Ultimate Flavor Tournament (Round 4): The Frosty Four

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on March 25th, 2013


Share

Three weeks ago when the Ultimate Flavor Tournament kicked off, 32 flavors had high hopes of being the next champion. Since then, 28 flavors have been eliminated, leaving just four flavors – The Frosty Four – to face off for a spot in next week’s final round.

The four flavors that are still standing represent the best of their respective flavor conferences. The Frosty Four includes Tin Roof Sundae (Vanilla Conference), Light Recipe Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks (Chocolate Conference), Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake (Fruit Conference), and Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter (Limited Edition Conference).

Which two flavors will win this week to advance to the final round? That’s for your votes to decide in the polls on the right. As always, our very own “Einstein of Ice Cream,” Mr. Ernie Pinckney offers his thoughts below on this week’s match-ups.

TIN ROOF SUNDAE vs. LIGHT RECIPE CHOCOLATE NUTTY MOOSE TRACKS

ERNIE SAYS: I picked both of these flavors to win their match-ups last week, and they did exactly that. They were bold picks, too, because both flavors were facing off against some tough competition (Tin Roof Sundae beat Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, while the “Nutty Tracks” took down Rocky Road). Which of these two fighters will win this round? It’ll be close, but I’m going with Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks.

STUFF’D STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE vs. LIMITED EDITION CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER

ERNIE SAYS: Who would have predicted that an underdog like Stuff’d Strawberry Cheesecake would have made it this far in the tournament? (Not me. I picked Black Cherry to beat the Cheesecake last week.) Does Strawberry Cheesecake have the “Stuff’d” to beat a Limited Edition powerhouse like Chunky Peanut Butter? I don’t think so, but I’ve been wrong before!

 

Leave a Comment

146 Responses to “Ultimate Flavor Tournament (Round 4): The Frosty Four”

  1. donna pancoast says:

    light nutty moose tracks all the way!!!

  2. Denise Wilson says:

    you really can’t go wrong with PB!

  3. Nancy N says:

    I think the Chunky Peanut Butter will be the final winner. :-)

  4. Carol says:

    Couldn’t decide between the cheesecake and the peanut butter!!! MMMMMMMMmmmm. All Turkey Hill is good!

  5. Sheila says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter all the way!!

  6. Jennifer says:

    I love all four of these Ice Cream flavors. It was hard to choose which flavor to win.

  7. Stan says:

    Just a note to reinforce our love for your fat-free chocolate marshallow frozen yogurt!

  8. John D. Barbuto. Sr. says:

    Have not found LIMITED EDITION CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER so hard to give it a vote.

  9. In my expert taste-tester opinion, I definitely feel that Chunky Peanut Butter will be the ultimate winner !!

  10. Debbie F. says:

    I rooting for the Chunky Peanut Butter to take it all…

  11. Hillary says:

    Peanut butter ice cream is the Greatest!

  12. Jacqueline Seewald says:

    I seem to be voting for the less popular ice cream flavors (sigh) but I stand by my choices!

  13. Elsie Nicolette says:

    Peanut butter is a Turkey Hill winner in every box!

  14. Norma says:

    Trail blazer and nature lover loves Moose Tracks.

  15. CathyR says:

    Can’t wait to see who the winner is! :)

  16. Marion says:

    Light recipe. Please work on developing more of these. I find very few a my grocery store. I have never tried the cheesecake or the peanut butter, but would choose the PB.

  17. marion says:

    Yummy match-ups!

  18. Ray Hand says:

    As always….Add some walnuts to any one of these recipes and you have my vote. All your flavors a GRRRREAT!

  19. please dont take rum raisin off it is the best flavor my husband eats that a lot

  20. Sara Wise says:

    The choices are getting harder and harder!

  21. Karen says:

    I’d love to know if people have actually tasted all these flavors or it they go on description only.

  22. Ralph says:

    Tell the grocery store to get a bigger variety of TURKEY HILL! I want to try them all.

  23. Jean Sagarese says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter is my choice

  24. Gloria says:

    I’d like to know how Tin Roof Sundae, my favorite, got its name. It definitely is a winning set of flavors in one.

