The Ultimate Flavor Tournament is back! (Pick the final four flavors to win year’s supply of ice cream!)

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on February 25th, 2013


Share

NOTE: The deadline has passed to pick the final four flavors, but you can still win free ice cream by leaving a comment on the blog. At the end of the tournament (about five weeks), we’ll choose four comments at random and each will receive a one-month supply of Turkey Hill ice cream. Good luck!

The Ultimate Flavor Tournament kicks off next Monday, March 4 and we’re giving away a year’s supply of ice cream to anyone who can correctly predict the final four flavors!

As many of you know, the Ultimate Flavor Tournament is patterned after college basketball’s annual NCAA playoffs. The six-week competition will start with 32 flavors in a series of head-to-head match-ups. Your votes will determine which flavors advance to the next weekly round (the “Sweet 16”) before finally narrowing down the list to two flavors.

Like we mentioned earlier, if you can correctly predict the final four flavors, you could win a one-year supply of Turkey Hill ice cream!

If more than one person guesses the final four flavors, we’ll choose one name at random to win the prize. Choosing the winners might sound easy, but no one was able to make the prediction last year (a few of you came close with three out of four correct answers).

To enter, take a look at the match-ups below and tell us which flavors will win their respective conferences. You can make your picks with a comment on this entry or email your picks to icecreamjournal@gmail.com. All picks must be received before the first round begins on Monday, March 4. Good luck, and may the best flavor win!

UPDATE (2/26): Touchdown Sundae has been removed from the Vanilla Conference (as last year’s winner it should have been retired) and replaced by Honey Vanilla Granola Frozen Yogurt. All readers who chose Touchdown Sundae as their Vanilla Conference winner have been notified and will be allowed to make a different prediction for the winner of that conference.

PICK THE WINNERS!

VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER:

CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER:

FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER:

LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER:

 

THE VANILLA CONFERENCE

All Natural Salted Caramel vs. Tin Roof Sundae

Fudge Ripple vs. Peanut Butter Ripple

Cookies ‘n Cream vs. Honey Vanilla Granola Frozen Yogurt

Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso vs. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

 

THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE

Rocky Road vs. All Natural Coffee

Dutch Chocolate vs. Double Dunker

Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream vs. Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

Phillies Graham Slam vs. Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

 

THE FRUIT CONFERENCE

Strawberries ‘n Cream vs. All Natural Cherry Vanilla

Banana Split vs. Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

Black Cherry vs. Fruit Rainbow Sherbet

Rum Raisin vs. Orange Grove Sherbet

 

THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE

Limited Edition Whoopie Pie vs. Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

Limited Edition Egg Nog vs. Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate vs. Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie vs. Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream

Leave a Comment

451 Responses to “The Ultimate Flavor Tournament is back! (Pick the final four flavors to win year’s supply of ice cream!)”

  1. Denise Wilson says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies ‘n Cream

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Coffee

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER:Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  2. donna pancoast says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    All Natural Salted Caramel
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  3. Lois Sidelnick says:

    I know the winners already. My favorites. can’t wait to start.

  4. IceCreamFiend says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies ‘n Cream

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Phillies Graham Slam

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Black Cherry

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  5. Jean Sagarese says:

    The Vanilla Conference – All Natural Salted Caramel

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE – Rocky Road
    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  6. Dee says:

    Vanilla Conference:Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate Conference:Dutch Chocolate
    Fruit Conference:Strawberries and Cream
    Limited Edition Conference:Whoopie Pie

  7. Wendy says:

    Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso
    Dutch Chocolate
    All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

  8. Gail says:

    Vanilla Conference: All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (And Others) Conference: Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference: Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conference: Coconut Cream Pie

  9. Jim in SOMD says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Rum Raisin

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  10. jan says:

    Vanilla conf. Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate and others: double Dunker
    Fruit: Stuffed Strawberry cheesecake
    Limited Edition: Pumpkin Pie

  11. lori says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Salted Caramel

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: dutch chocolate

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: strawberries n’ cream

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER:deep dark chocolate

  12. Chad says:

    Vanilla Conference Winner: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate Conference Winner: Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference Winner: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

  13. Jean Marie says:

    Vanilla Conference Winner- Fudge Ripple

    Chocolate Conference Winner(and others)- Dutch Chocolate

    Fruit Conference Winner- Strawberries ‘n Cream

    The Limited Edition Conference Winner- Pumpkin Pie

  14. Chip's wife says:

    Vanilla Conference: French Vanilla
    Chocolate:Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit: Souhern Lemon Meriange Pie
    Limited Edition: Coconut Cream Pie
    All Time Favorite of Mine: Butter Pecan

  15. Pam says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Phillies Graham Slam

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  16. Lou says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies and Cream

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Double Dunker

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Black Cherry

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Coconut Cream Pie

  17. jconley says:

    Vanilla Conference – Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate Conference – Yankee Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conference – Banana Split
    Limited Conference – Chunk Peanut Butter

  18. JoAnn Szewczyk says:

    Vanilla Conference: Fudge Ripple
    Chocolate Conference:Phillies Graham Slam
    Fruit Conference: Rum Raisin
    Limited Conference: Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream

  19. Yvonne Learn says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Black Cherry

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  20. Elsie Nicolette says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Salted Caramel
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  21. Chelsea W says:

    All Natural Salted Caramel vs. Tin Roof Sundae (ALL NATURAL SALTED CARAMEL WINNER)

    Fudge Ripple vs. Peanut Butter Ripple (PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE WINNER)

    Cookies ‘n Cream vs. Touchdown Sundae (COOKIES ‘N CREAM WINNER)

    Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso vs. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH WINNER)

    Rocky Road vs. All Natural Coffee (ROCKY ROAD WINNER)

    Dutch Chocolate vs. Double Dunker (DUTCH CHOCOLATE WINNER)

    Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream vs. Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks (LIGHT RECIPE CHOCOLATE NUTTY MOOSE TRACKS WINNER)

    Phillies Graham Slam vs. Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast (YANKEES PINSTRIPE BROWNIE BLAST WINNER)

    Strawberries ‘n Cream vs. All Natural Cherry Vanilla (STRAWBERRIES ‘N CREAM WINNER)

    Banana Split vs. Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake (STUFF’D STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE WINNER)

    Black Cherry vs. Fruit Rainbow Sherbet (BLACK CHERRY WINNER)

    Rum Raisin vs. Orange Grove Sherbet (RUM RAISIN WINNER)

    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie vs. Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel (LIMITED EDITION WHOPPIE PIE WINNER)

    Limited Edition Egg Nog vs. Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie (LIMITED EDITION PUMPKIN PIE WINNER)

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate vs. Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter (LIMITED EDITION DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE WINNER)

    Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie vs. Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream (LIMITED EDITION FRIED ICE CREAM WINNER)

  22. Julia says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Tin Roof Sundae

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Double Dunker

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Coconut Cream Pie

  23. Norma says:

    chocolate Moose Tracks will always be a winner with me. It’s THE ULTIMATE WINNER!

  24. jean says:

    Whoopie let the fun begin.
    Vanilla Conference: Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate Conference:Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit Conference: Stuffed Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition: Snyder PA Dutch Pretzel

    Can’t wait to party with the best ice cream ever!!!!!!!!!

  25. andrea says:

    Vanilla Conference: All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate Conference: Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conference:Strawberries and Cream
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  26. Sharon says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Banana Split
    Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  27. Amber S. says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Touchdown Sundae

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Rocky Road

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Strawberries n Cream

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  28. Karen Cohn says:

    Vanilla Conference: All Natural Salted Carmel
    Chocolate Conference: Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference: Black Cherry
    Limited Edition Conference: Coconut Cream Pie

    I love all these!

  29. Keely Hostetter says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER:
    All Natural Salted Caramel

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE:
    Double Dunker

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE:
    Banana Split

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE:
    Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream

  30. millie says:

    wow what can i pick haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa vanilla conference salted caramel chocolate conference double dunker fruit con,black cherry the limited edition con chunky peanut butter

  31. Vicki Spokes says:

    Tin Roof Sundae
    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Ltd. Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  32. Ann King says:

    I predict the four conference winners will be: Peanut Butter Ripple, Yankees Pin Stripe Brownie Blast, All Natural Cherry Vanilla, and Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter. My all time favorite is Peanut Butter Ripple which should be the ultimate winner.

  33. Juliette says:

    The Vailla Conference: Fudge Ripple.
    The Chocolate Conference: Dutch Chocolate.
    The Fruit conference: Strawberries and Cream.
    The Limited Edition Conference: Coconut Cream Pie.

  34. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    This is Caroline’s hubby. I am now a happy camper since my lovely wife was able to get my Valentine’s gift of 3 tubs of “Box of Chocolate. I have no idea why you left out “box of chocolate” from the limited editions, yes Deep Dark Chocolate is fine but the BOX is better.

