Ultimate Flavor Tournament 2014 (Round Five): The Final Two!

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on March 31st, 2014

It all comes down to this! 32 flavors began the tournament five weeks ago, each one with high hopes of becoming the next Ultimate Flavor Tournament champion. But only one flavor can win the title, and it’s down to this week’s final showdown between Peanut Butter Ripple and Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate.

Which flavor will be the Ultimate Flavor Tournament champ? Your votes will decide! Cast your vote in the poll on the right and leave a comment below with which flavor you think will win. Remember, we’ll choose one comment at random from all the comments left on the blog during the tournament to win a FREE one year supply of Turkey Hill Ice Cream. Good luck, and may the best flavor win!

Peanut Butter Ripple vs. Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

ERNIE’S ANALYSIS: This is it, folks. It’s been a crazy five weeks, packed with exciting wins and heartbreaking losses, and it all comes down to two flavors. And they couldn’t be more different. On one side, you’ve got a vanilla-based flavor packed with peanut butter. On the other side, you’ve got a chocolate-based flavor loaded with chocolate. Chocolate and peanut butter usually make a great combo, but in this match-up, they’re fierce freezer aisle opponents.

When breaking down this match-up, both competitors have their strengths. Peanut Butter Ripple is an Ultimate Flavor Tournament veteran, with at least one Frosty Four appearance under its belt. And it’s got peanut butter…and who doesn’t love peanut butter?

On the other hand, Deep Dark Chocolate is relatively new to tournament action. It appeared for the first time in last year’s tournament, but lost in the first round to Chunky Peanut Butter (which went on to win the tournament six weeks later). And it’s got chocolate…and who doesn’t love chocolate?

So who will win, the peanut buttery veteran or the chocolatey newcomer? I’ve got my own opinion, but at this stage of the game, I’m more interested in your thoughts, so feel free to leave a comment. In the meantime, I’m going to sample both flavors several times to see how they stack up!

Leave a Comment

880 Responses to “Ultimate Flavor Tournament 2014 (Round Five): The Final Two!”

  1. donna pancoast says:

    deep dark chocolate all the way!

  2. nina hilson says:


  3. Phyllis Strickland says:

    Neither of this would be my Ultimate Flavor choice!! Both are great flavors, but too mundane to be Champions. Just my 2 cents.

  4. Betty says:

    chocolate every time

  5. Marion Bowler says:

    That’s a tough decision. Like both equally!

  6. Mysta Johnston says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple Definitely!!!!

  7. Sheila says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple! It’s just so good!

  8. MC says:


  9. Mysta Johnston says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple Definitely!!

  10. J Kaiman says:

    I like both of them. Its hard to choose the best one.

  11. For me it’s anything with peanut butter!!! Glad it made the finals.

  12. Donna Keller says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple.

  13. scott says:

    Put them together and no one has to lose. Thanks for the tournament fun.

  14. Sherri Rosen says:

    Any flavor with the word “chocolate” in it, is a winner!

  15. Lois says:

    And the winner is…………….Deep Dark Chocolate!!!!

  16. millie says:

    peanut ripple I hope it wins

  17. Donna Keller says:

    Peanut Ripple all the way

  18. andrea says:

    Go PB Go!!!

  19. Norma says:

    Never learned to share? Get ’em both!

  20. LindaR says:

    Don’t care for either one, can/t wait for new refreshing spring & summer flavors.

  21. Patrice says:

    Peanut Butter …the ultimate

  22. Vera says:

    always Deep Dark Chocolate

  23. Susan J says:

    Tough choice! In the end, I had to vote for the chocolate. I mean…it’s chocolate!

  24. Lydia Stufft says:

    Deep-Dark is the only way.

  25. Richard F. Buckley says:

    If I had to choose between them, I’d go for the Peanut Butter Ripple, but as I’ve said before, my favorite flavor is definitely Butter Pecan, followed closely by Black Cherry.

  26. Harold Megargel says:

    2 scoops please…one of each please like a decadent Reese’s Cup!! I’ll pick PB Ripple as the winner.

  27. Jean Sagarese says:

    I am not a chocolate ice cream fan, but this was amazing when we got a container of it so it got my vote

  28. Michelle says:

    Dark chocolate!!!

  29. Tina says:

    Delicious ice cream!

  30. Amber Stamper says:

    My vote goes to Deep Dark Chocolate.

  31. Elaine Garfield says:

    chocoalte has to be the winner

  32. Sarah says:


  33. Sarah says:

    C’mon peanut butter lovers, get in there and vote!

  34. Cleo Browne says:

    The winner is Deep Dark Chocolate handsdown !

  35. Cleo Browne says:

    I really want to win the free Turkey Hill Ice Cream for a mouth watering year!

  36. Carol says:

    I love chocolate….Deep Dark Chocolate is the BEST! It has my vote.

  37. Harp & Guinness' Mom says:

    PBR Jams!

  38. Ellen says:

    Oh my, they both look so yummy. It’s really hard to pick one. Even though I like both, I pick Peanut Butter Ripple.

  39. Thelma M Jones says:

    Peanut butter ripple

  40. Diane G says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate.
    How much is a year supply of Turkey Hill Ice Cream?

  41. leecarr says:

    DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE is my choice and
    my second choice would not be the peanut butter ripple

  42. Randy says:

    “Deep Dark Chocolate” Is deep dark deliciousness!!!!! ๐Ÿ™‚

  43. Renee Neuberger says:


  44. Bob Pescinski says:

    PB Ripple all the way!

  45. joan says:

    With so many choices, how did we end up with these two? I had to vote for Deep Dark Chocolate, even though I love Peanut Butter Ripple, as well. But the one I really love is Turkey Hill Butter Pecan.

  46. Donna Straugh says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is yummm yummm yummmy

  47. Sharon says:


  48. Amy P says:

    I like chocolate, but Peanut Butter is better!!

  49. Debby says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!!!! but I still think it would be great if you put these final two together in one absolutely AWESOME new flavor! (then again, I can just add chocolate syrup to the peanut butter and sort of get the flavor!)

  50. Ron DiRisio says:

    There are plenty of peanut butter flavored varieties out there but only one DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE!

  51. Sally says:

    Neither of the two remaining flavors is my favorite, but of the two I’d have to choose Peanut Butter Ripple.

  52. IceCreamFiend says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple all the way!

  53. Heather Bruinsma says:

    I’ve never tried either, but the deep, dark chocolate sounds so delicious!!!!

  54. MaryBeth Eisenhauer says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple has been my favorite ever since I was a child. Simply the BEST and should WIN the contest.

  55. Lyn Wallace says:

    Love Chocolate – so this is a no-brainer. Deep dark chocolate

  56. Paul Fiumara says:

    Dig for Deep Dark Chocolate !

  57. sandra smith says:

    dark chocolate by a mile!

  58. gianna says:

    No question about itโ€ฆ..DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE

  59. Vicki Spokes says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  60. Linda T says:

    You had me at “deep dark;” it had to be chocolate! Bring it on!

  61. Corrie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  62. Robert Scheid says:

    DDC got my vote

  63. Josh says:

    How about deep dark chocolate peanut butter ripple?

  64. Lynn Hordines says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the best! There is nothing better than chocolate, even better, deep dark chocolate. I want some right now!

  65. Lynn Hordines says:

    Deep dark chocolate. Its the best! So creamy and rich. Love it.

  66. Jim in SOMD says:

    You can often find Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple in my freezer. I do not believe that the Deep Dark Chocolate has ever been there. First it is a Limited Edition and so it would depend on which month it is available. Some onths it would not break the top ten, let alone take down a hevayweight like Peanut Butter Ripple.

  67. Marie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate
    Deep Dark Chocolate
    Rah, Rah, Rah!!!

  68. Jennifer Benner says:

    Congrats to the final two! I love them both, if I had to pick one it would be Deep Dark Chocolate. I think Turkey Hill should combine the two flavors as a special edition. It should be Deep Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple! The best of both flavors. Love the ice cream! Keep up the great work.

  69. Elsie Nicolette says:

    I so like my chocolate and peanut butter together rather than isolated from each other ๐Ÿ™

  70. julie says:

    Chocolate w/peanuts and syrup

  71. J.C.SOLOCK says:


  72. sue hulme says:

    deep dark chocolate–although you could combine both for a fantastic flavor!

  73. Cheryl Butchko says:

    Peanut Butter!

  74. Bill Danson III says:

    I like both but if I had to choose one PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE has my vote

  75. jean says:

    Both are great. But love peanut butter and chocolate combo is eextra great

  76. IO says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple to win in overtime!

  77. Mary says:

    PBR all the way!

  78. Yvonne Learn says:

    Here’s a thought – what if you combined the 2 for a new flavor, say, “Chocolate Shadow Peanut Butter?

  79. I love them both but peanut butter is still my favorite but really the 2 mixed together would be really good

  80. Lou B says:


  81. Linda says:

    Call me crazy, but I said the winner from the get go would be something chocolate and yet I’m a huge Peanut Butter Ripple fan, so I had to vote for peanut butter!

  82. debbie says:

    How about we merge the two flavors and call it a tie…

  83. grams says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple all the way.

  84. marie grim says:

    both sound good to me. maybe mix em together. but if i had to pick one.. it’s chocolate #1

  85. Lori says:

    Now if they could just add peanut butter to the deep dark chocolate…that’s a winner

  86. Faye says:

    Love them b oth but had to go with the dark chocolate….Yummy…

  87. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    I will let hubby vote

  88. enid portnoy says:

    ROBERT FROST WROTE “The woods are lovely, dark and deep” but so is Chocolate, AND SWEET,lovely, dark and deep. Share the deep dark chocolate flavor of Turkey Hill anytime, and as a winner anywhere!

  89. Jill says:

    They are both good but have to say the Deep Dark Chocolate

  90. Ann Rea says:

    I am sure the Deep Dark Choc. is good, but can’t eat it – Peanut Butter is good along with the Egg Nog, which I know is not listed.

  91. Denise Wilson says:

    Never had the deep dark chocolate

  92. Teresa Motz says:

    I never really enjoyed chocolate ice cream until a couple of years age. Turkey Hill Deep Dark Chocolate is definitely worthy of a win ๐Ÿ™‚

  93. Teresa Motz says:

    I meant a couple of years ago! (See above comment!)

  94. Barb says:

    What a tough decision….both are great flavors!

  95. Nora says:

    as much as i love chocolate ice cream I am voting for the Peanut Butter Ripple cause I’ve tried this and it’s awesomely delicious!!

  96. TawndaM says:

    …can’t I just have some of both in a bowl??

  97. Noel says:

    Deep dark chocolate. It’s a Limited Edition? No way. Keep it forever!

  98. beth herr says:

    can’t beat dark chocolate

  99. Debbie says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  100. Pat says:

    They both sound great, but Peanut Butter Ripple has my vote.

  101. Max B says:


  102. pat bentzel says:

    I prefer chocolate over peanut butter

  103. Gloria says:

    It was hard to decide. How about mixing the two for a new flavor?

  104. ron savidge says:

    Like I said from the very beginning, Nothing can beat Peanut Butter Ripple.

  105. Marta Morgan says:

    love so many flavors but have to go with the dark chocolate!

  106. Tom says:

    Just had the Phillies Batterup. A winner. My son downed it about a day. Its back to Wegman’s for more!!

  107. REGGIE MCGEE says:

    Deep dark chocolate—-YEA

  108. Diana Beatty says:

    All the way with Deep Dark Chocolate yes.

  109. Sondra says:

    Who doesn’t love Deep Dark Chocolate? If it wins, maybe I can get it more regularly at the local supermarket – we haven’t had it in MONTHS!!!!!

