And the Ultimate Flavor Tournament winner is…

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on April 7th, 2014

Leave a Comment

250 Responses to “And the Ultimate Flavor Tournament winner is…”

  1. Barb Stenby says:

    Yay! That’s what I voted for!

  2. Barb Whitmer says:

    That’s what I was going to vote for; gotta love the deep, dark
    and it’s good for us!

  3. Lois says:

    I told you so!

  4. Wendy says:

    Turkey Hill Deep Dark Chocolate is the best flavor in the whole world!!

  5. Susan Benoit says:

    Two yeahs for the darker deeper richer flavor!

  6. Gloria says:

    Terrific! Deep Dark Chocolate, you were born to provide us with wonderful flavor.

  7. ned says:

    choc. peanut butter cup is best ever

  8. starknitter says:

    Now to get it in ZIP 10003

  9. Elsie Nicolette says:

    Since I have never tried this flavor looking forward to its return to the shelves in August.

  10. Ida Beek says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate got my vote and I absolutely love it. Too bad it’s a limited edition……maybe the yearly winners should become a permanent edition.

  11. Jim in SOMD says:

    Limited editon Ice Cream flavors are the “Mid-Majors” of the ice cream world and we often see how the Mid majors do in Bowl games and the NCAA Basketball tournament. Congrats to the Limited Editions winning again. However, I just purchased Peanut Butter Ripple for a victory celebration. However, now it will just be a regular bowl of Turkey Hill goodness. PBR all the way next year!

  12. Phyllis says:

    Yum, but I need to mix it with Vanilla Bean!

  13. WIlson says:

    I voted for this flavor all the way through!!!!!! YUM!!!!

  14. Debra Sawyers says:

    My family LOVES Turkey Hill ice cream.

  15. TawndaM says:

    Yeah! Celebrate with free samples?? 5 gal each should cover it… ๐Ÿ˜‰

  16. Jean says:

    Nothing’s better than DARK CHOCOLATE !!

  17. scott says:

    Congrats Deep Dark Chocolate. But really, there isn’t a Turkey flavor out there that is a loser. They are all great.

  18. Christina says:

    Cannot get enough of chocolate!

  19. Marta says:

    YAY! Glad but sad that I have to wait till August to have some if I can find! Meantime I’ll be eating some of my other favorites. GO TH Ice Cream!!!

  20. Russell says:

    It sounds yummy. Anxious to try it.

  21. Kim Durham says:

    Yay, Deep Dark Chocolate had my vote!

  22. Anthony Scavo says:

    I love Turkey Hill

  23. Denise Wilson says:

    Never tried it

  24. Dawn Reed says:

    Yum! Turkey Hill icecream is a family favorite is our household!!!

  25. Jennifer Hess says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate!!! Wow!!! Diet approved right. Dark chocolate is good for you!!

  26. Bev says:

    One can never have too much chocolate!

  27. Jill says:

    Yum, anything chocolate!!!!

  28. Rose McGonigle says:

    Voted for that all along!! Can’t wait to get a spoon!!

  29. Anita Murphy says:

    Congratulations Deep Dark Chocolate! I always knew you were a real winner! Go bask in your heavenly glory. See you soon in your frozen Tundra at my local grocery store.

  30. Bo horvath says:

    It’s not a surprise to me that chocolate came out on top! It’s what I voted for and will always be my family’s favorite!

  31. enid portnoy says:

    Wonderfully delicious choice -I knew chockaholics from all over besides me would vote this way!

  32. Linda Feldhouse says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate – what an awesome choice!!

  33. Pat says:

    I have been telling all along that this is the best flavor ever and should be made on a regular basis not just Limited Edition, one month a year.


  34. Ann Ryan says:

    Glad my choice is number 1.

  35. Donna Haas says:

    Love love love Dark Chocolate!! Congrats to the best flavor of them all!!

  36. Rose Marie Wilson says:

    YES!!!!!! I voted for it every time! Nice to see a deserving flavor win! When I grocery shop later today, I hope to find some Deep Dark Chocolate in the freezer case, but if not I’m sure I’ll find other favorites to choose from. Congrats to DDC!

