Ultimate Flavor Tournament 2014: The Thrilling 32 (Which flavor do you think will win?)

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on March 3rd, 2014


Share

Patterned after college basketball’s annual “March Madness” playoffs, the Turkey Hill Ultimate Flavor Tournament is a six-week competition designed to determine which Turkey Hill Ice Cream flavor is the best. And here’s the best part: your votes will determine the winning flavor!

The action starts today, with the 32 flavors featured in the polls on the right (cast your vote now!). The flavor that wins its match-up after one week of voting will advance to the next round. The weekly match-ups will continue until just two flavors remain.

Past tournament champs include Vanilla Bean (2008), Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup (2009), Light Recipe Moose Tracks (2010), Orange Cream Swirl (2011), Touchdown Sundae (2012), and Chunky Peanut Butter (2013). Once a flavor wins the tournament it’s retired from future tournaments, which means each year promises a new winner.

And, yes, there will be prizes. Feel free to leave comments throughout the tournament because, when the tournament is over, we’ll choose one comment at random to receive a ONE YEAR SUPPLY of Turkey Hill Ice Cream!

To get the conversation started, take a look at this year’s Round One match-ups below and leave a comment with your prediction for which flavor will be the tournament winner!

THE VANILLA CONFERENCE

MATCH UP #1 – Butter Pecan vs. Tin Roof Sundae
MATCH UP #2 – Fudge Ripple vs. Cookies ‘n Cream
MATCH UP #3 – Peanut Butter Ripple vs. Touchdown Sundae
MATCH UP #4 – Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge vs. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE

MATCH UP #1 – Rocky Road vs. Double Dunker
MATCH UP #2 – Dutch Chocolate vs. Strawberries ‘n Cream
MATCH UP #3 – Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream vs. Chocolate Marshmallow
MATCH UP #4 – Phillies Graham Slam vs. Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

THE ALL NATURAL CONFERENCE

MATCH UP #1 – All Natural Salted Caramel vs. All Natural Coffee
MATCH UP #2 – All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip vs. All Natural Vanilla Bean
MATCH UP #3 – All Natural Chocolate vs. All Natural Cherry Vanilla
MATCH UP #4 – All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition) vs. All Natural Raspberry (Limited Edition)

THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE

MATCH UP #1 – Limited Edition Whoopie Pie vs. Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie
MATCH UP #2 – Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel vs. Limited Edition Egg Nog
MATCH UP #3 – Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate vs. Limited Edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates
MATCH UP #4 – Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie vs. Limited Edition Key Lime Pie

Leave a Comment

551 Responses to “Ultimate Flavor Tournament 2014: The Thrilling 32 (Which flavor do you think will win?)”

  1. Butter Pecan will be the winner.

  2. Wm Snyder says:

    Chocolate Marshmallow

  3. Patti B says:

    Touchdown Sundae all the way!!!!

  4. IceCreamFiend says:

    I’m going with Cookies ‘n Cream to win it all!!!

  5. Abby Murphy says:

    After voting in all these match-ups….I’ve decided that I must taste all the ones I voted for (if I haven’t already!) Yum!!

  6. Denise Wilson says:

    Dutch Chocolate has a chance

  7. Sharon says:

    Shouldn’t touchdown sundae be out of the competition? That would have been my pick, but it won already, right?

  8. MC says:

    I’ve done voting!

  9. Diane F says:

    Light recipe extreme cookies ‘n cream should win! My favorite isn’t even listed – Limited Edition Greek frozen yogurt Baklava. It is soooo good!

  10. donna pancoast says:

    salted carmel all the way!!!

  11. Lori says:

    If touchdown sundae, which is a favorite of mine, won in 2012 and is retired why is it in the tournament, vanilla conference matchup # 3

  12. Robin Ames says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate. Or Limited Edition Whoopie Pie. Or Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge. Or Chocolate Marshmallow. Oh –wait a minute. This is my shopping list. Sorry.

  13. Lori says:

    Should have had Colombian coffee

  14. Shelley says:

    I am predicting a victory by All Natural Chocolate

  15. chris says:

    Tin Roof Sundae!!!

  16. Sharon says:

    Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie

  17. Lois says:

    Three points for Butter Pecan!

  18. Andy says:

    I love the AlL Natural Salted Caramel so much, that it should dominate the tournament to be the final winner…so I predict.

  19. joe barone says:

    My all time favorite is Coconut Cream Pie, I look forward to every Feb when it is scheduled, I wish every month was Feb…….

  20. Joan says:

    Of all the Turkey Hill ice cream I just voted for, I still love
    Butter Pecan the most, and think that should win the best ice cream. Thanks for asking.

  21. Myra Doloence says:

    I was having lunch with my elderly Aunt at a retirement facility and was served the best chocolate ice cream every. Found out it was Turkey Hill Dutch Chocolate!! Have been buying and devouring it ever since. I LOVE Chocolate and am a good judge of good chocolate.
    Now, my 19 years old grandson has gone bonkers over the Key Lime Pie – sorry it is limited. I am trying to buy up and put in my freezer as much of this ice cream as I can find.

  22. Bill D says:

    I will always love Graham slam from Day 1 it came out

  23. Donna says:

    My family thinks the ALL Natural Vanilla Bean and AlL Natural Salted Caramel will be the big winners…so delicious and with such few ingredients..yum

  24. Roman says:

    Chocolate, chocolate ..Dutch Chocolate, Gertrude Chocolate Box–they are my favorite flavors. GO CHOCOLATE!

  25. sue hulme says:

    Looks like there are flavors I have yet to try. but gosh to pick just one favorite is hard. I must say that the choc marshmellow and peanut butter ripple are hard to resist with a spoon digging up the mounds in the ice cream!

  26. Heidi says:

    Key Lime Pie. YUM!!

  27. Shelley Bordo-Bracken says:

    I am still waiting for the limited edition of Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates to arrive at our Giant Store in Aldan, PA. Please hurry. By the way, my family only buys Turkey Hill. We love it anytime of the year!

  28. Rita Graef says:

    My family eats so much ice cream that we have cleared out the side-by-side kitchen freeze and dedicated it JUST for ice cream…as I voted on flavors in the poll, I realize that we have not only tasted most of the flavors listed, but have repurchased many of our “favorites”. (In a family of five, one can have at least 5 favorites, right?) Turkey Hill is our go-to brand, and our all-around current favorite (judging by the TWO almost empty cartons in the freezer) is All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip. Thanks for making great ice cream!!

  29. Elaine Garfield says:

    coconut cream pie is my favorite

  30. J Andress says:

    Coffee is for drinking. Caramel is for eating!

  31. Elsie Nicolette says:

    I’m going with All Natural Salted Caramel. Let the tasting begin!

  32. Sally says:

    All Natural Vanilla Bean!

  33. kim says:

    Looking forward to another year of voting.

  34. Ida Beek says:

    I think Salted Caramel will win. However, there are so many delicious flavors it’s going to be a nail biting finish. To ease the stress I’m going to give each one a try…

  35. Phyllis says:

    Gertrude hawks box of chocolates needs to be more available. It’s a WINNER!

  36. Valerie Behlmer says:

    I love the way Turkey Hill has these different programs about their ice cream products. It is interesting and fun. Thanks so much. I think Cookies and Cream should win. My favorite.

  37. Linda T says:

    So many choices…so little time.

  38. Michelle Stavrou says:

    All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip! Absolute perfection.

  39. judith says:

    Actually the combo of butter pecan and chocolate would be delicious!!!

  40. LindaR says:

    Always loved butter pecan, hope it wins

  41. Dick Bradick says:

    Cherry Vanilla is the only one!

  42. Paula says:

    All Natural Salted Caramel. mmmmmmmmm

  43. Pamela says:

    All Natural Coffee

  44. Cath T says:

    It would be a big help to me if you put a description of each ice cream in the poll. I had to google a few of them because, as cute as the names are, they don’t really describe the flavors in the ice cream. Maybe it would help promote ice cream sales, too.

  45. Eric From says:

    Gotta be the whoopee pie…..

  46. Geri says:

    I think Chocolate Marshmallow will win!

  47. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    I agree with Cath. T on a small description of each candidate. I will keep my vote secret so not to push my opinions

  48. Dennis says:

    Love the All Natural raspberry

  49. Lou B says:

    All Natural Vanilla Bean!

  50. Yvonne Learn says:

    Have to vote for all-natural coffee!

  51. Patricia A. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is my all-time favorite!

  52. Jim in SOMD says:

    In the middle of a snow storm right now. Cleared the driveway and came into work. That being said, here we have the tough task of deciding who will take this year’s crown as top flavor.
    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    Tin Roof Sundae beats Butter Pecan
    Fudge Ripple beats Cookies ‘n Cream
    Touchdown Sundae beatsP eanut Butter Ripple
    Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge beats Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    and Tin Roof Sundae wins the conference.
    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    Double Dunker beats Rocky Road
    Dutch Chocolate beats Strawberries ‘n Cream
    Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream beats Chocolate Marshmallow
    Phillies Graham Slam beats Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    and Dutch Chocolate wins the conference.
    THE ALL NATURAL CONFERENCE
    All Natural Salted Caramel beats All Natural Coffee
    All Natural Vanilla Bean beats All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip
    All Natural Chocolate beats All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition) beats All Natural Raspberry (Limited Edition)
    and All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition) wins the conference.
    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie beats Limited Edition Whoopie Pie
    Limited Edition Egg Nog beats Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel
    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate beats Limited Edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates
    Limited Edition Key Lime Pie beats Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie
    and Limited Edition Egg Nog wins the conference.
    Dutch Chocolate upsets Tin Roof Sundae
    All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition) beats Limited Edition Egg Nog
    and then All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition) wins the whole thing.