  110. Phyllis says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple but I think the 2 together would be a WINNER!

  111. Tina Ingham says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple has been my favorite forever!

  112. Rachel says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way!!!!!!!!

  113. Andrea says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple should win! My entire family loves it. We like chocolate but Deep Dark Chocolate is too much chocolate.

  114. Joan says:

    Neither is my favorite. My choice would be vanilla with peanut butter and chocolate mixed in. But those choices lost out.

  115. jay says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate!

  116. Ida Beek says:

    Luscious dark chocolate got my vote.

  117. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    I love chocolate. But I think the underdog is the Peanut Butter Ripple and my vote will go to the underdog.

  118. Patricia Lysinger says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple. I don’t like dark chocolate

  119. Deb Ragno says:

    Deep Dark (Delightfully Delicious)Chocolate

  120. LaCinda Brooks says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!

  121. Kathy says:

    deep dark chocolate

  122. Tom Fagan says:

    There is no better combination than Peanut Butter Ripple and bananas and chocolate sauce!!!

  123. Dawn Opie says:

    The darker the better . . . mmmmmmmmmm!!!!

  124. darla h says:

    I’ll go with peanutbuttter ripple. I can always add deep dark chocolate toppings! Yum!

  125. Colleen says:

    Love then both but mix them and it’s even better!

  126. Rebecca C says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, Yes Please!!!

  127. Patti says:

    Deep dark chocolate! There are not a lot of choices for dark chocolate ice cream so this would be perfect!

  128. Diane R says:

    Peanut Butter rules!

  129. george says:

    deep dark chocolate is the best of the best

  130. Judith Carlow says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  131. April Eberts says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!

  132. Nancy says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way! ๐Ÿ™‚

  133. mike lefebvre says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple has it spoons down !

  134. Lou Chiacchere says:

    How could anyone resist the dark rich chocolate flavor

  135. Crystal B. says:

    YUMMM! Deep Dark Chocolate!

  136. Derek says:

    Peanut butter pie all the way!!! Oh wait that’s discontinued. Peanut butter ripple it is then.

  137. DawnK says:

    PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE without a doubt! I’ve been THE Biggest Fan with PBR running through my veins since I was a teenager…and it’s kept me a kid for several decades! There’s no competition… thank you! XOXOX

  138. mary ann herrmann says:

    ..c’mon chocolate!!

  139. Justin says:

    Deep dark chocolate sounds too good to be true!

  140. Jennifer says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple with a side of Dark Chocolate! Keep up the great work, Turkey Hill.

  141. justin rosini says:

    Chocolate absolutley all your choclate ice cream are the best ive been stationed in asia and europe where chocolate is a daily staple but nothing like comming home to the.u.s.a.to bowl of turkey hill deep dark chocolate exellent job always worth comming home to

  142. Richard Casey says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is everything you ever wanted chocolate to be — magnificent!

  143. Cathy Saynuk says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate sounds gourmet! I can imagine 2 scoops of it in a crystal ice cream dish after a
    fantastic seafood meal. I had to say that because I am in Maryland. But, Deep Dark Chocolate is no snob, so I can also picture it in a cone for a happy four-year old child!

  144. Wayne D. says:

    You know it’s gotta be, just gotta be Deep Dark Chocolate and nothing else!

  145. Lennie says:

    Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple is the favorite at this household of 6 children and 2 parents! Only 2 still live at home but when the others come to visit, they check the freezer (with permission, of course) ๐Ÿ™‚ There could be other flavors but Peanut Butter is the first gone! Thanks Turkey Hill for a lot of great flavors to choose from.

  146. Glenda Thompson says:

    The decadent, delicious, desirable Deep Dark Chocolate!!

  147. JUDY says:

    Peanut butter ripple for the win!!!

  148. Heide Milbauer says:

    Absolutely, it’s Deep Dark Chocolate! My favorite ever!

  149. bpaine says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate – because it’ll be just for adults and we can slowly indulge, savoring each mouthful, while the kids amuse themselves with Party Cake and Pretzel Whatever. Add a drizzle of salted caramel, topped with pecans and whipped cream – and oh yes, oh YES! a cherry with a stem,add a handsome worldly grey-haired bespectacled scientist by a blazing fire – and well – you can imagine the rest….

  150. Jenni says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!! ๐Ÿ™‚

  151. Sue says:

    Deep dark chocolate – the things dreams are made of! And, Turkey Hill is so creamy! (Try it with mocha syrup……..)

  152. Martin C. Zellers says:

    Turkey Hill can’t be beat.
    A dip of their ice cream is a treat.
    Trying to decide which is best.
    Is asking a lot in this test.
    I love them, I love them all.
    But my palate puts chocolate on call.
    I go to the store and look around.
    Turkey Hill shines and deserves a crown.
    So Deep Dark Chocolate gets my vote.
    I hope it wins, thats why I wrote.

  153. Rebecca says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!! You get it all in one scoop. Succulent, satisfying, full of protein, and all you need to say “AHHHHH”!

  154. […] usually make a great combo, but in this match-up, they’re fierce freezer aisle opponents. Read full article Video: How to Make Chocolate for DippingHow to Make Chocolate for Dipping. Part of the […]

  155. Melinda S says:

    Lb ripple!

  156. Sherrie Davis says:

    Wow! What a tough decision. My two favorite things … peanut butter and chocolate! I guess if I had to vote it would be the peanut butter. Turkey Hill does such a great job of making such wonderful ice cream and other items too.

  157. April says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!! Delicious! <3

  158. Marion says:

    Deep Dark Delioious Chocolate!!!

  159. Igor says:

    My vote is for Peanut Butter Ripple……but my personal passion is Rum Rais1n.

  160. Kim says:

    Peanut butter ripple! What if turkey hill combined PB and deep dark chocolate?! That’d be a perfect combo

  161. thomas ciravolo says:

    deep dark chocolate has my vote.. add a few blueberries on the side and you have a meal

  162. Beth Runkle says:

    Peanut butter ripple – but I agree with Kim – combining the two would be fanTABulous!!!

  163. Sarah says:

    I dint think I would have survived my first pregnancy without Peanut Butter Ripple. ๐Ÿ™‚ Now if you could just bring back the obsession of my second pregnancy: Ginger Snap!

  164. ann says:

    peanut butter ripple has my vote ๐Ÿ™‚

  165. Melinda says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple please!

  166. Donna says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  167. cheryl williams says:

    Peanut butter ripple that is my vote.

  168. Wanda Conrad says:

    I choose peanut butter ripple. I love chocolate too!!A combo of both would be fantastic!

  169. ellie leshansky says:

    It has to be Deep Dark Chocolate. What is more delicious than chocolate?

  170. Vicki Vilchek says:

    Deep DARK Chocolate!! (I love Box of Chocolates also!!)

  171. Tracy says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, though I see I’m in the minority just now.

  172. MIKE JONES says:


  173. Heather Risser says:

    Peanut buttle ripple!!!!!!! Yummy!!!!!!!

  174. Fran says:

    It really is a tough decision because both are so scrumptious! However, if I must – I will have to put my vote in on Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate. Soooo Good!

  175. LuAnn says:

    Love both. But I love Peanut Butter. SobPeanut Butter Ripple is my vote. And, if dark chocolate wins I will still love Turkey Hill!!

  176. Laura says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!!!

  177. Pam says:

    How can the classic peanut butter ripple with it’s creamy vanilla backdrop not win- hands down? It’s the best!!

  178. Marie says:

    Peanut butter ripple is the absolute best!!

  179. Patti Harmon says:

    You can never go wrong with chocolate so Deep Dark Chocolate is the winner!

  180. pete says:

    The world of sweets has always been dominated by just one thing and that has been proven time and time again. When you want to relax and let your worries vanish you turn to chocolate. Turkey Hill has afforded us this opportunity by giving the world DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE SO SIT BACK AND ENJOY LIFE AS IT IS MEANT TO BE….Great contest but the outcome was never in doubt…..

  181. Shelly Kozel says:

    Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter would be my ultimate favorite!

  182. leslie says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple please!!!

  183. Barbara Kesterson says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is definitely a winner.

  184. Ellen Barkman says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple (I can always put Chocolate Ice cream on on top if I want)! Yum!

  185. BarbK says:

    Deep dark chocolate is my vote. I can add peanut butter to other flavors myself, but to have the very rich flavor, it has to come from the dairy.

  186. r says:

    What’s beyond Ultimate?

  187. Sarah says:

    Deep dark Chocolate gets my vote!!

  188. Sarah W says:

    There is no flavor that can top Deep Dark Chocolate!!

  189. don bradley says:

    this chocolate is the best. mixing them together sounds appealing.

  190. andrea says:

    DEEP DARK CHOC. Absolutely!!!

  191. Glenn Uhler says:

    Regular flavors are great, but adding the peanut butter ripple texture puts Peanut Butter ripple over the top!

  192. Kris says:

    Chocolate will win! I love peanut butter but am not a fan of the vanilla it’s mixed with. Can’t go wrong when you mix chocolate with chocolate! ๐Ÿ™‚

  193. Barry Pile says:

    Come on, it’s no contest – Peanut Butter Ripple all the way. It’s good for you and helps you too!

  194. hillary says:

    deep dark chocolate – all the way… yummy!

  195. Cheryl says:

    Chocolate is yummy!

  196. T.Taylor says:

    peanut butter ripple by a landslide!

  197. Eva says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple ALL THE WAY!

  198. Michelle Coles says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!

  199. Linda M says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate just sounds so decadent how can you not choose that. I think that you should combine the two for a new flavor Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, sounds heavenly. I might just try to mix the two myself!

  200. James says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  201. NDNative says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple….

  202. Anne L. says:

    Peanut butter is okay, but nothing goes with chocolate better than more chocolate!

  203. Regina says:

    Wow, Deep Dark Chocolate is in the lead but it’s so sad that the champion might be a Limited Edition and we’ll have to wait until September to celebrate the victory.

  204. jan says:

    So glad to see deep dark chocolate in the final two. Hopefully it WINS,i’m definitely not a fan of peanut butter

  205. jeff says:

    deep cho is the best

  206. Kellie Kale says:

    I love your deep dark chocolate ice cream. Turkey Hill ice cream is a staple at our house.

  207. Nancy Miller says:

    Peanut butter ripple but of course!

  208. lois says:

    Absolutely Peanut Butter Ripple!!!

  209. Alyssa says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  210. Dave Town says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate HAS to be the winner!

  211. jim saylor says:

    peanut butter rips it

  212. Randy says:

    It’s hard to beat dark chocolate!

  213. nicole says:

    I really think that they would taste good together. Is there anyway you can make a combination flavor with both and then they both win? If not I think I would go with Deep Dark Chocolate but I do enjoy nuts in my chocolate! Our favorite is the Turkey Hill Ice Cream All Natural Chocolate and we add chocolate chips and walnuts. I would imagine that would be a great flavor!

  214. Linda Childers says:

    Definitely the dark chocolate. What’s better than chocolate? Oh, wait, that would be dark chocolate! We just love your lighter version of ice cream. We don’t even miss what’s missing. Thanks, and keep up the good work!

  215. KeriAnn Knoff says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way!!!

  216. Fran says:

    Deep, dark chocolate. Dark chocolate is good for you!

  217. Susan Eckers says:

    My choice would be to combine these two flavors. I love peanut butter and chocolate. Y U M M M !320

  218. Annie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  219. Nicole Shaffer says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  220. Martha Pullen says:

    Much as I am a peanut butter lover, I would have to choose the deep dark chocolate – nothing better than chocolate!

  221. Linda says:

    Peanut Butter for the win!

  222. Amanda says:

    Peanut butter ripple!!!

  223. Elizabeth says:

    If you combine the two I believe the flavor would make anyone believe they had died and gone to Heaven!

  224. love all things peanut butter! vanilla peanut butter ripple, pure & simple !

