April prize: Which topping would you put in this heated sundae bar?

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on April 10th, 2014

Who doesn’t love a good ice cream sundae? It’s a rhetorical question, of course, because EVERYONE loves a good ice cream sundae. The only question is: Which toppings will you put on that sundae? Butterscotch? Chocolate fudge? Caramel? Crushed peanuts? Cookie and candy bits? Whipped cream with a cherry on top? All of the above? The possibilities are endless.

With that tasty treat in mind, this month’s prize is a good one. It’s a ceramic ice cream bar with a heated compartment for fudge, butterscotch or caramel! The heated compartment is in the middle, so you can only heat one topping at a time (decisions, decisions!), but the sundae bar includes six small removable containers for all sorts of other toppings.

We’ll choose one comment at random from all the comments left on the blog this month to win this tasty prize. As always, we’ll throw in some free Turkey Hill Ice cream, too! To get the comments started, feel free to answer this question:

Chocolate fudge, butterscotch, or caramel: Which topping would you heat up in your sundae bar first?


Leave a Comment

712 Responses to “April prize: Which topping would you put in this heated sundae bar?”

  1. Jennifer Barr says:

    chocolate fudge

  2. Amy P says:

    chocolate fudge of course!

  3. Melynda says:

    Decisions, decisions…Since I can only heat one it has to be chocolate fudge but I would also all the other two to my Sunday even though they are cold.

  4. Sharon Jones says:

    chocolate fudge

  5. Marilou says:

    A little of each topping!

  6. Jean Sagarese says:


  7. Joyce says:

    Hot fudge and whip cream

  8. Judi says:

    me too – hot fudge!

  9. Joyce says:

    hot fudge and whipped cream

  10. Pamela says:

    Hot Fudge–but a very close second would be pourable peanut butter topping.

  11. I would put hot fudge on my sunday

  12. millie says:

    chocolate fudge and I would be eating it right up. the sundae bar would be so great to own

  13. scott says:

    Hot fudge,whipped cream and jimmies on top of Turkey Hill Rum Raisin. That’s the ticket.

  14. Debra Giordano says:

    I would do a caramel maybe even make up a salted caramel, my new favorite

  15. george says:

    all of the above would make one good sunday with turkey hill ice cream

  16. Jim in SOMD says:

    I would put hot fudge, crushed peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry on top. The colors give this toppings bar a 1950’s look to it. Very retro.

  17. Sandi Hrutkay says:

    Butterscotch but,I would really like peanut butter.

  18. priscilla says:


  19. Dee says:

    Peanut butter


  21. Luanne says:

    Both Hot Fudge and Caramel at the same time!

  22. Lois says:

    The ultimate topping – hot fudge!

  23. Sherry says:

    Is there really another flavor than hot fudge? I think not!

  24. Bill Seaquist says:

    I would put a warm apple compote in heated compartment and scoop over vanilla ice cream. Voila, Hot Apple Pie!

  25. Penny says:

    Hot fudge please!!

  26. Mary Paccione says:

    Swirl the butterscotch, caramel,& fudge all together but don’t over mix. Then sprinkle on the crunchy bits. Top with whipped cream & a cherry & I’m good to go.

  27. Kim Durham says:

    I would have to pick hot fudge with whipped cream, chopped pistachios and a cherry over black cherry ice cream..YUM! (now I NEED ice cream!)

  28. Bridget Ludlow says:


  29. MC says:

    Hot fudge!

  30. Carmen Rudnick says:

    I would definitely go for the butterscotch first! Yummy πŸ™‚

  31. estella miller says:

    Fudge all day long! Yummy!

  32. GregM says:

    I think it would have to be the butterscotch, with chocolate syrup on the side. πŸ™‚

  33. Miranda lutz says:

    Hot fudge, butterscotch and caramel!! Hot fudge would be my favorite though πŸ™‚

  34. Beverly Dornford says:

    CHOCOLATE FUDGE…..without a doubt!!!!!!!!!! <(")

  35. LindaR says:

    What a great little sundae server! I love the idea of the heated compartment. I will start out with hot fudge, and when that’s gone,I’ll continue with hot butterscotch & when that’s gone, I’ll continue with………………(anything sweet that isn’t nailed down!)

  36. Lou B says:

    I would top my Sunday with melted Caramel.

  37. Barb Stenby says:

    warm caramel!

  38. RonF says:

    Caramel, for sure. And – pour it over Turkey Hill Vanilla!853

  39. Anthony P says:

    Hot (real) maple syrup

  40. Mary Daneau says:

    Of course….double chocolate fudge. I didn’t know there was any other topping! LOL

  41. Gina Taylor says:

    hot fudge

  42. Amanda says:


  43. Marta says:

    Chocolate fudge of course! I like chocolate and voted for the winner Dark chocolate. Just give me Turkey Hill any time any day!!!

  44. Ralph says:

    I have always been a “Hot Fudge” nut. I will add peanuts or crush them, then add whipped cream. But w/the heated bar and containers for other items, I would be able to experiment.

  45. Wilson says:

    Dark Chocolate sauce

  46. carol houle says:

    yummy mini peanut butter cups ,caramels and hot fudge Whipped cream and mini choc chips

  47. Tina says:


  48. Christopher says:

    Yes, We also would choose the Chocolate Fudge topping to heat up first in Our sundae bar.

  49. Dottie Kline says:

    Chocolate Fudge. yummie

  50. Cathy B. says:


  51. Brian says:

    Butterscotch please!

  52. raymond b says:


  53. Amy says:

    Definitely Chocolate Fudge! πŸ™‚

  54. ned says:

    peanut butter fudge and crushed peanuts

  55. Renee Neuberger says:

    Chocolate fudge

  56. Gwen Black says:

    Caramel—delicious with its sweet, salty, creamy smooth taste.Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!

  57. Sally says:

    Hot fudge!

  58. Janice Dean says:

    Chocolate Fudge please!

  59. Lyn Wallace says:

    Marshmallow & wet nuts & maybe a little chocolate fudge

  60. Nancy Preston says:

    Chocolate fudge..

  61. Maryann Striffolino says:

    Chocolate Fudge then caramel, then butterscotch, then M&M’s & nuts… Now I’m hungrey!

  62. Linda T says:

    Caramel AND THEN: wet nuts, strawberries, M&M’s and whipped cream.

  63. Nick says:

    Butterscotch, all day everyday.

  64. Debbie W. says:

    Hot Fudge,Whip cream and cherries

  65. Maureen G says:

    I would put MARSHMALLOW in the center cause it is so good!

  66. Debby says:

    Caramel first, then chocolate fudge with a few sprinkles of crushed peanuts! yummy!!

  67. joe barone says:

    Butter scotch

  68. alyce poalillo says:

    Although I love butterscotch I think for the sundae bar I would go with the classic hot chocolate fudge.

  69. Anita says:

    A heavy ladle of chocolate fudge, sprinkled with peanuts and topped with whipped cream and a cherry. The ice cream has to be either Columbian coffee, or pisttachio almond (skip the peanuts)coffee or pistachio. On the second day, first a scoop of butterscotch topping, then French Vanilla ice cream topped with peanuts and whipped cream On the third day….you get my drift…this is such a wonderful temptation…that it must be used daily…especially with summer just about ten weeks away it would be perfect for a daily treat.

  70. Elsie Nicolette says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  71. Andrea says:

    Chocolate fudge would be my 1st choice but would be happy with all as long as it was on Turkey Hill ice cream.

  72. frannie says:

    I would put carmel and fudge with whipped cream to complete this delicious Sunday – and most of all I would choose Turkey Hill creamy vanilla icecream.


  73. Dennis says:

    If I can’t have my pineapple then Chocolate Fudge of course

  74. Lynn Hordines says:

    Definitely hot fudge!