  53. Nancy says:

    Tin Roof Sundae rocks !

  54. Pam says:

    I haven’t been able to try all of those flavors. Our local stores don’t stock them all. And then, of the ones I have tried, you seem to match up the ones I like the best. That forces me to pick between favorites. But, it is still fun to participate in the voting.

  55. Anne says:

    I believe the winner will be Peanut Butter Ripple!

  56. millie says:

    I love anything chocolate then coffee but still like pumpkin pie still have some hidden freezer

  57. grams says:

    have to go with yankees pinstripe brownie blast but love coconut and if I had been able to find it in a store near me, probably would have gone with that.

  58. gianna says:

    I’m a bit confused ;p? Touchdown Sundae was the 2012 champ…then why is it a contender in the vanilla conference under match up #3? Shouldn’t it have been retired?

  59. Alyssa says:

    I will always love cookies n cream!

  60. Norma says:

    March Madness it is. Just march right to your freezer. Any Turkey Hill is a winner.

  61. ANDY PALOTI says:

    Butter Pecan
    Cookies ‘n Cream
    Peanut Butter Ripple
    Coconut Almond Fudge
    Rocky Road
    Strawberries ‘n Cream
    Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream
    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast
    Natural Cherry Vanilla
    Natural Mint Chocolate Chip

  62. gianna says:

    I’m hoping that Natural Chocolate wins this year! :)

  63. Ben Patrick says:

    All Turkey Hill Flavours are delicious.

  64. raymond b says:

    CHERRY VANILLA and EGG NOG, tops in my book !

  65. sue says:

    always love the contest–gives me a great excuse to buy a half gallon of each and every entrant so i can make the correct pick!

  66. Isabel Etkind says:

    My choices in the All Natural category are as follows(not necessarily in this order but that is how they are listed in the poll):(1)Salted Caramel (2)Mint Chip (3)Chocolate and my personal favorite Raspberry. There are not enough flavor choices in the All Natural line which is restrictive to the allergic population and others that can not handle additives. The All Natural Raspberry should be part of the Regular Flavors. There is NO BERRY FLAVORED ICE CREAM IN THE ALL NATURAL LINE(NO RASPBERRY, Strawberry etc). This seems to be a very significant loss!!

  67. Bill Reiter says:

    Gertrude Hawke Chocolates should be the winner. Please make it available again at Giant.

  68. maryann says:

    Butter Pecan

  69. Heather Anderson says:

    Touchdown Sundae is the best in the list. HOWEVER, the REAL winner should be Graham Slam. GS is the BEST ice cream flavor or ALL time!!!!

  70. Isabel Etkind says:

    Cherry Vanilla is a non-flavor as there is not enough Cherry or Vanilla for a distinctive flavor. This flavor could easily be scrapped for a YEAR ROUND ALL NATURAL RASPBERRY OR STRAWBERRY ICE CREAM!!! NOW THAT BREYERS IS POLLUTED WITH TARA GUM THERE IS A REAL AND GROWING MARKET!!!

  71. Aliza Solomon says:

    The salty and sweet combos are the best!!!

  72. Marlene grove says:

    I’ll go with the tin roof sundae for round one!

  73. Caitlin Jennings says:

    Cookies ‘n Cream, Peanut Butter Ripple, and Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge for the Vanilla Conference!
    For the Chocolate (and others) Conference: Chocolate Marshmallow!
    The All Natural Conference: Salted Caramel!
    The Limited Edition Conference: Pumpkin Pie, Egg Nog, Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates (I refuse to choose between coconut cream pie and key lime, I haven’t had the chance to try either, and they both sound wonderful!)

    But to be completely honest, my absolute favorite so far (WHICH I HAVE SEARCHED EVERYWHERE FOR AND CANNOT FIND ANYMORE) is the Limited Edition Greek Baklava<3 That stuff is perfection! The only thing that may match it is the new Limited Edition Sweet Potato Pecan Pie coming out soon ;) I CAN'T WAIT TO TRY THAT.<3

  74. Karen Smith says:

    I love tin roof sundae, but key lime pie and salted caramel sound yummy too!

  75. Ken says:

    Butter Pecan will definitely be the winner this year

  76. Kathy P says:

    So many great ice cream flavors and so little time! Love them all!

  77. Christy says:

    Almost all your flavors are soo delicious!! It is very difficult to choose on some of the pairings like Whoopie Pie (one of my all time favorites) and the one i just tried for the first time in November, Pumpkin Pie (absolutely awesome flavor)
    For the times each of these was available, i was at the store every week (and more often) looking for either or both of them.

    Extreme cookies and cream is a family favorite whenever the store has it.
    Keep up the good flavors!!

  78. Aria H. says:

    I want Phillie’s Graham Slam to win! I love it!

  79. Bonnie says:

    Pumpkin pie is THE BEST!!!! Don’t knock till you try it it’s DELISH!!!!!

  80. Gingo says:

    Glad to see Limited Edition, Deep Dark Chocolate in the contest.
    We can’t wait to be able to purchase it again!

  81. James Todd says:

    Limited Edition Egg Nog all the way

  82. wendy lee klenetsky says:

    I’m a DEVOUT CHOCOHOLIC, ANY of Turkey Hill’s chocolate flavors are MY favorites!

  83. Donna says:

    okay——I vote for all natural raspberry MIXED with all natural chocolate. You can’t beat that!!!! Topped with a chocolate ganache and fresh raspberries!!!!!

  84. Lynn Dobriko says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough seems to be out front. I want Butter Pecan.

  85. Harvey says:

    More Chocolate!

  86. Donna says:

    Around here we don’t get the new flavors———occasionally one or two–but never the smorgrasbord of deliciousness! How can YOU JUST PICK ONE???

  87. Karen O'Neill says:

    Pumpkin Pie is my favorite in the Limited Edition. I also love the Natural Coffee! My goal is to try them all!

  88. John says:

    Butter Pecan!

  89. Rochelle Potak says:

    It’s hard to think about these great Turkey Hill flavors without running out to the supermarket to restock the freezer with a few new flavors!

  90. Jessica says:

    They all look yummy!

  91. Wendy Beaver says:

    Vanilla conference-predicted winners
    #1-Tin Roof Sundae
    #2-Cookies ‘n Cream
    #3-Peanut Butter Ripple
    #4-Chocolate Chip cookie Dough

    The Chocolate(and others conference)-predicted winners
    #1-Double Dunker
    #2-Dutch chocolate
    #3-Chocolate Marshmallow
    #4-Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

    The All Natural Conference-predicted winners
    #1-All Natural Salted Caramel
    #2-All Natural Vanilla Bean
    #3-All Natural Chocolate
    #4-All Natural Raspberry

    The Limited Edition Conference-predicted winners
    #1-Limited Edition Whoopie Pie
    #2-Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel
    #3-Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate
    #4-Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

  92. Kathy Rentschler says:

    ANYTHING Peanut Butter is a WINNER

  93. Brenda says:

    Too many to choose from to pick a winner!!

  94. Tin Roof Sundae is my all time favorite!!!!!

  95. I thought it was interesting that my most choices followed the majority.

  96. Tin Roof Sundae is my all time favorite. Second would be anything with peanut butter. Love Turkey Hill ice cream!!!!

  97. karen says:

    Pumpkin pie…seasonal…but a year round favorite for me.

  98. Wendy says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  99. Tom Piecuch says:

    All Turkey Hill Ice Cream Flavors are winners!

  100. Lila says:

    It’s hard to choose between some of them. I’ll just take one of each and keep on enjoying.

  101. Judy F. says:

    Oh my gosh, I haven’t eaten lunch yet and now it will have to involve TH All Natural Salted Caramel!

  102. Rick says:

    Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie gets my vote.

  103. Steve says:

    I have to go with limited edition coconut cream pie as the champion

  104. Judy says:

    Phillies Grand Slam—-it’s more than a home run!!

  105. Sue C says:

    Wish I had a store around here that carried ALL the different flavors of TH Ice cream,,,,as I’m seeing there are quite a few I haven’t had a chance to sample yet! But I still voted for the ones that SOUNDED like the one I’d like the best! Turkey Hill has the best flavors!

  106. kim says:

    Snyders chocolate covered pretzel ice cream wins hands down

  107. Nancy S says:

    Black Raspberry is my favorite Turkey Hill flavor, so I am voting for the All Natural Raspberry – which I did NOT know was available – and will be looking for that on my next trip to the store! :-) Please keep those All Natural flavors coming and I will keep buying – appreciate options that don’t have a lot of unnecessary ingredients…

  108. Donna Hampton says:

    I love every single one but have to go with the salted caramel.

  109. Ann says:

    Wow! What a line up this year. Some of these flavors sound good but are not available in my area.

  110. Josh says:

    Butter pecan or whoopsie pie allllll thaaaa wayyyy

  111. Cheri Magistro says:

    By voting, just realized you have light coconut almond ice cream. Can’t wait to try it!

  112. Michele T. says:

    While I LOVE Rocky Road, I cannot keep enough Banana Split in the freezer for my husband – must buy them 2 at a time or I’ll be ice cream shopping more than once a week.