  25. Stephanie H. says:

    Tin Roof and Chunky Peanut Butter!!

  26. jconley says:

    And the vote goes on……….

  27. Lou says:

    I cannot believe my Black Cherry did not make the final.

  28. IceCreamFiend says:

    PEANUT BUTTER ALL THE WAY!!

  29. Gail says:

    Love, Love, ice cream!

  30. Gail says:

    Turkey Hill all the way!

  31. norman says:

    this was one of the hardest decisions to make because there all good haven’t had a flavor that I haven’t liked yet keep up the good work

  32. Marion says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter all the way!

  33. Clarence says:

    where is licorice

  34. Yvonne Learn says:

    Well, neither of my favs made it this time…

  35. jan says:

    None of my favs made it..where are the “no nuts” fans

  36. sue says:

    it’s down to the wire!! peanut butter

  37. Jim in SOMD says:

    I chose Tin Roof Sundae but I think Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter will not only get to the finals, but win outright. Now if I could only visualize the winning lotto numbers, I culd retire with a frezzer full of all flavors and have weekly tournaments for the neighbors to pick the winners by judging taste in real-time. Wouldn’t that be awesome! Early rounds would have two flavors face-off every day until down to a managable 32 flavors, then the real Sweet 16 and so forth.

  38. CS Wright says:

    Haven’t tried the Chunky Peanut Butter yet, but I’m betting on that one to win it all. There’s just something about peanut butter in any form, that is a crowd pleaser. Hey Turkey Hill, how about a peanut butter pie flavour with bits of chocolate cookie crust….

  39. Mary says:

    I figure I can always make Tin Roof Sundae for myself–so I picked Moose Tracks.
    Whenever I can’t decide which ice cream cone I want–I always pick peanut butter.
    Those are my reasons and I’m stickin’ to ‘em!

  40. Alexa says:

    Moose Tracks vs Peanut Butter is going to be a difficult choice

  41. Ann King says:

    come on chunky peanut butter, you can do it!

  42. Sarah says:

    Tin Roof Sundae is always a favorite of mine but I think Chunky Peanut Butter will win it all.

  43. Donna says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter is great!!
    Hope you do the licorice.

  44. Mary says:

    Stawberry cheesecake sounds delicious!

  45. Robin Ames says:

    How can we already be down to four flavors??? It went by so fast!

  46. Lois Sidelnick says:

    chunky peanut butter willwin, only because butter pecan was not listed from the start. that is stil my fas.vorite. miss those nut

  47. Juliette says:

    OUCH! Can’t believe my strawberry doesn’t take it all!

  48. Justin O says:

    Tin Roof Sunday and Strawberry Cheesecake

  49. Amber S. says:

    Can’t wait to see what flavor wins! Looks like it may be Chunky Peanut Butter!

  50. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    I will go for the underdog and say that Stuff’d Strawberry Chhesecake will win. But according to most of the previous comments Chunky Peanut Butter will win hands down.

  51. CHRISTINE says:

    NONE OF MY FAVORITES MADE IT EITHER. BLACK CHERRY DIDN’T MAKE IT PLUS SO MANY OTHER FAVORITES OF MINE. OH WELL MAYBE NEXT YEAR.

  52. Susan J says:

    Very hard to choose – they are all delicious!

  53. leecarr says:

    4 flavors, 4 that I would live without, but
    I will vote for 2 and then one

  54. Cindi says:

    Prefer my peanut butter in chocolate ice cream, but the Chunky Peanut Butter is good too. Should turn out to be the winner.

  55. Lydia says:

    tin roof is it

  56. Andrea says:

    I agree that Chunky Peanut Butter will probably be the Ultimate Flavor.

  57. Randy says:

    I’m always rooting for the “underdog” …c’mon Strawberry Cheesecake!

  58. Paul Fiumara says:

    The underdog will make the final second three-pointer ; all the way with cheesecake.

  59. Ellen says:

    Tin Roof Sundae vs Chunky Peanut Butter, next week will be tough. I don’t know, I’ll have to flip a coin before the vote.