  225. willc says:

    Deep Dark Choc + PB ripple! it needs to happen

  226. Sue says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple please!!!!!

  227. Christie L says:

    I love peanut butter ripple!

  228. Michal OReilly says:

    Die hard Chocolate fan but have to give it to the Peanut Butter this time , there is no peanut butter ice cream that compares.

  229. Bonnie Filan says:

    Tough call. We love each flavor in our house. I’m going with peanut butter ripple but I truly believe Turkey Hill should create peanut butter deep dark chocolate ripple as a new limited edition to satisfy all taste buds.

  230. Llanda Lavender says:

    This was a hard one, but decided on PB Ripple. Now, if TH made a Deep Chocolate PB Role, think would cause massive brain explosion!

  231. Julianne Roybal says:

    My oldest son can’t have peanuts due to his allergy, therefore I voted for the Deep Dark Chocolate!

  232. Beth Mays says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  233. Krista says:

    Peanut butter ripple!!

  234. janet says:

    My very fav Turkey Hill Ice creams are the REAL ice creams that are All Natural No Additives. Wish you made them in more flavors.

  235. alicelynne says:

    I would have to vote for PB Ripple…just delicious!!!

  236. Shirley Cochran says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  237. Lori says:

    I vote for peanut brittle ripple. Peanut butter is always a winner in my book!

  238. Sasha Cory says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate for sure!

  239. Natalie says:

    Peanut Butter for sure!!!!

  240. Natalie says:

    Peanut Butter for certain!!!!

  241. Beth Rovenolt says:

    deep dark chocolate….I am salivating at the mere thought. yum

  242. Beth says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple – tasty protein!

  243. deep dark chocolate.

  244. Jane Imm says:

    Actually, I think a scoop of each in a bowl would be scrumtious!

  245. A.Shearer says:

    Peanut Butter ice cream is my favorite..Better yet..One scoop of Deap Dark Chocolate and one scoop of Peanut Butter..YUM!!

  246. Kaitlin Brown says:

    I have lived in Lancaster for all of my 27 years and peanut butter ripple had been one of my many many favorite Turkey Hill ice cream flavors for as long as I can remember! It is the BEST!

  247. Denise McCarthy says:

    Oh my goodness, I wish the two were combined. These are my 2 favorite flavors, but I would have to go with the PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE. (I can always add dark chocolate sauce). ๐Ÿ™‚

  248. Jane Imm says:

    Actually, I think a scoop of each would be scrumtious!

  249. Cheryl says:


  250. cathy says:

    Deep dark chocolate! It really is a hard decision because I love both! BUT if I have to choose I choose Deep Dark Chocolate! YUM!!Where is my spoon! LOL I need to run to the store and get some Ice Cream!!

  251. Liz Stark says:

    I think that Peanut Butter Ripple will win.

  252. Kevin Martin says:

    Deep dark Chocolate is King of the ice creams!

  253. starknitter says:

    I hope the Chocolate wins….and I hope I win too!

  254. laura says:

    Deep Dark DELICIOUS Chocolate.
    Melt in the mouth decadence, for young and old!

  255. Al Davis says:

    Peanut butter is classic comfort food we’ll savor in PEanut Butter Ripple but nothing beats the delicious decadence of Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  256. Mark says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate – because every bite will be chocolaty.

  257. Becky says:

    GOOOOO Peanut Butter!!

  258. Susan says:

    Deep Dark Chocholate for me!

  259. susan smoaks says:

    peanut butter ripple

  260. william costanzo says:

    I haven’t tried deep dark chocolate yet, they don’t have it in my stores at this time, I have tried peanut ripple and I loved it. an idea for that is to swirl some chocolate fudge in it. yum……..

  261. Barb Stenby says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate for the win!

  262. Patra Maher says:

    Peanut Butter in ice cream is such a special treat of sweet and salty blending. Hope it wins!

  263. Why Peanut Butter Ripple vs. Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate???

    It should Peanut Butter Ripple in Deep Dark Chocolate. That’s a champion to be made!!

  264. Dawn says:

    Chocolate is my pick but would love to see peanut butter rippled into that!

  265. Gretchen says:

    Deep dark chocolate to take it all. Who can possibly resist it’s dark beauty.

  266. Bill D says:


  267. AyanaR says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  268. Peter Young says:

    It has to be dark chocolate. Reading about all the health benefits of dark chocolate makes you feel much less guilty of life’s indulgences.. ๐Ÿ™‚

  269. Arthur Wicks says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  270. Craig says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple for the win!

  271. Edith says:

    Deep dark chocolate is my pick. I love dark chocolate and its about time its incorporated into an ice cream flavor!

  272. Janice R says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple but a very close call

  273. Gingo says:

    Another reason why Deep Dark Chocolate must be added to the YEAR Round flavors!!!!!

  274. Albert Kurtz says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, but what would be better is to combine them and have Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple.

  275. Brian Cooper says:

    If you had said DARK Chocolate, I wouldn’t have been impressed. Been there, done that. But DEEP DARK Chocolate? Yeah, I’m all in on that one!

  276. Arthur Wicks says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate of course…

  277. Gingo says:

    Another message being sent, that DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE must be added as a year round flavor !!!

  278. thomas says:

    just because it’s chocolate

  279. Debbie Lapinsky says:

    Turkey Hill ice cream is the best ice cream. It’s the only ice cream I buy for my family.

  280. CHRISTINE says:


  281. Dee Kilmer says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate wins every time!

  282. Darlene says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  283. Cyndi says:

    There are all sorts of chocolate ice cream flavors available. Time for a something different- Peanut Butter Ripple has my vote!

  284. Matt says:

    Dark Chocolate

  285. Max says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  286. Elaine Feuer says:

    Butter Almond natural is the best

  287. ashley cossette says:

    pleanut butter wins!!!

  288. Arianne Hargrove says:

    Peanut butter ripple is the absolute best. I love the great peanut butter flavor.

  289. isabella woo says:

    deep dark chocolate no brainer!

  290. Judy F. says:

    Both are winners in my book.

  291. this is the best ice cream! says:

    this is the only ice cream i buy!

  292. Chris says:

    I love peanut butter, but I have to go with deep dark chocolate!

  293. Debbie says:


  294. Karen Carew says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate has to win – chocolate is good for you!

  295. Deep Dark Chocolate!!! Although mixing the two together would be good too!

  296. Jackie says:

    It’s a hard choice because they are both such great flavors, but I’m a chocolate girl, so I go with the Deep Dark Chocolate!

  297. Margaret Smith says:

    I had to go with the Deep Dark Chocolate, but this was really a hard choice ๐Ÿ™‚

  298. Peter says:

    Peanut Butter ripple is the obvious winner here. Deep chocolate is a Cinderella at best and I think the clock just struck 12.

  299. Cynthia Cain says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way please!!!!

  300. Chanda W. says:

    Why can’t we all just get along? Paired together, the two would make a wonderful couple, would they not? Let’s vote “TIE”, and eat them both!!! YUM!!!

  301. Claire Godfrey says:

    Since I always chose the “Special Dark” bar out of the Hershey’s assorted chocolates bag, I will have to go with the Deep Dark Chocolate. Love, love, love it.

  302. Shelly Brubaker says:

    I’d have to be completely nuts not to vote for Peanut Butter Ripple…YUMMALICIOUS!!!

  303. Susan says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate for sure! ๐Ÿ™‚

  304. Richelle M. says:

    Peanut Butter ripple. Love PB!!!

  305. Donna Berube says:

    Peanut butter ripple wins hands down! ! Love it <3

  306. Amyy says:

    C’mon peanut butter lovers! What is better than peanut butter in ice cream???

  307. Linda T says:

    Goin’ with the Deep Dark Chocolate! Make me proud.

  308. Laurie Olzinski says:

    It’s hard to chose but I will go with Deep Dark Chocolate…

  309. rhoda says:

    Peanut butter is health food, I’snt it?

  310. Linda Comins says:

    This is a tough decision! But I’ll go with the peanut butter ripple. yum!

  311. greg says:

    Without a doubt, chocolate.

  312. Ron DiRisio says:

    God Bless Chocolate………God Bless Peanut Butter….God Bless Turkey Hill!

  313. Robin says:

    Got to go with the chocolate…peanut butter and chocolate is my all time favorite but peanut butter and vanilla just doesn’t make the “bang” I’m looking for. So, chocolate it is!

  314. Ellie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate. I eat ice cream every night before going to bed. As my mother always used to say “There’s always room for ice cream – it fills in the crackes

  315. Michele R. says:

    Peanut butter ripple.

  316. Marty says:

    Tough final match. Gotta go with Chocolate, but it may be best to combine the chocolate with the peanut butter! I know chocolate peanut butter won before, but I would vote for a repeat!

  317. Lisa says:

    SO hard to decide… but my heart says deep dark chocolate!

  318. Victoria Wagner says:

    Well, not a peanut butter fan so will have to vote for chocolate. I do wish people would reach out a bit and go for some new flavors rather than these same old types.

  319. Jen Smoot says:

    Peanut ripple for sure

  320. Sarah says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the best ice cream ever, in fact it’s so good, it was the food of the Greek gods before it was banned partly because it was so awesome and mere mortals kept trying to steal it from them, and partly because Hera thought everyone needed to go on a diet so she made them give up their peanut butter ripple ice cream in exchange for some repulsive melty liquid substance called Ambrosia, which made all the gods sulky.

    Actually, Prometheus thought he was stealing Peanut Butter Ripple ice cream to give to the poor suffering humans instead of fire. Frankly, Zeus wouldn’t have cared if Prometheus had simply stolen some lame thunderbolts, but the fact that he tried to steal Zeus’ private stash of peanut butter ripple ice cream was the unpardonable sin that got him chained to a mountain while vultures attacked him every day for eternity (until Hercules came along…btw, how do you think Hercules got so strong? duh, PBR).

  321. Carolyn says:

    Can I vote for both? Combined they would be heavenly!!!!!!!!!!!!

  322. Miriam Sollenberger says:

    Peanut Butter is the best. Can’t beat the taste.

  323. Don Desfosse says:

    Or? What is this you speak of, more? I don’t care how many votes either one gets. They are BOTH champions in my mind! I look forward to your announcement of the TIE!!

  324. Jill landers says:

    Chocolate! Always chocolate!!

  325. judy says:

    Peanut butter ripple

  326. chris says:

    Nobody doesn’t like extreme chocolate!

  327. Gabriele Wood says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple.

  328. robin says:

    is there any doubt?? of course deep dark chocolate is the winner! chocolate says it the very best!!!

  329. Jeffrey says:

    Why just pick one when they are soo good together ?so I’m off to pickup both of them for a well needed treat !

  330. I see how these two became the FRONT RUNNERS of this “taste off!” I mean really, peanut butter? The most near perfect food ever created, good taste, great source of protien, recommended by most mom’s as a go to dietary staple and did I mention, is just DELICIOUS!? It IS! THEN on the other hand, here we have the always desired DARK Chocolate, a chocolate connoisseur’s DREAM! Combined, there could be NO OTHER CHOICE, but each, on their own has serious sustenance how can one choose? Well, here goes….the coin is in the air….wait for it…………..ah, a worthy win for sure, DARK CHOCOLATE!

  331. Edward W. Rummel says:

    I’ve always preferred chocolate when I have apple pie ala mode. Deep Dark Chocolate is even better and healthier!

  332. Orlenda says:

    Well-looks like PB is loosing…oh poor PB…come here, I’ll put you in my freezer! Dont cry-we’ll just tell the other ice cream cartons that its condensation…

  333. Kathy says:

    No doubt about it – it will always be chocolate — and there’s nothing better in the world than dark chocolate!!

  334. Diana says:

    I just love anything with peanut butter! And the more PB swirls throughout, all the better!