  113. Anita says:

    My choice as of today is influenced by this nasty NE winter and probably won’t be a winner but I certainly look forward to both the season it represents and the ice cream….Strawberries ‘n Cream

  114. lisat says:

    Light Recipe Moose Tracks! Awesome!

  115. Angela says:

    All Natural Vanilla Bean? :)

  116. rose irizarry says:

    double dunker is a big favorite in my house :)

  117. Diane G says:

    They’re all winners. My favorites Fudge Ripple And Cookies ‘n Cream

  118. Tami Tipton-Fletcher says:

    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel – THE BEST EVAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!

  119. Barbara Hudock says:

    The classic rocky Road! Turkey Hill’s the best of any brand!

  120. tina m says:

    I think that chocolate marshmallow will be one of the flavors that is a favorite.

  121. Laura says:

    I feel like, after reading some of these comments, I seriously need to try salted caramel! The All Natural is my favorite line from Turkey Hill, but I really enjoy some of the limited edition flavors (coconut cream pie, and egg nog) as well!

  122. Alaina says:

    Peanut butter ripple!…can’t go wrong with peanut butter!!!

  123. Cheryl says:

    Sorry – the best flavor of all isn’t even in the tournament. Southern Lemon Pie is the greatest!!!

  124. alex says:

    I love all flavors of your ice cream

  125. John Caporale says:

    It just astonishes me the disrespect you show for the absolute best ice cream flavor on earth, Box of Chocolates. It just amazes me. In the stores they say, “we don’t put it out because there’s no space for it but every time we do it sells out in minutes.” I just don’t get it. And you don’t even include it in this “tournament”. Someone must be getting kickbacks from Coconut Cream. A product I’m sure you sell 3 or 4 packages of a day…

  126. Randall Gabrielan says:

    It looks like the squid flavor did not make the tournament. Maybe next year.

  127. by far, key lime pie is the winner, if feel like I am at the beach with that one. I would like to try the pumpking pie,but have not seen it in our grocery store. we have very limited choices at food lion.

  128. Charlie kalinowski says:

    Peanut butter ripple

  129. Liz Payne says:

    I am a real fan of Turkey Hill Ice Cream and it is very seldom I would even consider buying an other brand. However, I recently purchased your Key Lime Pie flavor and was left to eat it by myself. My entire family took a sample and rejected it completely. I was left with most of the container. I really liked the key lime flavor but found the graham flavor balls to taste like paper. I finally ate the ice cream part and spit out all of the graham balls. Needless to say my family made fun of me. Just needed to let you know .Liz Payne wppayne@comcast.net

  130. Debbie says:

    What about Bronx Bomber? It’s my fave:) My second fave is Double Dunker, so I’m glad it’s in the running!

  131. Joe Podolak says:

    My wife is upset when I go shopping and come home and say there is no turkey hill key lime pie ice cream at our store.

  132. Lori Kelley says:

    The All Natural Salted Caramel will win this competition hands down. My husband and I are ice cream connoisseurs. These two flavors together are just the right mix. Kudos to Turkey Hill for getting this one right….exceptionally right! Try it.

  133. John Caporale says:

    If anyone doesn’t vote for Box of Chocolates, they haven’t had it! (Yes, I found it in the contest. It didn’t come up in the list I saw at first.)

  134. Carol Martin says:

    CHOCOLATE ICE CREAM! I’ve just realized after voting that there are even more chocolate flavors in Turkey Hill Ice Cream than I thought there were. I’m going to the store right now…I’ll be back!

  135. Jennifer Barr says:

    butter almond

  136. Elaine says:

    My personal favorites are strawberries and cream and Neapolitan (3 flavors for the price of one) and light cookies and cream. I would really like to see on of them win. I also love your ice cream sandwiches but, unfortunately, the markets I shop at do not carry them.

  137. Eric says:

    All Natural Mint Choc Chip. There is no other choice.

  138. cheryl cirko says:

    there are a lot of flavors i have not seen in my local store! I will have to travel to other places to check out the stock. PS: phillies grand slam is the best, just sayin’ :)

  139. SS says:

    Wow, only 4 or 5 of my choices were leading. I must like different flavors than most people.

  140. Nancy N. says:

    I love the Egg Nog and Natural Coffee. This is always a fun time to see how my favorite flavors make out. :-)

  141. Christopher says:

    If Fudge Ripple survives Cookies & Cream, it will go all the way and be the winner!

  142. Kate says:

    I think Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough deserves to win!

  143. Cheryl says:

    Chocolate chip cookie dough!

  144. Stephanie O says:

    It’s currently 22 degrees outside, yet I’m happily debating the merits of chill-inducing ice cream — Eek! As crazy as it sounds, I could go for a bowl of Egg Nog or Dutch Chocolate right now with a cup of coffee!

  145. Christina says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip- a classic that everyone loves.

  146. Cindy Merrill says:

    If I could create an Ice cream flavor, it would be Maple Walnut with pecans, I’d call it Maple North and South.

  147. Rochelle says:

    Apparently I should NEVER become a food critic. I think I guessed wrong in just about every vote/ poll. So disappointed! (By the way, I wish our local Wal-Mart (basically our closest large grocery store) carried Turkey Hill!

  148. Sarah says:

    No fair pitting Limited Edition Coconut cream Pie against Key Lime Pie!

  149. Bonnie moyer says:

    How can I choose !!!

  150. Sarah says:

    Not sure why Strawberries ‘n Cream was in the chocolate category although it would taste good with some hot fudge on top.

  151. Richard says:

    Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream should take the tournament

  152. Eva Mack says:

    I like any ice cream with nyt added!

  153. I’m predicting Dutch Chocolate to have a strong showing!!

  154. Eva Mack says:

    Sorry …I like any ice cream with nuts added!!!

  155. amie b says:

    They’re all winners to me!!! I love Turkey Hill!!!!

  156. Valerie C. says:

    I love Egg Nog, Cherry Vanilla and Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates.

  157. Linda C. says:

    I think Vanilla bean or Dutch chocolate will win but…my favs are Pumpkin Pie and Light Coconut almond Fudge.

  158. jim michel says:

    where is GERMEN CHOCLATE CAKE IT WAS THE BEST ICE CREAM I EVER HAD

  159. Bonnie moyer says:

    Pumpkin pie limited edition !

  160. Terri Burns says:

    Wow! How do I choose with so many fantastic flavors? I guess to start it off I’ll go with Whoopie Pie!

  161. John says:

    Not only do I have a love of Turkey Hill Cookies and Cream but my cat, Madeline is a fanatic. Maddie loves the cream part and understands that she is not allowed to have the cookie part. Chocolate is bad for cats. She loves the Cookies and Cream so much that she knows the words and gets upset when we buy the all chocolate extreme version.

  162. Melody Bain says:

    Chocolate is always a fan fave….I predict a chocolate one will come out on top in the end.

  163. Amy P says:

    dutch chocolate!

  164. DAVE ANSPACH says:

    The vanilla conference looks tough all the way this year. Look for choclate chip cookie dough to pull off a tight win!!

  165. JT says:

    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast!!

  166. Jack Sofield says:

    Since Turkey Hill ice cream is one of the basic food groups, I don’t understand why my local grocer doesn’t carry the 15 gallon containers.

  167. My favorite has always been the All Natural Coffee Ice Cream but I love anything with peanut butter and the Phillies Graham Slam was awesome.

  168. Andrew Loiacono says:

    Call me old fashioned but for me there is nothing like NATURAL ingredients in ice cream. While I love all the Natural Flavors that you make, coffee is my favorite. I definitely would like to see you add some more flavors to the Natural varieties that you produce. Perhaps chocolate marshmallow or vanilla fudge. Turkey Hill is the only Ice Cream that I buy. Thanks for a great product.

  169. Cathy says:

    Slated Caramel is such a popular taste right now; I may have to go with that as the WINNER!

  170. Goldie Stears says:

    I am a Chocoholic!! Would love to try Gertrude Hawk’s Box of Chocolates before picking a winner. Will have to go with the Deep Dark Chocolate for the win! :)

  171. Mike says:

    Phillies Graham Slam eats up the competition!

  172. SueEllen H. says:

    Tin Roof Sundae is my all time favorite, but I’m loving the Gertrude Hawk’s Box of Chocolates right now!

  173. Rachel E. says:

    Well, after choosing all those ice cream flavors, I think I’m going to go get some. Yum!

  174. SaraJo says:

    Yeehaw for Salty Caramel!!!!

  175. So many flavors, so little time. It’s too sweet to fight about.

  176. Teresa Motz says:

    Can’t wait until summer! Luckily I don’t have to wait to enjoy Turkey Hill – it’s perfect no matter what the weather brings :-)

  177. Nita says:

    Nobody has Chocolate Marshmallow like Turkey Hill. I tried other brands in the past, but I came home to TH each time and am here to stay!

  178. Phil says:

    Coconut creme pie and key lime pie meeting in the first round!! Who’s responsible for the seeding in this tournament? These should be #1 seeds in separate conferences.

  179. Amber S. says:

    I’m rooting for Cookies n’ Cream again this year!

  180. Kim Kilonsky says:

    Hoping for Salty Caramel but I think it will be between Cookies N Cream and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

  181. Jeffrey says:

    You should have an all double churn conference.

