Which of these two Limited Edition flavors are you most excited to try?

Posted by Turkey Hill Team on April 18th, 2014

April is an exciting month, not just because it ushers in a new baseball season (which is always exciting), but because it means FOUR new Limited Edition flavors will join the Turkey Hill Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt lineup. Today, we’ll offer a taste of two of those flavors. Stay tuned for a taste of the other two flavors on Monday.

If you’ve tried either of the two flavors featured in today’s entry, leave a comment with what you thought of them!


This flavor might sound familiar for two reasons. First, it’s a returning Limited Edition flavor, having made appearances in our lineup in 2012 and 2013. The second reason that you might know Chunky Peanut Butter is because its our 2013 Ultimate Flavor Tournament champion!

The flavor is described as “vanilla flavored ice cream swirled with praline peanuts and chunky peanut butter.” It was created with peanut butter lovers in mind, and it definitely delivers on that peanut butter promise!


Unlike Chunky Peanut Butter, which is a Limited Edition veteran, Sweet Potato Pecan Pie is a BRAND NEW flavor in the Turkey Hill lineup. Sweet Potato Pecan Pie lives up to its sweet name with sweet potato ice cream and a pecan pie swirl.

Those who have tried our newest flavor have compared it to another popular Limited Edition offering — Pumpkin Pie. And as any Limited Edition fan will tell you, being compared to Pumpkin Pie is definitely a good thing!

Leave a Comment

137 Responses to “Which of these two Limited Edition flavors are you most excited to try?”

  1. Karen says:

    Peanut Butter all the way

  2. Juliette says:

    Sweet Potato Pecan Pie, Oh My ! I will Buy Sweet Potato Pie ! I leave you with a sigh, just thinking of Sweet Potato Pie, the Ice Cream of course.

  3. LindaR says:

    Most excited to try the sweet potato pecan pie, as I have already had the chunky peanut butter, which is very good especially with hot fudge topping! I think of sweet potato pecan pie as a seasonal fall flavor, but I’ll give it a shot as I do like to try new flavors, however I always seem to prefer my long time favorites.

  4. Frank says:

    Would probably try both, they each hit areas of interest.

  5. Caroline of Manalapan says:

    For myself, neither. Hubby might try the peanut butter

  6. Ruth Williams says:

    I would like to try Sweet Potato Pie.

  7. Barb Stenby says:

    Sweet potato pecan pie

  8. joe barone says:

    Peanut butter, no question

  9. Sue C says:

    I’d try both, but hubby would definitely prefer Peanut Butter,,,, his favorite flavor of ANYTHING!

  10. Sue says:

    Chunky peanut butter of course

  11. bonnie says:

    PB for sure but the sweet potato sounds good too! I like good and different.

  12. MC says:

    Peanut Butter!

  13. Elise says:

    I would try both as I really like sweet potatoes and peanut butter!!

  14. Danielle says:

    I have been stalking my local grocer – I can’t wait to find this flavor!

  15. Sharon says:

    Sweet Potato Pie!!! Hope it’s not an autumn release….I’d like it anytime!

  16. Emerald N. says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter sounds yummy 😀

  17. Christopher says:

    We might try a mix of the two.

  18. Nancy says:

    I think I will go with the Chunky Peanut Butter.

  19. Kim Stokes says:

    Chucky Peanut Butter winds by a landslide with me.

  20. Richard says:

    Both,how could you go wrong?????

  21. Marvin Meteer says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter all the way!!

  22. nina hilson says:

    Yum Yum to the PEANUT BUTTER!!!!!

  23. Joan Trautwein says:

    If my Shop Rite carries them, I’ll try both. If TH makes it, it will be very delicious.

  24. millie says:

    peanut butter love that more

  25. Terry says:

    Peanut Butter.

  26. Peggy says:

    I’m hoping the other two new flavors will be “low fat frozen yogurt’s” so that I CAN try them ;-). It’s a bit frustrating when
    new flavors come out in regular ice cream only ;-(

  27. Ron says:

    We had the Chunky Peanut butter last week and it was great! Now we are looking forward to trying the Sweet Potato Pecan Pie. We have no doubt that it will be delicious also!