  37. Carol Yemola says:

    Congrats! I wish you were available all year long!

  38. Charity says:

    Turkey Hill is my favorite. Unfortunately have some family members allergic to dairy. Leaves more for me but feel bad for them ๐Ÿ™‚

  39. donna pancoast says:

    If only it came in a slow churn variety to cut on calories but preserve the taste

  40. Linda T says:

    Told ya! Good choice; of course, ANYTHING Turkey Hill IS a good choice.

  41. anna schwirian says:

    Love love love dark chocolate ice cream it is one of my favorites

  42. leslie says:

    so glad deep dark chocolate won! thats what i voted for!!

  43. maryellen says:

    Love anything chocolate!!

  44. Barbara J Swartz says:

    I love chocolate!

  45. starina says:

    Love ice cream, the kids even more so!! Count me in on this giveaway!!! Thanks

  46. starina says:

    Count me in! I’d love to win, good luck all

  47. Marissa S says:

    Sounds amazing!

  48. Kimberly Fabri says:

    Being a judge in cooking contests in the past, and being with a cooking club, I believed I had chosen the correct winner, and I did! Yeah!

  49. Beverly Dornford says:


  50. carol duperry says:

    Great news that this is the very best this year hurray!!!!!!

  51. Tara Land says:

    As long as it is TH – ok. Just bought out my store’s supply of Key Lime Pie because it had a closeout tag under it. I could really use a couple of coupons now if you have some. THank you.

  52. Carol McDermit says:

    Congrats to Deep Chocolate but my all time favorite is still anything with Peanut Butter in it. Carol McDermit

  53. Jacqueline Seewald says:

    All your flavors are winners! But do more variety in lowfat and fat free!

  54. Anna Willis says:

    I agree, the yearly winners should become permanent flavors!

  55. kathy phillips says:

    would be awesome to win for our grandchildren.

  56. I love Turkey Hill icecreams…especially chocolate

  57. Kristin Zarchan says:

    Dark Chocolate is the best! Great win!

  58. gayle wiemeyer says:

    sorry,don’t do chocolate!

  59. Elaine Garfield says:

    no surprise to me good things are ever wonderful

  60. Karen Smyth says:


  61. Frances Point says:

    Yay for Deep Dark Chocolate!!!!

  62. Sue Zetoff says:

    Yea… i think I’m one of the best fans. This is a great flavor….thankyou..28883454

  63. Harold Megargel says:

    Throw some peanut butter in it and it would be better. Maybe the two finalists can mate and make an even better flavor.

  64. Bonnie Traher says:

    Oh my gosh. Deep dark Chocolate sounds wonderful

  65. Elaine Sipos says:

    Sounds delish! I will give this a try

  66. Christina says:

    So delicious!!

  67. tania wisner says:

    In my fridge right now!

  68. CYNTHIA KIDD says:

    I just love ice cream.

  69. Sylvia Hix says:

    Chocolate heaven~

  70. gianna says:

    I’m glad chocolate won….albeit I would have preferred the Natural chocolate (the Naturals are my favorites)!

  71. Debby says:

    It taste so EVIL but, is so GOOD.

  72. dctony says:

    Love my chocolate, but my store does’nt have this flav.

  73. Sheila says:

    Wow! I really thought Peanut Butter Ripple was going to win! But I’m certainly not complaining about Deep Dark Chocolate!

  74. Brian O'Keefe says:

    My 10 year-old chocoholic will be happy. Me? More Graham Slam please!

  75. Calshondra Williams says:

    Who doesn’t love Chocolate? Congrats on the win! All your ice cream is so delicious. It’s so hard to choose just one flavor.

  76. Amy P says:

    sounds good!

  77. ROBIN WOLFE says:

    I do not believe there a flavor of TURKEY HILL ICE CREAM, we do not like! TURKEY HILL makes the best ice cream. Truthfully, I grew up in Pennsylvania. First we tried Bryer’s ice cream, we made the switch to TURKEY HILL !~~

  78. MelodyF says:

    I wanna try it!