  35. Sally says:

    Vanilla Conference: All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (and others) Conference Winner: Dutch Chocolate
    Fruit Conference Winner: All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  36. Nancy N says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Salted Caramel
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Double Dunker
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Strawberries & Cream
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE: Coconut Cream Pie

  37. Sarah says:

    VANILLA – Tin Roof Sundae
    CHOCOLATE – Rocky Road
    FRUIT – Cherry Vanilla
    LIMITED – Coconut Cream Pie

  38. Sarah says:

    Really, there’re all winnners cause there’re made by Turkey Hill

  39. DaNeil says:

    Vanilla- All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (and others)- Double Dunker
    Fruit- Orange Grove Sherbet
    Limited Edition- Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream

  40. Rene says:

    Vanilla-Touchdown Sundae
    Chocolate-Rocky Road
    Fruit-Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition-Chunky Peanut Butter

  41. geri says:

    Vanilla Conference – Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso
    Chocolate Conference – All Natural Coffee
    Fruit Conference – Black Cherry
    Limited Edition Conference – Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  42. geri says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE – Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE – All Natural Coffee
    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE – Black Cherry
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE – Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  43. patty says:

    Vanilla———-All Natural Salted Caramel Chocolate——– Double Dunker Fruit————Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake Limited Edition———-Whoopie Pie

  44. Jill says:

    Vanilla conference-Peanut Butter Ripples
    Chocolate Conference-Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference-Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition-Whoopie Pie

  45. Barb says:

    The Vanilla conference – All Natural Salted Caramel

    The Chocolate conference- Dutch Chocolate

    The Fruit conference – Strawberries ‘n Cream

    The limited edition conference – Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  46. Elise says:

    Vanilla Conference Winner: Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate(and Others): Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit Conference Winner: All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  47. Ang says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE—Cookies n Cream

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE—Phillies Graham Slam

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE—Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE—Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  48. marie grim says:

    Tin Roof Sundae

    Phillies Graham Slam

    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  49. Pam says:

    The Final 4 will be:

    The Vanilla Conference – Cookies n Cream

    The Chocolate Conference – Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    The Fruit Conference – Cherry Vanilla

    The Limited Edition Conference – Chunky Peanut Butter

  50. Harriet G. says:

    Here are my choices:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies & Cream

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuffed Strawberry Cheese Cake

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  51. Marie says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER-Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    THE CHOCOLATE & OTHERS CONFERENCE WINNER – Rocky Road
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER – Strawberries & Cream
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE-Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  52. Robin Ames says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE– All Natural Salted Caramel
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE– Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE–Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE–Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  53. sarah oswald says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    Peanut Butter Ripple
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Phillies Graham Slam
    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  54. Mary says:

    Vanilla Conference – Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate Conference – Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference – Black Cherry
    Limited Edition – Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  55. EmilyFalcon says:

    VANILLA: Tin Roof Sundae

    CHOCOLATE: Double Dunker (my personal favorite, which I haven’t been able to find at stores in ages! :( )

    FRUIT: Fruit Rainbow Sherbet

    LIMITED EDITION: Chunky Peanut Butter

  56. Patricia Lysinger says:

    Vanilla Conference winner – Cookies n Cream
    Chocolate Winner-Phillies Grand Slam
    Fruit-Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition-Coconut Cream Pie

  57. donna joyce says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Fried Ice Cream

  58. enid portnoy says:

    Vanilla Conference Winner- Cookies ‘n Cream
    Chocolate and others- Rocky Road
    Fruit Conf.- Black Cherry
    Limited Edition- Deep Dark Chocolate
    Winners all!!!

  59. sue says:

    Vanilla Conf: Peanut Butter Ripple
    Choc Conf: Lite Recipe Chocolate Nutty Mooses Tracks
    Fruit Conf: Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conf: Chunky Peanut Butter

  60. Lori Wardle says:

    My picks for this years challenge are as follows:
    Vanilla Conference: Tin Roof Sundae
    Choc. Conference: Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference: Black Cherry
    Limited Edition Conference: Chunky Peanut Butter

  61. leecarr says:

    I am ready to vote, Monday come and I will be here

  62. CHRISTINE says:

    FUDGE RIPPLE
    DUTCH CHOCOLATE
    BLACK CHERRY LOVE THE STRAWBERRIES N CREAM AND BANANA SPLIT
    AND ORANGE GROVE TOO

    DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE

  63. carole says:

    All Natural Salted Caramel vs. Tin Roof Sundae
    Dutch Chocolate vs. Double Dunker
    Banana Split vs. Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie vs. Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  64. Erin says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE:
    AChocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE:
    Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE:
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  65. Bobi says:

    Cookies ‘n Cream
    Phillies Graham Slam
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  66. Ellen says:

    Vanilla Conf. Winner—–Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate Conf. Winner—Lt. Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit Conf. Winner——-Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conf. Winner—–Chunky Peanut Butter

  67. LindaR says:

    I can’t wait to win!

  68. Susan J says:

    Vanilla Conference: Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate and others Conference: Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference: Strawberries ‘N Cream
    Limited Edition Conference: Whoopie Pie

    This is making me crave ice cream and there isn’t any in the freezer. :(

  69. MeganKS says:

    Vanilla Conf: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate Conf: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conf: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conf: Pumpkin Pie

  70. Jeryl M. says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Light Receipe Extreme Cookies and Cream
    Stuffd Strawberry Cheesecake
    Whoopie Pie

  71. Kathy says:

    Chocolate chip Yankees brownie blast very good ice cream

  72. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    Here are my predictions:

    Vanilla Conference – Chocolate Cip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate (and others) Conference – Dutch Chocolate
    Fruit Conference – Orange Grove Sherbet
    Limited Edition Conference – Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

    On with the Tournament!!

  73. Amy says:

    Tin roof
    Double dunker
    Stuffed strawberry
    Snyder pretzel

  74. mary ann herrmann says:

    …and the winners are:

    the vanilla conference – peanut butter ripple
    the chocolate conference – all natural coffee
    the fruit conference – strawberries ‘n cream
    the limited edition conference – chunky peanut butter

    (at least MY winners!!)

  75. Edie says:

    Vanilla Conf: Cookies & Cream
    choc. Conf : Yankee Pinstripe
    Fruit Conf : Strawberries & Cream
    Lmt. Ed : Deep Dark Chocolate

  76. Ken says:

    Vanilla Conference–Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate Conference–All Natural Coffee
    Fruit Conference–Black Cherry
    Limited Editioin–Chunky Peanut Butter

  77. Machell says:

    The envelope please…the winners are…

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  78. Jeff says:

    The winners are…
    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Salted Caramel
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Orange Grove Sherbet
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

    May the battle begin!

  79. Cody says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies ‘n Cream
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  80. Robyn says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Tin Roof Sundae
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  81. Deborah Delgado says:

    Vanilla conference winner: Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate (and others) conference winner: Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference winner:Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Whoopee Pie

  82. Cole Evans says:

    VANILLA WINNER: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    CHOCOLATE ( AND OTHER) WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    FRUIT WINNER: Orange Grove Sherbet

    LIMITED EDITION WINNER: Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  83. Stacey Brown says:

    Vanilla Conference: All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (And Others) Conference:Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit Conference: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  84. Vanilla Conference:Tin Roof Sundae Chocolate(and Others): Light Recipe Nutty Moose Tracks Fruit Conference:Orange Grove Sherbet Limited Edition Conference:Chunky Peanut Butter

  85. Nancy Kelley says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE: All Natural Salted Caramel

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Double Dunker

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

    You can deliver my winnings next week. :)

  86. Andrea says:

    Vanilla: Tin Roof Sundae

    Chocolate: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    Fruit: Banana Split

    Limited Edition: Chunky Peanut Butter

    They are all so good, it is impossible to pick winners!

  87. Jennifer says:

    Vanilla Conference: Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate Conference: Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  88. Sherrie Taylor says:

    Vanilla Conf—-All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate Conf—Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream
    Fruit Conf—Strawberries ‘n Cream
    Limited Edition Conf—- Snyder PA Dutch Pretzel

  89. Marc Seigerman says:

    vanilla Conf.- Fudge Ripple
    Chocolate Conf- Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream
    Fruit Conf.- Black Cherry
    Limited ed. conf- Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  90. Suzanne says:

    Vanilla Conference – Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate (and others) Conference – Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference – All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Conference – Chunky Peanut Butter

  91. Courtney says:

    Vanilla Conference – All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (and others) Conference – Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conference – Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference – Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  92. Matt says:

    Vanilla Conference – All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (and others) Conference – Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks
    Fruit Conference – Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference – Chunky Peanut Butter

  93. Gini says:

    Vanilla conference winner: All Natural Salted Caramel
    Chocolate (and others) Conference winner: Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference winner: Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Whoopee Pie

  94. Steve says:

    Vanilla conference winner: Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate (and others) Conference winner: All Natural Coffee
    Fruit Conference winner:Banana Split
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  95. Kat says:

    The Vanilla Conference Winner: Cookies ‘n Cream
    The Chocolate (and Others) Conference Winner: Rocky Road
    The Fruit Conference Winner: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    The Limited Edition Conference Winner: Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  96. Elizabeth says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    Peanut Butter Ripple

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Phillies Graham Slam

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE
    Black Cherry

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

    Frozen Yogurt could have its own conference and winner:
    Honey Vanilla Granola Frozen Yogurt

  97. Josh Bloser says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE: CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH

    CHOCOLATE CONFERENCE: ROCKY ROAD

    FRUIT CONFERENCE: BLACK CHERRY

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE: CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER

  98. Stephanie Frederick says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    All Natural Salted Caramel

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Double Dunker

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE
    Orange Grove Sherbet

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

  99. Lisa says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies ‘n Cream
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Phillies Graham Slam
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  100. Amy says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Phillies Graham Slam
    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split
    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  101. Erica says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: chocolate chip cookie dough

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER:Dutch chocolate

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER:Strawberries ‘n Cream

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER:Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  102. Megan says:

    vanilla conference: chocolate chip cookie dough
    chocolate (and others): double dunker (my all time favorite!)
    fruit conference: strawberries n cream
    limited edition: Deep Dark Chocolate

  103. Oneisha Romain says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE: Cookies ‘n Cream

    CHOCOLATE CONFERENCE: Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream

    FRUIT CONFERENCE: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    LIMITED EDITION: Pumpkin Pie

  104. Mark Zeigler says:

    Vanilla Conference: Peanut Butter Ripple
    Chocolate Conference: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition: Chunky Peanut Butter

  105. Joann Gray says:

    Cookies & crea vs. honey vanilla granola frozen yogurt, dutch chocolate vs. double dunket, black cherry vs. fruit rainbow sherbet, limited edition egg nog vs. limited edition pumpkin pie.

  106. Jessica says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple!!

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Coffee

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Fruit Rainbow Sherbet

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  107. cvorodi says:

    Vanilla conference: Salted Caramel

    Chocolate conference: Dutch Chocolate

    Fruit conference: Black Cherry

    Limited edition: Dark Chocolate

  108. Sharon Caine says:

    These are what I think will win, not necessarily what I would choose:
    Vanilla Conference:Cookies and Cream
    Chocolate Conference:Rocky Road
    Fruit Conference:All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Conference:Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  109. Faye says:

    OMG I Love them ALL…..not sure about the licorice thought.