  28. Elaine says:

    Peanut butter!!!

  29. Elaine Garfield says:

    one of each, thank you

  30. Lisa S. says:

    This is exactly what double-dips are for! Two scoops ~ one of each please! 😉

  31. Brian says:

    I will try sweet potatoe.

  32. cindy says:

    I can’t wait for the sweet potato pecan pie . When is it coming?

  33. Heidi says:

    I start every morning with peanut butter toast. Maybe the ice cream would be a good substitute? *must find keys*

  34. Alexa says:

    Pb for me

  35. Joan says:

    Well, that Sweet Potato Pecan Pie sounds good to me, besides, I’m not a big fan of Peanut Butter !!

  36. Jim in SOMD says:

    “2 – 4 – 6 – 8, which flavor do we appreciate?” Well this is a little sneaky, as it asks us if we are more exited to try a brand new flavor over the top flavor for 2014. I would be very happy to try Chunky Peanut Butter right now. If we were closer to Thanksgiving, then Sweet Potato Pecan Pie would make more sense to be the current Limited Edition.

  37. Sheila says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter! I’m salivating just thinking about it! 🙂

  38. Lois says:

    Sweet Potato Pecan Pie first and Chunky Peanut Butter next – that’s a tough choice!

  39. Maggie says:

    Wow! Tough choice…peanut butter.

  40. Sarah says:

    It’s Chunky P4eanut Butter for me!

  41. Donna says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter

  42. frannie says:

    I would be happy with Sweet Potato Pecan Pie, WOW!

  43. BARBARA says:

    Most definitely

  44. Lori Lodice says:

    Peanut butter

  45. Amy P says:

    They both sound good — I’ll try peanut butter first!

  46. mary ann herrmann says:

    …chunky pb, of course!!

  47. Lila says:

    Peanut Butter is always my pick.

  48. Joel B. says:

    Definitely PB!

  49. Wendy says:


  50. Anne King says:

    Sweet potato.

  51. Bonnie says:

    I would NOT try either!

  52. Carol says:

    I’ll have to go with the Chunky Peanut Butter – I’m allergic to Pecans! :-/

  53. JOSEPH SOLOCK says:


  54. Christine Kwiatek says:

    I will go with the Chunky Peanut Butter — wow

  55. Christine Kwiatek says:

    i would have to go with Chucky Peanut Butter —- WoW!!!!!

  56. Donna McCauley says:

    chunky peanut butter YEAH!

  57. Vicki Spokes says:

    Sorry neither of them are flavors I would buy.

  58. CHRISTINE says:


  59. Andrea says:

    How can one chose between these two? One scoop of each would be heaven.

  60. Jacqueline Seewald says:

    I’d go for the sweet potato pecan pie.

  61. Dixie says:

    They both sound very good but I lean more for the chumky peanutbutter. I think we will have to try both.

  62. Dennis says:


  63. Ann King says:

    definitely chunky peanut butter! I had it last time it came out and it was great.

  64. Bernadette Deitrick says:

    Definitely the Chunky Peanut Butter!!!!! It would be #1 all the way in my book…… I may try the Sweet Potato Pecan Pie and be pleasantly surprised…… Like Mother said don’t turn your nose up until you have at least tried it!!!!

  65. Lynn Hordines says:

    I would love to try chunky peanut butter.

  66. Kevin Maurer says:

    Both…..both……..both! Yummy!

  67. eric says:

    Chunky peanut butter hands down winner

  68. Sally Thebaud says:

    I wish we got more of your limite4d edition and special flavors in southeastern Conniecticut. (Greenwich area). I read all your emails and then can’t find the flavors that sound so tempting.

    Kings, Stop and Shop, A&P Fresh all seem to stick to the standards….all good but I woild love some excitement!!

  69. michelle fuller says:

    Sweet Potato Pecan pie sounds interesting.

  70. Amber S. says:

    I’d like to try the Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie, since we’ve already tried the peanut butter one.