  182. Robert Monroe, Jr. says:

    I love ice cream but I REALLY love Turkey Hill Ice Cream! I decided to get healthier this year so I cut out meat from my diet and started regular exercise. So far, I’ve managed to lose about 30 pounds and the only indulgence I allow myself is Turkey Hill ice cream. I figured that it didn’t make any sense to deny myself one of my greatest pleasures in life so I still have the occasional small bowl of your frozen creamy goodness. Afterall, life without Whoopie Pie ice cream is a life partially lived!

  183. yankees pinstripe brownie blast! Love it, even though i’m a phillies phan!

  184. Kris H. says:

    Love me some classic Butter Pecan! Sometimes less is more, you know?

  185. Donna Del says:

    Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates is a delightful flavor. It was finally available in my area and I made sure that I purchased some. It was well worth the wait.

  186. Mary says:

    The flavors are great, but I would like to see something like banana fudge ripple or dark chocolate cherry.

  187. Janine says:

    All of the flavors are fantastic! They never last long in our house.

  188. Lori Lopez says:

    I would have to say Dutch Chocolate, there’s nothing better than a awesome tasting chocolate ice cream!! Thank you!!

  189. vince smith says:

    March Ice Cream madness! Now THIS is a tourney I’m going to enjoy getting the ‘scoop’ on! ;)

  190. Molly says:

    Go Deep Dark Chocolate! Whoooo!

  191. Julie Hein says:

    Cookie Dough all the way!!

  192. Danielle says:

    Oh all natural coffee yummy yummy for sure!!!

  193. Shannon Fissel says:

    Hands down turkey hill chocolate marshmallow is the best ice cream ever! Food of the gods, bless whoever invented it!

  194. Marty says:

    Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is by far the best, so this tournament is for 2nd place!!!

  195. Katie says:

    Pa dutch pretzel and Coconut Cream Pie are two of my favorites. I wish they were not limited addition!! The salted caramel sounds so good and I have never seen it anywhere I shop in Pittsburgh. I can’t wait to find it

  196. Donna says:

    No losers with Turkey Hill Ice Cream!

  197. Jane says:

    I am a purist, and love my Turkey Hill ice cream with nothing added (like cookies, or candy, or pretzels). My favorite is Fudge Ripple followed closely by Raspberry.

  198. Valerie Rajnic says:

    I am obsessed with the Natural Chocolate!! I’m a chocolate addict and it’s the best chocolate ice cream I’ve ever had!

  199. pat bentzel says:

    I think they are all winners, I hate to pick my favorite as I love to eat them all, Ice cream is the best

  200. Marion says:

    Now I want some Key Lime Ice cream.

  201. Jaimie says:

    My girls vote for Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

  202. pina says:

    Love the salted caramel. It melts and is even better.

  203. Michael Brand says:

    I predict that the Limited Edition Whoopie Pie will win the tournament! What better flavor to represent Lancaster Co., PA?!?

  204. Arlene Bolte says:

    The winner will have to be a chocolate one! In your notes before the voting, you said the past winners were retired. Why then is Touchdown Sundae in the running again? It won in 2012. Also the Vanilla Bean (which won in 2008) is in again, but maybe you consider it a different flavor with the “Natural” in front of it!!
    I still predict a chocolate flavor to be overall winner.

  205. Cynthia Weber says:

    I love Egg nog and Pumpkin pie ice creams!

  206. Ron Carlucci says:

    Key Lime Pie! Enough said. Going out to buy another half gallon. Be back soon.

  207. JUDY says:

    And may the best flavor win. Actually, all your flavors are already winners!! Yummy!!!

  208. Linda says:

    No losers in the entire contest!

  209. laurie says:

    Come on Whoopie Pie, you can win!!

  210. Nancy N. says:

    WOW!!! So many surprises so early in the competition!!! VERY EXCITING!!! -delish!!!

  211. Lorraine Myers says:

    ALL NATURAL BUTTER PECAN IS AWESOME!!!

  212. Lauren Sisco says:

    Phillies graham slam is amazing!

  213. Karen Mesler says:

    I love this contest! I just wish that all of the flavors were available in my area. I have never heard of some of them, except on this website.

  214. Karen Mesler says:

    I can’t read some of the letters!

  215. Nancy Young says:

    Please help make the Phillies Graham Slam a winner! The Phils will be playing soon and we need to support them – and eat more of this extraordinary ice cream! My personal favorite!

  216. rhonda bemis says:

    just recently i have found the coconut cream pie ice cream
    simply love it !!! should be around all the time.

  217. Mary Ann says:

    Ice Cream for a year! Ahhhhhh! Heaven! Love all the flavors but really enjoy the Eggnog Special Edition during the holidays. My favorite all year ice cream is the chocolate marshmallow! Yummmmmmm

  218. Bobi says:

    I just tried the Limited Edition Chocolate/Butter Almond All Natural and it was GREAT!

  219. Alan says:

    Waiting for a simple plain chocolate ice cream (or frozen yogurt) available in “Light”, Low-Fat, or Fat-Free variety….no Splenda, please.

  220. Kelly says:

    While I know that the normal chocolate or simple will win – I want something with peanut butter or the pretzel or salted caramel to win!

  221. erin says:

    Touchdown sundae is awesome!!

  222. Joe Sheve says:

    Best Limited Edition…Whoopie Pie! Wish it was year round!

  223. I believe its going to be the mint chocolate chip

  224. Kim says:

    Double Dunker is my weakness. Every time I need to go to the store, it comes home with me.

  225. joyce says:

    No matter which ones are chosen , they are all by far winners in my book and my household …. Turkey Hill Rules !!!

  226. Michelle says:

    All natural salted caramel sounds like a winner to me. Going to the supermarket now to try it out!

  227. Ter says:

    let’s go coconut almond fudge!!!!!

  228. cathy owens says:

    there are so many good flavors, it was really hard to choose. who doesn’t like ice cream, especially TURKEY HILL !

  229. Rebecca says:

    Peanut butter ripple – hands down!

  230. Traci says:

    Best contest ever!! Happy to add my votes :-)

  231. Diane says:

    Whoopie Pie or Chocolate Marshmallow!

  232. Karen Carew says:

    Turkey Hill Ice cream makes all this snow bearable!

  233. leecarr says:

    let the games begin and may the best tasting flavor win

  234. Chris says:

    Anything chocolate!!! Especially Deep Dark Chocolate!!! I gotta get that!

  235. Karen Carew says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream makes all this snow bearable!

  236. Jackie says:

    Tin Roof is my favorite, but would really like Maple Nut too

  237. Peg says:

    So hard to choose one over another. No such thing as a bad ice cream.

  238. Laurel Misko says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip is due for a win!!

  239. Rose says:

    There is nothing in the world like Turkey Hill ice cream for breakfast! My husband and I ate almost the entire container of Orange Creme Swirl one morning of when we didn’t have a freezer and placed the ice cream on the back porch when it was 28 degrees out. I am so glad the bears didn’t want to share.

  240. Barbara Kesterson says:

    Putting my money on Tin Roof

  241. Tyler Templar says:

    Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast all the way

  242. Cathy says:

    Gertrude Hawk box of chocolates is my new favorite!

  243. Debbie Heath says:

    Peanut butter ripple.

  244. Joan M Carr says:

    All Natural Salted Caramel

  245. Luis Ramos says:

    My favorite is anything mint flavored.

  246. Nicole says:

    Gertrude hawk box of chocolates!!!

  247. emma says:

    i’m rooting for double dunker- the best ice cream i ever put in my mouth!! yum!!!

  248. Amanda says:

    Whoopie pie is soo good!!

  249. Sandra says:

    Coffee (but it’s so hard to pick just one).

  250. Ron says:

    Let the games begin! I’m pulling for Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel. No matter which flavor finishes first, “we all win”!

  251. Becky Reiber says:

    Have to try that salted caramel!!!

  252. Jim S. says:

    Definitely Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup! A past winner which was only beat out by Vanilla Bean the first year of the tournament. Still haven’t found/tried Chunky Peanut Butter (last year’s winner). Sorry, let’s be fair, Touchdown Sundae is also a past winner and needs to be retired from the tournament.

  253. Stephen says:

    Coconut Cream Pie, THE BEST FLAVOR EVER !

  254. erica says:

    I have too many favorites to claim a favorite!! My husband loves the peanut butter ones and the kids drool over pumpkin pie!

  255. Cassandra Girouard says:

    If I had to pick just one it would be Chocolate Marshmallow

  256. Donald Cook says:

    I pick the Mint Chocolate Chip over the Vanilla. I think Turkey Hill’s is the best on the market for flavor and consisitency

  257. Ann Murphy says:

    Still live the orange swirl ice cream. It is so refreshing and reminds you of summer all year long!

  258. Katie says:

    I love chocolate chip cookie dough!!

  259. Vicki says:

    I would say hands down the winner will be the Light Extreme Cookies and Creme.This flavor is the best with chunks of cookies with the chocolate ice cream.THE BEST

  260. Jeff says:

    Great Tournament! Creative naming, it will be great to sample the winner!

  261. Yasuko says:

    I love Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  262. AJ White says:

    The all natural flavors is a great idea. Really appreciate the simple ingredients vs artificial “things”…The all natural mint choc chip is my pick with the limited ed. Key lime as a runner up. Two awesome flavors!

  263. Kristin says:

    I really love the chocolate peanut butter but almost any will do.It’s my way of relaxing with a bowl of ice cream. It always helps me relax and feel better. I suffer from anxiety and ice cream helps take the stress away. I’d love to win the contest because im not always able to afford to buy ice cream every month.