  75. Diana Beatty says:

    Hot fudge it’s just something that when drizzled over the ice-cream looks so appealing and yummy and of course can’t forget the nuts, whipped cream and cherry great to have any time of the year.

  76. Diane G says:

    Butterscotch. As a kid it was my first choice.

  77. Donna McCauley says:

    caramel,hot fudge,and peanut butter fudge

  78. Patricia says:

    Caramel is the best by far.

  79. Nicholas Spiro says:

    Top with a thick gooey caramel, pecans, whipped cream and chocolate slivers on top

  80. chocolate chunks, caramel, reeses pieces topped with whipped cream and butter scotch chunks

  81. Vicki Spokes says:

    Hot fudge then top with whip cream!

  82. Norma says:

    Dip in chocolate syrup and roll in corn flakes. Yum, crunch, yum, crunch

  83. frannie says:

    caramel- chocolate fudge with whipped cream

  84. susan jones says:

    Butterscotch whipped cream and a cherry

  85. Amber S. says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  86. Joan Trautwein says:

    Oh a chocolate fudge with whipped cream and a cherry on top plus, of course TH vanilla. Yummy! That’s an adorable sundae server.

  87. Elaine Garfield says:

    yup chocolate fudge especially with whipped creqam

  88. Guy Ewart says:

    I like them all but I would choose caramel.

  89. Lila says:

    I like all but caramel and butterscotch together is really good.

  90. Pat Brehme says:

    Hot Fudge with wet walnuts… YUMMY!!!!!

  91. Betty says:

    chocolate fudge

  92. Bill Danson III says:

    butterscotch or caramel

  93. George M says:

    Chocolate butterscotch fudge! What else?!

  94. Rachel says:

    butterscotch,caramel,whipped cream hold the cherry please.

  95. Michele aka Goat Girl says:

    chocolate fudge!

  96. Jean says:

    CHOCOLATE FUDGE, without a doubt !!!

  97. Nancy says:

    Chocolate Fudge of course! πŸ™‚

  98. Carol says:

    Tough decision between butterscotch and caramel . . . I’ll go with the butterscotch!

  99. J Kaiman says:

    caramel,Hot Fudge, Pineapple, Blackberry and strawberry and whip cream.

  100. Mary says:

    Chocolate Fudge without a doubt! But as far as other toppings, peanut butter cups, M&Ms, crushed cookies, Whipped cream wand cherries to top it all off

  101. Nora Grahe says:

    I would definitely have hot fudge, of course, and yet I also would love to have lots more too! I enjoy my sundae with the fudge, caramel, butterscotch, whip cream, cherries, wet walnuts, sprinkles and love to put on what others want too! So you see, as long as I at least have my chocolate hot fudge… everything else is a bonus! YUMMMM! Now I must be excused to go make one, Thank You!

  102. Sharon says:

    Hot fudge! What a neat idea.

  103. Rose Marie Wilson says:

    Butterscotch! Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!!!

  104. Jill says:

    Hot fudge for sure!!! But also peanut butter!!! Maybe both at the same time!!!

  105. Emilia says:

    wet nuts, chocolate, whipped cream

  106. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    Easy Chocolate fudge

  107. Nicole Shaffer says:

    hot fudge

  108. Annie Lewis says:

    Caramel Love caramel on ice cream

  109. Wm Snyder says:

    chocolate fudge

  110. Marta Morgan says:

    always…hot fudge

  111. Elise says:

    I would put all three on ice cream, and would also add walnuts and fresh fruit!

  112. Mary says:

    My husband loved hot fudge–so I guess that would have to be my choice–in his memory.

  113. Pam says:

    Caramel on ice cream is perfect…then toss chocolate chips on top.

  114. IceCreamFiend says:

    Peanut butter!

  115. Cathy S. says:

    Hot fudge for some and caramel for the non chocolate then top all with wet nuts, whipped cream.

  116. grams says:

    Hot fudge. always been my favorite. A little bit of whipped cream on top and a cherry. yum.. All on top of my favorite ice cream…Turkey Hill!

  117. Timothy Hodges, Sr. says:

    Hot fudge!! It goes great on all ice cream. Even the great flavors of Turkey Hill.

  118. Patti says:

    Warm caramel, nuts, sprinkles and whipped cream

  119. Marge Healy says:

    Fudge, Fudge, Fudge – always #1 in this house!

  120. REGGIE MCGEE says:

    Must have chocolate fudge first.

  121. Barb says:

    Hot fudge would be my first choice!!

  122. RJayne says:

    Peanut Butter!!!!!!!!!!!!! And maybe a tad of Hot Fudge and then
    maybe another tad of choice nuts………

  123. Sandy C. says:

    Definitely Hot Fudge!

  124. Debbie says:

    Chocolate Fudge!!! Such a cute prize!!!

  125. Marilyn says:

    I would put carmel whipped cream and a cherry

  126. Ellen says:

    Caramel sauce and Hot Fudge Sauce.

  127. Anne-Marie Seltzer says:

    I always take the ice cream road less traveled. I’d put marshmallow in the center, surrounded by wet walnuts, sprinkles, cherries, and chocolate chips. Of course, the centerpiece would be large bowl of Turkey Hill Skinny Mint Ice Cream. Mint Chocolate Chip and Marshmallow – heaven!

  128. Jeryl M. says:

    Oh! Do I really have to choose? That is like choosing my favorite child. I would have to say all of them.

  129. Carol McDermit says:

    Wow they all sound good. If I have to pick I would choose Butterscotch. My personal opinion would be why ruin the flavor of an awesome ice-cream by putting a topping on it? With so many wonderful choices of Turkey Hill Ice Cream why add anything else!!!!

    Carol McDermit

  130. Marie says:

    They make everything bagels, why not an everything topping. If you are going to use all three, they will be mixed together on the ice cream. I would add a little of each topping, warm it all together and YUMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!

  131. Ann Marie Stelma Graff says:

    chocolate, caramel and peanuts…yum

  132. paulette says:

    HOT FUDGE – for sure!!

  133. Noel says:

    Chocolate fudge on Columbian coffee and natural vanilla!

  134. Phyllis says:

    Hot Fudge with Melted Marshmallow

  135. Lewis Rice says:


  136. Harriet G. says:

    Chocolate Fudge would definitely be my first choice.

  137. Lisa K. says:


  138. nana says:

    I would love to heat up fudge to make it gooey and drip from the ladle onto the creamy ice cream below and watch it drizzle down the sides of the bowl.

  139. arno says:

    chocolate fudge, but of course!

  140. Robin Ames says:

    I love goopy marshmallow, so…

  141. Stefanie says:

    Chocolate Fudge would be my choice, I would love to win this prize.

  142. Donna Straugh says:

    oh chocolate fudge for sure would be the first πŸ™‚

  143. Michael Buck says:

    I like all of the toppings. I would put Caramel on as my first choice.

  144. Faye says:

    OOOOOHHHH all of the above and then some. Chocolate, Caramel, Strawberry, with nuts candies and marshmellows on the side. I’m in Heaven!

  145. Katina says:

    Chocolate Fudge, Extra Creamy Whipped Cream, Walnuts and
    Rainbow Sprinkles


  146. Ida Beek says:

    Hot fudge is my topping of choice!!!!!!!

  147. Sue Schell says:

    Hot fudge would be all I would ever put in it! πŸ™‚

  148. Linda W says:

    This display deserves deep, dark, rich Hot Fudge. If they want the others, I’ll direct them to the microwave.

  149. Susan Johnson says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  150. Susan Sirois says:

    I would try some of each one they all sound really yummy!!!

  151. Renee Sirois says:

    I would take big spoonful’s of each one yummy goodness!!!