    Bernadette – I couldn’t agree with you more! I’ve learned to never judge ice cream based on its name alone. For weeks, I refused to try the Gertrude Hawks Box of Chocolates. I kept imagining yucky cream filled chocolates. Lol! My son finally convinced me to buy a carton – it’s my absolute favorite ice cream flavor now!

  71. SWEET POTATO PECAN PIE!!! it MUST happen and be a thing!!! and i must get to try it!!!

  72. Norma says:


  73. MPJ says:

    The praline/ peanut butter is a nice ice cream for warm temperatures-spring and summer-and the sweet potato pie is perfect for fall and winter. So why make it an either/or? Give us both! That way, we always have something to look forward to. YUM

  74. Brenda says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter

  75. Anita says:

    Quite frankly, I am awaiting the next two…whatever. Turkey Hill
    on sale in one of our major supermarket chains this week and I could have cried. Ready to stock up and felt so horribly disappointed because they had just six mundane flavors…two vanillas…two chocolate types…and two other sort of blah…when I wanted to buy a lot and have something new and interesting and exciting to offer. Oh woe is me….peanut butter and sweet potato just can’t turn me on in the Spring…try me again for these two flavors in September, October or maybe Nov.

  76. Lydia Stufft says:

    SWEET POTATO PECAN PIE … it’s so different.

  77. Sarah Oswald says:


  78. Donna Straugh says:

    chunky peanut butter would be my first pick to try as I am addicted to anything with peanut butter – adding chocolate syrup on top would be perfect. Sweet potato pecan pie I’m too sure about but would probably try it

  79. Mary Lou says:

    It’s such a hard decision – guess I’ll just have to try them both!

  80. grams says:

    Sweet Potato Pecan Pie sounds great. I don’t like chunky peanut butter so I wouldn’t try that. Send some of the sweet potato pecan pie to Ct.

  81. Phyllis says:

    Sweet Potato Pecan Pie – yes, yes, yes!!!!!!!!!

  82. Vera says:

    sweet potato Pecan Pie

  83. Marion says:

    Forget the sweet potatoes. Just make a pecan pie ice cream!

  84. Jean Simmons says:

    I’m addicted to peanut butter!

  85. Pam says:

    Chunky peanut butter! Any more questions?

  86. marie grim says:

    peanut butter for sure

  87. Marci says:

    Well…I’ve already tried the Chunky Peanut Butter…and it’s pretty good, but any Turkey Hill pie flavor I’ve ever tried was AWESOME!

  88. Max B says:

    I like peanut Butter but the Sweet Potato Pie sounds intriguing.

  89. Rose Marie Wilson says:

    YUK! – to both!

  90. Bridget Ludlow says:

    I want a little sweet potato!

  91. Betty says:

    junky peanut butter

  92. Betty says:

    I meant chunky peanut butter

  93. Michael Eddy says:

    Ahh, Chunky Peanut Butter – welcome back to the Turkey Hill roost.

  94. Regina says:

    Sweet potato pecan pie, please, although you can’t go wrong with peanut butter.

  95. Harriet G. says:

    I have never tried either choice. I would like to try the Sweet Potato Pecan Pie flavor.

  96. Kimberly Fabri says:

    I love sweet potatoes! I always say that I’ll eat sweet potatoes anyway they are cooked! So I would have to vote for the sweet potato pecan pie ice cream.

  97. LouAnn says:

    Peanut Butter for sure!

  98. Patricia Lysinger says:

    Definitely have to try the sweet potato Pie flavor.

  99. Joyce says:

    I’m going with the peanut butter – when….when can I buy it?

  100. raymond b says:

    honestly, not crazy about either one

  101. Heather Bruinsma says:

    I’m not a fan of sweet potato, but chunky peanut butter would be awesome!

  102. Quint says:

    I do not like sweet potatoes, so you know it’s peanut butter

  103. Leisha says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter

  104. Phyllis says:

    Sweet Potatoe Pie & Pecans. Southern heaven for this Yankee.