  335. Edward W. Rummel says:

    What the Peanut Butter Ripple still needs is some chocolate ripple to go with it! Call it Chocolate-Peanut Butter Ripple!

  336. rhonda says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!

  337. John says:

    Peanut butter is good but you can’t beat a good dark chocolate.

  338. Karl Rahmer says:

    They say that chocolate is very healthy for you, particularly dark chocolate. However, Peanut Butter is the deep dark desire in all (most) of us. Couldn’t agree more….can we get a “Deep dark Peanut Butter?” Ha But I think in the end I have to sway on the side of Peanut Butter! Yumm…. Looking forward to the final results! Hands down…..PEANUT BUTTER! (I can nibble on chocolate to stay healthy!)

  339. Janice says:

    Wouldn’t it be great that everyone that voted for the flavor that won got a coupon for a free container of that ice cream…?

  340. Rita G says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate! Yum

  341. Kathy says:

    I would like both in the same cup!!!
    I would have to CHOCOLATE

  342. Edward W. Rummel says:

    How about Deep Dark Chocolate with ripples of peanut butter? Call it Deep Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple and get both favorites in the same dish!

  343. LMoore says:

    Easy answer – both are the best, so, make a mash up of the two into one container. Win-Win.

  344. Marvin says:

    Oh my goodness how I love Deep Dark Chocolate! It just doesn’t get any better!

  345. mary lichty says:

    Now who would not like a dark chocolate.The very best

  346. Donna says:

    Chocolate and peanut butter goes so well together. You have to go with your heart, and your gut, as to which should be the winner!

  347. Carrie Shoults says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate Yummy!

  348. Glen says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple Rules

  349. Jack McElwee says:

    Chocolate forever and they can add anything to it except marshmallow or bacon! I am a choc-a-holic as much as I am an anime-a-holic! When the final decision is made though, the winning flavour will be featured as dessert aboard our Lovely Angel 2 patrol starship in my latest fanfiction Places Between the Stars at fanfiction.net/anime/dirtypair/keimanandkei or at noveljoy.com/anime/dirtypair/keimanandkei or just check my Facebook, Twitter, animeleague, Google+ or if you’re over 50 my Anime Fanatics at AARP! Go chocolate!!- Jack/keimanzero/keiman0
    Campbelltown PA USA

  350. Lois Black says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  351. Suzanne says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate

  352. Yvonne says:

    Deep dark chocolate (and add a scoop of orange sherbert)

  353. Chet Knotts says:

    There’s got to be something in my ice cream so I have to vote for Peanut Butter Ripple!!

  354. Chuck Hollenbach says:

    No question about it. Dark Choc is the winner.

  355. Leon Pilewski says:

    Two worthy opponents! As coaches would say, there is no loser here! Go PB Ripple.

  356. Edith Cuttler says:

    Wed to a man that will make a peanut butter sandwich “after” a great meal,and so I cast a vote for the peanut butter ripple. Hubby won’t even be tempted to reach for the bread, just the bowl, ice cream scoop and the peanut butter ripple!

  357. Dawn Streeter says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  358. Margaret says:

    Choco choco chocolate!! Mmmmmhmm

  359. emma says:

    Nothing beats chocolate!!!!

  360. barbara says:

    glad to see chocolate is ahead

  361. Dan says:

    I live in UT so we don’t get those flavors out here. I would go with Deep Dark Chocolate cause peanut butter for me is something that you get to a point in eating it where it doesn’t taste the same. It has a single serving taste limit where chocolate does not. I can eat a great chocolate shake using a whole container of chocolate.

  362. Judy says:

    well, it’s not the two I would have chosen for the finale, but we all can’t have a team in the Super Bowl, can we?? Chocolate it is then, and may the best man win!! Good luck to both contenders…

  363. Matt Schultz says:

    Both are fine flavors, but my kids would much prefer Blitzburgh Crunch. However you should consider marketing it under another name. Touching anything Steeler related makes me feel ill.

  364. Deep Dark Chocolate should win. No other brand has this. Think of the antioxidants that are doing you good when you eat dark chocolate to all ice cream lovers. Moo Moo to Turkey Hill!

  365. Roger J Hudak says:

    Having given up faster cars, younger women, tobacco, and booze, my final vice in life is Turkey Hill’s Deep Dark Chocolate. It is a passion, a joy, and a reward for a day well spent and lfe well lived. Love it!

  366. Kay says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple hands down!!!!!!!!!

  367. Kay says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, hands down!!!!!!!!!

  368. Tamara Williams says:

    Chocolate is the best!

  369. Lynn Dobriko says:

    Limited Deep Dark Chocolate, please.

  370. Jandy says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, please!

  371. Diane says:

    Turkey Hill PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE is the very best!!

  372. Angela M. Nice says:

    How to judge perfection???well I’ll base it in the one that disappears first in my house. PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE!!! GO TEAM RIPPLE! With 2 teen boys in the house, if you get the chance to actually “see” ice cream in the freezer it’s only because the store didn’t have Turkey Hill there! Thanks, from a mom who can only eat ice cream during school hours! ๐Ÿ™‚

  373. Lauren G says:

    I wish you could mash the 2 together, but I guess you have to go with the dark chocolate on this one.

  374. Meredith says:

    I can’t stop eating the PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE…just one more spoonful of the vanilla then one more spoonful of the peanut butter…and on and on it goes!

  375. Katie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!

  376. Ted says:

    The experts have been saying for years that you should eat Dark Chocolate for your health — Turkey Hill is just trying to help keep us healthy!

  377. Lisel says:

    Coming from a house of chocaholics I would vote for Deep Dark Chocolate! Plus you could market it as a healthy choice of ice creams . . . don’t doctors recommend a healthy dose of dark chocolate daily?;-)

  378. Joan M. says:

    PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE for sure!!!!! I keep my freezer stocked with it!

  379. Jessica says:

    DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE!!! Such a hard choice, but gotta go with a gal’s best friend!!! I love chocolate!

  380. Ann W. says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way!!! Even scientists say dark chocolate is healthier for you ๐Ÿ™‚

  381. Tim Maier says:

    Summer and Turkey Hill Ice Cream….. I can’t wait!

  382. Joseph Stewart, Jr. says:

    One more vote for Peanut Butter Ripple. It’s one of the best that Turkey has come out with!

  383. Kara F says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!

  384. Elmer Shaw says:

    Chocolate anytime any where!!!

  385. Paul says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the only flavor for me.
    I eat 30-40 oz. of peanut butter per week. I have it on everything, an I mean everything.
    I would vote for peanut butter ripple, but You need to figure a way to disperse the peanut more evenly
    thru the ice cream.

  386. Donald W Sponsler says:

    Love, love, love me some Peanut Butter Ripple!

  387. Alaina says:

    I love peanut butter!!…so definitely the peanut butter one. Total comfort food.

  388. Roger says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way baby!! When something is this good, nothing can stop it from taking the ultimate prize, first place in the tournament and our flavor list. You are the champion of the world, go DDC go!!

  389. Deep Dark Chocolate is the richest, most delectable, and incredibly delicious ice cream ever.

  390. Tim Maier says:

    DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE will win. I have tried both finalists, and I think that Deep Dark Chocolate will win by a scoop!

  391. amy says:


  392. Lisa Pleva says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple – its a total nostalgic experience for me

  393. Diane Rabold says:

    Nothing better than Peanut Butter!!!!

  394. angie r. says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  395. Betty Waliczek says:

    Wow! Combine them and I can have the best of both worlds!

  396. Cheryl says:

    Chocolate of course!!!

  397. Beth Hosler says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  398. Denise Franke says:

    Peanut butter!

  399. Patty says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate all the way!!!

  400. debbie says:

    Combining them both would be best! Otherwise, I’d choose chocolate!

  401. There is no got there can only be one winner that’s hands down deep dark chocolate

  402. rose buns says:

    Deep. Dark. Chocolate. ๐Ÿ™‚

  403. Andrew says:

    DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE IS THE BEST EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  404. Juliet O says:


  405. susan p says:

    Well what a blast to vote for our favorite ice cream flavors. I’m so glad Deep dark chocolate made it the final two. How exciting to see who is the favorite, can’t wait. How turkey hill eating everbody.

  406. Ed Leslie says:

    MMMMM!!! Who doesn’t love chocolate ?

  407. Chocaholics unite!!!

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the Best!!

  408. Bill Rahn says:

    This is a tough one I have been eating peanut butter ripple for years but the Dark Chocolate is just so good. Could I eat it regularly for years like the peanut butter ripple? I think so.

  409. Kristin says:

    Go pb!! I could really use some right now lol

  410. Sharon Kulkis says:

    Gotta be Deep Dark Chocolate

  411. Lori says:

    Deep dark chocolate. Can you make it a regular and not seasonal since it is in the final?

  412. Leigh Ann says:

    Love the peanut butter ripple!!!!

  413. Michah Gordon says:

    chocolate…yum….the more the merrier…

  414. Circuitous says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple of course! Or a scoop of each, please!

  415. James R. Crouse says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple gets my vote. I also want to thank Turkey Hill for bringing the goodness of Lancaster County all the way to our Kroger stores in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Keep the coupons coming, too!

  416. rl says:

    peanut butter all the way (then I would buy the deep chocolate and just mix the two)

  417. jean whiting says:

    Oh, by all means Deep Dark Chocolate! I’m a fan of Extreme Cookies and Cream; this sounds even better!

  418. Jay Tice says:

    You can’t go wrong with any kind of chocolate.

  419. jean whiting says:


  420. I didn’t know you had peanut butter ice cream but we would likeit

  421. Debbie Maser says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple of course! Love! Love! Love! Turkey Hill and all the great flavors!!!

  422. Richard HARVEY says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate wins the contest by at least a mile!

  423. Rich Rampolla says:

    Nothihng bad about deep, dark chocolate but peanut butter ripplicious – yum

  424. Pam C says:

    Peanut butter ripple

  425. peanut butter ripple

  426. Maeve S. says:

    Definity the peanut butter ripple!! ๐Ÿ™‚

  427. Mary says:

    Peanut butter forever!!!! ๐Ÿ™‚ ๐Ÿ™‚ ๐Ÿ™‚

  428. Joanne says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple! Yum-o!!

  429. Scott says:

    PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE is the best

  430. Heather says:

    Deep Dark chocolate sounds so delicious! What a great flavor idea!

  431. RebeccaH says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is always a winner–hands down!

  432. bonnie says:

    PB, you just can’t go wrong!!!

  433. Nancy Whiting says:

    I think Deep Dark Chocolate is going to be the winner. Everyone likes chocolate!

  434. S. Diehm says:

    Gotta go with chocolate!

  435. Gloria Bandy says:

    I vote for the peanut butter ripple, but would love to see a combination of the two of them.

  436. Diane says:

    You call that a contest? Everybody knows that chocolate (the deeper, the darker, the better) rules the world!!! ๐Ÿ˜‰

  437. Mike Cavanaugh says:

    Deep”dark”chocolate, at last a delicious treat that is “healthy” too!

  438. eileen says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate, of course!!!!!!!!!!!

  439. Kriste says:

    I vote for Deep Dark Chocolate! But mixed with peanut butter would be heavenly!

  440. alex says:

    deep dark chocolate all the way, hands down.

  441. viki ley says:

    Peanut butter ripple takes it

  442. Leah White says:

    Peanut butter ripple- it is one of the only peanut butter ice creams without chocolate.

  443. Yvonne says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!

  444. clayton white says:

    PB ripple

  445. Emily says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!!

  446. chase kellough says:

    peanut butter ripple

  447. Laurie says:

    Deep dark chocolate: yes I’m a chocoholic and proud to admit it ๐Ÿ™‚

  448. Kathleen says:

    Love the chocolate! Love Turkey Hill even more!