  79. Heather Bruinsma says:

    Great! Now get them in Southeast Michigan. I want to try it.

  80. Sharon says:

    How can you lose with chocolate?!

  81. Linda W says:

    Yeah! The deeper, the darker, the better!!

  82. Janice Dean says:

    Yummm I love Chocolate and Turkey Hill! Good luck ๐Ÿ™‚

  83. Diane Nale says:


  84. Lisa Phelps says:

    anything chocolate has to be good!

  85. DDC is the winner for me!!!

  86. Ron DiRisio says:

    My daughter lives in California and can’t get Turkey Hill ice cream…… need to expand to the west coast so she can get DDC!

  87. linda m says:

    i voted for the chocolate in the finals….TH is delic!

  88. millie says:

    well love chocolate

  89. Linda says:

    Guessed it right!,,

  90. Nancy N. says:

    Great tournament!!! Sooo exciting!!! Can’t loose with anything chocolate, especially when it’s TH Deep Dark Chocolate!!!Delish!!! I’m an icecreamaholic, I know!!!

  91. Angie S. says:

    I voted for this flavor but couldn’t find it at my local Turkey Hill,so I bought my favorite,Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup.

  92. Diane Miller says:

    i voted for that

  93. acybergal2 says:

    Oh my, Dark Chocolate is my all time favorite chocolate and to make an ice cream Deep Dark Chocolate is a fantasy!

  94. Kathy says:

    I voted for mint choc chip with salted caramel as a close second, lol Need to try this!

  95. Nancy Baker says:

    That’s the one I voted for. Chocolate is the best.

  96. Shawn Young says:

    Love all Turkey Hill flavors! I mostly buy the Turkey Hill Natural now,but I love Deep Dark Chocolate!!!!

  97. Nancy says:

    Yes! Way to go Deep Dark Chocolate. I knew you could do it!!!!!! ๐Ÿ™‚

  98. Lou B says:

    Congratulations to Deep Dark Chocolate! All Turkey Hill products are winners.

  99. Rhonda Puryear says:

    Can’t have to much chocolate. My favorite thing to eat.

  100. Vicki Spokes says:

    Congrats to Deep Dark Chocolate and all it’s worthy competitors!

  101. Darnell Davis says:

    Yes! Love me some Deep Dark Chocolate! Now if I can find it in one of my local stores!

  102. Sarah says:

    My vote was for peanut butter ripple but I guess nothing can beat American’s deep love of all things chocolate.

  103. Kathleen Stover says:

    that’s what i love. i win!

  104. Mary Becker says:

    The best won!!

  105. LindaR says:

    Not a fan of chocolate ice cream, will wait for next year’s competition & hope there’s not so many chocolate flavors in the tournament.

  106. patty wiley says:

    I just knew that would win. Hum

  107. Jay Tice says:

    One of my favorites.

  108. ellie leshansky says:

    deep dark chocolately ggod

  109. Bridget says:

    No surprise this won!! You can’t go wrong with Dark Chocolate!! it’s good for your Heart,mind,body and Soul!!

  110. Amber Stamper says:

    Hooray for Deep Dark Chocolate!

  111. Karen says:

    Love dark Chocolate,can’t wait to try it

  112. judy baker says:

    sounds sooo good

  113. Ann Marie Stelma Graff says:


  114. Barbara Ijames says:

    It doesn’t matter which flavor as long as it’s Turkey Hill!!

  115. Spidazuk says:

    I voted for the awesome flavor of peanut butter but I can live with what would’ve been my second choice.

  116. Andi Micha says:

    Peanut butter was my winner, but this is a close runner up! And, this will be my hubbys favorite!

  117. DK says:

    I knew this one would emerge as the winner!

  118. Lisa Mazza says:

    Love dark chocolate!