  264. elaine meglathery says:

    natural salted caramel is awesome and graham slam is a fave. but limited edition pumpkin pie is to die for!! I don’t even like pumpkin pie. the graham in this ice cream is so plentiful and so delicious. I am so sad it is gone until next year. oh no I hope it will be back next year….

  265. Mike Hagenberger says:

    They are all Winners, some on Sunday, others on Monday.
    You, Can’t just have one favorite flavor. It has to do with the mood, time of day or time of life…A Birthday, a wedding or just a snowey day in Va. Thanks Mike H

  266. Wanda Gawronski says:

    Peanut butter ripple!

  267. Amanda says:

    Turkey hill ice cream is so delicious!

  268. Marivic says:

    Double dunker for sure!!!

  269. David Van Pelt says:

    Double Dunker will win it!!

  270. Jennifer L says:

    Extreme cookies and cream. Turkey Hill is the best!

  271. Chet Knotts says:

    If we have to pick just one, it’s Double Dunker!

  272. Jeanne tomlinson says:

    Touch down sundae is who I think will win, but I would personally select the lumited edition of coconut cream pie

  273. debbie says:

    My favorites….Salted Caramel,Deep Dark Chocolate and Key Lime Pie

  274. Alicia says:

    I could barely choose a favorite in so many categories–they’re all crazy good…

  275. Dawn says:

    Double dunker all the way!

  276. Donna Straugh says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream flavors are all absolutely fantastic. Voting for my favorites is quite difficult to say the least. Thank you Turkey Hill for offering your fans the opportunity to vote as well as a chance to win ice cream for an entire year. To win would be totally heavenly.

  277. Lauren says:

    Salted caramel sounds so gourmet!

  278. Brenda Bailey says:

    Wow, some were extremely difficult while others were no-brainers. :-)
    Here are my picks:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – Tin Roof Sundae
    MATCH UP #2 – Fudge Ripple
    MATCH UP #3 – Touchdown Sundae
    MATCH UP #4 – Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – Double Dunker
    MATCH UP #2 – Dutch Chocolate
    MATCH UP #3 – Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream
    MATCH UP #4 – Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

    THE ALL NATURAL CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – All Natural Salted Caramel
    MATCH UP #2 – All Natural Vanilla Bean
    MATCH UP #3 – All Natural Chocolate
    MATCH UP #4 – All Natural Butter Almond (Limited Edition)

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – Limited Edition Whoopie Pie
    MATCH UP #2 – Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel
    MATCH UP #3 – Limited Edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates
    MATCH UP #4 – Limited Edition Key Lime Pie

  279. I love Ice Cream. Almost any flavor. But my favorite BY FAR – Turkey Hill Coffee Flavor – All Natural. Partly because it does not have additional ingredients in it – and partly because….when I was a little girl, my older uncle used to come to our home and visit from far away. Every time he did – after he would get off the bus – he would go to a local drug store and buy some fresh, HAND-PACKED Coffee Ice Cream for our family. It was the best I had ever tasted! It was a rare treat! The taste of the Turkey Hill brand of All Natural Coffee Ice Cream probably comes CLOSEST to that great coffee ice cream we had as kids. I love it – and buy it all the time, along with All Natural Chocolate Chip Mint flavor. Thanks for being (what I think is) the ONLY COMPANY left that makes TRULY all natural ice cream!

  280. Sonya Petro says:

    I love just about every ice cream – but my all time winners are mint chocolate chip and butter pecan by a landslide :)

  281. Wanda Conrad says:

    It is tough to pick a favorite ice cream flavor, when variety is the spice of life!

  282. Cathy S. says:

    Any Turkey Hill flavor is a favorite in our family. Mine is Butter Pecan, but with 12 grandchildren, we are sure to please someone no matter what flavor we have when they visit.

  283. Joan Epstein says:

    I love Turkey hill Ice Cream! It is a taste of home (I grew up in PA) available even now that I live in New England. I only regret hat I have never seen the Snyders of Hanover limited edition flavor. It would be a double dose of home!

  284. Heather Bruinsma says:

    Double Dunker all the way!!!

  285. Pat Brehme says:

    I’m NUTS about Butter Pecan. I think that’s a WINNER!!!!

  286. Erin says:

    Love Double Dunker!!

  287. Ellen says:

    I am so glad to see Whoopie Pie as one of the Limited Edition Conference Contenders!

  288. Jennifer Schwartz says:

    Touchdown Sundae for sure!!! WINNER!!!

  289. Ellen says:

    So many choices. I have a lot of favorites. Butter Pecan and Peanut Butter Ripple are just 2 of my favorites.

  290. Kim craft says:

    Like them all really. It’s hard to vote. Of course I’m craving some of these yummy flavors

  291. Nikki says:

    Key Lime Pie is the best!

  292. DeniseG says:

    Voted… some surprising results so far.

  293. Art J. says:

    My favorites are the No Sugar Added flavors especially Mint
    Chocolate Chip because even though I have Diabetes I can
    actually eat these ice creams without causing a blood sugar
    spike. Mint chocolate chip satisfies my cravings for both
    chocolate and chocolate mints.

    These flavors are in a league of their own as far as I am
    concerned. Unfortunately they are often hard to find at
    my local grocery stores.

  294. Vickie Conner says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice cream. It is hard to pick just one flavor but I will choose Peanut Butter Ripple as my go to flavor.

  295. barbara says:

    mmm tin roof sundae

  296. Lee Moyer says:

    Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates is simply the best flavor ice cream ever created. Ever!

  297. Deb Ragno says:

    Not many people must have tasted Double Dunker because if they had, they wouldn’t have voted for the competition. It is hands down the best ice cream I have tasted in a long time.

  298. MaryBeth Eisenhauer says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple has been my FAVORITE since I was a little girl.

  299. Nicole Toscano says:

    Double dunker all the way!!!

  300. Kaj3654 says:

    Double dunker ice cream!!!

  301. Barb says:

    They all are so good! It was hard to vote!!!

  302. Mina Park says:

    My favorite is the whoopie pie! I don’t see it often in my grocery store though :(

  303. Veronica V. says:

    Cookie Dough for the win!!!

  304. Kacey says:

    Chocolate marshmallow has been my fave for years.

  305. Marge Healy says:

    I just wish that more stores here in New England would carry more of the Turkey Hill flavors.
    Shop Rite always has the best selection but even they sometimes do not have new or limited Editions.They do however, almost always have Light Coconut Almond Fudge – a real winner!!

  306. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    I am hoping that the Limited Edition of Egg Nog wins.

  307. PennysMom says:

    Touchdown Sundae, but it’s supposed to be retired. So if you substitute something else in, please make it Baklava Greek Frozen Yogurt. And if not that, then All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip.

  308. Janice Corturillo says:

    I think Chocolate Marshmallow will be the winner of the whole tournament!

  309. Cindy says:

    Coconut cream pie! Oh yum! Now I’m going shopping!

  310. Claudia says:

    Dutch Chocolate. Many of those flavors aren’t available at our store.

  311. Mike Covey says:

    C’mon people…..the limited edition PUMPKIN PIE is by far the best turkey hill (scratch that—BEST ICE CREAM OF ANY BRAND) flavor of all time!!!!! Don’t let it go out in the first round to whoopsie pie.

  312. Jen says:

    My all time favorite – Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. Double Dunker is my second favorite. Yum!

  313. Casey Sullivan says:

    Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream all the way!

  314. Lauren R says:

    Really liked Whoopie Pie. Hope you bring it back. All the flavors are amazing.

  315. Amy says:

    All-time favorite is cookies-n-cream!!!! If we only have vanilla flavor in our freezer, we make our own!

  316. Roger says:

    I thought former champions were retired from the competition but I see the 2012 winner Touchdown Sundae in this year’s tourney. Wouldn’t be surprised to see it win again. It’s awesome, and so are the Eagles!

  317. Karen says:

    All I can say is YUM!!!!

  318. bapperoo says:

    Isn’t it unfair to force us to pick favorites? They are ALL great!

  319. Roseann Moss says:

    Limited Edition Key Lime Pie LOVE the pie and the ice cream MUST be better. I am searching every grocery store in my area to try Limited Edition Key Lime Pie Makes me drool to think about it.

  320. Beth Fegley says:

    They are ALL delicious! !!!

  321. Rob says:

    Deep dark chocolate to win!

  322. Amanda says:

    It will be Double Dunker this year.

  323. Kim says:

    I think my favorite is Chocolate Moosetracks… Mmmmmmmm!!!

  324. Maggie says:

    Box of Choclates!!! Yum!

  325. Melanie D says:

    Loved the Pumpkin Pie! Wish I could find the Deep Dark Chocolate and the Butter Brickle.

  326. Kim Durham says:

    Salted Caramel will win!

  327. Chris L says:

    Gotta say Chocolate should have it’s on group and not be tossed in with others!

  328. Carol O'Connell says:

    Dark chocolate is so popular now, I predict the winner will be the Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate. I would like to see some more combinations like coffee/chocolate, butter pecan/chocolate, raspberry/peach. So many to choose from.

  329. Pat from CT says:

    All the Turkey Hill ice cream flavors are great (we may turn into Vanilla Beans at my house!), but . . . my absolute two favorite flavors are Deep Dark Chocolate and Coconut Cream Pie. It’s a good thing that they’re both Limited Editions, or I’d be in trouble. I’ve never had such a rich, creamy dark chocolate ice cream, and it’s nearly impossible to find really good coconut ice cream. Too bad these flavors are’t available at the same time, because they would be awesome together!