  449. Lauren uribe says:

    Deep dark chocolate. …makes me smile and fills me with hope.

  450. Lisa Walinski says:

    Turkey Hill is the only company that makes Peanut Butter Ripple, when we see it , we stick up!

  451. Harold Barlett` says:

    Peanut butter ripple wins hands down with me!

  452. Paula says:

    Deep dark chocolate for the win. Nothing can touch the smooth deep flavor of a decadent chocolate!

  453. Amy Romansky says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate! Mmmmm!

  454. J Byrne says:

    Deep dark chocolate is the best!

  455. Tina Truex says:

    Love them both but Peanut Butter Ripple.

  456. Michele Bauer says:

    peanut butter. at least you can drizzle chocolate on it

  457. Marilyn Malcarne says:

    Oh please make the winner Deep Dark Chocolate, then I can put Just Goodies peanut butter on it.
    Pure dairy heaven

  458. Portia says:

    Deep dark chocolate!!!!

  459. Lisa Jacobs says:

    Deep ark chocolate all the way! Yum!

  460. Portia says:

    Deep dark chocolate!!!

  461. Anita says:

    Definitely peanut butter ripple….served with hot fudge sauce!

  462. Jack Sofield says:

    Think of the great shake you can make with two scoops of deep dark chocolate in a glass of milk. ummmm.

  463. Jo says:

    Deep dark chocolate – yum!

  464. adonna cross says:

    peanut butter ripple for me!

  465. Sandy Rosenberg says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate, though I was just in Lancaster and purchased your BOX OF CHOCOLATES flavor! oh my goodnessโ€ฆ.It was so good we couldn’t bear to leave it when we returned home to NYC so we packed it in ice in a cooler and brought it backโ€ฆhaven’t seen that flavor here and needed to enjoy the yumminess at home.

  466. Janice says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is as good as it can be,
    and since I have to choose,
    that’s the one for me.

  467. Steven M says:

    mmmmmmmmmm chocolate

  468. Sandy Rosenberg says:

    Deep Dark Chocolateโ€ฆthough your BOX OF CHOCOLATES which I just purchased in Lancaster is AMAZINGโ€ฆso good we had to take it home with us in the car to NYCโ€ฆpacked in ice in a coolerโ€ฆ.made it homeโ€ฆfirst thing we ate when we got thereโ€ฆ.TURKEY HILL BOX OF CHOCOLATES ICE CREAM!

  469. Ellen B Wentzel says:

    I vote for Dark Chocolate. Can’t wait to get some.

  470. Alice Kintisch says:

    It’s SO hard to choose! But I have to cast my vote to Deep Dark Chocolate! Either one is a winner in my opinion!

  471. Melanie Diehl says:

    I wish I could have tried the Deep Dark Chocolate but none of the three supermarkets in my rural area had it. My one closet store tried ordering it for me but couldn’t get it. Why is that? I would love to know why you make these great flavors and limit who can get them.

  472. Pamela Nesbitt says:

    Yes-Deep Dark Chocolate for those days when nothing else will satisfy.

  473. Melissa McGovern says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the very best turkey hill flavor ever!! I wish it were a permanent flavor.

  474. Deep Dark Chocolate !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  475. Constance R says:

    definitely chocolate

  476. Terri says:

    Peanut butter ripple!! Topped with Hershey’s syrup ๐Ÿ™‚

  477. Mary says:

    Double dunker!

  478. bonnie Gilbert says:

    I definitely vote for thr peanut butter ripple. Imagine how awesome with hot fudge,

  479. Terry says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate …. a sure winner !!!

  480. Kim hardway says:

    Go peanut butter!!! Yum!!!

  481. Susan B says:

    No contest! DEEP Deep delicious Dark Chocolate for the win!

  482. Stephen Logan says:

    I like chocolate but I vote for Peanut Butter Ripple !!I can’t wait to try it out.

  483. Larissa says:

    There’s just something about peanut butter mixed in with ice cream. Always so delicious.

  484. Daria P. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, because I prefer vanilla as the base for ice cream. It tastes fresher. The peanut butter is a nice protein addition. More food groups are covered, making this flavor healthier. That’s my excuse for eating a big bowl of ice cream every day. ;->

  485. Suzanna Eisenhour says:

    I honestly wanted to vote for PEanut Butter Ripple because I love peanut butter, but on the other hand I love chocolate too & I didn’t know you had a Deep Dark Chocolate flavor. So saying all of that I think you should make a Deep Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple………that would be YUMMY!!!

  486. Barbara Bolam says:

    I haven’t met a Turkey Hill flavor that I haven’t liked!

  487. Robert Scheid says:

    Deep dark chocolate covered with chocolate syrup. The only way to go.

  488. Brian says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  489. Maureen says:

    Anything chocolate wins hands down!

  490. Clou09 says:


  491. brie rivera says:

    peanut butter ripple!

  492. chris fezell says:

    Who needs the Q when you’ve got the T. Hill! Your Peanut butter and cream are rippled perfectly to satisfy me anytime.

  493. Linda W. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!

  494. Sibyl says:

    Not peanuts without chocolate. That’s just wrong! So it has to be the deep chocolate.

  495. Nicole B. says:

    Dark chocolate all of the time.

  496. David says:


  497. holly mccaddin says:

    Looks like deep dark chocolate is winning! Yeah! This is the best ice cream ever! We love almost all of your flavors, keep up the great work!

  498. brooke says:

    peanut butter ripple out does any flavor ๐Ÿ™‚

  499. nicole kaplan says:

    mix them both half and half in a container, that would be ultimate

  500. Milagros says:


  501. matt says:

    my girlfriend buys me this flavor and I absolutely love it

  502. Linda says:

    I like both flavors & would love to see them combined (Deep Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple – yum!).

  503. A M says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  504. BettyG says:

    Definitely Peanut Butter Ripple!

  505. Andrea says:

    The chocolate looks totally decadent!

  506. Adrienne Mimassian says:

    Any flavor of Turkey Hill makes me happy but my favorite is still Phillies Graham Slam!

  507. Mike says:

    MMMMmmmm Deep Dark Chocolate .. Gotta WIN!!

  508. Sona Damergy says:

    Peanut butter is a great source of protein and I don’t have to worry about not being able to sleep when I eat it at night…not to mention ,it’s so delicious with the generous swirls of peanut butter. Peanut butter is the clear winner to me!

  509. Ted says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate should take it all!

  510. pipfrod says:

    There is just nothing better than a very deep, very dark chocolate to elevate my spirits and leave me wanting more and more.

  511. scott senn says:

    I could use a big bowl of ice cream right now.

  512. Sona Damergy says:

    Love, love, love, peanut butter and swirled in delicious vanilla Turkey Hill Ice Cream is the BEST!

  513. Eileen Fleshel says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate sounds AWESOME!

  514. Mark says:

    Both sound great, but I have to go with the Peanut Butter Ripple.

  515. Regina Furman says:

    Gotta be the chocolate first! Of course you could always make a chocolate “surprise” loaf, with Deep Dark Chocolate surrounding a core of Peanut Butter Ripple! That way there are no arguments in the family! ๐Ÿ™‚

  516. Christy says:

    deep dark chocolate is awesome!! Thank you Turkey Hill for making great flavors. (Only the peanut butter ones are not so good in my mind)

  517. edward says:

    where else can you get help for your heart by picking chocolate as the best

  518. Myrna says:

    Deep dark chocolate sounds wonderful. I love dark chocolate and try to have a piece everyday. I’m sure the ice cream would be great to have everyday.

  519. Ellen Laube says:

    Dark Chocolate

  520. Kim Emerick says:

    I love all TH ice cream…..you can’t go wrong with any of them, but anything w/chocolate wins over PB in my book!

  521. Cami Emerick says:

    I am a HUGE Turkey Hill IC fan. My fav happens to be Dutch Chocolate, but these two flavors are great, too!

  522. Krysti says:

    Peanut butter ripple!

  523. bonnie says:

    can’t live without chocolate!!!!!!!

  524. Deb Watras says:

    Chocolate of course!

  525. joan milby says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple reminds me of my childhood when my Dad came home from his evening shift at work and we sat at the kitchen counter with our peanut butter sandwiches. He never let me forget that I always asked him to “wrap it up Daddy” which was my way of getting him to fold each piece of bread in half. At 78 I still remember those good times with my dad and our peanut butter sandwiches snack. To me, peanut butter has always been a comfort food and what better way to enjoy some comfort than with some wonderful Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple!

  526. Jean says:

    deep, dark chocolate… swirled with maple walnut…and chunks of sugared walnuts…now THAT’S worth splurging on!

  527. Kathleen says:

    Peanut butter ripple strikes a good balance between the high quality TH vanilla and gooey sinful peanut butter!

  528. Lisa Kerstein says:

    Deep dark Chocolate-chocolate is the best and dark makes it a bit more healthy too.

  529. jeanne blauner says:

    go deep with deep dark choocolate!

  530. T. Bing says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple Definitely!!!!

  531. Barbara Sheaffer says:

    LOVE both flavors very much ! They would be terrific mixed together.
    My favorite would have to be “Peanut ripple” all the way !!!

  532. Lisa Kerstein says:

    Deep dark chocolate is the best. Also, we all know that dark chocolate is a bit healthier. Therefore great flavor and nutritious.

  533. Scott says:

    Peanut butter ripple! PB and delicious vanilla ice cream…how could you go wrong??

  534. Joyce says:

    I’m a die hard chocaholic. Can’t get enough of that chocolate!!
    Deep dark chocolate wins hands down!!

  535. Christina Gilbert says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate, I miss the old Dark Chocolate ice cream ,you used to make.

  536. Dorene says:

    Hard to decide, but I went with the peanut butter!

  537. Don says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate ice cream for a year , now that would be Heaven !

  538. Bonnie says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate…. I have something chocolate every day!!!

  539. John Builes says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple.

  540. Mike says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the fav in our house.

  541. Chip says:

    Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate, Deep Dark Chocolate. Need I say more?
    Ok, then I will……..

    NOTHING beats the awesome taste of DARK CHOCOLATE!

  542. Pattie Annoni says:

    I think the Deep Dark Chocolate. Turkey Hill got me through Chemo ,when I couldnt taste anything I would grab my Turkey Hill, a plastic spoon and eat untill I couldnt eat anymore!!

  543. Lauren Southard says:

    Dark chocolate can’t be beat.

  544. nan mory says:

    turkey hill deep dark chocolate is the number one choice
    every night!

  545. Sue W says:

    Vote for Chocolate
    But there are no losers in this house. We mix them!

  546. carol frey says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is delicious, but my husband loves Deep Dark Choclate so we have to buy both!

  547. Jack says:

    Yes, chocolate is good but NOTHING beats the taste of THIS peanut butter ripple.

  548. Joe says:

    Peanut butter goes with almost anything. Toast, bananas, celery, et. Can you imagine how good it is with ice cream? It’s unbelievable.

  549. Curly_Q says:

    Both I hope, would make a great mix…..

  550. Mike M says:

    Both flavors are okay, a bit mundane, but not bad. In fact, there aren’t many flavors that Turkey Hill makes that couldn’t be winners. I don’t like cherries, so anything containing said offending fruit is out, and because certain foods and/or beverages are just meant to be consumed a certain way, anything containing coffee *MUST* be HOT! Serving java any other way is just plain vulgar. :-รž

    Personally, I would have liked to see one of the more exotic, limited editions go all the way (such as the seasonal Pumpkin Pie or Egg Nog), Peanut Butter Ripple and Deep Dark Chocolate may as well just have been Vanilla. Ah…but I digress. Give me a scoop of each, please. ๐Ÿ™‚

  551. How difficult would solving world problems be if we each were enjoying a big bowl of chocolate ice cream?

  552. Venetia Botker says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the winner for me…yum!!!!!!!!!!!!

  553. Art M. says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate. Absolutely! No doubt about it. Just because it is.