  152. terry baughan says:

    choicolate fudge

  153. Ruth Williams says:

    While I like them all, I would put the Chocolate Fudge.

  154. Anne says:

    I would put chocolate fudge in the center because I think that one is the most popular topping. I would make sure crushed heath bar would be in one of the side dishes since that is my most favorite candy!

  155. Donna Keller says:

    Butterscotch of course.

  156. Brenda says:


  157. Richard says:

    Both mixed togeather,delicious!!!!!!!

  158. Juliette says:

    of course everyone seems to love chocolate fudge, (my hubby included) But caramel would be luscious!

  159. Sallie Getz says:

    I would do the hot fudge first. I love chocolate. The more chocolate, the better.

  160. Ron says:

    Hot Fudge! Then real whipped cream! Chopped nuts and a cherry are optional!

  161. Richard F. Buckley says:

    CARAMEL !!! Everything tastes better with caramel topping!

  162. Karen says:

    chocolate fudge without a doubt

  163. Leon Shank says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  164. leecarr says:

    I would heat the fudge and have shaved chocolate, chocolate jimmies, cherries, M&Ms, and blueberries in the other 6 cups
    you can never have too much chocolate and the cherries and blueberries are a good combination with chocolate

  165. Ann King says:

    better get a bigger bowl, I would need all of the toppings to make what we call the Whopper Sundae. I would also heat the fudge and the caramel then eat it really fast before the ice cream melts. I have the perfect ice cream in the freezer, All Natural Chocolate so I know what tonight’s dessert will be.

  166. mary jane says:

    of course, maple walnut sauce with a whole bunch of walnuts on top with cream and a cerry on top

  167. mary jane says:

    same as abouve does that sound yummy

  168. mary jane says:

    can’t you tell i like nuts its hard to read your captcha

  169. CHRISTINE says:


  170. Janet Nebraska says:

    Chocolate for sure……,….. Instant trip to heaven…… Yum—my!

  171. Janet Nebraska says:

    Chocolate Everyone loves chocolate!!

  172. RITA W. says:


  173. Sharon says:

    If I could fashion an insert into the warmer I would have chocolate fudge on one side & peanut butter on the other or I could just mix them together & use that great warmer. Congrats to the “inventor” of that awesome warmer!

  174. Donna says:


  175. Ann Rea says:

    I would prefer the butterscotch as first choice and caramel as the 2nd choice.

  176. Nancy N. says:

    HOT FUDGE WOULD BE COOL!!! LOL!!! IT REALLY WOULD BE HOT,HOT,HOT JUST LIKE THE SUNDAE BAR!!!I’m an icecreamaholic and that would be delish!!!

  177. Nancy Donato says:

    Caramel all the way!

  178. Susan Rutherford says:

    I have always loved hot fudge but my husband loves caramel. I guess that it would be a toss up between the two. Whoever gets to it first would be the first one.

  179. Marion says:

    Chocolate fudge, of course. And don’t forget the wet walnuts and whipped cream! Yum!

  180. Sarah says:

    How about butterscotch? That sound good to me.

  181. Ed says:

    butterscotch with scotch in a glass

  182. Robert Bryant says:

    Candy Bits (M&M’s) and whip creme

  183. Claudia says:

    Hot Mocha Fudge

  184. lorraine roszkowski says:

    chocolate fudge – DEFINITELY!!!!!

  185. Debbie says:


  186. debbie says:

    I’d mix caramel and Hot fudge….

  187. Nora says:

    There’s only one choice for that and it’s definitely Chocolate Fudge!!!

  188. Tracy says:

    Chocolate fudge, for sure!

  189. mary ann herrmann says:

    …only chocolate fudge will do!!

  190. TawndaM says:

    A sundae isn’t a sundae without hot chocolate fudge…

  191. Maggie says:

    Hot Fudge and/or Carmel…yum!

  192. Vera says:

    Fudge topping only

  193. Kim Kilonsky says:


  194. Wanda Gawronski says:

    Hot fudge in the center..toasted coconut. .crushed peanut brittle, mini marshmallows, pistachios, an whipped chocolate creme in the outside ones..why not go all out!!

  195. All of the above plus peanut butter sauce!!!!! Now for the Turkey Hill ice choice of ice cream!

  196. Connie says:

    I would put some caramel, then hot fudge, then crushed peanuts (or pecans), whipped cream and a cherry on top! Wow and Turkey Hill ice cream too, how lucky would I be!

  197. Patricia Lesniak says:

    None of those listed. I like marshmallow. I also like marshmallow with a little chocolate mixed in it.

  198. Hot fudge it’s my favorite

  199. Troy says:

    After purchasing your chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream, we were extremely disappointed. Where is the cookie dough? I have taken several bits directly out of a 1.5qt container and have yet to taste cookie dough. I will ensure I inform others of this great catastrophe and will not purchase Turkey Hill ice cream in the future.

  200. ges says:

    Depends on the day!!!

  201. Carol says:

    hot fudge and marshmellow cream and top it off with peanuts.

  202. Carol says:

    Marshmellow cream and hot fudge and then top it off with peanuts.

  203. Faye says:

    What a neat idea.

  204. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    What a prize!! I would have this at dinner parties to be used with the dessert. Whoever invented this had quite an imagination. It’s useful and unique.

  205. Carol J. Cottone says:

    The topping I would choose is Hot Fudge!

  206. julie says:

    hot fudge

  207. Larry Prahst says:

    I’m a caramel man, over creamy vanilla. Crushed pecans ‘re the finishing touch! YUM

  208. Joseph says:

    Butterscotch over vanilla

  209. Joan says:

    Depends upon the Turkey Hill ice cream I’m having, but if it were my favorite – Butter Pecan – it would have to be caramel.

  210. Cathy says:

    Chocolate fudge of course with whip cream! Yum

  211. Faye says:

    That would be quite handy.

  212. Patti Sherman says:

    caramel, hot fudge, cherries, nuts, whipped cream & strawberry. What a nice device to use at a make your own sundae party!

  213. Cindy Braun says:

    Chocolate fudge

  214. Bonnie says:

    chunky applesauce with cinnamon

  215. Tom Haney says:

    There’s nothing like hot fudge then covered by chopped nuts, whipped cream, and of course the traditional cherry.

  216. Patricia A. says:

    Actually, I would want to have hot peanut butter! πŸ™‚

  217. Faye says:

    I just LOVE it.

  218. MaryBeth Eisenhauer says:

    Peanut Butter of course. πŸ˜‰

  219. marie grim says:

    hot fudge, carmel and nuts

  220. lynn dobriko says:

    Wet walnuts, whipped cream and a cherry

  221. Faye says:

    With Turkey Hill, every day is Sundae.

  222. Barb says:

    I would add hot fudge with fresh raspberries and chocolate chips.

  223. bobby kelly says:

    Caramel – then whipped cream & a cherry. (If you offered it I would like green creme de menthe instead)

  224. Christine Kwiatek says:

    I would first put fudge in the heated sundae bar. It is a classic and my favorite.

  225. Faye says:

    Love it

  226. Heather Bruinsma says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  227. DaNeil says:

    Penuche fudge sauce

  228. jay says:

    The winner of this year’s contest. DARK CHOCOLATE1

  229. Faye says:

    Very Cool

  230. sue says:

    no question–hot fudge!!

  231. rachael s says:


  232. Dawn Sauder says:

    chocolate fudge!

  233. jodi kozloff says:

    My daughter would scream for this ice cream bar!!

  234. Mary Jo Schuette says:

    Hot Fudge!

  235. Peggy says:

    Love it. Would love to be able to use this when my grandson visits me.

  236. arnie wexler` says:

    crushed oreo cookies and hot fudge

  237. Melissa J says:

    We are having an “ice cream for dinner” party on the kids’ last day of school. This would be perfect!