  110. Karen says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    Cookies ‘n Cream

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Dutch Chocolate

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE
    Strawberries ‘n Cream

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie

  111. Nate W. says:

    Vanilla Conference: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate (and others) Conference: Phillies Graham Slam
    Fruit Conference: Cherry Vanilla
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  112. Nick Andes says:

    Vanilla Conference – Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate (and others) Conference – Phillies Graham Slam
    Fruit Conference – Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference – Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

  113. Julie says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER:Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER:Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  114. Heather Bruinsma says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Double Dunker

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

  115. Krista Martin says:

    Vanilla Conference: choc chip cookie dough
    Choc Conference: Double Dunker
    Fruit Conference: Black Cherry
    Limited Edition Conference: Whoopi Pie
    Ultimate Winner: Double Dunker

  116. Judy Koller says:

    I live all year till Dec gets here so I can get my absolute favorite flavor…..EggNog.

  117. R Simmons says:

    My husband is from West Virginia and has only been in the area for 9 years and has never tasted ice cream as good as Turkey Hill.

  118. Justin Orkin says:

    I would’ve picked Double Dunker for chocolate.

  119. Jim says:

    In these economic times, ice cream is certainly just an occasional treat for many. That means every spoonful has to be excellent since each bite will need to be thoroughly enjoyed and savored.

    So my pick for the winner would certainly be Phillies Graham Slam. Not because the Phillies have done well in the past or are expected to do well this year (sort of like the “Fox News” skit on the “Married with Children” TV show, the preferred viewing position for watching the Phillies is clearly with both hands wrapped around one’s throat, in the “choke” position). But Phillies Graham Slam is the best because the base for that ice cream flavor is particularly tasty by itself, and the nuggets of graham in every other bite are exquisite.

    Perhaps some small portion of the proceeds from the sale of Phillies Graham Slam could go to the local Little League teams, with the ultimate hope that it might some day improve the Phillies!

  120. James says:

    Love your strawberry! Back to basics!

  121. Bob says:

    Love to have those combinations that bring salty and sweet together with a little savory added in, like Butter Pecan or Maple Wlanut.

    but for this tournament, going to have to root for Coffee as an underdog!!

  122. Anything with your delicious CHOCOLATE FLAVOR gets my vote. Either big chunks, or chips or streaks, or whatever way you choose to incorporate my favorite ingredient:)

  123. Debi Pattie says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice creams! I bought Breyer’s ice cream for years, thinking it was the best I had ever had. Then one week Kroger had Turkey Hill ice cream on sale, so I thought I would try it. I have never again purchased Breyer’s! My very favorite is the all natural vanilla bean & the all natural chocolate. The taste as well as the texture of the all natural ice cream is so good; tastes like homemade! I think Kroger only carries a limited number of varieties; wish they carried more, because several of those talked about on your website sound delicious. Keep up the great work!

  124. Mary W says:

    I am so glad the cocoanut is back, wish it had a longer season. Last year I bought 15 cartons, and I still ran out! Put some fudge sauce on it, maybe some strawberries, and my mouth is just watering thinking about it. I guess I better remedy that. Yummy, my freezer is calling me!

  125. Prudence says:

    Turkey Hill is our favorite brand of ice cream. We adore the mint chocolate chip, Vanilla Cherry and Coffee. Yum yum!

  126. Suzanne says:

    The best flavor in my house would be the one thats in the freezer that particular week..too many are our favs!!!. I love the butter pecan and caramel especially!

  127. Nora says:

    Turkey Hill is a favorite in our house–especially Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup!

  128. Beverly O'Ferrall says:

    If it’s Turkey Hill ice cream, then it’s a winner. Winner, winner, ice cream after dinner!

  129. Rebecca says:

    I still love Peach!

  130. Steve O says:

    Light snyders chocolate pretzel my favorite! Why did Giant Food Stores quit carring it!

  131. Barbara Mason says:

    This is the year for Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough!!

  132. Sharon says:

    Ice Cream meets all the requirements for the food pyramid ( yes I still use this term) I even think of it as a breakfast food!! Eggnog is one of my favs., Rum raisin another see…fruits, Pumpkin is a veggie, YUM!!! P-nut butter is a protein! And of course dairy, cream & butter! All Set!!

  133. Wendy says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream is my favorite! I love the Nutty Neapolitan, which has chocolate, vanilla and butter almond together in the same container. The all natural ice creams are the best, especially the butter almond in the Neapolitan. I wish you made that flavor on its own. Just this week I went to get some of my favorite flavor and it’s not on the shelf. I’m in a bit of a panic and I hope it comes back. If not, I’m sure I can find many others to love!

  134. Sandi says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice cream, I just wish my Giant Eagle carried a bigger variety. My very favorite is Black Raspberry. Thank you for making it for not many do

  135. Carol says:

    Please bring back Cinnamon Ice Cream….it is so refreshing and great tasting!!!

  136. Scott says:

    can’t put coconut cream against fried ice cream, two of my favorites!

  137. Tom says:

    Double Dark Chocolate is the best ice I’ve ever had, hands down! Of course chocolate is my favorite vegetable.

  138. Lauren says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice cream! It’s the only brand I buy! I am a little disappointed to see that my favorite Limited Edition flavor didn’t make the tournament, though. I LOVE Southern Lemon Pie, and have for years! I would totally eat that year round if it was avaiable!

  139. Susan says:

    Deep dark chocolate all the way! No vanilla, no fruity stuff, just chocolate, chocolate, chocolate! The more the better!

  140. Stephanie O says:

    Turkey Hill ice creams and fro yo’s are simply SCRUMPTIOUS! I particularly love your Honey Vanilla Granola Frozen Yogurt and LIght Bavarian Espresso; each has a delicate sweetness that simply make my heart siiiiiiiiiiiiiiing … ;D

  141. mike farling says:

    anything with PEANUT BUTTER IS DELICIOUS!!!
    Add MORE peanut butter to the chocolate peanut butter receipes

  142. Jenn W says:

    I love Turkey Hill Ice Cream and enjoy trying all your flavors but the Chocolate ones are my personal favorites!!!

  143. Margie Gonzalez says:

    We love, love, love butter pecan! Also, light moose tracks. Have both in the freezer right now! Yummy!

  144. sand says:

    chocolate peanut butter cup is the best

  145. Matt says:

    Love this ice cream. Wish I could find a store with ALL the flavors. Can I have it delivered via the internet? Thanks.

  146. steve fitz says:

    Bring back the 64 oz half gallon . sf

  147. Norma says:

    I love to vote for my favorite, though it’s tough to choose from among all the talented contenders. I hope you choos me a winner, too. If you can spell it this way, so can I.

  148. Karen Carr says:

    The hardest two to pick between were rocky road and natural coffee–at the store, when I can, I buy both!!!

  149. rodney keller says:

    Rocky Road is the best!

  150. heather cyprych says:

    i absolutely love the light chocolate nutty moose tracks! it’s a light ice cream, but it doesn’t taste like it’s missing anything at all!

  151. maryann says:

    This is my favorite time of year. Love the voting and all the flavors. So hard to pick!

  152. randy says:

    i think banana split should of won

  153. Cathy says:

    The Chocolate Marshmellow is the best!

  154. Melissa says:

    I wish we could get samples of each before we voted! My stores here in VA don’t carry all these yummy flavors. It’s fun to imagine them, though!

  155. Cathy says:

    The box of chocolates is great with the little rasphberry cream candies covered in chocolate sprinkled throughout the chocolate ice cream- yummy!

  156. Deborah OBryan says:

    Sorry, no time to comment after voting for my favorite ice cream in each category I needed an ice cream fix. Off to the kitchen to indudge.

  157. Tim Mooney says:

    They are all winners in my book.

  158. dvikib says:

    Please, please, please bring back Peppermint Stick ice cream next Christmas. It’s been way too long since it was available and it’s by far the best peppermint out there.

  159. Shirley Cochran says:

    They are all winners but the limited pumpkin pie was my favorite!

  160. Debbie Lennox says:

    Double Dunker is a delectable delight!

  161. Cheryl Butchko says:

    I hope they bring back the Fried Icecream flavor. I loved that flavor! I was only able to buy 2 containers before it disappeared. :(

  162. Courtney says:

    Cookies N’ Cream all the way!!

  163. Ann King says:

    I am still rooting for peanut butter ripple, that has been my favorite for so long. None of the others, and I have tried many of them are as good. Not to say they are not good, but not the best.

  164. Courtney says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip is way awesome too!!

  165. Kim Kilonsky says:

    My very favorite is Black Cherry.In the middle of winter I am transported to a summer day on my grandmothers back porch eating a big bowl of Turkey Hill Black Cherry Ice Cream.Today that bowl of Ice cream conjures up very fond memories of my childhood.

  166. sandra smith says:

    I love most flavors of ice cream but have a great love for the frozen yogurts

  167. Dan says:

    Peanut Butter ice cream is not for me, but where is the bacon flavored ice cream?

  168. Margie says:

    The Limited Edition Snyders PA Dutch pretzel was terrific. Maybe you can make it a regular flavor.

  169. Kristie P says:

    I love anything with peanut butter in it and cookies and cream. Turkey Hill ice cream is the best!

  170. Michelle says:

    Double dunker is the BEST icecream ever.

  171. Michelle says:

    Double dunker is the BEST ice cream ever.

  172. Maria Mead says:

    Turkey Hill Black Cherry is my #1 favorite!

  173. Adam says:

    Lets go peanut butter. Anything peanut butter!

  174. karen salerno says:

    Bring the pretzel flavor into the full time lineup!!!! It is awesome!!!!

  175. Linda says:

    Coconut cream pie is the best coconut ice cream there is around! Please keep it on the shelves!!!