  554. lisa erkenbrack says:

    Peanut butter

  555. M. Brown says:

    One can NEVER have too much chocolate and the darker the better…..for medicinal reasons, of course…….it’s Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  556. Adele Rey says:

    Chocolate has been a long time favorite of all nations; and with The Top ice cream brand Turkey Hill bringing forth the most rich and creamy of all chocolates, two favorites become one. A perfect marriage, and thus The Perfect Choice.

  557. jim z says:

    Combime them and make peanut butter cup the real winner

  558. Jessica Gold says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple and Chocolate, together!!!

  559. jan brubaker says:

    peanut butter–the best of these 2 but all time favorite is double dunker.

  560. Bill Webb says:

    Dark Chocolate is the bestest!

  561. Patsy says:

    Love, love chocolate! Please consider adding mocha chips to this or the coffee ice cream. Would love to have all flavors in “natural” as I and others have food additive allergies. The natural is best anyway!

  562. Valerie says:

    Hmmm, I’ll say the Deep Dark Chocolate . . but I’d really, really, really like to mix them together : )

  563. SD Hornback says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple for the win! (hopefully)

  564. Dee says:

    Yummy dark chocolate!

  565. Bill r says:

    Dark Chocolate always

  566. Cheryl PD says:

    One can NEVER have too much chocolate! Deep and Dark?? Yes please!

  567. You have the yummiest Ice Cream and I like all I tasted.

  568. joe atchison says:

    The Deep Dark Secret is that the “Deep Dark Chocolate” should claim the Championship that it so rightfully deserves. Try it with or without peanut butter on top. You will love it.

  569. Geeta Soriano says:

    It’s the best deserve to win – “Deep Dark Chocolate”. yummmm

  570. Paula says:

    Dark chocolate anything has always been my favorite. But dark chocolate ice cream doesnโ€™t get any deeper than this. I love it!

  571. Rosemarie Umstead says:

    Deep, dark chocolate…yummmmm…..its the best!

  572. Judy Pekarthy says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the best. So chocolatey delicious and so good for you, too.

  573. Vanessa says:

    Deep, dark chocolate sounds amazing

  574. Diane Harper says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate, for sure!

  575. Sidney Weiss says:

    I”m for the peanuts!! There is nothing like the distinctive taste of peanuts. Peanutbutter Ice cream gets my vote!!!

  576. Shannon B says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is my vote! Would like to see what mixing the deep dark chocolate w/the peanut butter ripple would taste like! ๐Ÿ™‚

  577. Valerie Behlmer says:

    If we are down to these two then it has to be Deep, Dark Chocolate. Not a peanutbutter fan. Yum to Deep, Dark Chocolate.

  578. Alyssa says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  579. Jonathan says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple sounds like a real winner!

  580. Eric says:

    Going to have to go with Peanut Butter Ripple… it ain’t no all natural mint choc chip, but scrumdiddilyumptios nonetheless!

  581. Ann Murphy says:

    Peanut butter ripple……..love it!

  582. Twyla says:

    What! This is a no-brainer! Deep dark chocolate to infinity and beyond!

  583. Kathleen Walther says:

    Love peanut butter, but it had its year lady year. Let’s give chocolate an equal run. I say chocolate, chocolate, CHOCOLATE
    ALL THE WAY!! But….I really LOVED the key lime pie flavor !!

  584. Amy says:

    Neither of these two flavors really pull me in, but if I had to choose I would have to go with peanut butter. Wish that my favorite, cookies and cream, had made the finals instead!

  585. Lew says:

    You can’t go wrong with peanut butter.

  586. PEANUT BUTTER is 98% perfect ice cream, but topwith your favorite JELLY, and its 100%!

  587. Mike says:

    There is nothing better than Peanut Butter Ripple with a few hard pretzels on the side.

  588. Karen says:

    Deep dark chocolate out of these two choices…yes!

  589. christine says:

    deep dark chocolate has my vote

  590. Marian says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!! Have loved dark chocolate candy forever and this is totally yummy!!!

  591. Karen Lassiter says:

    Peanut Butter has had its day
    Chocolate, Chocolate all the way !!!

  592. Jodi Webb says:

    My son (11 yrs. old) and I had a quick consult and we vote for Deep Dark Chocolate.

  593. Catherine Frank says:

    Love, love, love Peanut Butter in ice cream!!

  594. Theresa Skalit says:

    I vote for Peanut Butter Ripple. The slightly salty taste of peanut butter swirled in sweet, creamy vanilla ice-cream compliment each other so well!

  595. William Krohn says:

    Chocolate is the only answer!

  596. Great tasting ahead

  597. E E merson says:


  598. Judith Mayhew says:

    I want them both together; what a taste treat!

  599. NJ Graybill says:

    Dark Chocolate; it is even supposed to have health benefits!

  600. Bonnie says:

    chocolate OK but PB ripple is full of protein. Just what I needed for my diet; a Turkey Hill PB diet ๐Ÿ™‚

  601. Fran says:

    Although I love peanut butter, Turkey Hill Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate is my choice. The Limited Editions have always been my favorite to go to…

  602. Guy Ray says:

    Peanut ripple rocks !!!%%%

  603. ron sworen says:

    If you like chocolate or are a card-carrying Chocoholic like me, you must vote for Deep Dark Chocolate!
    No other ice cream maker creates such a wonderous, complex, DARK chocolate ice cream like Turkey Hill. No one else is even close. It is the second best dark chocolate ice cream ever made….the best ever was of course Death By Chocolate….the special summer flavor of the month from Turkey Hill, a number of years ago. The frozen foods managers from 3 different grocery stores would call me when it arrived. Chocolate lovers would call me to see who had it. My kids complained to their mother that our new freezer was filled with only one kind ice cream. We do the same today with Deep Dark Chocolate!
    One complaint though…..the same I had with D.B.C…I find it next to impossible to get more than 3 or 4 servings from a container! keep up the great ice cream!

  604. John L. says:

    When it comes to ice cream, chocolate always tastes better than peanut butter! Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate for the win!!! ๐Ÿ™‚

  605. Lynda says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the winner with me!

  606. Marlene Strauss says:


  607. Karla says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  608. Jane Herron says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple. Put some chocolate syrup and whip cream. It is a peanut butter/chocolate dream.

  609. Rebecca Wilson says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate. Yummeh!

  610. Jean Sagarese says:

    I love Peanut Butter but Deep Dark Chocolate made me like it, and I would usually choose any flavor over chocolate

  611. Mary Jean Diemer says:

    I have to go with the dark chocolate……but I also love the peanut butter. So…put the two together in the same tub!

  612. Barry Minnick says:

    Peanut Butter — Chocolate or Vanilla!!! Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter!!

  613. becky says:

    I vote for both because they are both so delicious! I love Turkey Hill ice cream!!!!!!!!

  614. Debbie DeRyckere says:

    Can’t go wrong with CHOCOLATE!!!!

  615. Colleen says:

    Deep dark chocolate- I can always add yummy stuff to it, like Reese’s Pieces or Heath Bar bits!

  616. Oh Wow! I Love Em BOTH!…. But REALLY really Want To See Deep Dark Chocolate Limited Edition WIN !!!

  617. Greg Cole says:

    My favoite has got to be Deep Dark Chocolate!! After reading recent news articles, I believe that it is considered to be a “health food”!

  618. Elise says:

    I vote for Peanut Butter as there are not too many ice creams with it as an ingredient, and because nuts are healthy. It was hard to choose as dark chocolate is also healthy, and I know my mom would like the Deep Dark Chocolate ice cream! It was hard to choose , as Turkey Hill has so many good flavors! If I win, I will share the prize with my family and an ice cream loving friend who all do so much for me!!

  619. Dolores says:

    Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple has my husband so spoiled the grocery store that I use to shop at stop stocking it. Well I was no longer going to shop there since I could not buy his favorite ice cream. Now he is perfectly content because where I shop now has always carried it. When I buy it I have to buy a minimum of 4 containers.

  620. Paul Nettleton says:

    I love chocolate. Not a day goes by that I don’t eat some. I’ve been told that if I would bleed, I would bleed chocolate! So deep dark chocolate ice cream gets my vote!

  621. Rosemary Sterner says:

    Peanut butter ripple is my all time go to. I love to try the new flavors, none of them are ever not to my liking, but I always come back to the creamy vanilla with the uber delicious peanut butter ripple dancing through it. Turkey Hill is the BEST!!! Rosemary Sterner

  622. Maryann Reid says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is my favorite!

  623. karen m says:

    peanut butter, and more peanut butter ,anything with peanut butter is for me!!!!

  624. Christine Adams says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the favorite in our house!!!

  625. Krystal says:

    Peanut butter! The only thing better….bacon!

  626. kerrie basara says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple…. mmmmmmmm…. makes a great milkshake too!!!

  627. Karen Fulton says:

    I like both but if I had to choose just one it would be the peanut butter ripple.

  628. Barb says:

    Turkey Hill Peanut Butter Ripple is the best and my all time favorite. Nothing like the peanutous taste of PB Ripple.

  629. I vote for deep dark chocolate but must comment as well that I haven’t seen root beer for a long time. Has that been discontinued?

  630. Paul Chalupa says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is good but I’ve grown up on Peanut Butter Ripple and it has to be the winner!!!

  631. I vote for deep dark chocolate. However, I have not seen root beer for a long time. Has that flavor been retired? Really good flavor!

  632. Love peanut butter but chocolate makes me Happy a day without some kind of chocolate is a day lost!

  633. Louise Minner says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is moovelous! Yum!

  634. Dan Kaminsky says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  635. Love peanut butter but dark chocolate makes me Happy a day without some kind of chocolate is a day lost!

  636. Barbara Dillon says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  637. Cathy says:

    Tough call but have to go with Deep Dark Chocolate!!!

  638. Debi says:

    Both are great, however, that dark chocolate has to be the winner…thank you, Turkey Hill, for all the wonderful ice cream!

  639. I was blessed to live in PA for a number of years and tried lots of Turkey Hill flavors. My all time favorite is Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. It’s the best.

  640. Barbara says:

    Deep dark Chocolate

  641. Michael Fama says:

    Definately deep dark chocolate. I’ve called several times to offer my opinion that it be available all year long.
    It is absolutely the best.

  642. Lilly says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!!!!!!!!

  643. Lilly says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!

  644. Amanda says:

    Peanut butter is one of the best foods ever invented. It has got to be Peanut Butter Ripple

  645. Lilly says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!!!

  646. Gary Vogel says:

    Not a big peanut butter fan,but I love chocolate! So it’s Deep Dark Chocolate all the way for me!

  647. John Caporale says:

    Box of Chocolates

  648. Hidemi Walsh says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate! So irresistible!

  649. kathy phillips says:

    peanut butter ripple is number one.
    I have an 11 year old autistic grandson who thinks all flavors of ice cream should have peanut butter in them. No matter what kind we purchase, I have to add peanut butter to it.

  650. TC Richter says:

    Ohhhh, so hard to pick one because all Turkey Hill flavors are De-lish! So, “eanie, meanie, mineie,moe”- it’s, it’s – ohhh, Peanut Butter Ripple!!!!!

  651. Leslie Woz says:

    I vote for the dark chocolate – it sounds so indulgent and delicious. Personally I would sprinkle walnuts on it and would have a dessert to die for!!!!

  652. Mary Ansell says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!! Yum!

  653. Abby Murphy says:

    Oh Peanut Butter ripple for sure!! Yummmmmmmm!!!

  654. Darlene Weaver says:

    I must go with the Chocolate!!!!!! There is none better!

  655. Catherine Green says:

    I love chocolate, but I REALLY LOVE peanut butter ripple!! I will be more than happy to try any…and ALL of your flavors should I
    be chosen as the winner!!