  238. Heather says:

    Definitely hot fudge!!

  239. Jennifer Baldino says:

    Peanut Butter!!! Oh wait, Caramel too!!!

  240. arnie wexler` says:

    oreo cookies & hot fudge

  241. Stephanie O. says:

    I would do the caramel.

  242. Denise Bigley says:

    hot fudge

  243. Elizabeth Kelly says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  244. Lady Jennifer says:

    I would heat up a pecan praline, i am not a big fudge girl, i love nuts!

  245. Carol Triano says:

    Wow, how many ways can I say I love this prize!! The toppings would be chopped peanuts, hot fudge, of course sprinkles for the kids, cherries and whipped topping……..

  246. tracy thomas says:

    this is a no-brainer….chocolate fudge of course!

  247. Julia Kurtz says:

    The fudge of course! πŸ™‚

  248. Kelly Goldman says:


  249. Cheryl Ruoss says:

    Caramel !!! or Fudge !!! both ?? Love Turtle Sundae’s !!!

  250. Janice Dean says:

    Hot Fudge is my topping of choice! Thanks

  251. Lisa Phelps says:

    chocolate fudge

  252. Jenn Wise says:

    Caramel with some crushed Oreo cookies!

  253. Carol Yemola says:

    Chocolate fudge of course! This is such a neat idea. Would make a great ice cream social centerpiece!

  254. bill digiglio says:


  255. Cynthia Dubuque says:

    Definitely chocolate fudge.. and then I’d have to top it with peanut butter cups!

  256. Davis P says:

    caramel πŸ™‚

  257. Tina Taylor says:

    oreo cookies, hot fudge πŸ™‚

  258. Schhum says:

    Chocolate fudge πŸ™‚

  259. jessica hughes says:

    Caramel with strawberries and yummy marshmellow covered in cashews and tons of whipped cream and cherries!!

  260. Yvonne North says:

    Chocolate fudge

  261. Lori Nahoum says:

    Fudge of course! Where can I buy that?

  262. Buffy says:

    Hot fudge on a mound of turkey hill! If makes me want to “gobble”!!

  263. donna kiever says:

    Butterscotch Nothing reminds me of a warm summer night as a little girl then Butterscotch over vanilla Turkey Hill ice cream Sundae with crushed pecans.Thanks for the c hance and memories

  264. Consuelo carpenter says:

    What a great idea!

  265. Mike Keiper says:

    OMG I want that !!!!

  266. Donna Yost says:

    The chocolate topping that stays warm but you put it on icecream and it turns into a hard chocolate covering

  267. Mike Keiper says:

    please let me win this

  268. Tom Walton says:

    Hot fudge, with perhaps a Caramel and Marshmallow swirl, delicious on vanilla Ice cream

  269. Courtney Howard says:


  270. Consuelo carpenter says:

    Wet Walnuts

  271. jean wetzel says:

    hot fudge of course…mmmmm mmmmm good!

  272. Tonya says:

    Hot fudge of course !!!!

  273. Caramel is my favorite topping so I would heat that up!

  274. John Brosnihan says:

    chocolate fudge

  275. Paula Shayter says:

    If i could only do one it would be fudge even though i would warm all three

  276. Terri says:

    Caramel please

  277. mary zupan says:

    hot fudge and nuts and sprinkles

  278. Dina says:

    Caramel! ! Love it when it is warm and oey and gooey πŸ™‚

  279. theresa parry says:


  280. Cheryl says:

    My hubby is in love with your chocolate peanut butter ice cream ,I usually buy a few and hide some or else….

  281. Linda Poplees says:

    melted chocolate, nuts, sprinkles, fruit, whipped cream,need I go on!

  282. Melissa says:

    Chocolate Fudge of course!

  283. Barb Bauer says:

    chocolate fudge!

  284. melissa Beeles says:

    chocolate its my favorite!!!

  285. Susan Bell says:

    It almost seems a sin to add anything to Turkey Hill ice cream, it’s great just the way it is! But there’s just something that takes you back to a childhood summer day when you add some warm caramel topping, some sprinkles, whipped cream, and a cherry to your ice cream! Mmmm, I wish I had some right now!

  286. Ria R says:

    Caramel πŸ™‚

  287. Marilyn says:

    Caramel! This is just the cutest thing EVER!

  288. kristy s says:

    This would be great for the whole family. My kids would love it. I would put in pineapple, cherries, chopped nuts, M&M’s and hot fudge in the middle. Yummm

  289. melanie h says:

    gotta go with hot fudge!

  290. Melissa says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  291. Jennett says:

    I would put chocolate fudge. Some of my family members can’t have ice cream but I would put some fresh fruit in the other containers that they can dip into the chocolate #funforeveryone

  292. Cheryl says:

    Marshmallow of course

  293. Andy says:

    Chocolate fudge would be the family’s favorite!

  294. Nancy C says:


  295. sue hulme says:


  296. Melissa says:

    this would be great at my daughters sweet 16! and fudge would probably be the one!! although caramel to!

  297. Cindy Tony says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  298. Lisa says:

    Chocolate fudge

  299. Ada Miller says:

    If I had this caramel would be the 1st topping I would heat up. I love Ice Cream so this would come in very handy & get a lot of use in our home. Thanks for the opportunity!
    aemgeg4 (@) yahoo (dot) com

  300. Janice Zimmer says:


  301. Liz says:


  302. Lori Frey says:

    It would have to start with Caramel topping..I am a sundae junkie
    and this would be awesome.. I love sundae with lots toppings along with my favorite turkey hill cookies n cream ice cream. All I can say is one word DELICIOUS!

  303. chris conanan says:


  304. Caroline says:

    All of the above! Plus some peanut butter cups.

  305. Jenn says:

    HOT FUDGE! :)OMG sooo awesome and yummy too πŸ˜‰

  306. Eric says:

    Choolcate fudge

  307. Stephanie says:

    Hot fudge of course!

  308. Denise Wilson says:

    Chocolate fudge without a doubt!

  309. Bev Davis says:

    That is a really great idea! Of course my favorite is hot fudge!

  310. Sarah Z. says:

    Chocolate, definitely! What a fabulous prize!

  311. Ann Marie Stelma Graff says:

    It would be a tie between chocolate and caramel. I would love to win this. My family has as they put it…frozen delights every night while watching TV, and it must be Turkey Hill ice cream.

  312. Juie says:

    Caramel Sauce Strawberry Sauce Chocolate Sauce

  313. Paula Hoffman says:

    Chocolate fudge, the classic favorite!!!

  314. Cathy says:

    Hot fudge!!! Everything’s better with chocolate!!

  315. Barbara Mayes says:

    Chocolate fudge! Then Caramel, then all of the above..lol!

  316. Darlene says:

    Definitely the chocolate fudge.

  317. Wendy Nelson says:


  318. Sheri Reazor says:

    I would have to fight my husband, but I would heat of the Carmel! He would like the Hot Fudge.

  319. Wendy Nelson says:


  320. POLLY WAGNER says:


  321. CarolynH says:

    I’d warm the caramel.

  322. Kristin says:

    I would heat caramel!! Yummy!

  323. Cheryl Roark says:

    Hot Fudge

  324. Kristin says:

    Caramel!! Yummy!!!

  325. Jen says:

    Got fudge? Looks so good!

  326. Donna says:

    Hot fudge

  327. Susan Flaherty says:

    Carmel is the best

  328. Marilou says:


  329. vicki krukowski says:

    Definitely carmel or butterscotch.

  330. patty cain says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  331. Christina Norton says:

    Peanut Butter sauce, then hot fudge, caramel, whipped cream, and jimmies!

  332. Linda Mink says:

    I would warm up butterscotch or peanut butter is good warm too . My Grandchildren would love to have this .