  176. Melinda Sulzbach says:

    I have been a fan of Turkey Hill ice cream, frozen yogurt and ice tea for years. I love the Wildberry Tea and the Blueberry as favorites. We drink the diet Green tea all year round. And my husband’s fav is the Mango tea. As far as the ice cream or yogurt..anything with chocolate and raspberry. I think “Box of Chocolates” is awesome and should be loved all year, not just at Valentine’s day……. M. Sulzbach

  177. well, when I was pregnant with first child, I ate a half gallon of chocolate peanut butter cup in 2 days! could be the reason my daughter grew up loving ice cream and chocolate with peanut butter…

  178. Marlene Francis says:

    I like Mint chocolate chip.

  179. roxane says:

    I’m a crazy icecream fan! I have a few 1/2 gallons that were in the running! I love the limited edition flavors. Always looking for something new. I love green tea! Haven’t seen that flavor yet at the stores I shop… Available yet?

  180. Colleen Hyser says:

    Any TH ice cream is the best but the FAVORITE is anything with Peanut Butter and Chocolate. Sadly I can’t find it here anymore : (
    I love Turkey Hill …

  181. al says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream reminds me of the “ice cream of my youth”. It’s made with “real ingredients” and the flavors taste “real” not artifical.
    When you’re old and on a limited income, Turkey Hill is the one and only ice cream worth buying!

  182. Ron says:

    Philadelphia style TH ice cream is the best. I have been a loyal customer for at least ten years, which is about how long I think it has been around. Cherry vanilla and coffee are fabulous. But…..now it’s rebranded to All Natural, and the price is no longer the same as the regular ice cream. Very disappointed by that. Have not bought a half gallon since the change was made and the “sale” price in the stores is 2 for $7.00. Sad to see, in tough economic times, you change the packaging and increase the price. Unfortunately, I am now buying Breyer’s. It is also “All Natural” but they have not played any pricing games. Please change the price back so I can go back to the original “Philadelphia Style”!

  183. Jeanette Lippy says:

    I think Peanut Butter Pie frozen yougurt is the best flavor!

  184. Ana says:

    Where can you have your ice cream and candy at once( and not get in troouble from MOM)? Only in a Turkey Hill Box o Chocolates!!!!

  185. thomas ciravolo says:

    best ice cream ever

  186. Barb says:

    So many great flavors to choose from, but I have to say your Mint choc chip is the one I buy the most. :)

  187. Robin says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Coffee

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Black Cherry

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER:Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  188. Susan Campino-Haynes says:

    Cookie Dough of course, Chocolate chip mint, Light Moose tracks…I find it too difficult to make a choice…

  189. Shelia says:

    I love your choc.chip mint. I have tried other brands because they were on sale and they just can not compair to yours. Turkey hill ice cream is so full of flavor and so creamy and smooth. They can keep their coupons for other brands, i’ m hooked on Turkey hill

  190. Cate says:

    Can’t wait to taste the winners. Of course, Turkey Hill is always the winner any flavor. Thanks for being creative in your offerings.

  191. sherry mcconaghay says:

    There is not another brand available that beats the creamy, rich, taste of Turkey Hill ice cream! So glad we live in PA where Turkey Hill flavors are readily available all the time. What can you always find in our freezer? Turkey Hill ice cream! Turkey Hill ice tea is always found in our refrigerator. We are a Turkey Hill family!

  192. I love the Southern Lemon Pie – Deliciousl
    Tastes just like lemon meringue pie!!
    I always tell other people to try it. If you
    like lemon merinque pie,,,,,you’ll love this
    flaver.
    Being as I was born in Lancaster county.and used to]
    go there often to see my parents ,,,,,,,,,,,,I was
    happy to see that you brought it to Ohio where I now
    live.

  193. Gail Whitman says:

    I love Tin Roof Sundae and the Philadelphia style Vanilla. I love when my local store has them on special so that I can justify buying several containers. Can’t pass up a sale, right?

  194. Chris M-H says:

    Still love Moose Tracks no matter if it’s full fat or light!

  195. Now a senior citizen, I have been eating ice cream virtually all of my life, have tasted many brands and flavors over the years, and even worked summers at a major ice cream company while in college, with access to some wonderful ice cream. That said, my all-time favorite – some in my freezer right now – is Turkey Hill Light Recipe Moose Tracks! I give it to my guests, and they always want more!!

  196. Jodid may says:

    I love all Turkey Hill ice cream, its the only kind to buy. My favorite was the strawberry cheesecake but sadly it is no more. I am really loving the over stuff’d right now, mmmmmm….. Time for a bowl of ice cream!!

  197. No celebration, birthday party, or family get together is
    complete at our house without Turkey Hill Ice Cream!! It’s
    truly become a part of our family….traditions and favorites!
    Everyone gets “happy” with so many flavors to choose from and
    enjoy :)
    Thank you Turkey Hill!!

  198. Maggie Bailey says:

    Im sooo crushed that your flavor Baked Apple Pie isnt available any longer, for that reason, my lil heart is broken.

  199. Keith says:

    Your ice cream is so good that we had to take a trip down to PA to go se and go through The Turkey Hill Experience!
    p.s. We love your ice tea also!

  200. DARLENE narvae says:

    the peanut praline ice cream is so delicious. its has layers of texture and taste. when i close my eyes i back down south. thank you.

  201. Joel Cannon says:

    So I had the All Natural Cherry Vanilla this week. Quite possibly the creamiest and most delicious Ice Cream I have ever had. Double Dunker is great too. How bout Turkey Hill doing a Japanese style Red Bean Ice Cream…I’ve had it twice in my life and it was great. Keep up being Awesome, Turkey Hill.

    GO PHILLIES.

  202. Brianna says:

    GOOOOO DOUBLE DUNKER!!!! This flavor is my all-time go-to.

  203. Mike Salvio says:

    Turkey Hill Deep Dark Choclate is the finest chocolate ice cream I have ever had. It compares to premium ice cream store flavors made by Cold Stone and others and I believe, comes out on top. The deep rich flavor is second to no other chocolate ice cream I’ve ever had. I hope to see this flavor on the store shelves as a permanent flavor.

  204. Tom Doherty says:

    Turkey Hill, that’s Pennsylvania talk for MMM Good

  205. kathleen says:

    After a winter like this-anytime your suggled in after supper with a bowl of your favorite flavor, close your eyes and summer comes to mind. I really helps

  206. Alisa Kaplan says:

    The only ice cream my kids will eat! Sometimes it’s hard to find Dutch Chocolate_guess it’s every ones favorite too.

  207. Charlene Molnar says:

    Just tried Double Dunker for the first time yesterday, and it’s the best chocolate ice cream I’ve had in a really long time! GO DOUBLE DUNKER!!!!

  208. Jessica says:

    All natural coffee ice cream is my absolute FAVORITE!! :D

    Keep up the good work, Turkey HilL!

  209. Dina says:

    Ice cream has always been a “stable” in our family for as long as I can remember. I am now retired and have lived in 5 different states including PA. Turkey Hill ice cream is the best ice cream I have eaten especially the chocolate peanut butter and chocolate marshmellow.

  210. christa kontes says:

    I love Double Dunker. It is THE BEST ice cream flavor of all the ice creams (and all brands) I have ever tried.

  211. Mary Ryan says:

    Cookies and cream will always be my favorite! Love Turkey Hill products!

  212. Heather says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream is my FAVORITE!! Some of these flavors I have never seen in my local store though and I would like to! They sound sooooo good!!

  213. william lee says:

    Yankee pinstripe brownie blast – the BEST ice cream ever!!!!

  214. Linda says:

    Vanilla best is old fashioned goodness at its best!

  215. Peggy Elk says:

    Turkey Hill Ice Cream is my all time favorite! I love all the flavors and have a hard time picking just ONE when I am buying!
    Thanks for making it so good!
    Peggy

  216. Dee Kilmer says:

    Love Turkey Hill ice cream! I hope the finalist will be some form of chocolate flavor — that’s my favorite!

  217. Beryl Britton says:

    ANY flavor of Turkey Hill Ice Cream is heads and tails over any other brand. I know because I hear about it from my family if the store is out of a particular T.H. flavor and I sustitute another brand.

  218. Mary Freiert says:

    Good Morning So sorry I missed the dead line for the voting ! My comment is simply I love your ice creams!! My all time favorite is the birthday cake. What a great idea to make the ice cream taste like the birthday cake! My family likes anything with peanuts or peanut butter and chocolate in the ice cream Your have so many flavors to choose sometimes it hard to only choose 2 when they are on sale 2 for $5.00. But what a good problem that is. Keep up the good work. PS I am a huge collector of cow items and would love to add the cow ice cream bowl. Thank you for all the hard work I am sure it takes to have a successful business in today economy .Mary Freiert

  219. Kim says:

    We are the winners because we are eating the ice cream! My favorite since I was a kid is Mint Choco Chip. Love Turkey Hill ice cream!

  220. Zak says:

    ‘I find Turkey Hill Ice Cream to be udderly delicious!’ There, I’ve said it again!

  221. Kristi says:

    I cannot fathom that Columbian Coffee is not on this list. It is the best flavor ever! Please don’t EVERY take my Coffee Ice Cream away!

  222. Cheryl mccollum says:

    Absolutely love all Turkey Hill flavors -every one is a winner in my book ! My very favorite is Chocolate Peanut Butetr – I buy it every week and it is so yummy – milky chocolate and salty swirls of pb – heaven ! Never stop making it though I do love to see all the limited edition flavors arrive .

  223. ROSEANN LEVY says:

    Eating Turkey Hill ice cream is like celebrating Thanksgiving every day

  224. Michele McCartney says:

    I can’t believe my favorite, Phillies Graham Slam, didn’t win! Can’t get enough of this flavor!