  656. Donna Fernandez says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  657. Cath T says:

    Chocolate, any chocolate flavor, will always win in my mind, against any flavor. I just can’t get excited by pb in ice cream.

  658. Carol O'Connell says:

    How about a combo of peanut butter ripple and deep, dark chocolate? Yummmy

  659. Christen Sullivan says:

    Yikes! Peanut Butter & Dark Chocolate are my two favorites- tough call! I guess I will have to go with Peanut Butter Ripple this time around but I so wish I could choose both.

  660. Lisa says:

    It’s a tough choice, but I have to vote for the peanut butter ripple. No, the chocolate. No, the peanut butter. Yeah, the peanut butter ๐Ÿ™‚

  661. Jeannette Massey says:

    Peanut butter for the win?

  662. Lisa W. says:

    Yummy Peanut Buutter Ripple, baby!!

  663. Rebecca says:

    Peanut butter ripple!! As I sit here and eat peanut butter!!! Ha!

  664. Stan says:

    gotta be deep dark chocolate – just gotta be

  665. Nancy says:

    Oh Yeah….Deep Dark Chocolate!

  666. Peg Stevens says:

    I would vote for Deep Dark Chocolate, even though I think the best thing would be to combine the two flavors.

  667. Paula Stone says:

    Peanut Buttle Ripple…of course.

  668. Brecken Pettit says:

    Deep dark chocolate! Both together would be awsome!

  669. Jane Maz says:

    LOve the deep dark chocolate! Turkey Hill ice cream is the best. ๐Ÿ™‚

  670. Marjorie says:

    We choose deep dark chocolate! Because it’s chocolaty and deeelish!!!

  671. Marjorie says:

    Chocolate is the best. It’s chocolaty deeeelish!

  672. Janet says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is to die for!!!! Hands down a winner!

  673. Nancy Schools says:

    I voted for Peanut Butter Ripple but I wouldn’t be disappointed if Deep Dark Chocolate won.

  674. Susan says:

    Dark chocolate gets my vote. It’s healthy, right? Since it’s dark chocolate?

  675. Shannan says:

    I dig around the carton for the ripples of peanut butter. Peanut Butter Ripple is the winner in my book!

  676. Cindy says:

    Definitely the deep dark incredible chocolate! There is no other ice cr like this; awesome!

  677. David Lubell says:

    It’s worth its weight in chocolate. The ultimate chocolate-lovers chocolate.

  678. Rose McGonigle says:

    Has to be the Deep Dark Chocolate…sounds like a winner to me!!

  679. Sadie Beadle says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple sounds awesome !! I wish I’d some of it today to go along with the peanut butter M & M’s ๐Ÿ™‚

  680. Carol says:

    With chocolate the most important ingredient – either one is a win win!

  681. Beth says:

    Deep dark chocolate for the win!!!!! Yum!!!

  682. Debbie Welling says:

    Tough decision. I like them both!!

  683. I think the Deep Dark Chocolate would be Fantastic BUT my all time favorite is the BUTTER BRICKLE!!! I love it. It is the best ice cream I have ever eaten. I can’t wait for it to come out & I hope & pray my little grocery store in this town will carry it! Its Da’ Bomb!!

  684. Christine Fellin says:

    It MUST be CHOCOLATE!!!!!!!!

  685. Meghan says:

    Chocolate all the way!!! Don’t get me wrong, I love some pb but dark chocolate always knows how to fix any situation! Go dark chocolate!!!

  686. Heidi says:

    Deep dark chocolate

  687. Shelley Hunter says:

    deep dark chocolate!!!

  688. Shelley Hunter says:

    The deep dark chocolate

  689. Leslie C says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  690. Linda says:

    I say deep dark chocolate for sure

  691. Trishc says:

    Deep dark chocolate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  692. Tim Anderson says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, although I wouldn’t mind scoop of each on a cone.

  693. Leon says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the most–all utter flavors aren’t even close!

  694. Michael says:

    Peanut Butter!

  695. Kim G says:

    Why, deep dark chocolate, of course!!

  696. Diane says:

    You can’t go wrong with chocolate- decadent, delicious chocolate!

  697. Breck says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple for the win !!

  698. erperrino says:

    Chocolate, hands down, BUT my all-time favorite- EAGLES touchdown Sundae whatever happened to it???????????????

  699. Angela says:

    I am all for mixing the two final flavors together. But if I have to choose one, it would have to be Peanut Butter Ripple.

  700. Paula A. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple. I figure that I can eat my favorite dessert and get my dairy and protein.

  701. Chris Molina says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple should be number one. Peanut butter is just as American as Apple pie. It’s in its own food group and Turkey Hill proves it.

  702. Kris DeVoss says:

    Peanut Butter without a doubt!!!

  703. Marilyn Stiles says:

    PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE gets my vote!!!!! Yummoooooo….

  704. Larry Zutavern says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple wins in OT

  705. karen hunter says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  706. Christina Cwenar says:

    Why pick one or the other…mixboth and they are both winners.

  707. Barbara Law says:

    Of course, Butter Ripple!

  708. Mayfair Magee says:


  709. Roberta Pack says:

    Deep chocolate wins my vote. Thank you.

  710. Laura Smeltzer says:

    My vote…combine the two flavors and that would be the ultimate!

  711. Valerie Wood says:

    I can haz PEANUT BUTTER??? Oh, yesssssssssss!!!!

  712. Yvonne Snyder says:

    Mmmm…..Dark Chocolate! My vote will always go for chocolate !

  713. Yvonne Snyder says:

    Yummy Dark Chocolate

  714. Greg says:

    Well let me say this is a hard choice, But Peanut Butter Ripple edges out!!!! Now I have to run out and get some. I scream You scream We all scream for TURKEY HILL ICE CREAM!!!!!!!!

  715. Michelle says:

    Peanut butter ripple it would have to be. Ice cream for a year sounds great during pregnancy!

  716. lisa says:

    Too tough to decide. Can’t I compromise and have a scoop of each?

  717. sharon says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple would be my pick but if you combined the two it would be a flavor explosion! โ™ฅ

  718. krissie says:

    I vote for Peanut Butter Ripple!!
    Cant go wrong with peanut butter and ice cream!!

  719. Frank Klemas says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate for me!

  720. Sarah says:

    I love Turkey Hill ice cream. It’s my sweet treat in the evening!

  721. james says:

    deep dark chocolate for sure!!!

  722. Susan G says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple won’t double dribble……It’s the Winner!!

  723. Marty Hughes says:

    Definitely the Chocolate!! I like the PB but the chocolate wins out.

  724. Cheryl says:

    Chocolate for sure. Dark chocolate is to be good for you right?

  725. Anne boes says:

    Always chocolate ,chocolate and more chocolate

  726. Pauline Sardo says:

    peanut butter ripple!

  727. Diane says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the winner hands down. Now it would be good later on to mix the two and have like a dark chocolate peanut butter ice cream. MMmm . . mmmm!!

  728. Pam says:

    I had always gone for a “Competitors” brand which was my ultimate favorite (WAS), but then I tried the Deep Dark Chocolate and wrote Turkey Hill to ask to PLEASE make this a year round indulgence. Every year I mark my calender so I can stock up as soon as it hits the shelves. Its taste is like a rich frozen chocolate pudding packed with real dark chocolate shavings. Unbelievable! Please make this a year round choice.

  729. ED DORAZIO says:

    Anything peanut butter is always my favorite snd the ripple is a fantastic finish. Go peanut butter ripple.

  730. Linda Meunier says:

    Oh what a hard decision! I actually tried a scoop of both together.. It was different, but then again it’s ice cream! I LOVE ice cream!! We should own stock in your company with how much of your ice cream we have in our freezers! Anyway, I would have to vote for deep dark chocolate.! Best chocolate ice cream I have ever had!

  731. Tonya Earwaker says:

    nothing beats dark chocolate and they say it’s good for your health!!

  732. kara r says:

    love your ice cream!

  733. lorraine knoch says:

    PBR is the star!!!

  734. Alison says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate…sinfully delicious!

  735. CHOCOLATE CHIP MINT is all I can say.

  736. Pete Marchetto says:

    Definitely Deep Dark Chocolate, this time.
    Pete&Nancy Marchetto

  737. Sam Marinelli says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate for sure!!!

  738. Cathy Bradford says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  739. Bernika Simmons says:

    Deep Chocolate all the way!!

  740. J. Formisano says:

    The velvety experience of deep dark chocolate is indescribably delicious!

  741. Rosemary Sams says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  742. Barb Owensby says:

    Both flavors sound great! I voted for peanut butter.

  743. Amanda says:

    Definitely Deep Dark Chocolate!!!! It is THE best chocolate ice cream out there!

  744. Cathy says:

    I know everyone loves peanut butter BUT Deep Dark Chocokate…so indescribably delicious…and we all know dark chocolate is good for you! Yay for L.E. Deep dark choc!

  745. Babs Hudock says:

    Can’t go wrong with either flavor, but Deep Dark Chocolate gets my vote!

  746. Lori says:

    PB ripple!

  747. Cindi says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is it. Too bad it isn’t Peanut Butter in Deep Dark Chocolate!

  748. Michelle says:

    I loved the DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE I have been looking for it since this past fall and can’t find it anywhere… IT is the BEST menopausal ice cream EVER!!!!

  749. Carol McDermit says:

    Seriously anything with peanut butter is amazing. So rich and creamy. Love Love Turkey Hill Ice Cream!!! Don’t even look at other brands in the stores. I know when I buy Turkey Hill I am getting the best for flavor and price.

  750. Bill Frey says:

    Both are very good but I prefer chocolate

  751. Kim Cowgar says:

    Have to go with the peanut butter ripple because for me, unfortunately, there is a thing as too much chocolate.

  752. Gayle Holman says:

    Love, love, love your Peanut Butter Ripple!

  753. Georgianne Chepalonis says:

    I think it would be a fantastic idea to combine the two to make “Deep Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple”!!! …I’m thinking the Peanut Butter Ripple will win even though I voted for the Deep Dark Chocolate!

  754. Peggy says:

    I add my own peanut butter to the natural vanilla. Now I can just scoop!

  755. Marge says:

    Deep dark chocolate is a fantastic idea. Now everyone who is health conscious will be happy. (Dark chocolate is the new lets-be healthy-food).

  756. Daavid B says:

    Gotta go for the DDC especially if it is like the old DBC. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  757. Luanne Strohecker says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple simply because I am reminded of my wonderful mother who enjoyed every bite of this flavor of ice cream!

  758. Dianne Simmons says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the best ice cream ever!! My alltime favorite.

  759. Patty says:

    Can’t decide. Both sound delicious!

  760. Amanda says:

    both are great, but I would have to go with the deep dark chocolate!

  761. Robin says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  762. Mac says:

    Tough choice! I have a slight preference for the Peanut Butter Ripple, but it looks as though the Deep Dark Chocolate is ahead (for now). I happy whoever wins!!

  763. John says:

    My vote is for the BEST ice cream I EVER had, “Deep Dark Chocolate”!!!! (Sorry, Penn State Creamery.)Now, How do I vote 739 more times???

  764. Beverly Coulter says:

    Peanut butter can’t be beat!

  765. Penny says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate

  766. Patricia Lenhart says:

    It has to be the chocolate. Best flavor ever.

  767. Jimbo says:

    My local JayC is very small and we only have 4 flavors of Turkey Hill to choose from. Maybe one day we will get a bigger JayC with more Turkey Hill!!

  768. Carol Fran says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate — I personally would love to eat one huge scoop of both the Deep Dark Chocolate and the Peanut Butter Ripple. However, I need to respect so many people who are allergic to peanut butter – including a few of my grandchildren -I have to go with Deep Dark Chocolate.