  330. Heidi says:

    This is pure EVIL! Choose just one? Not possible! I bless and curse the day I found Turkey Hill ice cream. Far superior to any other I’d ever eaten. In fact, I’d go so far as to say I never had ice cream before Turkey Hill. I could eat a carton of Peanut Butter Fudge in 15 minutes flat.

    I think my doctor was surprised to draw my blood and find I have ice cream running through my veins instead. I just gave him a coupon and now he completely understands! :D

  331. Brian Morin says:

    So many tasty varieties of ice cream. I’ll eat all of them!

  332. NJ says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  333. Sondra says:

    Who can vote for the ultimate winner? Any given Turkey Hill flavor on any given day, is a winner in my book!

  334. Krysti says:

    Graham Slam!

  335. Michael Barnett says:

    I like the yogurts. The quality and the taste is the best.

  336. Kris says:

    Cookie dough for life!
    (Though that Key Lime Pie is pretty amazing, as was the Baklava one and the Southern Lemon Pie before.)

  337. Stewart says:

    My Final Four:
    Tin Roof Sundae
    Dutch Chocolate
    All Natural Salted Caramel
    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

  338. Capt. Jack says:

    Go Phillies Slam!!!

  339. ron savidge says:

    There is only one winner!!! Peanut Butter Ripple !!! By a mile.

  340. renee says:

    I’m sorry to see Bronx Bomber didn’t make it…thats my favorite. But I can’t leave the grocery store without All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip. My daughter can’t live without it. My husband and son love every one!!

  341. Terri says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream is the BEST!

  342. daisy l says:

    butter pecan will win all the way.

  343. wai l says:

    All Natural Salted Caramel all the way

  344. wai h.l. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple alll the way.

  345. Gary says:

    I’m going with a real dark horse – Chocolate Marshmallow.

  346. Mark & Tree says:

    Sorry to see our favorites (Mint Chocolate Chip and Butter Pecan) are not everyone’s favorites. We do see a trend for chocolate lovers though. Dutch Chocolate will be the winner.

    Mark & Tree from New Jerz’ee

  347. Vicki Spokes says:

    No matter which flavor officially wins Mint Chocolate Chip is our family favorite!!

  348. Sue says:

    Phillies Gran Slam to start the season off right! Without A-Rod the Yankees will have to bring in some young players.

  349. Kim Cowgar says:

    The Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel sounds just divine!

  350. L says:

    Nuts about nuts so it has to be Butter Pecan.

  351. Valerie says:

    Ahhh, the voting made me hungry : ) Wish Chocolate Peanut Butter wasn’t retired, but as long as the winner is chocolate . . . yums

  352. Jim says:

    All natural vanilla bean. Nothing but the finest.

  353. REGGIE MCGEE says:

    I love this contest—hope I win so I can taste all of the flavore.

  354. Of all the flavors that should win is the Phillies Graham Slam. Let’s Go Phillies! From a Phillies die hard family.

  355. Mary Markovich-Sedlock says:

    Peanut buttah ripple! Yum get in ma bellay!

  356. Carolyn says:

    All-natural Mint Chocolate Chip is the hands down winner all the way! – It’s the best ever :)

  357. Leon Pilewski says:

    Great idea; a March madness you can really sink your teeth ( and the rest of your mouth) into! GO BUTTER PECAN!!

  358. Gloria says:

    I want Tin Roof Sundae to win or any with coconut in it, but I predict Limited Edition Snyder’s Pa Dutch Pretzel will take the crown, simply because of the pretzels. Lots of people like pretzels. Add them to delicious TH ice cream, and you’ll probably have a winner.

  359. Mary Ricketts says:

    Whoopie Pie is the ice cream of love!

  360. Carissa says:

    Rocky Road!!

  361. Shelli Shepherd says:

    Touchdown Sundae is my pick!

  362. I love your flavors. Since you make the All Natural line w/ sugar(instead of corn syrup), I wish someday you could make MORE flavors w/ just sugar.

  363. peggy says:

    TURKEY HILL EGG NOG !!! That is after vanilla bean then dutch chocolate …

  364. Tina Ingham says:

    love love love the gertrude box of chocolates

  365. Patty says:

    Double Dunker will be the winner!

  366. Suzanne says:

    Whatever happened to black walnut ice-cream? It would win hands down!!

  367. Rosie Britton says:

    Good Luck to all the contestants! Even if you don’t win, just remember that you are Yummy!!

  368. Dwayne Magee says:

    I’m rooting for the tried and true underdog….mint chocolate chip

  369. Larry Zutavern says:

    This is more fun than picking March Madness Basketball Tournament. And tastier too!

  370. sarah oswald says:

    THE VANILLA CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – Butter Pecan
    MATCH UP #2 – Cookies ‘n Cream
    MATCH UP #3 – Touchdown Sundae
    MATCH UP #4 – Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    THE CHOCOLATE (AND OTHERS) CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – Double Dunker
    MATCH UP #2 – Strawberries ‘n Cream
    MATCH UP #3 – Light Recipe Extreme Cookies ‘n Cream
    MATCH UP #4 – Phillies Graham Slam

    THE ALL NATURAL CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 – All Natural Salted Caramel
    MATCH UP #2 – All Natural Mint Chocolate Chip
    MATCH UP #3 – All Natural Cherry Vanilla
    MATCH UP #4 – All Natural Butter Almond

    THE LIMITED EDITION CONFERENCE
    MATCH UP #1 –Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie
    MATCH UP #2 – Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel
    MATCH UP #3 – Limited Edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates
    MATCH UP #4 – Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie

    I predict that *(TOUCHDOWN SUNDAE)* will win over them all

  371. Daria P. says:

    I am hoping my favorite, Columbian Coffee, will win. However, if I were to guess what the general public might choose, I would say Tin Roof Sundae

  372. Liz says:

    OOOOhhhh so many delish flavors! Voting made me hungry to try each!

  373. Farrah heil says:

    Slovenia cookie dough! All this ice cream voting makes me want some right now!

  374. Lydia says:

    coconut cream pie

  375. carol kaplan says:

    Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge is my all time favorite ice cream and the fact that it is a ‘light’ recipe is just the maraschino cherry on the sundae of my day!!! I hope Turkey Hill never retires this flavor!!!

  376. Stefanie says:

    Cookies N Cream is my favorite and I hope it wins!

  377. Carol S. says:

    Nearly impossible to pick a favorite as it just depends on the mood that strikes me on a particular day. I always say my favorite is the one that hasn’t been invented yet. That just means that I’m always looking forward to the latest creations of total ice cream joy!

  378. Barb Bauer says:

    Of all the choices, natural vanilla bean is my favorite, with chocolate syrup, of course.

  379. Doreen S. says:

    MATCH UP #4 – Light Recipe Coconut Almond Fudge

  380. lisa mullins says:

    I don’t agree with the majority apparently according to my votes. So I’m going to say that people will pick Butter pecan, not my vote though. (I still say to bring the limited edition lemon southern pie in the line. It’s the best & very refreshing)

  381. Peanut butter ripple is the ultimate winner.

  382. Brenda says:

    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  383. Michael C says:

    To pick just one great flavor is impossible or even two at this point. I would just like to say that all the flavors are good because you only make the good stuff. Quality, Quantity, Flavors are what make Turkey Hill Stand out from any other Brand. So dig right in and enjoy your bowl

  384. Norma S says:

    Gertrude Hawk will win. What’s not to like about your favorite ice cream paired with your favorite candy?

  385. EdD says:

    All the flavors or winners, I would have no problem eating any of them. I like butter pecan as the winner but there are no losers on the list. One flavor not on the list but I really like, and recently re-discovered is Orange Cream Swirl. Brings back memories of a different time and an orange cream pop cycle. Thank you for the time to express myself

  386. Joanne Loew says:

    Waiting to see my favorite on the list…Choc-Mint. Now that’s a winning flavor!

  387. tom k says:

    Touchdown sundae is going all the way.

  388. Daphne Turner says:

    I had so much fun going through the voting process. Salivating all over my keyboard now, oops.

  389. Mark Weinberger says:

    Phillies all the way, they will beat the Yankees this time! Butter Pecan is actually my favorite.

  390. Debra Russo says:

    Dutch Chocolate will definitely advance to the next round!

  391. Jenn says:

    Whoopie Pie all the way!! :)

  392. Marissa says:

    Im hoping dutch chocolate will win. I live in a family of 7 and my husband and i are expecting our first baby a little girl and we are hoping she will be an avid ice cream lover like we all are. We always buy turkey hill ice cream and have to keep about 4 quarts of ice cream in the freezer each week because we always have our dish of ice cream after dinner :)

  393. Deb K says:

    Vanilla – Butter Pecan
    Chocolate – Choc Marshmallow
    All Natural – Natural Vanilla
    Limited Addition – Key Lime

    My husband has been eating Choc Marshmallow since he was a little boy. It brings great memories and is a comfort food for the end of the day. I think this is the Winner…

  394. cynthia schwabenbauer says:

    Never tried Double Dunker? Now’s the time! Soooooverygoooodddd

  395. MATCH UP #4 – Limited Edition Coconut Cream Pie vs. Limited Edition Key Lime Pie

    is a sad mix i was hoping they was finalist

  396. IO says:

    Butter Almond needs to win so it is no longer a limited edition but a permanent edition like it use to be!!!!!