  225. Jay Hartman says:

    Vanilla Conference: Cookies and Cream
    Chocolate Conference: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conference: Strawberries and Cream
    Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  226. Carol Ankrum says:

    One of the things I miss MOST about PA now that I live in Florid is TURKEY HILL PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE ICE CREAM!!!! I wish for the day that Turkey Hill finds a distributor in the WARM state!!! Perhaps you could partner up with Martin’s Chips to find a distributor for both???? :-)

  227. Charlotte Faeth says:

    I love vanilla bean! It can enhance whatever you like to serve – cake, cookiess, cobbler… Or, it’s wonderful all by itself!

  228. Ray Hand says:

    Any time you can have an Espresso flavor combines with a “light” recipe you will have a winner. Add walnuts and God will smile down on you and the angels will sing your praises!

  229. pete mapelli says:

    i love all the turkey hill premium flavors they are absoloutely delicious but nobody comes close to the all natural vanilla bean it is sensational, delicious and just out of this world. if you haven’t had some do yourself a favor and try that flavor

  230. sandy reuling says:

    First of all I love Turkey Hill Prices!
    But if there is a favorite it would be chocolate chip cookie dough……..
    It reminds me of the days when I was a little girl and I would eat my cookies and milk. Now you get the same great experience only all in one mouthful and bowl.
    It always brings back memories of me and my older brother dipping in milk with our chocolate chip cookies.
    We are all grown up now but it does give me a great memory every time I eat your ice cream (along with a smile on my face)
    I am glad Turkey Hill can do this for me.

  231. bink says:

    I have tried other brands because they were on sale, and have yet to find one that can compare to the taste of Turkey Hill.
    Even the higher priced trendy brands don’t come close.
    I have about 5 favorites that I am constantly switching between.
    Right now i’m on a Rocky Road.

  232. Edward says:

    Tasted salted carmel at harrisburg farm show pa. It was to die for but could not find in stores.

  233. Linda says:

    I would love to try the all natural salted carmel, but cant find it
    I love the choco pnutbutter, rum raisin and I want to try the chunky pnutbutter! Where oh where might I find these yummy flavors?

  234. lynda says:

    I’m a Mets fan but Yankee pinstripes wins hands down.
    Cookoies and Cream, and Cookie Dough are favorites in our house as they are team neutral:)

  235. Donald Brubaker says:

    I’m 78 years old and have been eating Turkey Hill ice cream since it’s inception. Ice cream still remains as my most favorite dessert as well as when I want a treat.

    Don Brubaker

  236. Jill Fitzgibbons says:

    I love, love, LOVE chocolate covered pretzel ice cream. I never even used to eat ice cream until I stumbled across it one day, then my husband started joking about how I was addicted to it. And then…..every store around here stopped carrying it. I’m desperate and don’t know what to do!

  237. MrsDrL says:

    While I’m not a big consumer of ice cream, I find it hard to resist Rocky Road as well as the Yankee Pinstripe. My family on the other hand can eat any flavor ice cream any time of the day or night. I do like the flavor of Turkey Hill ice cream the best. YUM!

  238. I have been a fan of Turkey Hill from your beginning.Now in my seventies and still having a dish every time Ican.I LOVED your special edition Gertrude Hawkes,although it sold out in this area too fast.My husband and grandkids love your ice cream and geen tea immensly!

  239. Marion says:

    How did I miss the chance to try to pick the final four? I need to read my emails better.

  240. Brenda Parry says:

    The problem with picking a favorite flavor of Turkey Hill Ice Cream is that it is nearly impossible! ALL of their flavors are sublime, the best ice cream I have ever tasted. I love the unique limited edition flavors, such as Pumpkin Pie, and the sports themed flavors like Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast. The old standbys such as Neapolitan and Coffee are amazing. Who can pick just one?

  241. Mrs. Mary Allison says:

    My family loves Turkey Hill ice cream so much that before it was available to us in Southwestern PA, we came to Lancaster County 2x a year to pick some up and give out for Christmas gifts!! We still love it (all of them) and still have Turkey Hill be a part of our family get togethers and special times. Thank you for making a great product that has high quality and tastes sooo good!!

  242. Ed says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE – Tin Roof Sundae

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE – Rocky Road

    THE FRUIT CONFERENCE – Banana Split

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE – Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  243. M Dun says:

    Those who did not vote for rum raisin did not vote for it!
    Try it you will love it

  244. M Dun says:

    Those who did not vote for rum raisin did not try it!
    Try it you will love it

  245. Michelle says:

    I love the limited time flavors that Turkey Hill comes out with!

  246. Brenda says:

    My family and I enjoy Turkey Hill Ice Cream year round.
    I usually buy the same flavors. When I see a new flavor I will buy it and try it and never disappointed.

  247. Kristy Ober says:

    I have LOVED and ONLY eated Turkey hill Ice Cream since my family moved to Lancaster when I was 7, and I am coming up on my 39th birthday…LOVE LOVE LOVE Mint Choc Chip and Choc/PB cup

  248. John says:

    Start making Chocolate Malted Chip again, low sugar even better

  249. Suzanne R says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: All Natural Salted Caramel

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Rocky Road

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Strawberries and Cream

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  250. Shannon says:

    My family is addicted to Touchdown Sundae!!! Love your ice cream!!

  251. Lori Biggy says:

    OMG I just can’t get enough of your coffee ice cream. My daughter doesn’t help matters.
    I love to swirl and mix it in my bowl so it’s like a milkshake. I only ever do this with coffee ice cream. I have been doing this since I was a little girl. I am now 50. My 10 yr. old does this now too.
    DELICIOUS

  252. Matt says:

    By far your Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream is the absolute best on the market at this time, in my opinion.

  253. J.A. says:

    oh,wow. Way too many choices to pick just one! I love the peppermint candy cane, though.

  254. John M. Potucek says:

    Still LOVE Turkey Hill “Dreamsicle” the VERY best on a hot Summer Day!!

  255. john degeorge says:

    turkey hill ice cream has most nautral favor tasteing ice cream i’ve had ,,and there limited fried ice cream i can not wait for it to come out will buy alot of it ……….thanks

  256. Nancy says:

    My ultimate favorite flavor is the Limited Edition Box of Chocolates. Turkey Hill Ice Cream is one of the creamiest brands of ice cream. It’s not too sweet or gritty either. Next to the box of chocolates would have to be peanut butter cup. I love the chunks of peanut butter swirled with not too chocolaty chocolate ice cream. You guys are awesome!

  257. Deb says:

    I LOVE the Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates flavor!!! I had trouble locatng it, but I was so happy when I found it at our local store this past weekend! My daughter is visiting next week from Mississippi, and I wanted her to tast my favorite flavor. Yummmmmmm…

    Also, thanks for the coupons you offer!

  258. Linda Dunaway says:

    I absolutely love the coconut cream pie AND egg nog flavors…..your ice cream is the best!!!!

  259. Sherry Sawyer says:

    I don’t think I’ve ever met an ice cream that I didn’t like… but mostly I just like vanilla… and then, I add my own goodies… trying to keep the calorie count fairly low. Actually, I usually eat frozen vanilla yogurt. But, almost all these Turkey Hill flavors sound delicious!!!!!! (I’ve tried quite a few!)

  260. Michael Hinton says:

    I LOVE TURKEY HILL ICE-CREAM. IT’S MY ONE AND ONLY AND I WILL EAT IT UNTIL I DIE! :D lol

  261. Eleanor says:

    I love egg nog, moose tracks, cherry vanilla, the Yankees and the Phillies flavors, mint chocolate chip. There are so many and Turkey Hill tastes soo goooood!!!

  262. Kristen says:

    Whhops, shame I’m too late to join the fun of picking the final four, but that’s okay. I still voted in the “thrilling 32″! Bring on the dairy deliciousness!

  263. vince smith says:

    THis is a fabulous idea -Since moving to Pittsburgh, Turkey Hill hsa been my ‘go to ice’ cream. I got in just in time to start this year’s 32….Go ice cream!

  264. vince smith says:

    my mistake -missed the ’32′ -but oh, well -go ice cream anyway! ha ha

  265. Lorraine says:

    I just want to say all the mentioned flavors sound and are delish, but my all time favorite is Butter Pecan. I love it!!! I’m so surprised it didn’t make any of the lists. It will always be my favorite.

  266. Denise says:

    Some of these were hard to vote because they both were family favorites. Great ice cream!

  267. Pam DeLorenzo says:

    Though late, here is my two cents:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE: you mean there’s a question about this? Anytime vanilla is featured, it’s a hands down winner. In this case the Natural Salted Carmel wins.

    As for the CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE: Phillies and Yankee’s? come on, no contest; it’s Pinstripe Brownie Blast all the way.

    Then there’s the THE FRUIT CONFERENCE: I’d have to say Strawberries n Cream because nothing says ice cream like a blend of fruit with ‘n Cream in it. Can you say “to die for”?

    Finally, THE LIMITED: it’s tough to top Pumpkin Pie (unless it’s with cream), but I’m going to choose Coconut Cream Pie because when it’s cold out and I eat this I can only fantisize that I’m in the tropics sitting under a coconut tree with a cool delicious and creamy treat (like Turkey Hill’s Coconut Cream Pie)!!

  268. Beth R says:

    Love the PA Dutch pretzel ice cream. Always dip pretzels in my ice cream and this allows me to get a jump on it. Never can have enough ice cream especially Turkey Hill.

  269. Sara says:

    Chunky pb!!

  270. Sharon says:

    I just discovered Double Dunker and I love it!!!!

  271. Joel G says:

    I found my thrill… in Turkey Hill!

  272. Terry T says:

    Double Dunker is the BEST FLAVOR EVER!!!! It should run away with the title. EXTREMELY YUMMY !!!!!

  273. Stephany blickenstaff says:

    My family loves Turkey Hill. We buy it at least once a week. Our favorite special edition is blitz burg. Yummo

  274. Janice says:

    I always buy Turkey Hill. I love Box of Chocolates. But I have to say Double Dunker is my absolute favorite.

  275. Bar bara says:

    Its hard to pick any one flavor of turkey hill ice cream..they are all DELICIOUS!