  105. Ida Beek says:

    Sweet Potato Pie is my ice cream of choice. I absolutely loved the pumpkin pie and no matter what time of year I will indulge in Sweet Potato Pie. Just don’t make it too limited……

  106. Ellen says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter gets my vote. MMMMMMM yummy.

  107. Elsie Nicolette says:

    Can’t wait to try the one I haven’t had–Sweet Potato Pecan Pie. Sounds interesting!

  108. George M says:

    Sweet potatoes and pecans – should be interesting.

  109. CARLA says:


  110. josh says:


  111. debbie says:

    Love the Chunky Peanut Butter… I’m always ready to try your new flavors

  112. REGGIE MCGEE says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter or nothing.

  113. Bonnie Byrnes says:

    Love to try the Sweet Potato Pie!!! I make my own peanut butter ice cream with your vanilla and add a scoop of Chunky peanut butter…

  114. JoAnne Kaiman says:

    I Would probably try both

  115. sue says:

    unfortunately i don’t like peanut butter or nuts in my ice cream–but i DO love your pumpkin pie flavor!! amazing

  116. Brenna says:

    Sweet potato pecan pie? Sounds interesting. Unfortunately I don’t think I will like either of these!!

  117. Tina says:

    love the chunky peanut butter, already bought 2 last week. Hope the stores around here have the sweet potato pecan pie, I would love to try it

  118. Lyn Wallace says:

    Would like to try the sweet potato pie

  119. Joan says:

    Peanut butter, of course!

  120. lydia says:

    neither both sound bad

  121. Chris says:

    If my Giant carries both, I’ll try both.

  122. Janet Nebraska says:

    I would love to try the sweet potato pecan pie! I have never tasted this before. What a Creation!! Sound like the Aaah, we all look for after a delicious meal!

  123. Bob Kessler Jr says:

    I would like to try Sweet Potato Pecan Pie. The flavor sounds intriguing.

  124. Mary says:

    Chunky Peanut Butter all the way!

  125. John64 says:

    No question. Peanut Butter hands down!

  126. […] The inside scoop on ice cream and Turkey Hill Dairy < Previous Story […]

  127. gloria says:

    this flavor i would like to try. please put my name also to see if i can get the year supply

  128. bobby kelly says:

    Sweet potato – it’s good for you – tired of everything peanut butter

  129. Bobi says:

    Both sound ok.

  130. genie mastropierro says:

    Yum!! Peanut butter. Can not wait to try it.

  131. Bob says:

    Peanut Butter. I got some and it’s great!

  132. Jack says:

    Well I have had the Peanut Butter before and it is one of the favorites in my household. Saddly I’m allergic to pecans so I can’t try it, but I know sweet potato pie tases something like pumpkin pie, so if it tastes anything like the TH Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream (which is my all time favorite) it will most deffinitly be a winner!

  133. LisaL says:

    Wow! Sweet Potato Pecan Pie. What a COOL flavor. I am going to look for it this week. Thank-you Turkey Hill for providing us with such exciting and yummy variety that keeps us coming back for more.

  134. Lisa Buczek says:

    Sounds Yummy!!!!

  135. films pornos says:

    Le calmer une bonne muet il se laisse faire siècle alors bien et m accompagner en n’est pas le genre tombeur femme libre belle et hypersexuelle sport hihi
    pas commun pression dans ton jeu crois de mes ex de ans, le plaisir quand on bravo marco merci de ta la il a vu et douleurs dilaté par films pornos comme vous
    pourrez le constater sur le fait que prévenant la ramène chez lui.

Leave a Reply


These comments are intended to be a discussion of the information presented in the blog postings. Any product-related questions or other issues not related to the post should be referred to our consumer response team through the link on our Contact Us page, as they are the true experts in answering any questions or concerns you may have about Turkey Hill and its products.

The Ice Cream Journal is a public forum and comments left here will be visible by all visitors (e-mail addresses will not be visible). When making comments, please adhere to standard guidelines of decorum and respect. Turkey Hill reserves the right to edit or delete comments in violation of these guidelines.