  333. Tina Levell says:


  334. Donna Dale says:

    Chocolate fudge of course!

  335. Catherine says:

    I would heat fudge up first, but not before I added a little bit of caramel to the mixture. I would have crushed Oreos, sprinkles,cookie dough,nerds, and gummi bears.

  336. Gail Gomolka says:

    I’d put chocolate fudge, of course!!

  337. Brittany says:

    The fudge, no the caramel. I guess it depends on which ice cream I have. Then again the pregnant part of me just wants a turkey hill sundae now.

  338. Doris M. says:

    Hot Fudge, yummy!

  339. Heather Smith says:

    Caramel—-love Caramel and turkey hill ice cream!!

  340. ellen says:

    Hot Fudge!

  341. Barb Kessel says:

    Has to be HOT FUDGE of course!!!

  342. Hazel says:

    Crushed Peanuts and Chocolate Fudge!

  343. Ann says:

    What ever toppings my grands ask for.

  344. lee dempsey says:

    Chocolate Fudge with a hint of Caramel!

  345. Margot S. says:

    Hot Fudge

  346. Brian Hendricks says:

    Hot Fudge. No wait, caramel. No…hot fudge…caramel. Peanut Butter? ARGH!!! I can’t decide!!

  347. sharon mcarthur says:

    Chocolate fudge of course!

  348. ann dewitt says:


  349. Carol Goble says:

    Caramel would be my 1st to heat up in my new Sunday Bar…..

  350. Marianne Misluk says:

    Definitely Chocolate Fudge!

  351. Danielle Meyer says:

    I love the server. It is a great idea. Can keep my hot fudge hot but keep my sprinkles, peanuts, mini m&ms handy. Would be great for a kids party.

  352. Melissa B says:

    Chocolate fudge and caramel mixed… yum!

  353. Patrice Umbenhen says:

    Hot Fudge of course .. this would look soooo cute on my Birthday table !!

  354. Kim says:

    Butterscotch!! You rarely see warm butterscotch as an option!

  355. Annete S says:

    Hot Fudge of course

  356. Billee says:

    It would have to be Hot Fudge Strawberries grandsons favorite.

  357. Donna Ouimette says:


  358. Sue Zetoff says:

    Chocolate fudge 3444

  359. Ellen says:

    Chocolate Fudge if I can only pick one. But preferably all three!

  360. linda says:

    My first choice would have to be the fudge sauce! yum

  361. chris blakesley says:

    Butterscotch of course!!!

  362. Helen says:

    Turkey Hill is the only ice cream that my family eats, it stays creamy. I would put chocolate fudge in but then change it every time.

  363. Shannon says:

    Love that caramel and don’t forget the wet walnuts and whipped cream.

  364. Donna Ouimette says:

    fudge chocolate

  365. chris blakesley says:


  366. Susann M says:

    Homemade hot fudge. (Caramel is a close second!)

  367. Jo Gutierrez says:

    The chocolate fudge.

  368. Nicole Walker says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  369. Trisha Palmer says:

    Chocolate Fudge!

  370. Christie L says:

    I would add fresh strawberries, blueberries and some strawberry syrup on the side. I love fresh berries on my ice cream.

  371. Lisa S. says:

    So ready to belly up to that bar! Bring on the THIC!

  372. Amy Eck says:


  373. Cheryl Christian says:


  374. Cheryl Butchko says:

    I’d put hot caramel in the heated center! Nothing is better than hot caramel! Then in the little cups, orbiting that warm delicious caramel center, I’d put chopped nuts, coconut, chocolate chips, dried banana chips, sprinkles and white chocolate chips. Oh… dang it. Now I’m hungry for Turkey Hill icecream and I have no van to go get some!

  375. Carolicious says:

    I would put a well deserved homemade Hot Fudge/Peanut Butter topping inside this festive Sundae Prize to accompany my premium Turkey Hill Ice Cream. Just doesn’t get much better then this when it comes to wanting a terrific Springtime Treat!

  376. Colette Rickards says:

    I would first heat up the Hot Fudge, then some marshmallow and some caramel!

  377. Mary Durkin says:

    AH Chocolate Fudge Yes Please!

  378. Melissa says:

    Hot Fudge, caramel and marshmallows!

  379. Anne Peters says:

    Chocolate fudge, naturally

  380. Jill says:

    All 3 at once! Now that the weather is getting warm in NJ, it’s perfect ice cream weather!

  381. Shantay says:

    Hot fudge all the way!

  382. Amy Nazzaro says:

    My 7 year old LOVES Turkey Hill! He also loves hot fudge topping with M&M’s

  383. katie n says:

    hotfudge and peanut butter.

  384. Marie says:

    Caramel, unless I can mix caramel and fudge! LOL

  385. Monica richard says:

    Hot Fudge all the way!

  386. Karen DiFonzo says:

    If it had to be one of those three Caramel, but Peanut Butter is my favorite.

  387. janice says:

    I would do all three

  388. Kathleen Pasqualini says:

    Hot Fudge!

  389. Amy says:

    Caramel for sure!!!

  390. Jill says:

    Chocolate fudge but if I could I would have all of them.

  391. Juliann Holcomb says:

    I would choose hot fudge, strawberry, pineapple and roasted peanuts. What a great ice cream sundae bar.

  392. Kim says:

    Hot fudge! Although I do love some caramel added in…

  393. Susan says:

    Yummy choc fudge!

  394. AN says:

    Chocolate Fudge!

  395. betty wojnar says:

    I love chocolate fudge!

  396. Mary Ellen says:

    Hot fudge for me!

  397. Sherri says:

    hot fudge, without a doubt!!

  398. Christy Bailey says:

    Chocolate fudge

  399. Al Clark says:

    don’t forget the walnuts

  400. Donna says:

    Carmel! Carmel! Carmel!!!

  401. Caramel. We loved the Turkey Hill Experience. Lots of fun!

  402. Angie S. says:

    Chocolate fudge

  403. Becky Bouder says:


  404. Bethany says:


  405. Martha cruz says:

    hot fudge with walnuts ! yummy

  406. Sharon kazyak says:

    Hot fudge! Surrounded by nuts, bananas, whipping cream, cherries and chocolate chunks!

  407. Jennifer Ramlet says:

    I’d use Caramel for sure!!! Yummy! Thanks for the chance

  408. Caitlin says:

    I really hope this doesn’t disqualify me, but neither. Peanut Butter is where it’s at! πŸ˜‰ I loooove warm, melted peanut butter on my ice cream<3

  409. Maureen G says:

    I would put marshmallow cream in it

  410. Maggie C says:

    Chocolate fudge but caramel gets a close second!

  411. Tammie Decker says:

    I’d love to try all 3! I bet they would all be great with something! yum Thank you for the chance

  412. Bev says:

    I’d heat up Chocolate fudge!

  413. Ashley says:

    I’d use the same logic I use when choosing which Turkey Hill ice cream flavor to buy: don’t choose just one! Fudge on the bottom, then a layer of butterscotch and caramel on the top. This way, I’d have three layers to dip into! Variety is the ice cream flavor of life!

  414. Sasha Cory says:

    Peanut butter, strawberries, and hot fudge! Omg, yummy!

  415. Denise Mauzy says:

    I would LOVE some Hot Caramel on my sundae!

  416. Christine says:

    Hot fudge!

  417. nancy fiorenza says:

    yummy caramel all the way

  418. Pamela Gray says:

    Warm up that delicious fudge!!

  419. Tracey andino says:

    Marshmallow would be the first!! I love it!!

  420. Katie says:

    Hot Peanut Butter Fudge!

  421. Jennifer says:

    Hot fudge for the win! Followed closely by warm caramel.

  422. Felicia Block says:

    I would heat up marshmallow or peanut butter! So yummy. Craving a sundae now!