  119. Michael Eddy says:

    Major disappointment. Really? Chocolate? Don’t care how deep and dark it is – it’s CHOCOLATE!! Why not go vanilla next time? Way to wuss out TH voters. “Limited Edition”…chocolate. That’s almost as exciting as the weatherman saying it’s going to be sunny and warm in LA. Guess I’ll have to get my peanut butter fix elsewhere – w/ Friendly’s Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup SundaeXtreme. Better luck next time peanut butter lovers.

  120. Chara says:

    I’ve never tried your ice cream, but I’m a fan of ice cream in general. I’d love to win.

  121. Evelyn Eckenrode says:

    Yum!!! DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE!!!!!! Love it!

  122. michael b. says:

    Good choice…especially like the dark chocolate shavings throughout. However, Whoopie Pie and Double Dunker are the best I’ve had and my family and I have tried most of them.

  123. Terry says:

    Yep my favorite

  124. blanche says:

    Our family (of 26 ) LOVES Turkey Hill Ice Cream !!

  125. Jared G says:

    Love how it’s written in the form of a news story. Go Deep Dark Chocolate!

  126. brian says:

    My favorite!!!

  127. I love dark chocolate!would love to win free for a whole year!

  128. Christina says:

    Love Turkey Hill.

  129. Karen Engle says:


  130. james says:

    couldn’t have made a better choice~!!!

  131. sandy says:

    sounds great, when do I get some?

  132. Kim Kilonsky says:

    Yeah! So happy Peanut Butter did not win again. I very much dislike peanut butter,but I LOVE chocolate!!!

  133. Cindy Vayko says:


  134. Cindy says:

    Oh my!

  135. Rachelle Martin says:

    love it!!

  136. Joan says:

    Since Deep Dark Chocolate won the battle, does that mean that Turkey Hill might decide to make it a year-round flavor, hmmm?

  137. Janelle says:

    Thanks for a fun contest!

  138. Cath T says:


  139. They were all good but I guess the best won

  140. DH says:

    This is as close to death by chocolate any of us could ask for!
    Sooooooo rich, creamy and heavenly bits of chocolate throughout!

  141. denise isaacs says:

    Turkey Hill’s Deep Dark Chocolate I have to have some

  142. denise isaacs says:

    I would love to try some of Turkey Hill’s Deed Dark Chocolate Ice cream!

  143. Donna says:

    All Turkey Hill ice cream flavors are winners!

  144. Andrea says:

    All TH ice cream flavors are winners but chocolate is not our favorite. Voted for peanut butter but our kids “lived” on Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup growing up!

  145. kathy English says:

    who could ague with that”

  146. Elizabeth says:

    Great winning choice.

  147. Susan J says:

    It had to win — it’s chocolate, after all. ๐Ÿ™‚

  148. Catherine Brown says:

    I have fallen in love with anything deep dark chocolate I look forward to tasting this for sure

  149. Barb R says:

    Love dark chocolate!

  150. Dana M. says:

    Yum! Haven’t tried this flavor yet, but sounds delicious!

  151. vicki B says:

    Winner hands down!

  152. Kathy says:

    Turkey Hill has the BEST ice cream and flavors!

  153. dorothy mchugh says:

    woohoo..congrats to Deep Dark Chocolate. You had my vote from the beginning..and I knew you could do it!!!

  154. Norma says:

    Unlimited deliciousness for a limited flavor.

  155. Karen says:

    We love the deep dark chocolate. So glad it won!

  156. Marybeth Nein says:

    This sounds delicious! Send me some coupons please!

  157. MsWdoesLOVEsomeTurkeyHill says:

    I kept voting for Peanut Butter Brickle but Chocolate in any form is A-OKAY with me too!!!

  158. Kym Dauphinee says:

    Can’t wait sounds great when are you sending it??

  159. Kym Dauphinee says:

    sounds great when is it coming?

  160. Sonya Allstun says:


  161. Carol F. says:

    can’t wait to try it!

  162. Fran Schneider says:

    yeah! just for me

  163. shar johnson says:


  164. Donna Straugh says:

    Congratulations Deep Dark Chocolate!!!! Personally, I was rooting for Peanut Butter Ripple but I have no negative feelings for you. You re delicious as well. My consolation would be if I were selected to receive Turkey Hill Ice Cream for the next year.