  397. Linda W says:

    My favorites are doing well. Will support them to the end.

  398. Debby says:

    My family loves the Whoopie Pie Ice Cream!!! It is our all time favorite ice cream. I wish it was on the shelves all year round. I wrote it on my calendar to look for it in the stores so I could stock up but could only find 3 cartons:( I can’t wait until it comes out this year!

  399. Sarah says:

    No surprise Chocolate peanut butter cup was retired so early. All time favorite! Rooting for good ol’ fashioned cookie dough although I must say your salted caramel is DIVINE! would love a year’s supply of THAT goodness :)

  400. Mona says:

    Salted Caramel gets my vote…..and Key Lime Pie

  401. Carrie says:

    This is such a GREAT way to bring awareness to the many flavors of Turkey Hill! Looking forward to the results!

  402. Ginny Whipple says:

    With so many great flavors, it will be interesting to see which one wins. Since my husband eats your ice cream EVERY day, it would be great to win a year’s worth of Turkey Hill Ice Cream!

  403. Cindy Jo says:

    I hoping for All Natural Raspberry.

  404. Laraine Izzo says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate reaches the deep, dark recesses of my tummy to satisify the need for TH ice cream.

  405. Jill says:

    Anything CHOCOLATE!!!!!

  406. Ann W says:

    Rocky Road!!!

  407. LauraG says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip for it all!

  408. Deb says:

    Pumpkin Pie and Butter Pecan in the same bowl is delightful!!

  409. Matt Smith says:

    Double Dunker is the BEST!

  410. Kathy B says:

    Hands down new favorite in our house is the All Natural Salted Caramel. Can’t keep it in stock!!

  411. Ned says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough wins the Golden Scoop (my fav is the 2009 champ)

  412. janice says:

    Wow… just did my voting. Not even lunch time, and already planning what ice cream I am picking up on the way home from work.

  413. Lorraine Myers says:

    The ALL NATURAL is the best!!!! just like homemade!! No other like it on the market today – all the other ice creams out there have additives that shouldn’t even be in our precious ice cream!

  414. John Sery says:

    Zillions of Steeler Fans in the Washington DC/Metro area.
    Please expand distribution of Blitzburgh Crunch !!

  415. Neil S says:

    Your All Natural is the best ice cream of any, hands down!!

  416. Sherry Campagnolo says:

    Coconut Cream Pie is to die for!!!

  417. Sue says:

    I predict it will be Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel in the final four! Can’t beat pretzels and Turkey Hill Ice Cream!

  418. Linda says:

    Missed my favorite – Stuff’d Junior Mint. Love it!

  419. Lori says:

    My two favorites would be Pumpkin Pie and Key Lime Pie.

  420. Mark S says:

    Actually, I’ve yet to meet a Turkey Hill flavor I didn’t like.

  421. Debbie says:

    Double dunker double dunker woo hoo!!!!!

  422. Debbie says:

    Have to look for the Gertrude Hawk at my store tonight – sounds heavenly!!

  423. Jorgee says:

    Key Lime is awesome!!

  424. Deb says:

    I’m a chocolate lover, but I really love the salted caramel ice cream :)

  425. Janice says:

    When younger, I made Chocolate Chip cookies just to eat the dough. But, now we know how bad it is to eat it raw. I am forever grateful to Turkey Hill for giving me a way to eat it safely, and the molasses touch…heavenly. Go Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough!

  426. CHRISTINE says:

    I VOTED AND SAW SOME SURPRISE VOTES.
    LET THE FUN BEGIN……

  427. Michele aka Goat Girl says:

    Last week we got a carton Coconut Creme Pie and it was the creamiest ice cream I’ve ever had. How can this flavor only be a limited edition flavor???? I could eat it every day!

  428. I had fun entering in my votes for the tournament. I brought home for the 1st time to try Pistacho Almond ice cream. Moo Moo to Turkey Hill for their new innovative flavors!

  429. LOTTIE BERMAN says:

    Chocolate marshmallow wins cause it is the best.

  430. Teresa Motz says:

    My New Year’s Resolution is to try many different flavors of Turkey Hill. At least I know this is one I can keep (and with a smile on my face!)

  431. Marion says:

    Coffee and Whoopie Pie are winners!

  432. Max B says:

    I can’t believe Snyder pretzel is beating out egg nog.

  433. Twila says:

    Colombian coffee!

  434. Whoopie Pie should never be limited. This is the most incredible flavor ever created by Turkey Hill, and I have been a die hard Chocolate Marshmallow lover for ages. My entire family will devour a half gallon of Whoopie Pie in one sitting!

  435. RebeccaH says:

    I’ve not tried all the flavors, but out of the ones I have tried, they’ve all been good. You can’t go wrong with Turkey Hill. #1 in my book!

  436. Tracy says:

    My family cannot decide on just one flavor to win so 1 son chooses Cookies & Cream, 1 son chooses Pumpkin Pie, 1 son chooses Double Dunker, hubby chooses All Natural Raspberry, & momma chooses Butter Pecan!

  437. Edwin Roberts says:

    Don’t need much coxing to try any flavor Turkey Hill makes. The quality and flavors are unparalleled. Thank you.

  438. Jill Van Arsdale says:

    1 of everything!

  439. Linda H says:

    To pick just one is WAY too hard! I’m gonna be forced to go buy every flavor listed & do my own Ultimate Flavor Tournament!

  440. John H says:

    Nothing beats All Natural Vanilla Bean!

  441. frannie says:

    Already added to Turkey Hill e-mail.

    Just want to comment on your Cherry Vanilla, it is to die for.
    where in the world does Turkey Hill get those hugh CHERRIES? This should really be on your voting list.

  442. Alicia says:

    Good Luck Rocky Road!!!!!!!!!!!!

  443. Linda H says:

    Since its almost impossible to find a “bad” Turkey Hill ice cream flavor, I’m just gonna be forced to do my own Ultimate Flavor Tournament here at home (& repeat as necessary)

  444. marie grim says:

    i think rocky road will be the winner

  445. Ann King says:

    I am still rooting for peanut butter ripple but it is not doing so well. Hope for more votes.

  446. Pauline says:

    I have to go for Butter Pecan. My all time favorite since I was a little girl. After seeing some of the comments I will be looking for some of the All Natural Salted Caramel to try. That sounds delicious too.

  447. Brandon says:

    Personally, chocolate peanut butter cup can never be topped, by this or any other brand. But Graham Slam, you may just save this baseball season!

  448. Jack Sobel says:

    Limited Edition Whoopie Pie is the best !!

  449. Amanda Scully says:

    The chocolate marshmallow ice cream in the marshmallow bomb diggity. The rich chocolate ice cream with a gooey marshmallow filling that makes your mouth water just thinking about it.

  450. Shawn B says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  451. beth ann says:

    I think the rasberry cream that as special that i found last year was the best and never found it again.

  452. Tina says:

    We only buy Turkey Hill Ice Cream here in NC. We need more variety though!!!! So many of these flavors have yet to be tried here in the south! Please send some!!

  453. Pat from CT says:

    TRUE STORY: Coconut Cream Pie is one of my all-time favorite flavors. In the summer of 2011, and because it’s a Limited Edition, I still had an unfinished container of it in the freezer, saving it because I didn’t want it to be all gone (and my husband knew he wasn’t allowed to touch it). Sunday, August 28, at around 2 a.m., thanks to Hurricane (or “Tropical Storm”) Irene, we lost our power. By mid-morning, it was very apparent that certain items in the freezer were starting to defrost, and I certainly wasn’t going to let the (now soupy) Coconut Cream Pie Limited Edition ice cream go to waste, so I ate all that was left. What a dream-come-true this would have been if I were still a kid – eating all that ice cream for breakfast!

  454. Linda B. says:

    I really enjoy Turkey Hill ice cream…. sooo creamy. But I really do think that the salted caramel has a good chance of winning it all!!!

  455. JJ says:

    The all reliable Rocky Road…….so GOOOD!!!!!

  456. Tom says:

    Salted Caramel & Natural Cherry Vanilla could end up in overtime for the Championship!!!

  457. SANDRA D. says:

    SPRING IS ALMOST HERE. I WANT A “PHILLIES GRAHAM SLAM”!!!

  458. Lindsay says:

    OMG, love Coconut Cream Pie and Key Lime Pie…tough decision!!! Not to mention, Dutch Pretzel vs. Egg Nog and Pumpkin Pie. The Limited Editions are the best!!

  459. ZAK says:

    Limited Edition Snyder’s PA Dutch Pretzel

  460. Kathy S. says:

    Touchdown Sundae and Dutch Chocolate win from the above flavors, although you can’t go wrong with simple vanilla. It’s hard to choose, as they are all yummy! :)

  461. Susan Santucco says:

    Tin Roof, Fudge Ripple, and the only other one worth mentioning is RASPBERRY
    Well, you asked…..

  462. Kayleen says:

    My money’s on Dutch Chocolate (my favorite)!

  463. patd says:

    Went to Turkey Hill Experience and they had black walnut ice cream. It was delicious but I have never saw it in the stores. I would love to buy some of this.

  464. lori says:

    I love chocolate IS this the contest ? I want a years worth of ice cream.

  465. Dan Sampson says:

    A lot of the tournament flavors I haven’t had the opportunity to try as I live in Utah and our local Smith’s only carries a handful of flavors. The best of which is chocolate chip cookie dough. I would really like to try Turkey Hill Chocolate Marshmallow. Any ideas on how I can get it out here?