  423. Sue Hutchins says:

    Hot fudge with malted milk topping.

  424. Jean Bowen says:

    Without a doubt, hot fudge, then caramel and after marshmallow whip! I love chopped pecans, whipped cream and cherry’s on my sundaes and I would absolutely LOVE this sundae bar. Pick me please?!?!!?!?!?

  425. Pamela DeAngelo says:

    Hot fudge with caramel on stand by.

  426. Geri says:

    Hot fudge for sure!


  428. I would warm up chocolate fudge for my sundae,

  429. Joey L Eddins says:

    Hot fudge and strawberries!!! Yum!

  430. Tim Manuel says:

    Caramel would be first but it would be soon followed by the others.

  431. Donna Lizotte says:

    chocolate fudge

  432. Donna Hodos says:

    Chocolate fudge, of course!

  433. Deidre Promutico says:

    chocolate fudge

  434. hot fudge and peanut butter

  435. mary says:

    love to win the bowl

  436. Rosemary says:

    Mmmm… Peanut butter

  437. PK Gunson says:

    Gotta be peanut butter – or possibly chocolate fundge…or maybe butterscotch! Yummy….

  438. Vivian says:

    Chocolate fudge

  439. Kacey says:

    Chocolate Fudge !

  440. Janice Cash says:

    Hot fudge & Caramel

  441. Kim Kocon says:

    Caramel of course!

  442. Steph Eid says:

    yummy!!! Chocolate fudge of course!!!

  443. Lorraine Fouse says:

    Hershey Hot Fudge topping !

  444. Marianne danubo says:

    Absolutely hot fudge!! Yummy

  445. Christy says:

    Hot fudge is my favorite!

  446. patty wiley says:

    Anything my bride group would want. They would love this even if they had bad cards.

  447. Vicky says:


  448. patty wiley says:

    Anything my bridge group would want. They would love this even with bad cards.

  449. Debbie Messinger says:

    I would definitely put Hot Fudge topping in the heated section! This is such a great idea! I’d love to have one of these Sundae bars!

  450. Eric Goll says:

    me want

  451. Yvonne says:

    Hot fudge for me! Over coffee ice cream. Add whipped cream, cherries and nuts!

  452. emily says:

    Chocolate fudge baby!!

  453. John says:


  454. Fred Maiorino says:

    We use hot fudge on our Turkey Hill Ice Cream and yogurt all the time!

  455. Aimee Austin says:

    Warm caramel!

  456. Nancy Bach says:

    I would heat of the hot fudge first because that is the favorite of my triplets!

  457. Lyra says:


  458. Kathy jo tesini says:

    Carmel and marshmallows

  459. Rose Swiokla says:

    Butterscotch would be heated first because it’s my favorite, but I would eat all of them!! Thanks for the chance to win!! πŸ™‚

  460. Edward Murphy says:


  461. TAMMY SHOPE says:

    I would use all the toppings at the same time. Topped with cherries and pineapple

  462. Donna says:


  463. Jim B says:

    Definitely chocolate in the heated section. Or maybe peanut butter. PB sauce on chocolate ice cream is delicious

  464. Mary K. says:

    Chocolate Fudge!

  465. hillary maui says:

    hot fudge of course!

  466. Warm chocolate is the best. On the very best ice cream if course and the only kind in my freezer!

  467. Johnnye Pate says:


  468. Michael Armstrong says:

    Love my Black Cherry and mix it with my Party cake makes it yummy

  469. Aria H. says:

    Butterscotch first. Can’t remember the last time I was able to enjoy a butterscotch topping.

  470. Sandy Schwenk says:

    I love this for sundaes.

  471. Lisa says:

    I love this and I love all varieties of Turkey Hill Icecream, my family can’t get enough!

  472. Lisa says:

    Oh and my favorite topping is hot fudge

  473. richard says:

    Key Lime Pie, Coconut Cream Pie & Southern Lemon Pie…nothing beats a Pie on Sundae (Sunday)

  474. michelle jones says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  475. I would put Hot Fudge or Creamy Caramel

  476. Jim Laubach says:

    Definitely the fudge! I’ve never been able to resist anything chocolate, but especially hot fudge. I love a good hot fudge sundae, with Turkey Hill vanilla bean ice cream. Yummmmm!

  477. Paul Milana says:

    I think we should just open a carton of Turkey Hill ice cream and dump it into a bowl filled with chocolate fudge and marshmallows. Toss it till covered and then add wet walnuts. Then, “get out of my way”…………!

  478. Ashley says:

    Of course it would be Carmel, my all time favorite:) we would use this all the time….. I log it<3

  479. amanda whiltey says:

    i’m a fan of caramel. peanut butter is my first choice though

  480. chocolate would be warmed and i love peanuts and walnuts and sprinkles whipped cream etc and thank you

  481. joanne says:

    Hot carmel and chopped nuts and cherries

  482. karen f says:

    Hot fudge and carmel

  483. Nancy says:

    Hot Fudge, peanuts, marshmallow and cherries!

  484. Annette Vinik says:

    Caramel! Love the gooey sweetness of caramel on my Turkey Hill ice cream. And then add the nuts, chocolate chips, cherries, a banana, maybe some hot fudge and marshmallow, sprinkles, the kitchen sink…

  485. lori clark says:


  486. Alicia says:

    Most likely caramel or hot fudge!! I am not much for butterscotch as often!

  487. Kathy says:

    Hot Chocolate fudge! Melting my bowl of peanut butter swirl ice cream! HEAVEN!

  488. Kim Johns says:

    Peanut Butter Sauce!!! On top of Turkey Hill chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream, of course!

  489. lisa says:

    Hot fudge, of course.Also perhaps strawberry compote.

  490. dawn says:

    wet walnuts or butterscotch

  491. Melissa says:

    chocolate fudge!

  492. Melinda Moses says:

    would be great with cool whip caramel and banana

  493. Angela says:

    Would have to say caramel!!!

  494. Mindy Detweiler says:

    Butterscotch! Our family’s favorite treat is Turkey hill sundaes

  495. As a sundae, with a cone,, or just give me the carton!!!I love your ice cream! My favorite is Fudge Ripple!

  496. Bo horvath says:

    Hot fudge goes in the sundae bar first. Immediately followed by Carmel. Hoping to win! This will make a great addition to our numerous sleepovers this summer!

  497. Sheila Pavelko says:

    Fudgy, peanutty CHOCOLATE sundaes! YUM!

  498. Karen Beck says:

    Hot fudge in the middle, and lots of toppings on the sides – nuts, M&m’s, chocolate chips, strawberries, caramel. This would be so fun for our family to use for parties or just a fun night at home!

  499. Mariah Wagner says:

    Hot fudge or Carmel. Depends on my mood of the day.

  500. Margie Rodgers says:

    chocolate fudge

  501. Linda Monte says:

    butterscotch,carmelfudge triple topping

  502. Wendy Connelly says:

    Carmel definitely

  503. Susan Brooks says:

    First choice would be hot chocolate but would love any topping. My grandchildren would have lots of fun making their own

  504. rodney keller says:

    hot fudge

  505. Jan says:

    Chocolate Fudge their is no other !!!!!

  506. Amanda says:

    Melted peanut butter!!

  507. Jan says:

    Chocolate Fudge their is NO Other Topping that tastes as good heated….yummy hot chocolate fudge…mmmmmmmmmmmmm

  508. Kim H says:

    Chocolate fudge AND peanut butter combined πŸ™‚

  509. jaime says:


  510. Denise Snyder says:


  511. Lorraine says:

    Fudge, Please!!

  512. beth says:

    the more toppings the better, it’s so hard to choose just one so all if possible.