  276. Steven Myers says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Dutch Chocolate

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Banana Split

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Coconut Cream

  277. Wendy says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is my favorite flavor!

  278. Bill says:

    Tin Roof Sundae, any day!

  279. Debbie says:

    Our go to flavor is No Sugar Added Vanilla Bean….very creamy and can dress up any way we want. Also, definitely a fan of Blitzburgh. However; we hope to find PA Dutch Pretzel to try, it sounds awesome!

  280. pat bentzel says:

    There are no losers in this contest, I love black raspberry.I want to eat a spoonful of each flavor every day ,it could take me forever( I hope) to pick just one as the best.

  281. We were tired of eating ice cream because there was no to very little choices that excited your taste buds. When in to my store to find a new item(s) on the shelf, starting with vanilla with junior mints, wow it was a hit, and I immediately contacted Turkey Hill and informed them that they had a hit. Ice cream continues at our house as long as Turkey Hill is on the shelf.
    Thank You
    Phillip Conrads

  282. Howard Moss says:

    I predict the final 4 will be:
    • Vanilla Conference: Cookies ‘n Cream
    • Chocolate (And Others) Conference: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    • Fruit Conference: Black Cherry
    • Limited Edition Conference: Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

  283. Kelly says:

    Turkey Hill has the best flavors of ice cream than any other brand out there! They have a flavor for everyone to love and their limited editions are awesome!

  284. JOYCE REYNOLDS says:

    All the flavors are great… wish is was sold in Florida! The flavor I wish you’d make is cinnamon.. had it in South Dakota and loved it and can’t find it anywhere!

  285. Marc Kravitz says:

    coconut cream pie is awesome. should be a regular flavor and sold year round. tastes great and with the cake pieces, you could eat it as a meal.

  286. Rachel says:

    Mmmmm, Turkey Hill ice cream! All winners, in my opinion!

  287. Jackie says:

    Love the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup and we have friends from Florida that come up and we have to have this in our freezer. They would love for you to have it in their markets.

  288. Deb says:

    Omg too many good flavored to choose from! Ever since I bought your whoopi pie I haven’t been able to buy another brand! Your is way too good no one can compare!!!

  289. Walter Seymour says:

    Bring back the New York Yankees Ice Cream soon !!!
    We are thinking baseball and ice cream !

  290. Amy T says:

    I didn’t even know about this until an email today! No fair!

  291. Tina says:

    I love the Phillies Gram Slam ice cream. In my area it is so hard to find. I think it sells out as soon as it is stocked at my local store. Please make extra for ice cream/ baseball season is right around the corner!

  292. Carol galinsky says:

    I don’t know if u ever considered a carnival flavor with bits and pieces of snack food from a carnival such as cotton candy

  293. Joe Maguire says:

    Whoopie pie is by far the best ice cream I ever had!

  294. Ed p. says:

    Now THIS is March Madness. I cant believe I’ve actually tried this many flavors. Turkey Hill also provides a lot of flavors in nonfat and yogurt. Now Ineed to go have a bowl. Hey Phillies fans, get those votes in.

  295. asers says:

    Love all the flavors esp all the peanut butter and choc combination!!

  296. Jerry Vovcsko says:

    Elegantly delicious…always a winner…that’s Turkey Hill Vanilla Bean.

  297. Jerry Aumente says:

    Of all the many brands of ice cream I have eaten, Turkey Hill is far and away the best. I have never been disappointed in any of the many flavors I have tried. I look forward to each new combo you put on the market. Keep them coming.

  298. Connie says:

    So many awesome flavors, so little time to try them all!!!!

  299. LIana says:

    You can go wrong with chocolate ice cream from Turkey Hill. Quality superior to none.

  300. Todd M says:

    You have ruined all other ice creams for me TH……..thank you!

  301. Diana says:

    Anything with a peanut butter swirl and chunks of chocolate gets my vote!

  302. Dorothy Terwilliger says:

    The Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie is the best I have ever tasted. The flavor and the chunks of crust combine to be such a taste treat. Please make it all of the time.

  303. jim stark says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Peanut Butter Ripple

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Rum Raisin

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter

  304. sandy says:

    so many flavors , so little time to try all, where do I start?

  305. Bill says:

    Moose Tracks !!!
    The ultimate ice cream treat.

  306. Jennifer says:

    Moose track & pumpkin pie are my faves! Love Turkey Hill!

  307. Kellie Dugan says:

    Your Yankees brands pin strip brownie blast and Bronx bomber sundae are the best ice creams ever!!! (^^^) When it is on sale we stock up enough to last until the next sale.

  308. Lori A Riegel says:

    OMG!!!! So many flavors so little bowls!!! I recently moved to Sarasota Florida where Turkey Hill Ice Cream cannot be found —- I miss it sooooo much and can’t wait to get my fix the next time I visit my home state of Pennsylvania!!!!

  309. Lori A Riegel says:

    Just moved to Florida and they don’t know what they’re missing — best ice cream ever — please send some our way!!!!

  310. elaine m says:

    I love voting for my favorites! But it is making me very hungry! thanks turkey hill! Graham slam rocks!!

  311. maryann trotta says:

    Love, love, love the peanutbutter cup chocolate ice cream! YUM

  312. J.Do says:

    i love the mint cookies yogurt, its hard to find, because every buys it so quickly
    Also, i love the no sugar ice cream for husband who needs to watch his sugar intake
    Love love turkey hill!!!
    J.do

  313. Tina Catoe says:

    Just love all of your flavors that I have tried. Hope to visit one day.

  314. Edward McCormick says:

    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast is the best Chocolate Ice Cream EVER MADE!!!!

  315. Edward McCormick says:

    Ynkees Pinstripe Brownie Blast is the best Chocolate Ice Cream EVER MADE!!!

  316. Jane Mahoney says:

    By far the most delicious flavor ever is Double Dunker. OMG… the combination of the mocha flavor with the chunks of cookie dough and crunchy chocolate are mixed with such perfection, it is pure heaven. And if you really want to add to it, some hot fudge and whipped cream.

  317. Paula K says:

    Love love love your all natural lineup, the current butter almond/chocolate combo is the best! Hubby has dye allergies and that “other” all natural is NOT. they use yellow # 5 and annatto. So we are forever in your debt, he can eat ice cream again!

  318. Ann N says:

    I love the all naturals! I only wish more of them were available in my area, but I’ll eat what I can get!

  319. Michael H says:

    Phillies Graham Slam is the best!

  320. Michael H says:

    Please bring back the Peanut butter brownie you had a couple years ago that was soo good!

  321. Love Turkey Hill Pumpkin pie ice cream and also Butter peacan is so rich with flavor and pecans in every bite . Can’t go wrong here in the south to enjoy Turkey Hill .

  322. janet Jones says:

    I love all the flavors!

  323. Mary Kiecal says:

    I LOVE them all but Dutch Chocolate makes me weak in th knees!

  324. Lillian says:

    We were “The Philadelphia Ice cream” family – not now Turkey Hill is the “bomb”. Won’t have a family gathering with out it

  325. LOTTIE BERMAN says:

    my fav is chocolate marshmallo.

  326. sande says:

    Light bavarian espresso- the best ice on the face of this earth-truely addictive-can’t get enough

  327. Mickey says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice cream. I love Ltd Edition Fried Ice Cream, I mean how can you go wrong with cinnamon ice cream? But my absolute favorite is Stuff’d Double Cookies ‘n Cream. Oreos and those crunchy bits in there, wow, tastes like God must have made it!

  328. Wendy says:

    Turkey Hill Ice Cream is definitely the ice cream of choice in our home.

  329. Liz says:

    Mom always has Turkey Hill in the freezer when I come home on college breaks. Anything with chocolate!!!!!

  330. Jessica Z. says:

    Turkey Hill is amazing, you just can’t go wrong with any flavor, really!

  331. Katharine says:

    I LOVE Turkey Hill ice cream! YUMMMM!

  332. Helene says:

    All of the flavors of Turkey Hill are winners. It is quality ice cream and you can always find a variety of flavors to choose from and each one is better than the other. I would recommend Turkey Hill to anyone who is an ice cream lover.
    I do have to say that I really miss it though. I used to live in Massachusetts but have moved to Florida and have not been able to find it in my local grocery stores. I do hope you will start selling it in our local stores. My zip code is 33542. Thank you!

  333. Norma says:

    Coffee is one of my FAVORITES!

  334. AnnMarie says:

    Vanilla winner: Cookies ‘N’ Cream

    Chocolate winner: Rocky Road

    Fruit winner: Black Cherry

    Limited Edition winner: Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

  335. Marcia Gliss says:

    love all of the turkey hill flavors. It is so rich and creamy- a truly premium ice cream.

  336. L Myers says:

    Any time you want a refreshing treat, reach for any flavor of ice cream, but make sure it is Turkey Hill!

  337. Jan Williams says:

    I told my granddaughter I was giving up dairy but when the Gertrude Hawk Chocolate came out I gave in. I went to my local grocery store and couldn’t find it. I asked one of the clerks if they were out. He said he thought so. I asked him to go in the back and check. When he said there was none I went to a manager. When he couldn’t find any more I asked to see the dairy buyer. I was obsessed. Finally, I think to get rid of me they told me to come back on that Friday as the delivery would be Thursday evening. I was there Thursday evening just before they closed to make sure I got some and then bought two.

  338. joretta says:

    So hard to choose and predict! They’re all so yummy!

  339. lee says:

    omg grahman slam rocks!!!!!!!

  340. Bruce Gillette says:

    Cannot wait for the Fried Ice Cream to come out. Will you ever do the Shoo Fly Pie Ice Cream again? Toasted Almond? Carrot Cake? Creme Brulee ? How is that for suggestions? Bruce G.