  60. Elaine says:

    stuffed strawberry and tin roof, what a dream come true

  61. LindaR says:

    It’s always hard for me to pick the “winner”….I love them all!
    So for me it’s a win-win situation!

  62. Judi in rural NY says:

    They are all winners!

  63. Bobby Kelly says:

    Leave peanut butter on bread with jelly – not in delicious Turkey Hill ice cream!

  64. Kim Kilonsky says:

    Please don’t let it be PB.I hatePB!

  65. Rose Marie Wilson says:

    Very disappointing! In my opinion, none of these flavors should be in the running, let alone the final four! It doesn’t get any better than Cookies and Cream, Southern Lemon Pie, Mint Chocolate Chip, Yankee Brownie, or several others that are EVER so much better than these four. Yuck to peanut butter anything. Ditto to coconut.

  66. E.Hummel says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter all the way!!!

  67. millie b says:

    chunky peanut butter is there yyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  68. Michael Eddy says:

    was able to buy some Chunky Peanut Butter last week at my locla Stop & Shop – delicious!! So needless to say – it just got my vote.

  69. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    None of the 4 really send me but I voted for ones I would take if that was my only choice of TH

  70. Mary Bowers says:

    it’s anyone’s guess at this point! but chunky peanut butter will most likely win!

  71. OKAY!! C.C.C.DOUGH IS OUT SO I’LL GO WITH MY NUMBER TWO CHOICE!
    MOOSE TRACK’S IT IS!!
    GO TRACK’S
    ED,EDD OR EDDIE

  72. Kathleen says:

    Go Tin Roof…this was my all-time favorite since I was a kid!

  73. Vicki Spokes says:

    Okay I voted, now time for my bowl of ice cream!

  74. maryann says:

    Go tin roof

  75. Heather Bruinsma says:

    Bummed that Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough didn’t win, but whatever wins, I’ll be happy because Turkey Hill ROCKS!!!

  76. Gail Johnson says:

    THUMBS UP for Chunky Peanut Butter & Turkey Hill Ice Cream

  77. Jennie says:

    I love the Chunky Peanut Butter cause it is chunky like me!

  78. Lila says:

    Peanut Butter is a world wide favorite and of course I love peanut butter anything. Really need to go get some.

  79. ges says:

    Light, Light, Light!!!

  80. Bobi says:

    Chunky peanut butter.

  81. Barb says:

    Chunky peanut butter all the way!!!!

  82. Judy says:

    Wow, I’ve really botched it this year-I’ve lost almost every round but one can’t really lose when you’re eating Turkey Hill, can they??

  83. gianna says:

    Never fails, I keep picking the one with the least votes!

  84. chris jenkins says:

    thank you very much for the coupons.i will use every one.sure have been enjoying doing this.

  85. marie grim says:

    gotta be strawberry cheesecake!

  86. Tina Ingham says:

    chunky peanut butter all the way! love that icecream

  87. Tina Ingham says:

    chunky peanut butter

  88. Tina Ingham says:

    chunky pb all the way

  89. Donna says:

    I have always liked peanut butter.

  90. alicelynne says:

    Long Live Chunky Peanut Butter!!

  91. Linda S. says:

    My absolute favorite is anything chocolate, & the Chocolate Nutty Moose Track flavor is REALLY a dark chocolate, but the problem is that it is a “light” flavor & my stomach cannot “take” “light” ice cream. I guess it is the sugar alcohols in the ice cream that reek havoc on my stomach. SO, in that case, I will have to go with the Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter ice cream as my second choice, but the one I would be voting for if it came right down to voting for one! Sorry, Moose Tracks!

  92. sarah oswald says:

    CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER TO WIN!!! YUMMMMMMMMY!!!!!

  93. Melanie C. says:

    Turkey Hill Ice Cream is the Best!

  94. Danielle says:

    I hope Chunky Peanut Butter wins it all! It’s truly a delicious, brilliant flavor that mixes something we all love – peanut butter – with an exotic twist – praline peanuts!