  165. Sabrina P says:

    Only the best can win. mmm

  166. susan says:

    omg, so ready to try it, love the peanut butter!!

  167. Pam says:

    I have never been a chocolate ice cream fan, but, congrats to the winner. Fortunately, there are so many other flavors to enjoy.

  168. Audrey Kreider says:

    I can’t wait to nibble on this batch of yummy chocolately heaven!

  169. Judith Davita-Rauch says:

    Deep in my soul I knew this Dark Chocolate would win!

  170. debbie says:

    This was a tough final showdown….

  171. luis lopez says:

    Turkey hill is the best.

  172. Teresa Motz says:

    A worthy Winner! Congrats Deep Dark Chocolate – We love ya ๐Ÿ™‚

  173. Diane Gruenke says:

    Have not tried Deep Dark Chocolate yet, but now I need to!

  174. Linda says:

    Although I LOVE chocolate, I have not had Deep Dark Chocolate yet! But now that it’s the winner, I guess I need to go out and buy some!

  175. jennifer finn says:

    I really love all ice cream!!

  176. Elaine Terreri says:

    My husband’s favorite chocolate.

  177. Mike Scherr says:

    You mean there are other flavors??????

  178. Renee McGarry says:

    Yum! Love Deep Dark Chocolate <3

  179. norma says:

    YUM! nothing better than dark chocolate!

  180. Irene Melfi says:

    Yummo!! The best….!!!

  181. Soooooooooo good. Then again- ice cream, chocolate- how could it not be.

  182. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    Hubby sill go with that plus box of chocolate

  183. Mary says:

    I’ll put some PB on mine!

  184. only the best for the best…..delicious

  185. Ellen says:

    Yummy choice I’d say.

  186. Sue Schell says:

    All I can say is Delicious ๐Ÿ™‚

  187. lydia says:

    yea my vote counted now I got to run out and get some

  188. Marie says:

    So very glad that it won. That’s what I voted for!!!!!!! Yumm, yumm, yumm!!!!!!!

  189. Sondra says:

    Yea!! Deep Dark Chocolate #1!!! I knew he could do it!!

  190. marie grim says:

    yummy. number one in my book. turkey hill is the best

  191. IceCreamFiend says:

    Winner, winner, chicken dinner!

  192. ann says:

    Yea!! Dark chocolate rules!!

  193. Karen K. says:

    Nice win!!

  194. Harriet G. says:

    Congratulations Deep Dark Chocolate! I enjoyed reading your great acceptance speech.

  195. Wanda Gawronski says:

    Thats great!! But we are the one’s who are winners! !

  196. Lori D. says:

    I eat Turkey Hill all the time…’s my favorite ever!!!! So Yummy!!!

  197. Harry Heriegel says:

    What else can I say but deep dark chocolate sounds good right about now.Well then any good Turkey Hill Ice cream would do the trick.Yum Yum

  198. Tom Guentner says:

    The people have spoken….

  199. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    Chocolate conquers all! There were so many chocolate entries that it made sense that one would come out on top. Now is the time to get to the store and stock up on the winner!

  200. Cathy Fisher says:

    Please make the Deep Dark Chocolate a permanent flavor.

  201. Gingo says:

    YES, now maybe we’ll be able to enjoy Deep Dark Chocolate year round !!!!!!!

  202. LindaR says:

    We need a recall

  203. Ruth Williams says:

    I’m sure Deep Dark Chocolate is good but I doubt if any flavor could replace my favorite Black Cherry.

  204. Juliette says:

    Although I am not a chocolate lover, my hubby and family are! He is out at the supermarket celebrating by buying any turkey Hill chocolate they have in the freezer!

  205. Ann King says:

    I was rooting for peanut butter ripple but the dark chocolate is very good also.

  206. Wendy Dulin says:

    Thank God for chocolate.

  207. Karen says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate is the flavor of the year in many items.

  208. Frances Nyitrai says: it.

  209. Ron says:

    Deep Dark Chocolate did not get my vote but that doesn’t mean that I won’t join in the celebration. There is always next year!