  466. Michelle Bitman says:

    I am going with whoopy pie or Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast

    as the two tops

  467. Dave says:

    any new flavor that has banana, such as banana berry or fudge. Other wise Dutch chocolate is the best chocolate period!

  468. John L. says:

    Whoopie Pie or Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast for the win!!! :D

  469. Regina says:

    So delighted that the Ultimate Flavor Tournament is back again this year. Such fun! Perhaps Yankees Pinstripe Brownie Blast will win even though the Yankees failed in their tournament this year.

  470. jim r says:

    i love the way the chocolate marshmallo tastes…soooo creamy

  471. Renee says:

    How did I miss the all-natural salted caramel??

  472. Mary S says:

    Anything Chocolate!

  473. Love The Phillies and Phillies Grand Slam!!

  474. Michelle K says:

    So many flavors, so hard to choose just ONE favorite!

  475. Elizabeth Mink says:

    Cherry Vanilla is my favorite right now. You add so many cherries that you get cherries in every bite.

  476. Cindy V says:

    Rocky Road is the one to beat…..

  477. Cindy V says:

    Rocky Road will be the favorite, if not the winner…..

  478. janet says:

    Chocolate Marshmallow / whoppie pie

  479. Michelle Bachert says:

    Double Dunker will be the champion!

  480. Tammy says:

    Chocolate peanut butter cup. Hands down!

  481. Chrissy says:

    All ice cream flavors are the winners! I love all ice cream. Yum!!

  482. Angela says:

    Key lime pie

  483. Dave Town says:

    The winner should be Key Lime Pie… to try it is to love it!

  484. Suzanne says:

    Vanilla bean with sprinkles!!

  485. Christine Fellin says:

    Whoppie Pie is the ONE!

  486. Ed delaney says:

    My favorite flavor Is not even listed…Rum Raisin

  487. Jessica says:

    Ginger Snap is my favorite.

  488. Eric says:

    Whoppie Pie is awesome!

  489. Janice says:

    This is so hard to choose as all Turkey Hill flavors are AWESOME!!! But I am going with Dutch Chocolate this year.

  490. Cath T says:

    All Natural Chocolate!

  491. Tracy says:

    Phillies Graham Slam is the best ice cream ever. Seriously, I would live on it if I could.

  492. Christine A says:

    WHOOPIE PIE! WHOOPIE PIE! WHOOPIE PIE!

  493. Ashley Brown says:

    I hope the natural vanilla or rocky road wins this year!

  494. Judy Cole says:

    Caramel and chocolate all the way – how about a Milk Duds flavor?

  495. Lori Goldman says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough! Turkey Hill is the best ever!!

  496. Carol says:

    It’s all good. Too bad the stores can’t accomodate all the differant flavors.

  497. MJenkins says:

    My all time favorite is the Butter Almond!

  498. Lyoder says:

    This chocoholic loves any of the chocolate flavors. Team Chocolate Marshmallow is a front runner along with Deep Dark Chocolate!! Pretty much anything with chocolate in it is a winner with me.

  499. christine says:

    MY favorites aren’t listed so I will say All Natural Butter Almond

  500. curt says:

    Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates is the best recently added flavor. Thanks for extending to multiple month distribution. Coconut Cream Pie is close behind.

  501. Justin Orkin says:

    Extreme cookies and creme

  502. Llanda Lavender says:

    It was Double Dunker that turned me into an addict for Turkey Hill Ice Cream.

  503. Louisa Scott says:

    Love anything with peanut butter in it!!!!!

  504. Denise says:

    I have so many favorites, whatever flavor wins will probably be one of my favorites! Turkey Hill rocks!

  505. Julie says:

    I found Double Dunker and eat a carton in 3 days~ hands down favorite. :)

  506. Lee Henthorn says:

    C’mon Graham Slam!!!!

  507. Lee Henthorn says:

    C’mon Graham Slam!!!

  508. Doreen S. says:

    Touchdown sundae

  509. Pat says:

    Really looking forward to the Graham Slam vs. Brownie Blast. I feel like Slam unfairly took a loss last year – it’s the best ice cream flavor I’ve ever had!

  510. Joe says:

    Coconut Cream Pie is the closest thing to heaven that you can taste!

  511. Patty says:

    I’m eating some of the next winner right now…….yuuuummmmmm!

  512. Stacy says:

    bring back whoopee pie, please…..

  513. Mike M says:

    I’m into the limited edition flavors, myself. While I doubt they’d get very far against the stiff competition, I’d really like to see something more exotic like the Pumpkin Pie or Egg Nog take it.

  514. Derek says:

    I’m glad peanut butter pie froyo isn’t on here, it’s hard enough to decide between whoopie pie, pumpkin pie and snyder’s pretzel

  515. Lin says:

    I hope you continue making ALL NATURAL and that stores in Columbia,SC will get more of the different flavors…THANKS

  516. karen says:

    My heart is torn between Coconut cream pie & key lime pie!!!

  517. Caroline says:

    After voting didn’t realize there was so many flavors I haven’t tried. excited to try the Snyder pretzel one. Love pretzels but have not found it in stores.
    Just in time for spring, love ice cream

  518. Carol says:

    All Natural Cherry Vanilla has always been and will always be my all-time favorite!

  519. Doreen S. says:

    It’s so hard to pick just one. They are all so so good1

  520. amanda says:

    i can’t believe how many different flavors there are!

  521. Deb Freeman says:

    I think the Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate is by far a favorite. With half the population being female, and what woman doesn’t like chocolate, it is a no brainer.

  522. R Johnson says:

    Double Dunker is hands down the best chocolate flavor ever. And that is saying a lot because I used to say that about Chocolate Malt Chip (by the way, bring that back, please).

    We also miss Alpine Espresso.

    Deep Dark Chocolate and Lady Liberty getting nods from the ladies in my family. Also Bronx Bomber.

  523. Olivia Campbell says:

    Key Lime Pie and Butter Pecan is a “must have” in our freezer,while Black Cherry is in my Moms’freezer.

  524. Thomas says:

    The Vanilla Conference has a “Retired” past champ???

  525. Danielle says:

    let orange cream swirl stay, i love this kind and so does my family, its the best

  526. Danielle says:

    I want pumpkin pie to stay, its the best

  527. bobby kelly says:

    I have always had mint chocolate chip as my favorite – but your egg nog is just out of this world delicious and tops them all!

  528. chris jenkins says:

    love the voteing.I eat at least two flavors at a time

  529. Bethany Torrenti says:

    Let’s go limited edition Gertrude Hawk Box of Chocolates! You can do it!!!!

  530. Charlene says:

    Thank-You Turkey Hill for giving us a Great Ice Cream.Turkey Hill Ice Cream is our family’s favorite ice cream,it the only ice cream we buy. You have given us So many wonderful,fabulous,tasty,ice cream choices.We truely love our ice cream.Wow tough choice we hope that “Tin Roof Sundae ” wins. Tin Roof Sundae has: Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Swirl with Chocolate Peanuts. Wow this one we hope wins. We are very Loyal Turkey Hill customers.Turkey Hill you have the best Ice Cream !

  531. J G says:

    LIMITED…EDITION…WHOOPIE…PIE

  532. Violet says:

    PLEASE bring back box of chocolates, amazing ice cream. When it does come back we are stocking up on it!!!

  533. pete says:

    I said it before and I’ll say it again, Turkey Hill got it right the first time. They know ice-cream……..

  534. Shawn Hussey says:

    If the past is any indicator of the future, I believe we will see a new Turkey Hill ice cream flavor champion this year.

  535. Heather Simons says:

    There are too many amazing flavors to pick! Just tried Coconut Cream Pie and Double Dunker for the first time tonight-both amazing!

  536. Rachel says:

    Brownie Blast!! I love super chocolatey ice creams :) If I had to choose any Turkey Hill dessert though, I’d go with the strawberry cheesecake Stuffed! That stuff is super addictive!

  537. frank behm says:

    turkey hill is the best by far.

  538. Bring on the ice cream. Yum.

  539. Amy says:

    Double Dunker is by far my favorite! My husband loves the Blitzburgh Crunch.

  540. Linda says:

    I’m the winner when I’m enjoying Turkey Hill!

  541. Elizabeth says:

    On A HOT Summer day when you are so thirsty you think nothing will help try 7-Up with Vanilla Bean Ice Cream You will think you died and went to Ice Cream Heaven !!!

  542. Kathy Conti says:

    Key Lime Pie would be my choice but the peoples choice will be Butter Pecan

  543. Richard Hedger says:

    Difficult to decide between the all natural Vanilla/Chocalate or the all natural vanilla/salted caramel. My vote is for the salted caramel.

  544. Dorothy Minkema says:

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough will win but my personal favorite is Peanut Butter Cup. OMG – it is so good, you could hurt yourself on it!!!!!

  545. Ann says:

    Another set of rounds worth voting for. Thank you Ernie for setting this up each year! I would love to d your job for a day and maybe test some ice cream while I’m there. :)

  546. Andrea says:

    I guess I’m boring but All Natural Vanilla Bean should win since it is delicious and so versatile.

  547. R Johnson says:

    Come on Dutch Chocolate!!!!! Come from behind!!!

    Also rooting for Deep Dark Chocolate

  548. R Johnson says:

    Now that Dutch Chocolate is out, go Deep Dark Chocolate!

  549. Fionnuala says:

    Double Dunker!

Leave a Reply

 

These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.