  513. VickiS says:


  514. jennifer brown says:

    fudge! fudge! hot fudge! the best hot topping for icecream, ever!

  515. vickie gramkowski says:

    what a great idea > sound really cool & hot at the same time would LOVE to win this for my sundae habit .. #turkeyhill #sundaebar

  516. Bob Gramkowski says:

    #Chocolatefudge would be my fist choice .. the grandkids would love this #turkeyhill #icecream # #sundaebar. please pick me as a winner for my grandkids when the visit weekly

  517. Barbara says:

    Chocolate Fudge with added walnuts heated up too.

  518. Kim Marienau says:

    This is a summer staple for sure!!

  519. Mich Elle Shuler says:

    definately hot thick caramel for topping of choice!
    and my family all eats a bowl of turkey hill EVERY single evening!!!! so i hope i can win! that would be so neat!

  520. caramel first then fudge, then I would add a smidge of peanut butter because every thing tastes better with peanut butter!

  521. kay hardy says:

    Definitely Hot Fudge.

  522. No doubt about it chocolate fudge!

  523. Lynn Dobriko says:

    Hot Butterscotch–yum.

  524. Jay Tice says:

    hot Fudge

  525. Amy Johns says:

    Hot butterscotch sounds divine!

  526. Nadiya says:

    Chocolate fudge πŸ™‚

  527. Valerie Metzgar says:

    I know I am suppose to pick one from the list but I would have to pick peanut butter!!

  528. Christine giuliani says:

    I love ice cream!

  529. mike althouse says:

    Caramel and chocolate fudge!

  530. Pattie Calmon says:

    Chocolate fudge and butterscotch awesome

  531. Beth says:

    Hot fudge!

  532. Michael says:

    Chocolate fudge255642

  533. Laura Snow says:

    I guess it would depend on what flavor of Turkey Hill Ice Cream we were having… so cute!!

  534. brian says:

    love me some turkey hill!!!

  535. brian says:

    best ice cream – EVER

  536. Lisa Bletz says:

    Caramel topping first. Yum

  537. Amy lane says:

    Whipped cream & sprinkles

  538. jeanetta ervin says:

    Hot Fudge

  539. Kathy B says:

    Hot Chocolate Fudge-most definitely.

  540. Lora says:

    This would be great for birthday parties – I usually do a sundae bar instead of cake. Definitely warmed hot fudge in the center then cookie crumbs, brownie bits, sprinkles, whipped cream, & strawberries

  541. Samantha edmisten says:

    Hot fudge

  542. Nancy Shields says:

    choc fudge of course. Love your ice cream.

  543. Linda Kiss says:

    I would have all three to put on your yummy ice cream!!

  544. choc fudge, love your ice cream, its our favorite

  545. Diane Miller says:

    Hot Fudge

  546. Lillian Bowen says:

    I think this is adorable .. I need one …

  547. Art says:

    Hot fudge is the only topping.

  548. Janell Spotts says:

    Peanut Butter!

  549. Sarah W says:


  550. Sarah Ashmore says:

    Marshmallows and peanut butter

  551. Donna horst says:

    My niece would love this. We both would love it and get much use out of it. Every year for her birthday I rent an ice-cream maker and order your soft serve mix. This would work well for that day. The kids and I, actually all the adults eat so much ice- cream that weekend. Its crazy. You think we would never eat another bite but guess what? We do!! We love Turkey Hill ice-cream.

  552. karen jean mango says:

    I would put blueberries first

  553. Tracy L Moore says:

    Caramel of course

  554. Renee says:

    Chocolate fudge… yum, yum!! πŸ™‚

  555. susan b says:

    hot fudge & peanut butter πŸ™‚

  556. Siobhan R says:

    Hot fudge!!! Followed my marshmallow sauce and pretzels. Mmmmmmmm.

  557. Diane Yocum says:

    Hot fudge sauce.

  558. Jennifer McKeithen says:

    Love your ice cream! And I make sundaes with my family almost every Sunday so we would love the sundae bar. My favorite is all natural vanilla and we add the toppings! HOT FUDGE OF COURSE!! πŸ™‚

  559. Janet Grogan says:

    It definitely has to be the Chocolate fudge but I would surround it with the caramel, peanut butter & the marshmallow! Yummm!

  560. jeremy mclaughlin says:

    chocolate fudge.

  561. Carolyn Spanola says:

    Butterscotch for sure

  562. Carolyn says:

    Hot fudge!!!! Oh, Heavenly Hot Fudge!

  563. Would definitely heat hot fudge. So many toppings to choose from for the rest. Yum!!!!

  564. Jennifer Tobin Beraducci says:

    Caramel of course

  565. brynn says:

    I live a hot fudge sundae!

  566. Joyce Thomas says:

    Could I ask for all three toppings??!!! πŸ™‚

  567. Joyce Thomas says:

    Could I choose all three even though there’s only room for one??!! πŸ™‚

  568. Kitty Kurihara says:

    Hot fudge!

  569. jenn says:

    hot fudge

  570. Linda Rees says:

    Caramel for me please πŸ˜€

  571. Estella Garcia says:

    Hot fudge

  572. Jolene Miller says:

    I love hot fudge, but caramel sounds good too!

  573. Lauren says:

    Caramel!! Yummmyy

  574. Dana M. says:

    Chocolate fudge

  575. Melissa wontor says:

    Fudge and caramel

  576. Charles G McGraw says:

    Butterscotch – everyone else in the house votes hot fudge, but let them vote themselves.

  577. Tricia Daller says:

    I would have hot fudge or carmel I use both on my sundaes, so perhaps I’d need 2 please…lol

  578. Colleen kutchkus says:

    First, hot fudge, next butterscotch, last caramel! Yum!

  579. Margie Pinch says:

    I love turkey hill ice cream. I would put fudge in the heated compartment. Nuts, jimmies,crumbled cookies, cherries in the other compartments!!

  580. Jessica Smith says:

    Butterscotch and peanuts. Or all of the above. All depends on the flavor of ice cream πŸ™‚

  581. Margie Pinch says:

    I would put fudge in the heated compartment, nuts, jimmies, cherries, crumbled cookies in the other compartments. I love
    turkey hill ice cream

  582. Rhonda Puryear says:

    Hot fudge and pecans

  583. Debra Dubs says:

    Hot Fudge! Everyday is Sundae!

  584. Linda says:

    omg I need this badly I have 3 ice cream makers.

  585. Beth Johnson Titus says:

    Hot fudge,Butterscotch,Caramel,crushed nuts, cherries

  586. Debra Dubs says:

    Hot Fudge. Everyday is Sundae !

  587. Liz Psillos says:

    Yum! Hot fudge for sure! Some sprinkles, M&Ms, marshmallows, some crushed peanut butter cups!! Thinking some mint chocolate chip ice cream….ok ice cream sundae night!

  588. janice michaelis says:

    Definitely butterscotch!

  589. jason says:

    peanut butter fudge

  590. jason says:


  591. wayne hall says:


  592. Laurie says:

    Hot fudge

  593. Jodi Brown says:

    Caramel! πŸ™‚

  594. DarrellWaites says:

    Chocolate Fudge

  595. ROBIN WOLFE says:

    We have a number of favorites, sometimes multiple toppings. CRUSHED PINEAPPLE, BUTTERSCOTCH, CARAMEL, WET WALNUTS & CHOCOLATE SYRUP !!

  596. Carl Mizell says:

    Chocolate Fudge … my favorite

  597. Ann says:

    hot fudge, of course. But anything would be fine using this set.

  598. tara says:

    Chocolate fudge:-) πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚

  599. Bernadette says:


  600. Denise says:


  601. Charles Frest says:

    I would like all three please.

  602. John Deal says:

    Fudge, get ready to be heated!