  95. Definately Peanut Butter!!!

  96. Beth Antram says:

    PB Baby!!

  97. Beth Antram says:

    PB Baby!!!

  98. B says:

    Tin Roof Sundae!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  99. RJayne says:

    How about a draw?? Put both in the same Turkey Hill container. The peanut butter fans will be happy and the stuff’d strawberry
    cheesecake fans will be thrilled. Wait, which flavor would be
    first in the container..Back to the voting.

  100. donna joyce says:

    Tin Roof Sundae All the Way! Yeah Baby :)

  101. Edith says:

    Tin Roof Sundae!! :-)

  102. Linda says:

    Stuffed strawberry..mmmm good!

  103. Jay says:

    Hands down, Chunky PD. Best I have ever had!

  104. Jay says:

    Hands down, Chunky PB. Best tasting flavor I have ever tasted!

  105. Harriet G. says:

    I voted even though my favorites are no longer in the race.

  106. MLS-Luvs-IceCream says:

    Tin Roof Sundae all the way!

  107. MaryLou says:

    any coupons?????

  108. Elaine says:

    i hope my favorite wins, it will always win with me no matter what, go strawberry

  109. Kathleen Walsh says:

    Go Chunky Peanut Butter! You can do it!

  110. Pop C says:

    Well I like cheesecake, but if I want cheesecake I’ll buy Pellman’s. When I want ice cream? It’s Turkey Hill. I’ll have to go with the Tin Roof Sundae.

  111. Bonnie Traher says:

    Moosetracks

  112. Laurie Vonhagel says:

    Peanut Butter!!

  113. Christy says:

    I’m just glad that all 4 in the finals are ones I like, but Chocolate Nutty Moose Tracks FTW!

  114. ARP64 says:

    I picked Chunky Peanut Butter to be the winner. Don’t let me down fellow Turkey Hill Ice Cream lovers.

  115. Lori says:

    Wow, such different flavors… I guess I am old fashioned and none of my favs made it in! All Turkey Hill ice cream is good so all winners! I still vote for Chocolate Marshmallow!

  116. Crystal says:

    I don’t understand why the Chunky Peanut Butter is a limited edition. It is my favorite!!! A MUST try!!!

  117. Pam says:

    Just like my favorite sports teams, the ones I root for rarely seem to win. But I still love sports. My favorite flavors didn’t win, but I still love ice cream.

  118. Elizabeth says:

    Wouldn’t it be neat if the second two could be combined to make: STUFF’D STRAWBERRY CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER CHEESECAKE?!?!
    It would be the ultimate peanut butter and jelly mix:)I think I’ll buy both and try it:)

  119. Emilia says:

    Seems like peanut butter is always a favorite…not mine though! It’s OK as long as you keep making the ones I love!

  120. Gail Watson says:

    I have always loved Tin Roof Sundae and I hope it wins! When it comes to peanut butter I just don’t like it in my ice cream but I do love cheesecake in my ice cream :)

  121. Danielle Connor says:

    Turkey Hill is my fav!! I just moved back to Illinois from West Virginia and can’t find this brand as easy. My favorite flavor was the limited edition Pittsburgh Steelers flavor but in this case I’m going Limited Edition Chunky Peanut Butter! Go Turkey Hill!!

  122. Alicia Knab says:

    Can’t Wait!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  123. Ann says:

    I’m rooting for Chunky Peanut butter..Love Turkey Hill Ice Cream!!

  124. Ann says:

    Can’t wait to see who wins!!

  125. Nicole C says:

    Strawberry cheesecake vs. PB?!?! so hard to decide! I love the cheesecake chunks but the peanut butter is so addicting!

  126. Nicole C says:

    So exciting! can’t wait to see the winner!

  127. Sarah S. says:

    I’m dying to try the Stuffed Strawberry Cheesecake! Maybe I’ll win, then I’ll be eating it, plus lots of other yummy ice cream!

  128. Sarah S. says:

    I have eaten your chunky peanut butter ice cream and it is great but I got to be in the mood for the peanut butter.
    Thanks for the chance to win!