  341. Bruce Gillette says:

    What Ice Cream would be the creamiest, richest ice cream made? Is a custard useable for an Ice Cream? or only soft ice cream? Bruce

  342. PETER says:

    My Fiancee Loves Your Pistachio. And when I bring it home in the evening, she smiles. And at bedtime, she indulges on your awesome Pistacho. And later, I have a smile on my face. Peter

  343. The “F” factor Fearon Family favorite fives are the orange sherbet on a hot Summer day,Cookies/cream, Rum/rasin,Peanut butter swirl and cookie dough we enjoy these flavors with family/friends or without….a favorite past time on family night are board games and a bowl of icecream

  344. Turkey Hill icecream mends brokenheart and bring families together

  345. Ida Beek says:

    Our all time favorite for the Christmas Holidays is Rum Raisin. It’s decadent, delectable, delicious and we would be crushed if it ever went away.

  346. joe says:

    we love original vanilla.2 cartons in freezer right now.turkey
    hill is the best.

  347. Joe says:

    All your flavors are winners! We love the Phillies Graham Slam even though we are Mets fans.

  348. Marty Greenspan says:

    Vanilla Conference Winner: Cookies & Cream
    Chocolate (and Others )Winner: Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Fruit Conference Winner: Stuff’d Strwaberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition Conference Winner: Coconut Cream Pie

  349. Holly says:

    I really miss the Whoopie Pie Ice Cream that was out last year…will you be bringing it back this year? I hope so :)

  350. Becca says:

    Tin Roof Sundae rocks!!

  351. Marty Greenspan says:

    Your Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie should NOT be in this category next year. It is so great that it should become one of your regular flavors! Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  352. Donna says:

    I enjoy the peanut butter swirl, but you did away with the best ever and that was the “Philly Style Vanilla Bean”. PLEASE bring it back.

  353. Morgane Agarwal says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream any time, anywhere with everyone!!

  354. Edward Menold says:

    Vanilla Conf- Tin Roof Sundae
    Chocolate Conf- Rocky Road
    Fruit Conf- Stuff’d strawberry cheesecake
    Limited edition- Coconut Cream Pie

  355. Carrie says:

    Our whole family loves ice cream. My boys asked for ice cream while we were home for our “snow day” yesterday. It was a lot of fun eating ice cream in the warmth of inside watching it snow outside!

  356. Kristi says:

    Final 4
    All Natural Salted Caramel
    Ltd. Edition Snyders PA Dutch Pretzel
    Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake
    Ltd. Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  357. mary menchyk says:

    fudge ripple is my favorite

  358. Margarita says:

    I love the coconut pie!!!!!

  359. Megan says:

    Yummy!

  360. Kas says:

    Yankee Pinstripe Brownie Blast is a masterpiece! It is our family’s favorite. Hope it becomes a permanent flavor!

  361. Nancy Fuller says:

    My winners are:
    Vanilla – Choc Chip Cookie Dough
    Chocolate – MY UNDISPUTED FAVORITE – Light Receipe Chocolate Moose Tracks
    Fruit – Black Cherry
    Special – MY OWN 2ND FAVORITE OF ALL TIME – Deep Dark Chocolate. This is a true chocolate lover’s dream come true!

  362. Jerry Dilaj says:

    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Ice Cream is a winner, because the brownies are as good as my wife’s. Don’t you dare tell her I said that!

  363. Tracy M. says:

    This was harder than picking NCAA teams! My favorite 2 Limited Ediition Flavors (EggNog and Pumpkin Pie) were pitted against each other. . .What a showdown!

  364. Renee Macintire says:

    Omg, we love your ice cream! My daughter has a peanut allergy but I know that most flavors of our product are safe or her to eat! Party cake is her most favorite but I love the cool white mint and hubby loves chocolate marshmallow. Keep up the great work. We only buy turkey hill! So glad to be born and raised in PA to enjoy your great product!

  365. Janet says:

    I was disappointed to get the email telling me about this only to see that the voting is over!

  366. STEVE SALMON says:

    I DON’T CARE WHO WINS. JUST GIVE ME MORE TURKEY HILL ICE CREAM

  367. Jeanne Smith says:

    Nothing can go wrong with the coffee ice cream-even if you don’t drink coffee. It’s the very best!

  368. TURKEY HILL ICE CREAM IS THE BEST OF THE BEST!! I love all the flavors, my list can go on and on and on and on and on………

  369. John says:

    The three best flavors are Blitzburgh Crunch, Blitzburgh Crunch, and Blitzburgh Crunch! Was able to buy it once here in Virginia, but they must’ve stopped due to the season ending. Bring it back, because I need my fix!

  370. Heather nicholas says:

    They are all good!

  371. Sr. Bernadette Okulicz, FSSJ says:

    The famous saying “I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream” (Turkey Hill of course!)is definitely my endorsement for the best comfort food there is.

  372. david durant says:

    we are coffee and chocolate lovers and we have kids ,so its hard to pick but

    Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream

    Light Recipe Bavarian Espresso

    Dutch Chocolate

    Natural Coffee

    this is very hard becauce you have so many good flavors and you send me coupons so we try a variety ,thank you!

  373. Vickie Ross says:

    My husband would be in heaven if I won a month’s supply of Turkey Hill ice cream. However, it would probably be 31 cartons to last him a month!

  374. H says:

    Nutty Moose Tracks is the BEST

  375. barbara watt says:

    I am in my mid 50′s and have recently started eating ice cream. I never really cared for it until I tried yours. The taste and creamieness is just unbelievable. Now I have a big bowl every night ! All those years without, I can’t believe. thank you

  376. John C. Hosler says:

    How about making a flavor called Chocolate Almond? Many just love it, but it is getting harder and harder to find. I’ll bet Turkey Hill could make it a great treat & seller !!!!

  377. Gwen Black says:

    Vanilla Conference: Cookies N’ Cream
    Chocolate Conference: Rocky Road
    Fruit: Stuff”d Stawberry Cheesecake
    Limited Edition: Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  378. Janice says:

    VANILLA CONFERENCE WINNER: Cookies ‘n Cream

    CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE WINNER: Rocy Road

    FRUIT CONFERENCE WINNER: Orange Grove Sherbert

    LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE WINNER: Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  379. Marybeth Nein says:

    I would love to see a mix of Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup and Chocolate Marshmallow! That would be awesome!

  380. gmom maybe says:

    so many flavors so little time. Srawberry cream, black cherry, pistacio, chocolate hmm love them all. The new honey baklava frozen yogurt is a real treat. Thanks

  381. I have been a fan of Turkey Hill for a long time. When I moved to Ohio, it was one of the things I missed most about Pennsylvania. Now my stores carry Turkey Hill Ice Cream and I am very happy. I love trying all of the special editions. The chocolate peanut butter cup is a must have at least once a month. BUT my all time go to flavor is French Vanilla.

  382. David says:

    There all winners when there made with pure love and natural ingredients and by the best ice cream makers in the world Turkey Hill (who else).

  383. Judy M says:

    Some of these flavors sound really great, but my all time favorite is the All Natural Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, and Butter Almond…Yum!

  384. kala says:

    love all your flavors love to get coupons for your product. keep up the good work,

  385. Tom says:

    To the THD staff, you out done yourselves this past year (2012). As you put out your new Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie ice cream, what a great flavor, and also the other new flavor Salty Caramel Vanilla! How about, my offer to THD staff in 2011, of Butterscotch Caramel Vanilla? I am cheering on your other flavors of Black Cherry and Dutch Chocolate to the final four!!! Bring it on, lets get this Ultimate Ice Cream Tourament done with flying colors!

  386. Charlotte Bertram says:

    With all of that yummy, creamy goodness, its so hard to choose a favorite, although, anything with peanut butter and chocolate, is always good.

  387. jay says:

    Dutch Pretzel!Dutch Pretzel!Dutch Pretzel!Dutch Pretzel!

  388. jay says:

    Dutch Pretzel #1!

  389. mary johnson says:

    Turkey Hill is the MOST flavorful, Best selections and LEAST expensive ice cream of ALL. Many FLAVORS I crave and lots of MONEY I SAVE. !!!! Thanks

  390. DIANE HUNSINGER says:

    I LOVE TURKEY HILL DOUBLE DUNKER ICE CREAM!!! DELICIOUSNESS!

  391. Dan Avery says:

    Free ice cream from Turkey Hill! What a deliciously cool prize!

  392. Tom Noble says:

    I am a Yankees fan in baseball but Phillies graham is AWESOME and my ice cream winner. You have to be a Turkey not to love Turkey Hill Ice Creams.

  393. Denise George says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

    Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks

    Black Cherry

    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  394. craig r says:

    black cherry is the best ice cream ever ! vanilla bean is right up there .

  395. Charlie Haubrich says:

    I cant choose! All of your flavors are delicious! Hands down the best ice cream on the market! Thank you!

  396. Mary Ann Kline says:

    Just wanted to tell you that the Black Cherry rocks!!!! I love your ice creams. The Phillies Graham Slam is an ice cream which is unique; smooth yet crunchie in spots. You have a great “inventor” team there. My ideal job would be as a taste tester for Turkey Hill :o )!

  397. My absolute favorites are chocolate chip cookie dough and vanilla and chocolate together!!

  398. Marguerite Corbett says:

    My all time favorite ice cream is the natural vanilla! I like other flavors too (double dunker, tin roof and many others. But vanilla is always good :) )You have ruined other ice creams for me! Even when another national brand (breyers, friendlies, ect) is on sale I don’t bother because I know I wont like the ice cream as much and if I’m going to cheat on my diet I might as well have the good stuff!

  399. Pam Frisco says:

    Turkey Hill makes the best tasting Ice Creams…Dutch Chocolate is one of the best chocolates I have ever tasted! I have really never tasted a Turkey Hill flavor I didn’t like…I love ice cream!

  400. John Chambers says:

    I didn’t see my favorite Turkey Hill Ice Cream, Butter Pecan. While I have tried other flavors I always come back for more Butter Pecan. It has the perfect balence of ice cream to nuts and goes down easy. Keep up the good work and making new interesting flavors. John Chambers, Lansdowne, PA

  401. Alecia Malick says:

    Vanilla Beam Rocks and Box Of Chocolates with Gertrude Hawks (the best chocolates ever!) What more can you say? Oh My Gosh! Turkey Hill Ice Creams are most definitely the best on the market, none others compare! Chocolate. Marshmallow. Nuts. Natural Flavors. Life is good!