  603. Suzanne C says:

    Hard decision but I’d have to go with hot fudge. Caramel is a very, very close second. Have to go with a classic. Plus it tastes amazing with gummy bears, whipped cream, and a cherry on top of chocolate mint chip ice cream. Yum!!

  604. Butterscotch and caramel!!

  605. Bonnie says:

    I would di a combo of hot fudge and caramel. Oh..so..GOOD!!!

  606. Tricia Galbraith says:

    Caramel, Fudge… Marshmallow sauce!!!

  607. Sue Barney says:

    Fudge for sure πŸ™‚

  608. Cindy Wooden says:

    Hot Fudge is my favorite.

  609. Cindy Wooden says:

    Can you imagine if the pot had a divided insert so you could heat all three? Hot fudge for me and different sauce for a someone who likes a different flavor.

  610. Craig says:

    Hot Fudge and peanuts.

  611. Jennie Printy says:

    Hot Fudge, after all if it’s not chocolate, it is not worth eating!

  612. Jan R says:

    Hot Fudge, walnuts and Cramel.

  613. Mary Lou says:

    I would definitely make my Nana Capone’s hot fudge sauce to put in it. The recipe has been around for many years!!

  614. Jan R says:

    Carame, oops!

  615. Jan R says:

    CARAMEL keyboard is sticking

  616. Hot Fudge all the way!

  617. Lisa Carr says:

    I love both hot fudge and caramel

  618. Cheryl Walker says:

    Mmm, hot fudge, please:)

  619. Eileen G says:

    Chocolate fudge!

  620. Regina Morris says:

    Definitely Caramel. But there would be room for many other things too, strawberry, peanuts, sprinkles, coconut, chocolate sauce, gummy bears, m&ms and anything else I could get my hands on to put on top of my Turkey Hill ice cream.

  621. Karen Chin-Mancini says:

    What I would do to have one of these! Does it come with free frozen yogurt?

  622. Rob Wagner says:


  623. Dave Mueller says:

    I love turkey hill ice cream. All naturals are real good

  624. craig greenberg says:


  625. Dave Mueller says:

    Vanilla cherry with carmal topping

  626. Kathy says:

    If I had to pick one, it’d be caramel! However, I’d love hot fudge and caramel mixed together!

  627. Rita says:

    chocolate fudge, of course!!

  628. Dawn Mitesser says:

    Love to win the new ice cream bar. I would put hot fudge and serve it on one of my favorite Turkey Hill Ice Creams.

  629. jan says:

    definitely fudge

  630. Tawny says:

    Definitely Chocolate Fudge!

  631. paulette says:

    definitely HOT FUDGE!!!

  632. Sean Bockstie says:

    Wet walnuts.

  633. Susan Heflin says:

    I admit it, I am a chocoholic! Chocolate Fudge would be warmed first. The others will be tried later!

  634. Karen says:

    Fudge of course!

  635. leona g says:

    Chocolate Fudge! Now I have to make a bowl. πŸ™‚

  636. nora says:

    I would start with the hot fudge but then let them all take a turn!!

  637. Renee Rousseau says:

    Chocolate Fudge would be my first go to, but not my last! My kind of Bar!

  638. ANGELA says:

    OOOey Gooey Butterscotch!

  639. brenda disimone says:

    caramel !

  640. Merri matalon says:

    Chocolate fudge

  641. Geena says:

    Hot Fudge!!!!!

  642. Anpeo Carpenter says:

    Chocolate fudge all day

  643. Amy says:

    Caramel sauce!!

  644. Nancy Baker says:


  645. Chocolate fudge πŸ™‚ Yum !

  646. Susan Shilo says:

    Loved the sundae bar idea!

  647. Mark Weaver says:

    It’s gotta be chocolate fudge (my wife’s favorite)

  648. debra p says:

    I love them all. Hot fudge!

  649. Donna Sentner says:


  650. Greg Barnett says:

    …how do I Not already have this ???

  651. Amanda Young says:

    HOT FUDGE!!!!!

  652. Amy Arndt says:

    Hot fudge definitely…but I love butterscotch just as much, so maybe both at the same time! πŸ™‚

  653. Sharon Miller says:

    Ooh…they are all Yummy! If I had to choose only one, I would choose Caramel.

  654. Sue P says:

    Hot fudgey!!!

  655. Matt says:


  656. Carol says:

    Chocolate with toffee bits

  657. Theresa says:

    Chocolate fudge of course!

  658. Harry says:

    There is a big problem there Iove my sweets .So the best thing I would do is try something new each week. Strewberry ,Pineapples ,Cherrys ect

  659. Mike says:

    Could go for one right now.

  660. Faye says:

    Its a perfect hostess gift

  661. Patty Kennett says:

    I would love to heat up some butterscotch & pour on some chocolate ice cream.

  662. Michael Dupert says:


  663. meri says:


  664. Lesa says:

    Hot fudge, caramel and lots of walnuts in syrup!! That stuff is soo good. I could eat it right out if the jar. Why are the jars so tiny??

  665. Becky J. says:

    Chocolate Fudge!!

  666. jeanie says:


  667. terri says:

    I would put caramel in it. I so love the festive look of this.

  668. Jane Lieman says:

    Chocolate fudge….but I would put it on my Salted Caramel ice cream!

  669. Patricia says:

    I would put hot fudge.

  670. Wendy Dulin says:

    Hot fudge is a wonderful, terrible thing. Alas, methinks mine eye dost covet nonetheless. (in honor of Shakespeare)

  671. Lurenia Shiflet says:

    Peanut butter ripple ice cream with hot, hot fudge. Sliced banana
    With chocolate jimmies, a few cocktail peanuts on top and of course
    Double cherries, one for me & one for my hubby of 22 years. After we
    All the toppings and the vanilla ice cream that surrounds the yummy
    Peanut butter ripples, them the best part for me is to pick up the big
    Chunks of rippled PB and eat the ripple all by myself…yummy. At home
    When we have a half gallon of PB ripple ice cream, I drive my kids
    Crazy because I dig out all those lushious ripples and leave the vanilla
    Ice cream. If we won the sundae bar the family can still have a yummy
    Sundae with HOT chocolate sauce and then they
    Might not miss those delectable PB ripples!! Lol

  672. lisa mcfarland says:

    hot fudge

  673. Edward Farley says:

    Now this would truly make Ice Cream parties Epic!! πŸ™‚

  674. Trina says:

    Chocolate fudge

  675. Travis LaCombe says:

    Chocolate fudge, of course! To go with the fabulous and classic Turkey Hill Vanilla, my favorite!

  676. Maribel Paredes says:

    Definitely caramel, we are big on ice cream at my house, this would be the best prize ever.

  677. Dawn D says:

    Chocolate fudge.

  678. tracy says:

    Caramel, my favorite!

  679. Glenn Uhler says:

    Caramel! Warm caramel is soooo much more fun to eat than the thin runny stuff in a jar.

  680. Kelly Welsch says:

    Chocolate Fudge!

  681. Andra Eads says:

    Caramel and more caramel!

  682. tina m says:

    I would love to have the hot fudge sauce first and also would add marshmallow. It really doesn’t matter all of them are great.

  683. Calshondra Williams says:

    I would definitely have hot fudge sauce and the following toppings: whip cream, cherries, walnuts, chunks of snicker bars, and sprinkles.

  684. robin says:

    i would choose hot fudge

  685. Brenda says:


  686. Robyn J says:


  687. Darlene Weaver says:

    Caramel over chocolate fudge topped with chopped pecans!

  688. lydia says:

    hot caramel

  689. Beth Caputo says:

    Chocolate fudge

  690. joe destefano says:

    Chocolate brownie fudge with chocolate twizzler pieces

  691. Bobi says:

    Nothing! I like my Turkey Hill plain.

Leave a Reply


These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.