  210. mary ann herrmann says:

    …hooray!! works for me.

  211. Suzanne says:

    That was my choice!

  212. Karen says:

    It’s the new health food.

  213. pete says:

    Never a doubt who the winner was going to be..Now as reward to all those loyal fans out there I think Turkey Hill should bring it back much sooner then August..How about it T.H. pretty please…

  214. CHRISTINE says:


  215. kitty says:

    I’m glad it was the Chocolate too.

    I just found Turkey Hill Pistachio Almond. Where has this been hiding? Can’t believe I missed it. I love it. It’s a must try.

  216. Marion says:

    Dark Chocolate all the way!

  217. leecarr says:

    so rich, so dark, so worthy

  218. Sarah Oswald says:

    I have never found this in the stores but I would love to try it. I think all turkey hill ice creams are a winner but than again I am a ice creamaholic. I could eat it everyday. too bad there isn’t an ice cream diet out there I would be the first in line to try it.

  219. Susan says:

    Knew this would win !

  220. Bonione says:

    Well, truth is I almost hate chocolate. If it is mellowed out with another distinct flavor, ok, maybe. I can eat some milk chocolate, again with another flavor. Yup, it’s true, some people don’t like chocolate

  221. Margie Rodgers says:

    not my favorite but…..

  222. R Johnson says:

    Way to go Deep Dark Chocolate!!

  223. susan p says:

    It was no suprise I knew Deep dark chocolate. How can anyone pass up that wonderful flavor. Congrats again!!!!!!

  224. Tom says:

    Con grats to Deep Dark Chocolate.
    On the other hand I went to Wegman’s for the Batterup Phillies Ice Cream. Only to find out it has been discontinued.
    So in the great Philadelphia tradition BOO!!!

  225. Regina says:

    Congrats Deep Dark Chocolate! You got my vote and I’m wishing the days away until September.

  226. Mary says:

    Hurrah!! This is the best ice cream flavor ever!! So glad it won/ Hope it now becomes a regular all time flavor!!

  227. REGGIE MCGEE says:

    I knew it.

  228. Gert Sporecki says:

    Great choice.

  229. linda napier says:

    I tasted the deep dark chocolate when I visited the Turkey Hill Experience with my grandson. It was the best flavor that I have ever tasted.

  230. Marta Morgan says:

    hey….it’s chocolate….always a winner!

  231. bobby kelly says:

    Still not my favorite – love the egg nog too much!

  232. stefanie says:

    Ooooh! Deep, Dark chocolate! I would like some right now, please. Please?

  233. Mary S. says:

    Turkey Hill Ice Cream is my favorite brand of Ice Cream, and CHOCOLATE is my addiction. So a Deep Dark Chocolate will most certainly appease my chocolate addiction!

  234. Michael says:

    Chocolate is a favorite of our house. Would love to try this flavor.

  235. Joseph says:

    Any time of the year is a great time for Turkey Hill ice cream. Now there are more flavors to enjoy.

  236. Debra Roetman says:


  237. Betty says:

    chocolate all the way

  238. Rhonda says:

    I missed the vote, but would have definitely voted for Dark Chocolate! I am the extreme ice cream addict and love Natural products! Good Job!

  239. toni says:

    I have been a Turkey Hill fan for quite some time. My only point of sadness is my favorite flavor is a limited edition. Where is Gertrude’s Box Of Chocolates. I used to buy quite a bit of it and serve it at the rehab I work at. I can only hope that it will return. Thank you very much.

  240. barry says:

    I only found 1 box of it last year and have been looking for it since then. they neen to make it more than 2 months a year.

  241. Rita Daley says:

    Dark Chocolate has always been my choice of Turkey Hill Ice Cream. At times I add Coffee for the Mocha flavor.

  242. sue says:

    can’t wait for August!!

  243. JoAnn Armstrong says:

    Awesome flavor!

  244. michele says:

    coconut cream pieeeeee

Leave a Reply


These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.