  129. Dee says:

    With sooo much protein in the peanut butter you get dessert and the main course in one! So I say go chunky peanut butter, win, win, win!

  130. Ashli Z says:

    Our triplets LOVE the Chunky Peanut Butter!

  131. Ashli Z says:

    Our triplets LOVE the Peanut Butter!

  132. WELL AS WE ALL KNOW ALL YOUR YOUR ICE CREAM FLAVOR’S ARE SO GOOD IT’S HARD TO CHOOSE WHEN STANDING IN FRONT OF THE DISPLAY CASE, BUT BAD LUCK HAS HIT ME THAT I’AM ALLERGIC TO COCONUT SO I CAN’T TRY YOUR TIN ROOF SUNDAE SO MY VOTE GOES WITH THE CHUNKY P.B. WHICH IS VERY GOOD MAY I ADD. BUT MAYBE IT SHOULD BE A TIE BECAUSE THE REAL WINNER’S ARE YOUR LOYAL ICE CREAM EATER’S THAT GET TO TRY EVERY NEW AND PRESENT FLAVOR’S.
    THAT’S IT WERE THE WINNER’S NOT JUST ONE OF YOUR GREAT ICE CREAM FLAVOR’S?
    COME EVERYONE VOTE FOR US(THE ICE CREAM EATER’S OF AMERICA) WE WIN! WIN WIN!! WE WIN!!!
    DOWNTOWN (EDDIE) BROWN–VOTE NOW FOR US>>THE E.O.A. VOTE VOTE VOTE!!!

  133. Lance Kolsky says:

    Tin Roof Sundae, a party for your taste buds.

  134. Lori Robinson says:

    peanut butter always gets my vote!

  135. Lori Robinson says:

    peanut better always bets my vote!

  136. Lori Robinson says:

    peanut better always gets my vote!

  137. ROBIN ENDLEY says:

    HMMMMMM….FUNNY HOW THE “TOUCHDOWN SUNDAE” INGREDIENTS SOUND LIKE THE ONE I SUBMITTED TO YOUR COMPANY ON JANUARY 12,2012-CASE #981066.

  138. bill wilton says:

    Tin Roof Sundae stirred in with some Natural Vanilla makes it even better than a 10! Try it

  139. bill wilton says:

    Tin Roof Sundae mixed in with some Natural Vanilla makes it even better than the 10 that if is! Give it a try!

  140. Janet says:

    It has to be Chuncky Peanut Butter!! There is do many other Turkey Hill flavors that goes so great with the peanut butter, and t&t is what I look for. I just love to mix my flavors, but with the peanut butter for me it will be two scoops to one scoop of another. Peanut butter ice cream is so satisfying. Love, love, love it!!

  141. Debbie P says:

    Love Tin Roof Sundae :)

  142. Scott Adams says:

    Went with Tin Roof Sundae, it’s a classic. Besides, I would rather melt peanut butter and put it on my ice cream. Sorry Chunky Peanut Butter!

  143. Kimbra says:

    I eat Strawberry Cheesecake every night. Lately my grocery store Darrenkamps hasn’t had it.. I would think I had kept it on the shelves with all that I bought.. They can’t say they didn’t have the turn over for that flavor that’s for sure. I haven’t tried the “stuffd” since I buy it in half gallons and it is the “light” recipe. Can’t imagine something so yummy is considered light.. Please bring it back to Darrenkamps in Mount Joy.. I might perish without my daily fix of TH Strawberry Cheesecake…

  144. Marjorie Bigham says:

    I only eat Turkey Hill…love them all but Tin Roof is my all time favorite!! Now I have to go very some….

  145. CONNIE KELSEY says:

    The ultimate flavor for me is the vanilla bean caramel sea salt!!! This flavor is just awesome!!!

  146. CONNIE KELSEY says:

    I used to buy breyers. Now for several years I ONLY BUY TURKEY HILL! VANILLA BEAN ALL NATURAL, CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER SWIRL. AND VANILLA BEAN CARAMEL SEA SALT!! I HAVE TO HAVE IT EVERYDAY.

Leave a Reply

 

These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.