE peanut butter, hate jelly!
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMM SOUNDS SO GOOD LOVE YOUR PEANUT BUETER ICE CREAM BUT WOULD USE GRAPEJAM CANT WAIT TO TRY IT
Not only does this sound oh so yummy but it looks yummy too. Wrote down recipe to try soon.
No, thanks. I’ll take my peanut butter and jelly on bread and leave my ice cream unadulterated!
FABULOUS! Could also put peanut butter on the graham cracker first, then layer the jelly on top of the PB. You could also place some of the wooden popsicle sticks into the softened ice cream before putting it into the freezer. Might be easier than sticking it into hardened ice cream. Or let it sit for a short while to soften it a little and then return to the freezer. Then when hardened, dipp the “sandwich” in the peanuts.
I’m with Marion! No thank you!
i have been making a kind of this recipe awhile minus the popcicle stick. Good for a once in while change, but not for a steady diet.I used crunchy peanut butter instead.of dipping in peanuts
Sounds delicious!
Excellent idea, because who doen’t love peanut butter and jelly and especially with your special ice cream!
This would be a treat that my family would enjoy-we also really like the jams and jellies from Cherry Hill, so it would be a true Lancaster County treat when we make it- as we would use Turkey Hill Ice Cream and Cherry Hill jams and jellies!!
Mmm, mmm good!
Looks soooo yummy!!!I would like that, but my husband would like it more. He just LOVES P&J. Also loves TH. What a combo. When he worked, he took p&J sandwiches every day. Never ever got tired of them. He would just LUV this. Can’t wait to make one for him and surprise him. Thank you so very very much!!!!!!!
Creative idea; sounds like something that I would like. Will have to try it.
I’m with Marion & Nancy….YUCK!
Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwiches are not my favorite. The ice cream version sounds delicious.
Mmmmmm!!!
I would certainly enjoy this treat. However, my son, being allergic to peanuts, would have to skip it. But he could just enjoy his favorite Turkey Hill flavor.
Sounds good to me. I like to try different things.
Sorry, but I would just skip the feezing part and chomp right in.
I have been making ice cream sandwiches with graham crackers for years since the ’70s. However never put additional toppings on.
Add a cup of milk to this recipe, blend, and you have an awesome milkshake!
Sounds incredible!!!!my boys will love them not to mention my husband and brother too!!! will try them soon….thanks turkey hill…gotta love you….
Sorry not my cup of tea.
Great idea for “big” kids!
Sounds amazing!!
UGGGHHHH No way!!
this would be even better diped in chocalate!
Yummy! Want one NOW!!!!!!!!
It sounds interesting, since I love peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. I’d try it.
sounds like a banana would work in there too
Yum I want some! sharing is nice.
Hi THD staff and all their ice cream fans! I like the idea of this ice cream sandwich. But, I started my own since early in February 2013. I have obtained a good brand buttermilk waffles, and have used another brand product’s ice cream, and made a sandwich with the two together, as this brings back old times. When we kids going to the admusement park with family, we would always order a Belgian Waffle Ice Cream sandwich (what a treat that was for us)! Today, I cannot find this sandwich anywhere. So our friends at Turkey Hill, here is the opportunity to re-establish yourselves. Here is the challenge; Can you bring back the nostigla ice cream bricks, so that your loyal THD fans, can make their own delicious ice cream sandwich? Pleasee, thanks!
My husband took peanut butter and jelly sandwiches to work for many many years. He also LOVES his ice cream–Turkey Hill, of course!!! he will just love peanut butter and jelly ice cream!!! Bring it on. He can eat the whole thing!!!!!!!
Sounds like it maybe tasty. I would buy some. We all love PB and Jelly sandwiches.
Sounds good. Who doesn’t like PBJ.