  769. bruce says:

    chocolate rules

  770. Dennis says:

    Like them both but it’s gotta be PB!!

  771. jean says:

    Love the Deep Dark Chocolate

  772. Diane says:

    Peanut Butter would be my choice, but the combined flavors would be the greastest choice

  773. marlene says:

    I think the peanut butter ripple would be my choice. i don’t think i have tried either flavor.

  774. Muriel Pfeifer says:

    I wish Turkey Hill would make these great flavors in “ALL Natural” ice cream. I hate all the chemicals in the “regular” ice cream. The selection of “ALL Natural” flavors is too small.

  775. J hess says:

    Peanut butter ripple:)

  776. margo farneth says:

    peanut butter ripple

  777. J hess says:


  778. Elizabeth says:

    Deep dark chocolate!

  779. sandra robinson says:

    oooh—just to smush my entire face into deep dark chocolate

  780. Wanda Gawronski says:

    CHOCOLATE! !!! Nothing more to say..it’s the best!

  781. Jill says:

    I love any flavor of chocolate. It has to be the chocolate flavor.

  782. I vote for Deep Dark Chocolate. I like peanut butter but not in my ice cream, cookies or icing.

  783. Pat Thompson says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!! Love it!!!!

  784. Jennifer D. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  785. J. Dubbs says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  786. Robert Bryant says:

    It is all about CHOCOLATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  787. Robert Bryant says:

    I already made a comment, but you could have a one really BIG winner if you just combined the two flavors together and made Chocolate Peanut Butter Ripple!!!

  788. Wendy Dulin says:

    Add dark chocolate fudge to peanut butter ripple – perfection!

  789. Lorraine Leonard says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple!!!

    But…..I would also vote for a combination of the two!!

  790. Rena says:

    DEEP…DARK…Chocolate……….but actually a scoop of each would be the ultimate. ๐Ÿ™‚

  791. Diane VanDenburgh says:

    Oh, come on, anything with peanut butter is always the BEST!

  792. belinda bowersox says:

    mmmmmmmm chocolate!

  793. Bcar says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the best I have ever had! I so want it to win and wish it was out year round!

  794. David Trout says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!!!!

  795. Stephanie says:

    I choose, the Deep Dark Chocolate. Because the rich chocolate flavor. Yes, I’m a chocoholic! Keep up the good work Turkey Hill.

  796. CMC says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!

  797. Bev Howell says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple…but it was a close call.

  798. Beverly Daily says:

    Dark chocolate is good for us. Sounds like a perfect reason to eat this ice cream. LOL!!!

  799. Roxane says:

    peanut butter ripple! I have some in my freezer now! Along with a few other flavors but hey they all can’t make the cut! Has to be one winner in the tournament! I think peanut butter beats chocolate! now the combination is another story…

  800. Nancy Austin says:

    Deep dark chocolate makes this choice a health food that is super delicious

  801. JESSICA S. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple for the win! I like chocolate, but I think the Deep Dark Chocolate might be too much of a good thing!

  802. Paul B says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple – Both peanut butter & chocolate are great ice cream flavors but peanut butter & I have the same initials.

  803. Jessica says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate: Deep & Dark = Decadent. Plus, it’s chocolate.

  804. Michelle says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple-not much of a chocolate fan!!!

  805. Ronald Schendorf says:

    It’s gotta be Deep Dark Chocolate! Chocolate rules and dark chocolate’s good for you!

  806. Pershopper says:

    Two words. Dark. Chocolate.

  807. Jeff Geisel says:

    I cannot believe these are the two finalists. Has anyone out there ever had Blitzburgh Crunch? Pumpkin Pie? Touchdown Sundae? These two flavors wouldn’t even make my top 10. Ice Cream novices….

  808. peeje says:

    Love both flavors as well as many others, but I chose the dark chocolate as the best because dark chocolate is good for the heart and blood vessels:-) ๐Ÿ™‚

  809. Mike says:

    Hoping Peanut Butter Ripple has come from behind victory!

  810. Bob Eagan says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple gets my vote!!!

  811. Joyce says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate…YUM YUM!!!

  812. Donald Cook says:

    My favorite did not make the finals but my wife’s favorite is the peanut ripple.

  813. Sarah says:

    Chocolate sounds like the winner to me!

  814. David says:

    What about BOTH together in a bowl?!? Huh, chocolate the peanut butter together?

  815. Trina Lehman says:

    Love Dark chocolate

  816. Trina Lehman says:

    Love dark chocolate!

  817. Janelle Bordlemay says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple <3

  818. Linda says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple hands down!!

  819. Patrice says:

    Peanut butter ripple! It was my dear friend Jerry’s favorite.

  820. Kelly Gray says:

    I say put a scoop of peanut butter ripple with a scoop of the dark chocolate for twice the goodness.

  821. amanda says:

    I love peanut butter ripple!!!!!!! yum yum

  822. eleanor says:

    love the Peanur butter ripl

  823. eleanor says:

    love te peanut butter repl

  824. Bethany Westbay says:

    Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate. I love dark chocolate.

  825. Joyce M. says:

    This is such a simple answer since I hate the smell of peanut butter I obviously vote for Limited Edition Deep Dark Chocolate. I enjoy your ice cream but my dh has some every night.

  826. Pauleta Holloway says:

    The Deep Dark Chocolate sounds awesome. It is beneficial to your health and a lot more people could eat dark chocolate then peanut butter. So it’s a win..win situation. We love your ice cream so I am sure which ever flavor is picked it will still be a winner!

  827. Pauleta Holloway says:

    The Deep Dark Chocolate sounds awesome. Dark chocolate has beneficial qualities and some people can’t eat peanut’s so the dark chocolate sounds like a win…win. We love your ice cream so which ever flavor is picked I am sure it will be a winner!

  828. Barbara says:

    Peanut butter peanut butter peanut butter

  829. Dale says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple is the best! Chocolate is Chocolate, PBR is at least not just a flavor, it’s a mix!


  830. lorriana says:

    I have to say if you think Chocolate is Chocolate you have never tasted this finalist. Oh my gosh it is the absolute best I have ever tested and this is saying a lot as I am a true dark chocolate connoisseur. I search for the very best and was estatic when I found it. I adore salted nuts with my ice cream so I add those pretty regularly but either way it is an truly decadent treat!!!

  831. John Masiejczyk says:

    It’s Dark Chocolate ALL THE WAY!!! Nothing better than any kind of chocolate…. Your Dutch Chocolate is great, but the Dark Chocolate is OUT OF THIS WORLD.

  832. omamaa says:

    Oh my goodness… It just HAS to be PEANUT BUTTER RIPPLE!!!!

  833. Hey there everyone .. Turkey Hill Ice Cream sure is GREAT but I Think it was Forest Gump who said it best life is like a box of Chocolate you never know what your going to get!.. Go Chocolate Hint Hint

  834. Kathy says:

    peanut butter ripple all the way. You can’t miss with something peanutty buttery and smooth.

  835. Sue C says:

    Nothing beats chocolate!

  836. Chrissy V. says:

    I would eat both together, but if I can only choose one it be CHOCOLATE…wait Peanut Butter…no wait, CHOCOLATE, (really!)

  837. Pamela Davis says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate has my vote! Rich, chocolatey, delish! Mmmmmm…

  838. Jim Ambrose says:

    Since BACON was not an option, I have to go with the second best choice which is PEANUT BUTTER. Dark Chocolate is an acquired taste, as is vanilla. Nobody really likes them out of the gate. It is only through the power of suggestion that people consider and are swayed to the dark side or the vanilla side.

  839. Bev Howell says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple…but it was a clos call!

  840. Lorraine Myers says:

    I’m going to say Peanut Butter Ripple will be the winner!

  841. Lorraine Myers says:

    I’m going to say Peanut Butter Ripple!!

  842. Jan says:

    deep chocolate- what more could a chocolate lover want, especially from turkey Hill which makes the best ice cream anyhow

  843. Ann says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the winner!

  844. Linda says:

    Deep, Dark Chocolate is a flavor I have searched for…I find that really intensely chocolate ice cream desserts satisfy in just a few spoonfuls…Churn ON, Turkey Hill, and thanks!

  845. kyle says:

    Peanut butter ripple ice cream I would buy it$$$

  846. Cory says:

    The “Deep Dark Chocolate” Flavor isn’t just the BEST Flavor that Turkey Hill has…
    It’s actually the BEST ICE CREAM I’ve EVER HAD!!!
    I can’t find any other flavor of Ice cream from anywhere, that can even get Close to being as Good as Turkey Hill’s “Deep Dark Chocolate” is!!!
    They BETTER Make it a Permanent Flavor figures it out, and puts out a carbon copy of it!
    It could go down as being the MOST Profitable Flavor, Tirkey Hill has EVER HAD! Once they make it available to Everyone , Everyday!!!

  847. angie says:

    I’m not gonna lie, I’d eat both. The Deep Dark Chocolate would have to be my vote.

  848. chris says:

    Deep dark chocolate by far! Can’t wait to try!

  849. Catherine says:

    Deep dark chocolate all the way!

  850. jonathan wright says:

    I would eat both. i voted for the peanut butter.

  851. Barb Hodges says:

    I vote to combine them into one. Yum

  852. Lisa K. says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple

  853. PAM SCHIRMER says:


  854. Kayleen says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate! ๐Ÿ™‚

  855. Linda says:

    Prefer chocolate and peanut butter, but given the choice, it is chocolate all the way.

  856. craig says:

    Chocolate Peanut Butter should be on here that is the best flavor!

  857. Carol says:

    Love chocolate marshmallow

  858. John Hamlin says:

    Always bet on chocolate!

  859. kimberly gifford says:

    I would buy both and take a scoop of each!!! But if I had to pick just one I would scoop the Deep dark chocolate first!!!

  860. Debbie Swartz says:

    Peanut butter, peanut butter, peanut butter! Yum!

  861. carole says:

    Hooray for Deep, Dark Chocolate!!! More chocolate the better!!

  862. Brenda says:

    Deeeep daarrk chocolate!!!! Yum!!!

  863. Rita Hubbs says:

    Has to be peanut butter ripple.

  864. Cathy S. says:

    My husband the chocolate lover would say the darker chocolate the better, especially since any Turkey Hill ice cream would be a favorite.

  865. Karen Hall says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate For all Chocoholics

  866. Heather D says:

    I have to say anything with peanut butter is delicious!

  867. Cathy says:

    Of Course the Peanut Butter Ripple, sounds delish

  868. Madi says:

    Deep dark chocolate for sure ๐Ÿ™‚

  869. MARIA CALLAS says:

    Deep dark chocolate is awesome.

  870. Patrick Kaim says:

    Could you please send me more coupons to my home address?
    I already used all of the ones for your ice cream products?

    Patrick Kaim
    175 Charles Street
    Lynbrook, NY 11563-1907

  871. Cheryl says:

    Tie !!

  872. Lori Lopez says:

    yum, ice cream for a year

  873. Lori Lopez says:


  874. jill says:

    no thought required…deep dark chocolate…but, have to admit sometimes we swirl chunky peanut butter thru it!

  875. JoAnn Parker says:


  876. Tom Haney says:

    Has to be Peanut Butter all the way.

  877. Jason Serota says:

    deep dark chocolate, for those people who desperately need their chocolate fix!

  878. George Dvorak says:

    Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple, Peanut Butter Ripple

  879. Marge Healy says:

    Deep,Dark Chocolate would definitely be my first “hands-ons” choice.
    Hope it makes it to the permmnent flavors for Turkey Hill. There is another locla dairy here in New England that has had a similar flvoe for at least 30 years and still going strong.

    Also, I do not do Facebook so think it unfair to folks like me to have a contest on it.

Leave a Reply


These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.