  402. Doris Combs says:

    I love every flavor of ice cream that Turkey Hill makes. No
    brand can beat it.

  403. Diane VanDenburgh says:

    Are you kidding me, have you ever had fried ice cream? If you did you would definitely vote for IT!!!

  404. Colleen Donnelly says:

    I love every flavor of Turkey Hill that I have ever tasted but my heart belongs to cookie dough

  405. Marie says:

    Our whole family loves Turkey Hill’s quality sweetness in season and out!

  406. Marie says:

    We tried Turkey Hill’s ice cream for the first time last year and really liked it.

  407. Marie says:

    We enjoy Turkey Hill’s large variety of ice cream flavors.

  408. Marie says:

    Ice cream never gets boring.

  409. June says:

    Looking forward to trying any new flavors coming out this season, Dutch Chocolate is my favorite year round.

  410. Kathy Flanagan says:

    I love most flavors of your ice cream. Chocolate is my favorite. I used to eat the graham slam, but I have celiac disease and have to have gluten free and chocolate and the cherry is the best.
    Kathy Flanagan

  411. Bill says:

    The new all natural vanilla and the natural vanilla in the black containers are both very good. The natural neopolitan is excellent too. Do you still make that??? Not sure. Too many choices and lose track (not Moose Tracks). Almond vanilla/chocolate is good too.

  412. annette Milliman says:

    Love the orange swirl cream. Makes a wonderful float with some orange soda!

  413. Kathye says:

    I cannot pick just four flavors. My family had tried many flavors and love them all!! We would love to receive and eat ice cream all year long..

  414. Linda Candela says:

    The Whoopie Pie was outrageous. I’m sorry I missed the entry for which one to vote for. Every year I look forward to my Southern Lemon Pie. Can’t wait for May!! Love your regular ice cream as well as your frozen yogurt. Just tried the Greek yogurt with Baklava. Delicious!!! Keep the new flavors coming!!

  415. carey persico says:

    Love them all!

  416. Judy says:

    Sorry I missed the entry to vote, but I’d love to win free Turkey Hill ice cream!

  417. laurie says:

    My favorite is Skinny Minty, especially when it is topping freshly made brownies!

  418. joe says:

    just had my wifes favorite turkey hill ice cream.butter pecan.
    sooo! good.

  419. Cheryl Hafer says:

    I saw I missed the deadline for voting, but to win ice cream for a YEAR WOULD BE VERY NICE, AND IF I DON’T WIN ICE CREAM FOR A YEAR COUPONS WOULD BE GREAT TO HELP WITH THE COST!!

    I COULDN’T BELIEVE THE WHOOPIE PIE AND SNYDER’S CHOCOLATE COVERED PRETZELS IN THE SAME. LOVE BOTH OF THEM, WAS SAD TO SEE THE WHOOPIE PIE GO FOR THE YEAR, STILL FIND THE SNYDER’S CHOCOLATE COVERED PRETZELS AT SOME STORES.

    I LOVE CHOCOLATE BUT THE DOUBLE CHOCOLATE IS TOO MUCH CHOCOLATE. I EVEN PUT HERSHEY’S CHOCOLATE SYRUP ON MY ICE CREAM.

    WE LOVE THE VANILLA BEAN FOR MILKSHAKES.

    MY ONE SON IS A YANKEE FAN AND THE OTHER IS A PHILLIE FAN, SO THEY LIKE THOSE FLAVORS.

    HAVE A GOOD DAY!!

    Cheryl

  420. AC Nunn says:

    Dutch Chocolate
    Moose Tracks
    Cherry Vanilla

  421. Roseann Sillasen says:

    Turkey Hill Ice Cream is a staple in our house. We just love it!!!

  422. Roseann Sillasen says:

    Can it get any better. Turkey Hill Ice Cream is a staple in our house. We just love it!!!

  423. Barbara P. Sullivan says:

    Since the deadline has passed, I won’t cast a vote. If I were going to vote, the only flavor I would vote for would be Coffee. Actually, I’m addicted to Turkey Hill Philadelphia-style Coffee, which I’ve recently replaced with Turkey Hill Natural Coffee. In the area where I live, (Staten Island, one of the five boroughs of New York City), every supermarket carries the Turkey Hill brand, but I can find Philadelphia-style Coffee (now Natural Coffee) in only one chain, and even there not all the time. By the way, I still prefer the black packaging of the Philadelphia-style series over the white and yellow packaging of the Natural version.

  424. loves so many flavors!! got a big freezer to keep more choices on hand when on sale.All phillies fans here,but i sneak yankee pinstripe brownie blast for me.When i would have a hard day @ work,my husband would bring me a pint of stuff’d strawberry cheesecake to eat @ the end of a very stressful hot day. nothing like knowing a little turkey hill reward is waiting for you! thx!& keep up the creative yummy work!!

  425. Lee says:

    I’ve got to say that while I love your All Natural Ice Creams, when it comes to your entire catalog, the limited edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates is my all time favorite from Turkey Hill.

  426. Mike Wilson says:

    I have yet to find a Turkey Hill ice cream that I didn’t like. My favorite is peanut butter cup. You sure put lots of candy in your ice cream. Southern Lemon Pie is also one of my favorites, but it is difficult to find in my area.

  427. CathyR says:

    It’s getting more difficult! I really want all of them to win! :)

  428. Linda Marichak says:

    The Ultimate choice is Turkey Hill Ice cream. The consistency to me is more important than the flavor. It has to be Turkey Hill!

  429. Christine Evans says:

    There so much variety but the All Natural Salted Caramel is a favorite in our house,can’t keep enough of it on hand.

  430. RB says:

    My husband and I love chocolate peanut butter ice cream.

  431. Justine Kinch says:

    I love Rocky Road. My husband loves vanilla bean. But who doesn’t love ice cream? Oh Yeah!!!!

  432. melissa says:

    My family really enjoys Turkey Hill ice cream. It always tastes fantastic, and there is never a lack of variety. We really enjoy the limited edition flavors, and cant wait to see what you folks come up with next!

  433. Jani jonas says:

    several years ago I lost a freezer full of Turkey Hill Ice cream…baked apple dumpling limited edition ….in. Hurricane (Irene, 2011). I was heartsick, as I was stocking up on this amazing flavor…I knew it was a limited edition and it would be disappearing shortly…so I bought up all the 1/2 gallons I found. so ironic that I lost power and 20 gallons melted away. And then you didn’t make it this year!!! Yikes!!!! The special edition pumpkin pie was next best…keep them coming…. Every time I love a flavor the best, you pop up with another one….fried ice cream…amazing…..can’t wait for next year….thank you thank you

  434. Mariza says:

    Yum…we love the coconut pie limited edition. Wish you would add it to the lineup for all the time!

  435. susan barger says:

    Can’t seem to find the low cal Moosetracks locally! Having withdrawal…. Need to win ice cream…..

  436. Linda Johnston says:

    I think the voting is very close on a lot of the favors but it there are some many delicious flavors. I can see each week getting harder to pick your favorites.

  437. John Bunn says:

    cocoanut cream pie should become a regular produced item year round — can never find it in any of the stores in my area. Why have such a great item and only make it once a year?

  438. Jan M. says:

    Any of the Turkey Hill flavors are good!! Thanks for a chance to win a years supply of your ice cream. We love this brand. Have never tried the Whoopie Pie one. Would love to try it.

  439. ELLEN FISCHER says:

    We love the Turkey Hill Ice cream company, I would like the opportunity to win your great product to try all of the ice cream flavors that you offer. I purchase Turkey Hill once a week and would love to be the winner!

  440. Marsha Thompson says:

    I love Turkey Hill Ice cream all natural the Philly Style Chocolate was my very favorite, but all the flavors are fantastic. Cookie and Cream is so good it is hard to stop with just a bowl full.Yes sorry to say I sometimes have two bowls telling myself after all it is all natural and we do need dairy products each day to stay healthy.Love your creamy ice cream.

  441. Naomi G Vega says:

    All the flovors are tops with me I dont have a favorite I but all that are available in my area..
    but Moose tracks and Coconut are my favorite yes I’d like to win. However I just want to have more Turkey hill Ice cream available in my area (Brooklyn NY)I buy Ice cream almost every other day.

  442. Chesterschika says:

    I could not live without my Turkey Hill Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream! I have tried dozens of varieties and no one comes close to Turkey Hill!

  443. Charles Stimac says:

    Turkey Hill beats all other’s hands down! ‘Specially the Coconut Cream Pie! Only negative side is this flavor is only available for a short time each year.

  444. ann reynolds says:

    Please more reduced fat ice cream flavors.

  445. Conor Furey says:

    I like to eat Turkey Hill ice cream

  446. Diana Riconda says:

    I love all the Turkey hill flavors but my absolute favorites are the traditional flavors like french vanilla, vanilla, butter pecan etc.

  447. [...] example below is the annual Ultimate Flavor tournament by Turkey Hill. Patterned after the March Madness tournament, the idea is to have a contest of ice [...]

  448. [...] example below is the annual Ultimate Flavor tournament by Turkey Hill. Patterned after the March Madness tournament, the idea is to have a contest of ice [...]

  449. [...] example below is the annual Ultimate Flavor tournament by Turkey Hill. Patterned after the March Madness tournament, the idea is to have a contest of ice [...]

  450. Sue Chehrenegar says:

    I find it interesting that Turkey Hill is a Philadelphia style ice cream, and that it is one of the few companies that sells black raspberry ice cream. Maybe word spread among the shops in Bucks County,PA, about the man who always asked for tht flavor.

    He liked to treat his family to a cold dessert in the summertime. He knew that at least one of his daugeters would need help with fininshing her cone, before its contents melted. He was all to happy to lend his assistance. That man was my father.

Leave a Reply

These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.